CourtListener 10265751•Keegan v. Halpern CA1/1
Texte intégral
Filed 11/5/24 Keegan v. Halpern CA1/1
NOT TO BE PUBLISHED IN OFFICIAL REPORTS
California Rules of Court, rule 8.1115(a), prohibits courts and parties from citing or relying on opinions not certified for
publication or ordered published, except as specified by rule 8.1115(b). This opinion has not been certified for publication or
ordered published for purposes of rule 8.1115.
IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA
FIRST APPELLATE DISTRICT
DIVISION ONE
MOLLY KEEGAN et al.,
Plaintiffs and Appellants,
A169399
v.
NICOLE ALEXANDRA HALPERN, (Alameda County
Super. Ct. No. 23CV045142)
Defendant and Respondent.
Appellants Molly Keegan and Michael Zajonc appeal a judgment in
favor of respondent Nicole Alexandra Halpern after the trial court sustained
her demurrer to appellants’ unlawful detainer complaint without leave to
amend, concluding the notice terminating Halpern’s tenancy was defective
because it did not include certain “safe harbor” information set forth in a
regulation promulgated by the City of Oakland’s Residential Rent
Adjustment Board (the Board). While the enabling ordinance establishes a
defense in an unlawful detainer action for noncompliance with the
ordinance’s notice content requirements, the court erred by implicitly finding
the regulation created a broader defense based on the failure to include in the
termination notice content that is not required by either the ordinance or the
regulation. We therefore reverse.
1
I. BACKGROUND
A. The Rent Adjustment Program and Measure EE
The City of Oakland’s Residential Rent Adjustment Program
Ordinance (rent control ordinance) regulates most residential rent increases
in the city and outlines the process for mediating rent disputes. (Oakland
Mun. Code, § 8.22.010 et seq.)1 It also establishes the Board. (§§ 8.22.020,
8.22.040.) Among the Board’s duties is the development and adoption of
regulations for “implementation” of the rent control ordinance. (§§ 8.22.020,
8.22.040, subd. (D)(2).) The Board is part of the Rent Adjustment Program
(or RAP), which is defined by the rent control ordinance as the city
department that “administers” the ordinance. (§ 8.22.020.)
To “strengthen and effectuate” the rent control ordinance, the city’s
Just Cause for Eviction Ordinance was adopted as initiative Measure EE at
the general election in November 2002. (§ 8.22.320, subd. (2); Rental Housing
Assn. of Northern Alameda County v. City of Oakland (2009) 171 Cal.App.4th
741, 749.) Measure EE was intended to “protect[] tenants against arbitrary,
unreasonable, discriminatory, or retaliatory evictions,” and it prohibits
landlords from terminating a tenancy without good cause. (§§ 8.22.300,
8.22.330.) According to the ordinance, just cause eviction protections would
help prevent landlords from using no cause evictions to evade the rent control
ordinance. (§ 8.22.320, subd. (2).) To that end, Measure EE provides that a
landlord may not evict a tenant except for one of the grounds enumerated
therein. (§ 8.22.360, subd. (A).)
Measure EE also imposes certain content requirements for a notice
terminating tenancy. (§ 8.22.360, subd. (B)(6).) When appellants sought to
1 Undesignated statutory references are to the Oakland Municipal
Code.
2
terminate Halpern’s tenancy, these requirements included, as relevant here,
“[a] statement that advice regarding the notice terminating tenancy is
available from the Rent Board.” (Former § 8.22.360, subd. (B)(6)(b).)2 The
failure to include the required statements in the notice “shall be a defense to
any unlawful detainer action.” (§ 8.22.360, subd. (B)(6)(e).)
B. Regulation B.6.b
The Board adopted regulation 8.22.360, entitled “Good Cause Required
for Eviction.” When appellants served Halpern with a notice terminating
tenancy, section B.6.b (former Regulation B.6.b) of that regulation provided:
“This regulation sets out the preferred language Landlords must insert into
notices terminating tenancy or notices to cure or quit regarding advice from
the Rent Program. As preferred language, the language used in this
regulation is ‘safe harbor’ language that, if used by a Landlord in applicable
notices, cannot be challenged by the Tenant as being not in compliance with
. . . [section] 8.22.360[, subdivision] B.6.b. Other language imparting the
same information may also be acceptable.”
