CourtListener 10288779•People v. Howell CA3
Texte intégral
Filed 12/5/24 P. v. Howell CA3
NOT TO BE PUBLISHED
California Rules of Court, rule 8.1115(a), prohibits courts and parties from citing or relying on opinions not certified for
publication or ordered published, except as specified by rule 8.1115(b). This opinion has not been certified for publication or
ordered published for purposes of rule 8.1115.
IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA
THIRD APPELLATE DISTRICT
(Plumas)
----
THE PEOPLE, C100320
Plaintiff and Respondent, (Super. Ct. No. F2200042)
v.
SAMUEL OLIVER HOWELL,
Defendant and Appellant.
Appointed counsel for defendant, Samuel Oliver Howell, filed an opening brief that
sets forth the facts of the case and asks this court to review the record and determine
whether there are any arguable issues on appeal. (People v. Wende (1979) 25 Cal.3d 436.)
Defendant has also filed a supplemental brief challenging the sufficiency of the evidence
supporting determinations that he did not act in self-defense at various stages of the case.
Finding no arguable errors that would result in a disposition more favorable to defendant,
we will affirm the judgment.
1
BACKGROUND
On January 27, 2022, the People filed a criminal complaint charging defendant with
assault by means likely to cause great bodily injury (Pen. Code,1 § 245, subd. (a)(4); count
I) with a great bodily injury enhancement (§ 12022.7, subd. (a)) and two counts of
misdemeanor battery (§ 242; counts II & III).
The Preliminary Hearing and Information
The trial court held a preliminary hearing on October 14, 2022. The People
presented evidence that Anthony A. was at the bar he owns on December 8, 2021, when a
disturbance broke out. He heard something and saw defendant take three swings at Ryan B.,
missing each time. Anthony A. stepped between the men, told defendant to “knock it off,”
and grabbed defendant. In response, defendant grabbed Anthony A.’s shoulders and threw
him, causing him to fall to the ground and lose consciousness. Anthony A. was transported
to the hospital where a CAT (computerized axial tomography) scan was performed, and he
received staples to the back of his head.
Judy J. was at the bar on the night in question and witnessed a disturbance. She first
heard defendant call Ryan B. a “bad ass,” and Ryan B. responded that defendant did not
know him. She then heard a scuffle and turned to see that defendant grabbed Anthony A.,
and she saw Anthony A. fall back into the railing of the fireplace and hit his head. She tried
to intervene, and defendant pushed her to the floor.
Emily L., who was also at the bar that night, saw defendant invading Ryan B.’s
personal space. Ryan B. told defendant to back up, but defendant kept getting closer to him,
and they ended up within a foot of each other. Ryan B. pushed defendant back, and
defendant reacted by swinging his beer bottle at Ryan B. hitting him with either the bottle or
his body. Ryan B. again pushed defendant, and Anthony A. tried to intervene, but defendant
pushed Anthony A., who hit his head on the fireplace. It was a violent fall, and Emily L.
1 Subsequent undesignated statutory references are to the Penal Code.
2
thought Anthony A. was dead because he was stiff as a board and unconscious for 8 to 10
minutes. Various patrons tried to force defendant to leave, and in the commotion, he kicked
Emily L. Defendant was violently trying to kick anyone involved. Once defendant was
outside, someone locked the door. On cross-examination, Emily L. agreed defendant was
hearing impaired and stands close to people as a result.
Defendant’s attorney argued defendant’s push of Anthony A. was not likely to result
in great bodily injury, and he had acted in lawful self-defense after he was pushed by Ryan
B. Nonetheless, defendant’s attorney conceded there was adequate evidence to hold him
over for trial on the simple batteries, but not for the assault with great bodily injury count.
The trial court disagreed, finding probable cause to hold defendant to answer as charged in
the complaint.
On October 27, 2022, the People filed an information charging defendant with two
crimes against Anthony A: assault by means likely to cause great bodily injury (§ 245,
subd. (a)(4); count I) with a great bodily injury enhancement (§ 12022.7, subd. (a)) and
battery with serious bodily injury (§ 243, subd. (d); count II). The information further
alleged defendant committed a misdemeanor battery (§ 242) against Judy J. (count III) and
Emily L. (count IV).
