CourtListener 10286450•In re E.F. CA2/4
Texte intégral
Filed 12/2/24 In re E.F. CA2/4
NOT TO BE PUBLISHED IN THE OFFICIAL REPORTS
California Rules of Court, rule 8.1115(a), prohibits courts and parties from citing or relying on opinions
not certified for publication or ordered published, except as specified by rule 8.1115(b). This opinion
has not been certified for publication or ordered published for purposes of rule 8.1115.
IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA
SECOND APPELLATE DISTRICT
DIVISION FOUR
In re E. F., a Person Coming B328574
Under the Juvenile Court
Law. (Los Angeles County
Super. Ct. Nos.
23LJJP00049,
23LJJP00049A)
LOS ANGELES COUNTY
DEPARTMENT OF
CHILDREN AND FAMILY
SERVICES,
Plaintiff and
Respondent,
v.
V. M.,
Defendant and
Appellant.
APPEAL from a judgment of the Superior Court of
Los Angeles County, Debra L. Gonzales, Judge Pro Tempore.
Dismissed
Benjamin Ekenes, under appointment by the Court of
Appeal, for Defendant and Appellant.
Dawyn R. Harrison, County Counsel, Kim Nemoy,
Assistant County Counsel, Veronica Randazzo, Deputy County
Counsel, for Plaintiff and Respondent.
Mother V.M. challenges the juvenile court’s jurisdictional
findings over her son, E.F., made under Welfare and Institutions
Code section 300, subdivision (b)(1).1 After mother’s appeal was
filed, the juvenile court terminated jurisdiction and issued an exit
order granting mother and father J.F. joint legal and physical
custody of E.F. Mother did not appeal the latter order, and there
is no effective relief that can be granted. We decline to exercise
our inherent discretion to reach the merits and accordingly
dismiss the appeal as moot.
FACTUAL AND PROCEDURAL BACKGROUND
Mother and father are the parents of E.F., who was born in
December 2021. On December 30, 2022, father was arrested for
domestic battery (Pen. Code, § 243, subd. (e)(1)) for allegedly
slapping or pushing mother during an argument in a restaurant
parking lot. The same day, mother was arrested for driving
under the influence (Veh. Code, § 23152) and child endangerment
(Pen. Code, § 273a, subd. (a)) for allegedly driving while
intoxicated. E.F. was in the car, which mother crashed into a
1 All further statutory references are to the Welfare and
Institutions Code unless otherwise indicated.
2
median and road signs. E.F. was released to maternal aunt after
being evaluated at the hospital. He was uninjured.
The Los Angeles County Department of Children and
Family Services (DCFS) investigated the incidents, which
parents denied. The investigation revealed that parents engaged
in a domestic incident in November 2022 and both had previous
misdemeanor convictions for driving under the influence.
Parents agreed to live apart while the matter was pending and
were receptive to participating in services. DCFS noted that
parents seemed remorseful notwithstanding their denials.
On February 7, 2023, DCFS filed a dependency petition
under section 300, subdivisions (a) and (b)(1). It alleged E.F. was
at risk due to parents’ domestic violence (counts a-1, b-1),
mother’s untreated emotional problems and father’s failure to
protect (count b-2), mother’s substance abuse (count b-3),
mother’s driving under the influence (count b-4), father’s driving
under the influence (count b-5), and father’s substance abuse
(count b-6). DCFS did not detain E.F., who remained released to
both parents.
At the initial hearing on February 7, 2023, parents entered
general denials to the allegations and reported they were
participating in services. The juvenile court found there was a
prima facie case that E.F. was a person described by section 300,
but services could prevent his detention. It ordered E.F. to
remain released to both parents, ordered DCFS to make
appropriate referrals, and set the adjudication hearing for April
13, 2023.
DCFS prepared a jurisdiction/disposition report in advance
of the adjudication hearing. E.F. showed no signs of abuse or
neglect and both parents’ homes were appropriate. Mother
refused to answer the dependency investigator’s questions about
the allegations; she referred the investigator to counsel. Father
3
admitted he had argued with mother on December 30, 2022 but
denied a physical altercation. He also said he never saw mother
drink that day and did not know if she put E.F. in danger. He
denied substance abuse issues and driving under the influence
with E.F. Maternal aunt, with whom mother was living, reported
no concerns about E.F.’s well-being. Paternal grandmother and
step-grandfather also denied any safety concerns. DCFS
concluded that E.F. remained at substantial risk and
recommended the court sustain the petition and order family
maintenance services. It also amended count b-4 to allege that
father knew or reasonably should have known that mother
transported E.F. while intoxicated and failed to protect him.
At the April 13, 2023 adjudication hearing, DCFS
proceeded only on counts b-3 and b-4, those concerning mother’s
alleged substance abuse and driving under the influence and
father’s failure to protect E.F. Counsel for DCFS and for E.F.
argued that the court should sustain both counts; both cited
parents’ previous DUIs, denials, and lack of insight. Mother’s
counsel denied the allegations and asserted that there was no
current risk to E.F. Father’s counsel requested that the court
dismiss the petition in its entirety, or, alternatively, dismiss the
failure to protect allegation involving father or adjudicate the
case under section 360, subdivision (b).2
The court stated that it had read and considered the
evidence and counsel’s arguments. It found counts b-3 and b-4
true by a preponderance of the evidence and found E.F. to be a
person described by section 300, subdivision (b). The court
dismissed the remaining allegations. At disposition, the court
2 Section 360, subdivision (b) permits the juvenile court to
order services and supervision for a child under its jurisdiction
without adjudicating the child a dependent of the court.