Former Regulation B.6.b continues in a separate subparagraph: “The
following statement must be included in notices terminating tenancy or
notices to cure or quit regarding advice from the Rent Program. ‘Information
regarding evictions is available from the City of Oakland’s Rent Program.
2 Section 8.22.360, subdivision (B)(6)(b) was amended in 2023, after
appellants served Halpern with the notice terminating tenancy in 2022.
(Oakland Ord. No. 13737.) Appellants ask us to take judicial notice of
Oakland Ordinance No. 13737 because in Halpern’s response brief, she refers
to specific language the ordinance added to Measure EE. We grant
appellants’ unopposed request for judicial notice. We additionally note that
Regulation 8.22.360 was amended in 2024. We refer to the ordinance and
regulation as they existed when appellants sought to terminate Halpern’s
tenancy.
3
Parties seeking legal advice concerning evictions should consult with an
attorney. The Rent Program is located at 250 Frank H. Ogawa Plaza,
Suite 3315, Oakland, CA 94612, (510) 238-3501, website:
www.oaklandnet.com. (as of January 2004.)’ ”
C. Trial Court Proceedings
In September 2023, appellants filed an unlawful detainer suit against
Halpern. The complaint attached the notice terminating tenancy that
appellants served on Halpern a year earlier. The notice stated, among other
things, that “[a]dvice concerning this Notice is available from the City of
Oakland Residential Rent Adjustment Program, located at 250 Frank H.
Ogawa Plaza # 5313, Oakland, CA 94612, and available by phone at (510)
238-3721.”3
Halpern demurred to the complaint, arguing that the notice
terminating tenancy failed to comply with former Regulation B.6.b because it
did not include RAP’s website or the advisement to consult an attorney if
seeking legal advice. In opposition, appellants argued that they complied
with the regulation because they provided sufficient contact information for a
reasonable person to find RAP. They also noted that the uniform resource
locator (URL) set forth in former Regulation B.6.b. was broken. They further
contended that Halpern was equitably estopped from claiming the notice was
inadequate because after she received the notice, she sought and obtained
additional relocation assistance and an extension of eight months for the date
of withdrawal of the unit. Finally, appellants argued that the Ellis Act (Gov.
3 The suite number for RAP’s address and the phone number included
in the termination notice differ from that set forth in former
Regulation B.6.b. Halpern did not challenge those portions of the notice in
the trial court, and it appears the information may have been correct anyway
based on the current version of Regulation B.6.b.
4
Code, § 7060 et seq.) preempted the notice requirement in Measure EE and
former Regulation B.6.b.
The trial court sustained Halpern’s demurrer without leave to amend.
It concluded that while appellants were not required to use the language set
forth in former Regulation B.6.b verbatim, their notice of termination was
legally deficient because it did not provide Halpern with the URL for RAP’s
website or advise her to consult an attorney if seeking legal advice. The court
entered judgment in favor of Halpern.
II. DISCUSSION
A. Standard of Review
We review the order sustaining the demurrer de novo. (Aguilera v.
Heiman (2009) 174 Cal.App.4th 590, 595.) We assume the truth of all
properly pleaded facts alleged in the complaint, but not conclusory factual or
legal allegations contained therein. (Barnett v. Fireman’s Fund Ins. Co.
(2001) 90 Cal.App.4th 500, 504–505.) Additionally, we ignore the allegations
that conflict with the content of the complaint’s exhibits. (Id. at p. 505.)
Appellants bear the burden of demonstrating that the trial court erred.
(Aguilera, at p. 595.)