The Section 995 Motion, Jury Trial, and Sentence
Following several replacements of defendant’s appointed counsel, the trial court
approved defendant’s request to substitute retained counsel and for a continuance of the trial
so newly retained counsel could prepare. This counsel filed a motion to set aside the
information for lack of evidence (§ 995) arguing the preliminary hearing evidence did not
establish probable cause that defendant had used force likely to cause great bodily injury
and had not acted in self-defense. The People opposed this motion, arguing the preliminary
hearing transcript contained ample evidence to hold defendant over for trial. Defendant’s
reply brief argued his motion addressed solely a question of law so no deference to the
magistrate’s findings was required and that the People’s witnesses established he had acted
in lawful self-defense. While not reflected in the minute order on the day scheduled for
3
defendant’s motion, the trial court’s action of setting the matter for a trial readiness
conference implicitly suggests the court’s denial of this motion.
On the first day of trial, defendant filed motions in limine seeking to exclude: any
evidence of injury to Anthony A. or Emily L. until the People provided substantial evidence
establishing defendant had not acted in lawful self-defense and that defendant had acted
with force likely to cause great bodily injury to Anthony A. Defendant further moved to
exclude evidence that Anthony A. saw a fight break out, that Ryan B. asked defendant to
back away, that defendant struck Ryan B. with a beer bottle, that Anthony A. did not see
Ryan B. make any motions prior to defendant swinging at him, and that Anthony A. stepped
in to break up “defendant’s assault.” Finally, defendant sought to preclude testimony that
defendant pushed Judy J. to the ground. The record reflects the trial court allowed this late
filing and had not reviewed the written motions, but denied the motions based upon the oral
representations of what they contained.
At trial, the People presented evidence consistent with the preliminary hearing
testimony. Anthony A. owned a bar in town and was at the bar on December 8, 2021.
Defendant was also at the bar that night. Anthony A. saw defendant take three swings at
Ryan B., who did not swing back. Anthony A. then stepped between them, telling defendant
to “ ‘Knock it off,’ ” and took ahold of defendant’s bicep.2 Defendant responded by
throwing him down, but Anthony A. kept ahold of him resulting in both men falling to the
floor, and Anthony A. hitting his head on the wood stove. The next thing Anthony A.
recalled was seeing a first responder and being transported to the emergency room by
ambulance. He received three staples to close the cut on his head and had a CAT scan.
Judy J. was at the bar on December 8, 2021. She saw defendant talking to Ryan B.
Defendant commented that Ryan B. was a “badass,” and Ryan B. responded that defendant
did not know him. Judy J. stopped paying attention, did not see how the fight started, and
2 Anthony A. denied trying to hit or shove defendant, testifying he only tried “to grab ahold
of him.”
4
next noticed defendant pushing Anthony A. down toward the fireplace. Defendant looked
angry. Judy J. tried to intervene by grabbing defendant’s arm,3 but Anthony A. hit his head
on the fireplace anyway and lost consciousness. Anthony A. regained consciousness three
or four minutes later.
Emily L. was also at the bar on December 8, 2021, and saw defendant and Ryan B.
get into an argument about eight feet away from her. Defendant got close to Ryan B. and
continued moving toward him, even though Ryan B. did not appear comfortable with the
proximity. Ryan B. told defendant, “ ‘Get out of my face,’ ” and defendant moved closer so
that they were face-to-face. Ryan B. pushed defendant backwards, and defendant reacted by
swinging a beer bottle at Ryan B. The bottle shattered, although it was not clear if the bottle
had hit Ryan B. or the bar. Ryan B. shoved defendant backwards again, and Emily L. yelled
for Anthony A. Anthony A. yelled, “ ‘Hey, knock it off’ ” and then grabbed defendant,
trying to stop the altercation. Defendant had Anthony A. by the shoulders and shoved him
backwards, causing the pair to fall, and Anthony A. hit his head on the wood stove.
Anthony A. was on the ground, so still he appeared dead.
Emily L.’s boyfriend pushed defendant toward the door, and they both fell. She went
to investigate, and defendant kicked Emily L.’s lower calf by her shin. She was standing in
front of him, and he was kicking at multiple people in the area, lashing out. He looked
angry. Another patron tried to grab defendant, and everyone was yelling at him to get out of
the bar. He eventually left, and the bartender locked the doors. On cross-examination,
Emily L. agreed that defendant was hard of hearing and sometimes read lips.
The parties stipulated to the admission of a police report, and defendant exercised his
right to remain silent and not present additional evidence. Thereafter, the People argued that
defendant started the incident with Ryan B., attacked the victims when they tried to
intervene, was not reasonably at risk of suffering great bodily injury, and therefore,
3 Judy J. was pushed to the ground during the altercation but could not say it was defendant
who pushed her.
5
defendant did not act in self-defense. Defendant countered, arguing his pushing Anthony A.
was not the cause of Anthony A.’s injury, he was not the initial aggressor, and had acted in
lawful self-defense.