4
expressed concern that both parents “do not appear to recognize
the seriousness of the incident” and accordingly denied father’s
request to proceed under section 360, subdivision (b). It declared
E.F. a dependent and ordered him released to parents. It further
ordered parents to participate in family maintenance and
preservation services.
Mother filed a notice of appeal immediately following the
hearing. While her appeal was pending, this court granted
DCFS’s request for judicial notice of a November 20, 2023
juvenile court exit order terminating jurisdiction and awarding
parents joint legal and physical custody of E.F. Neither parent
appealed from the exit order.
DCFS subsequently filed a motion to dismiss mother’s
appeal from the jurisdiction and disposition orders as moot.
Mother opposed the motion, arguing that the appeal could be
dismissed only via written opinion and should be heard on the
merits. We deferred ruling on the motion until the matter was
fully briefed and assigned to a panel.
DISCUSSION
“A court is tasked with the duty “‘to decide actual
controversies by a judgment which can be carried into effect, and
not to give opinions upon moot questions or abstract propositions,
or to declare principles or rules of law which cannot affect the
matter in issue in the case before it.’” [Citation.] A case becomes
moot when events ‘“render[ ] it impossible for [a] court, if it
should decide the case in favor of the plaintiff, to grant him any
effect[ive] relief.’” [Citation.]” (In re D.P. (2023) 14 Cal.5th 266,
276 (D.P.).) In a dependency case, “relief is effective when it ‘can
have a practical, tangible impact on the parties’ conduct or legal
status.’ [Citation.]” (Id. at p. 277.)
“Where, as here, the juvenile court terminates its
jurisdiction without issuing any order that continues to impact
5
the parents, the question of whether an appeal can grant the
parents effective relief becomes more difficult.” (D.P., supra, 14
Cal.5th at p. 277.) Depending on the circumstances, an order
terminating juvenile court jurisdiction can render an appeal from
a previous order in a dependency proceeding moot. (In re Rashad
D. (2021) 63 Cal.App.5th 156, 163.) “However, dismissal of a
dependency appeal for mootness following termination of
jurisdiction ‘is not automatic, but “must be decided on a case-by-
case basis.’” [Citation.]” (Ibid.; see also In re S.G. (2021) 71
Cal.App.5th 654, 663–664 [“The termination of juvenile court
jurisdiction does not categorically prevent a reviewing court from
granting effective relief in all cases”].) A parent generally may
not overcome mootness by “complaining of ‘stigma’ alone” or
citing speculative future harm. (D.P., supra, 14 Cal.5th at p.
277.) He or she may demonstrate the availability of effective
relief “where a jurisdictional finding affects parental custody
rights [citation], curtails a parent’s contact with his or her child
[citation], or ‘has resulted in [dispositional] orders which continue
to adversely affect’ a parent [citation].” (Id. at pp. 277-278.) Put
another way, when a parent demonstrates “a specific legal or
practical consequence that will be averted upon reversal, the case
is not moot, and merits review is required.” (Id. at p. 283.)
Mother does not attempt to make such a showing or
otherwise dispute that her appeal is moot. She argues only that
“discretionary review of mother’s challenge to the jurisdictional
findings is appropriate.”
When a dependency case is moot, “courts may exercise their
‘inherent discretion’ to reach the merits of the dispute.” (D.P.,
supra, 14 Cal.5th at p. 282.) “As a rule, courts will generally
exercise their discretion to review a moot case when ‘the case
presents an issue of broad public interest that is likely to recur,’
‘when there may be a recurrence of the controversy between the
6
parties,’ or ‘when a material question remains for the court’s
determination.’ [Citations.]” (Ibid.) We also “may consider
whether the challenged jurisdictional finding ‘could be prejudicial
to the appellant or could potentially impact the current or future
dependency proceedings,’ or ‘“could have other consequences for
[the appellant], beyond jurisdiction.’” (Id. at p. 285.) In addition,
we “may consider the nature of the allegations against the
parent” and “why the appeal became moot,” including whether
the mootness is due to a parent’s prompt compliance with their
case plan or otherwise laudable behavior. (Id. at p. 286.)
Ultimately, we are “guided by the overarching goals of the
dependency system: ‘to provide maximum safety and protection
for children’ with a ‘focus’ on ‘the preservation of the family as
well as the safety, protection, and physical and emotional well-
being of the child.’” (Ibid.; see also id. at p. 287.)
Here, mother contends discretionary review is appropriate
because she promptly and diligently complied with her case plan
and the findings against her are more serious than those
involving father (who did not appeal). We are not persuaded
review is warranted under the circumstances presented here.
Mother has not offered any reason we should consider the appeal
on the merits now that the exit order, which gave parents joint
legal and physical custody over E.F., has become final. Her
appeal does not present an issue of broad public interest, and she
does not argue that there may be a recurrence of the issues
between the parties or that a material question remains. Any
impact that the challenged findings may have in future
proceedings is far too speculative for us to exercise our inherent
discretion to consider the challenged order. (D.P., supra, 14
Cal.5th at p. 282.) We accordingly decline to address the merits
of mother’s appeal.
7
DISPOSITION
The appeal is dismissed as moot.
NOT TO BE PUBLISHED IN THE OFFICIAL REPORTS
COLLINS, J.
We concur:
CURREY, P.J.
MORI, J.
8
Vous vous demandez comment ce texte s’applique à votre situation ?
Consultation gratuite, sans engagement
Décrivez votre situation. Notre équipe vous recontactera par e-mail pour votre consultation.
Poursuivez vos recherches dans ChatGPT ou Claude
Connectez Omnilex pour rechercher dans le corpus juridique depuis votre assistant IA.