B. Former Regulation B.6.b Did Not Impose Additional Notice
Content Requirements
Appellants focus their briefing on the issues of whether former
Regulation B.6.b exceeded the scope of the Board’s rulemaking authority,
whether the regulation was preempted by the Ellis Act, and whether they
substantially complied with the regulation, but we turn first to the threshold
issue of whether former Regulation B.6.b created notice content requirements
in addition to those set forth in Measure EE that landlords must comply with
to avoid a defense in an unlawful detainer proceeding. By sustaining
5
Halpern’s demurrer on the ground that the notice terminating tenancy did
not include the URL for RAP’s website and language advising her to consult
an attorney if seeking legal advice, the trial court implicitly concluded that it
did. Reviewing former Regulation B.6.b de novo (Manriquez v. Gourley (2003)
105 Cal.App.4th 1227, 1234), we reach the opposite conclusion.
There is no dispute that appellants complied with former
section 8.22.360, subdivision (B)(6)(b) of Measure EE by including in the
notice “[a] statement that advice regarding the notice terminating tenancy is
available from the Rent Board.” (Former § 8.22.360, subd. (B)(6)(b).) The
notice stated that “[a]dvice concerning this Notice is available from the City
of Oakland Residential Rent Adjustment Program” (of which the Board is a
part), and it also included RAP’s phone number and address. On the face of
Measure EE, appellants’ termination notice was sufficient to avoid an
unlawful detainer defense under the ordinance because Measure EE states
only that the failure to include the statement required by the ordinance
“shall be a defense to any unlawful detainer action.” (§ 8.22.360,
subd. (B)(6)(e).) Halpern did not claim otherwise in her demurrer.
Halpern contends, however, as she did in the trial court, that former
section 8.22.360, subdivision (B)(6)(b) of Measure EE established a “floor” for
the information that must be included in the notice terminating tenancy, and
that former Regulation B.6.b created additional notice content requirements.
Specifically, she points to the first and third sentences of former
Regulation B.6.b as evidence of the Board’s intent to require that termination
notices include certain categories of information. Halpern appears to be
arguing that appellants’ failure to include in the termination notice all of the
information set forth in former Regulation B.6.b’s “preferred” language
established a defense to their unlawful detainer complaint, even though
6
Measure EE does not require landlords to include that information in
termination notices to prevent a defense. (§ 8.22.360, subd. (B)(6).) In other
words, she is interpreting former Regulation B.6.b as creating a defense in
unlawful detainer proceedings separate from or broader than the defense set
forth in section 8.22.360, subdivision (B)(6) of Measure EE. We disagree with
this interpretation.
In construing former Regulation B.6.b, our task is to determine the
Board’s intent in promulgating the regulation. (Manriquez v. Gourley, supra,
105 Cal.App.4th at p. 1235.) Generally, we apply the same rules governing
interpretation of statutes to the interpretation of regulations. (Berkeley
Hillside Preservation v. City of Berkeley (2015) 60 Cal.4th 1086, 1097.) “ ‘We
give the regulatory language its plain, commonsense meaning. If possible, we
must accord meaning to every word and phrase in a regulation, and we must
read regulations as a whole so that all of the parts are given effect.
[Citation.] If the regulatory language is clear and unambiguous, our task is
at an end, and there is no need to resort to canons of construction and
extrinsic aids to interpretation. [Citation.]’ . . . When [the agency’s] intent
‘cannot be discerned directly from the language of the regulation, we may
look to a variety of extrinsic aids, including the purpose of the regulation, the
legislative history, public policy, and the regulatory scheme of which the
regulation is a part.’ ” (Hoitt v. Department of Rehabilitation (2012)
207 Cal.App.4th 513, 523, disagreed with on another ground by State Farm
General Ins. Co. v. Lara (2021) 71 Cal.App.5th 148, 185, fn 19.)
Looking to the language of former Regulation B.6.b, the first sentence
states that the regulation “sets out the preferred language Landlords must
insert into notices terminating tenancy or notices to cure or quit regarding
advice from the Rent Program.” (Italics added.) Halpern appears to focus on
7
this sentence and its use of the term “must” as support for her argument that
former Regulation B.6.b created an unlawful detainer defense based on the
failure to include in the notice terminating tenancy the additional
information set forth in the regulation’s preferred language.