The trial court instructed the jury on the elements of battery causing serious bodily
injury (CALCRIM No. 925), self-defense (CALCRIM Nos. 3470, 3471, 3472), and simple
battery (CALCRIM No. 960). Thereafter, the jury found defendant not guilty of counts I
and III, but guilty of counts II and IV. The trial court denied defendant’s oral motion for
judgment notwithstanding the verdict.
On January 12, 2024, the trial court denied defendant’s request for probation and
sentenced defendant to the low term of two years for count II, plus a concurrent term of six
months for count IV. The court also imposed a $300 restitution fine (§ 1202.4, subd. (b)), a
$300 suspended probation revocation restitution fine (§ 1202.44), a $30 conviction
assessment fee (Gov. Code, § 70373), and a $40 court operations assessment fee (§ 1465.8).
The court reserved jurisdiction to determine victim restitution and set the restitution hearing
for March 8, 2024.
Defendant timely appealed. Appellate briefing in this matter was completed on
October 21, 2024.
DISCUSSION
Appointed counsel filed an opening brief that sets forth the facts and procedural
history of the case and requests this court review the record and determine whether there are
any arguable issues on appeal. (People v. Wende, supra, 25 Cal.3d at p. 436.) Defendant
was advised by counsel of his right to file a supplemental brief within 30 days from the date
the opening brief was filed. Defendant has filed a supplemental brief, which we understand
6
to challenge the sufficiency of the evidence supporting determinations that he did not act in
self-defense at the time of his section 995 motion and following trial.4
The Section 995 Motion
“ ‘To prevail on a section 995 motion to set aside an information, the defendant must
establish that he was “committed without reasonable or probable cause.” [Citation.] To
establish probable cause sufficient to withstand a section 995 motion to dismiss, the People
must make some showing as to the existence of each element of the charged offense.
[Citation.] “Evidence that will justify a prosecution need not be sufficient to support a
conviction. [Citations.] ‘ “Probable cause is shown if a man of ordinary caution or
prudence would be led to believe and conscientiously entertain a strong suspicion of the
guilt of the accused.” ’ [Citations.] An information will not be set aside or a prosecution
thereon prohibited if there is some rational ground for assuming the possibility that an
offense has been committed and the accused is guilty of it. [Citations.]” [Citation.] “[T]he
showing required at a preliminary hearing is exceedingly low.” [Citation.] An information
should be set aside “only when there is a total absence of evidence to support a necessary
element of the offense charged.” ’ ” (Zemek v. Superior Court (2020) 44 Cal.App.5th 535,
544.) “ ‘ “[E]vidence which will justify prosecution under the above test need not be
sufficient to support a conviction.” [Citation.]’ (People v. Superior Court (Decker) (2007)
41 Cal.4th 1, 7.)” (Ibid.)
“ ‘When we review a section 995 motion, we “disregard[] the ruling of the superior
court and directly review[] the determination of the magistrate.” [Citations.] We will not
set aside an information “if there is some rational ground for assuming the possibility that an
offense has been committed and the accused is guilty of it.” [Citation.]’ (People v. San
4 Defendant’s supplemental brief also summarily asks this court to “review the denial of all
of the Defendant’s motions” and the effectiveness of the representation of his counsel at the
preliminary hearing. We have done this in compliance with People v. Wende, supra,
25 Cal.3d at page 436.
7
Nicolas (2004) 3 Cal.4th 614, 654.)” (Zemek v. Superior Court, supra, 44 Cal.App.5th at
p. 544.)
Here, defendant argues insufficient evidence was presented at the preliminary hearing
to establish that he was not acting in lawful self-defense. We disagree.5 The People
presented testimony that defendant initiated a verbal altercation with Ryan B. Defendant
insulted Ryan B., invaded his personal space, and then swung repeatedly at Ryan B. when
Ryan B. tried to push him away. The bar owner (Anthony A.) attempted to intervene as was
his legal duty, telling defendant to knock it off and grabbing him. (See, e.g., Coorough v.
De Lay (1959) 171 Cal.App.2d 41, 45-46) [bar proprietor owes a duty to protect against
invitees’ dangerous conduct].) Defendant responded by throwing the bar owner to the
ground. Similarly, Judy J. and Emily L. attempted to intervene following defendant’s
assault of the bar owner and were attacked themselves. This evidence constitutes a rational
basis for concluding that there was a possibility that defendant was guilty of the crimes
charged consistent with the magistrate’s determinations. (Zemek v. Superior Court, supra,
44 Cal.App.5th at pp. 544-545.)
Defendant’s Convictions by Jury
Defendant also challenges the sufficiency of the evidence supporting the jury’s
rejection of his claim of self-defense. In reviewing a challenge to the sufficiency of the
evidence, our “task is to determine whether, in light of the whole record viewed in the light
5 Given this conclusion, the record does not support that defendant received ineffective
assistance of counsel at this hearing. (People v. Mickel (2016) 2 Cal.5th 181, 198 [“to
establish a claim for ineffective assistance of counsel, a defendant must show that his or her
counsel’s performance was deficient and that the defendant suffered prejudice as a result of
such deficient performance”]; see Strickland v. Washington (1984) 466 U.S. 668, 687-692.)
Moreover, there is nothing in the record suggesting that defendant could have presented
additional evidence to establish a claim of self-defense sufficient to defeat the People’s
showing at the preliminary hearing. On the contrary, defendant was convicted at trial on
similar evidence despite his express assertion of self-defense as argued by his retained
counsel of choice. Accordingly, defendant cannot establish he was prejudiced by counsel’s
alleged deficient performance. (Mickel, at p. 198.)
8
most favorable to the prosecution, a rational trier of fact could have found the elements of
the crime beyond a reasonable doubt.” (People v. Felix (2009) 172 Cal.App.4th 1618,
1624.) We “ ‘ “must presume in support of the judgment the existence of every fact the trier
could reasonably deduce from the evidence.” ’ ” (People v. Smith (2005) 37 Cal.4th 733,
739.) “The credibility of witnesses and the weight accorded the evidence are matters within
the province of the trier of fact.” (People v. Ramos (2004) 121 Cal.App.4th 1194, 1207.)
We “ ‘must accept logical inferences that the [trier of fact] might have drawn from the
evidence even if [we] would have concluded otherwise.’ ” (People v. Halvorsen (2007)
42 Cal.4th 379, 419.) “Reversal on this ground is unwarranted unless it appears ‘that upon
no hypothesis whatever is there sufficient substantial evidence to support [the trier of fact’s
finding.]’ ” (People v. Bolin (1998) 18 Cal.4th 297, 331.) “Moreover, unless the testimony
is physically impossible or inherently improbable, testimony of a single witness is sufficient
to support a conviction.” (People v. Young (2005) 34 Cal.4th 1149, 1181.)
The jury was instructed the People had to disprove beyond a reasonable doubt that
defendant believed he was in imminent danger of suffering bodily harm, reasonably
believed force was necessary to defend against the danger, and used no more force than was
reasonable. (CALCRIM No. 3470.) The jury was also instructed that if defendant started
the fight, he had the right to self-defense only if he, in good faith, tried to stop fighting.
(CALCRIM No. 3471.) Finally, the trial court instructed the jury that defendant could not
provoke a quarrel so that he could then excuse his use of force. (CALCRIM No. 3472.)
Substantial evidence supports the jury’s determination that defendant did not act in
lawful self-defense when he battered Anthony A., who had merely intervened to aid Ryan
B., or when he battered Emily L., who came to Anthony A.’s aid. There is substantial
evidence suggesting defendant intentionally incited the fight when he called Ryan B. a
“badass,” invaded his personal space, and refused requests to back away. Moreover, the
evidence also supports an inference defendant acted disproportionately in response to being
pushed back from his unwanted advances by trying to hit Ryan B. three times with a beer
bottle that broke sometime prior to Anthony A.’s intervention either from colliding with
9
Ryan B. or the bar. This disproportionate behavior continued in defendant’s response to
Anthony A.’s command to “knock it off” and grabbing of his swinging arm in an attempt to
stop the fight, to wit, his throwing Anthony A. to the ground and then kicking Emily L.
Having disposed of defendant’s specific complaints and having undertaken an
examination of the entire record pursuant to Wende, we find no arguable errors that are
favorable to defendant. Accordingly, we will affirm the judgment.
DISPOSITION
The judgment is affirmed.
/s/
WISEMAN, J.*
We concur:
/s/
DUARTE, Acting P. J.
/s/
KRAUSE, J.
* Retired Associate Justice of the Court of Appeal, Fifth Appellate District, assigned by the
Chief Justice pursuant to article VI, section 6 of the California Constitution.
10
Vous vous demandez comment ce texte s’applique à votre situation ?
Consultation gratuite, sans engagement
Décrivez votre situation. Notre équipe vous recontactera par e-mail pour votre consultation.
Poursuivez vos recherches dans ChatGPT ou Claude
Connectez Omnilex pour rechercher dans le corpus juridique depuis votre assistant IA.