We acknowledge that former Regulation B.6.b’s first sentence, when
read in isolation, is arguably ambiguous as to whether the Board intended to
require landlords to include the regulation’s preferred language in notices
terminating tenancy. However, basic principles of statutory construction
require us to interpret the regulation as a whole so as to “ ‘determine its
scope and purpose and to harmonize the various parts of the enactment.’ ”
(Jarman v. HCR ManorCare, Inc. (2020) 10 Cal.5th 375, 381; see County of
Sacramento v. Pacific Gas & Electric Co. (1987) 193 Cal.App.3d 300, 309
[“[T]he plain meaning rule does not compel rote application of the common
meaning of words without regard to the context in which they are used.”].)
When the first sentence of former Regulation B.6.b is viewed together
with the rest of the regulation, it becomes clear that the regulation merely
creates one way in which landlords can comply with former section 8.22.360,
subdivision (B)(6)(b) of Measure EE.
The next sentence in former Regulation B.6.b clarifies that “preferred
language” means “ ‘safe harbor’ language that, if used by a Landlord in
applicable notices, cannot be challenged by the Tenant as being not in
compliance with [section] 8.22.360[, subdivision] B.6.b.” The plain meaning
of this sentence establishes that use of the “preferred language” referred to in
the preceding sentence does no more than allow landlords to avoid an
unlawful detainer defense based on noncompliance with former section
8.22.360, subdivision (B)(6)(b) of Measure EE. Nowhere does the regulation
expressly state the inverse, that the failure to include the preferred language
8
in a termination notice provides a defense in unlawful detainer proceedings.
That this sentence says use of the preferred language prevents a defense
under section “8.22.360[, subdivision] B.6.b” suggests instead that the
regulation itself was not intended to create an unlawful detainer defense
separate from or broader than that provided in Measure EE. Had the Board
intended to create a defense based on noncompliance with the preferred
language, it could have easily said so. (See People v. Superior Court (Romero)
(1996) 13 Cal.4th 497, 520 [had the Legislature “wanted to authorize a
motion to dismiss . . . without invoking” a specified statute “it could easily
have done so simply by deleting” reference to that statute].)
The third and final sentence in the first paragraph of former
Regulation B.6.b states, “Other language imparting the same information
may also be acceptable.” Because the preceding sentence establishes that the
purpose of the regulation’s “preferred language” is to provide safe harbor
protection to landlords, the phrase “[o]ther language imparting the same
information may also be acceptable” appears to specify that other language
may also provide safe harbor protection.
Significantly, the plain meaning of former Regulation B.6.b’s third
sentence—that language other than the regulation’s preferred language may
be acceptable under the regulation—is irreconcilable with a conclusion that
the regulation’s first sentence was intended to mandate inclusion of the
preferred language in termination notices to prevent a defense in unlawful
detainer proceedings. Construing those sentences together and in context of
the entire regulation, a more logical reading of the first sentence is that
landlords must include the preferred language in notices terminating tenancy
to guarantee they receive safe harbor protection under the regulation. Such a
construction internally harmonizes former Regulation B.6.b (Dyna-Med, Inc.
9
v. Fair Employment & Housing Com. (1987) 43 Cal.3d 1379, 1387 [statutes
must be harmonized where possible], superseded by statute on another issue)
and gives meaning to the phrase “may also be acceptable” in the third
sentence—contrasted with the first sentence’s use of “must”—by suggesting
that using other language in termination notices does not ensure safe harbor
protection (Sonoma County Bd. of Education v. Public Employment Relations
Bd. (1980) 102 Cal.App.3d 689, 701 [“significance should be given to every
word, phrase, sentence, and part of an act”]).
After this first paragraph in former Regulation B.6.b is a subparagraph
that sets forth the regulation’s preferred language, which includes the URL
for RAP’s website and language advising parties to consult an attorney if
seeking legal advice. Mirroring the first sentence of the previous paragraph,
this subparagraph begins, “The following statement must be included in
notices terminating tenancy or notices to cure or quit regarding advice from
the Rent Program.” The placement of this language in a subparagraph with
the regulation’s preferred language after having already established that the
purpose of the preferred language is to provide safe harbor protection
supports an inference that this sentence was merely intended to make
explicit that landlords must use the preferred language to guarantee that
they receive safe harbor protection under the regulation. (See Woodland
Park Management, LLC v. City of East Palo Alto Rent Stabilization Bd.
(2010) 181 Cal.App.4th 915, 923, fn. 5 [where the intended application of a
statute is doubtful, “organization . . . may properly be considered in
determining intent”].)
In sum, former Regulation B.6.b, when read as a whole, does not create
a defense different from that set forth in section 8.22.360,
subdivision (B)(6)(e) of Measure EE and instead provides one way—but not
10
the only way—in which landlords can comply with former section 8.22.360,
subdivision (B)(6)(b) of the ordinance. In reaching that determination, we
achieve harmony between the various parts of former Regulation B.6.b, and
every word and phrase serves a function.
Further, it is a fundamental rule of construction that courts “ ‘must
select the construction that comports most closely with the apparent intent of
the Legislature, with a view to promoting rather than defeating the general
purpose of the statute, and avoid an interpretation that would lead to absurd
consequences.’ ” (People v. Hernandez (2021) 60 Cal.App.5th 94, 106,
abrogated on another ground by People v. Lewis (2021) 11 Cal.5th 952, 961–
962; accord, Coso Energy Developers v. County of Inyo (2004) 122 Cal.App.4th
1512, 1527, 1528 [courts should adopt an interpretation that avoids “absurd
consequences”]; Woodland Park Management, LLC v. City of East Palo Alto
Rent Stabilization Bd., supra, 181 Cal.App.4th at p. 920 [same].)
Halpern’s proposed construction would lead to such results. This is
because former Regulation B.6.b’s preferred language does not include a
statement that “advice regarding the notice terminating tenancy is available
from the Rent Board,” as required by Measure EE for notices terminating
tenancy. (Former § 8.22.360, subd. (B)(6)(b), italics added.) Instead, former
Regulation B.6.b’s preferred language is much broader, stating that
“ ‘[i]nformation regarding evictions is available from the City of Oakland’s
Rent Program.’ ” (Italics added.) Under Halpern’s interpretation of former
Regulation B.6.b, a tenant may have a defense in an unlawful detainer action
on the ground that the termination notice failed to include this specific
language, even if the notice contained a statement that advice regarding the
notice terminating tenancy is available from the Rent Board. The Board
could not have intended such an absurd result. Although former
11
Regulation B.6.b states that “[o]ther language imparting the same
information may also be acceptable,” courts will not necessarily conclude that
a statement that “advice regarding the notice terminating tenancy is
available from the Rent Board” imparts the same information as the
regulation’s preferred language, given the breadth of the latter. (Former
§ 8.22.360, subd. (B)(6)(b).) Accordingly, we assume the Board did not intend
to create an unlawful detainer defense based on noncompliance with former
Regulation B.6.b.
Because we conclude that former Regulation B.6.b does not establish
an unlawful detainer defense based on the failure to include in the notice
terminating tenancy the information set forth in the regulation’s preferred
language, and because it is undisputed that appellants complied with
Measure EE’s notice content requirements, we must reverse the trial court’s
order sustaining Halpern’s demurrer without leave to amend.4
III. DISPOSITION
The judgment is reversed, and the matter is remanded to the trial court
with directions to vacate its November 13, 2023 order sustaining without
leave to amend Halpern’s demurrer to the complaint and to enter a new order
overruling the demurrer. Appellants shall recover their costs on appeal.
(Cal. Rules of Court, rule 8.278(a)(1), (2).)
4 Given our determination that former Regulation B.6.b did not create
an additional unlawful detainer defense, we need not specifically address
other issues in appellants’ briefing regarding whether former
Regulation B.6.b exceeded the scope of the Board’s rulemaking authority or
whether the regulation was preempted by the Ellis Act.
12
LANGHORNE WILSON, J.
WE CONCUR:
HUMES, P. J.
BANKE, J.
A169399
Keegan v. Halpern
13
Vous vous demandez comment ce texte s’applique à votre situation ?
Consultation gratuite, sans engagement
Décrivez votre situation. Notre équipe vous recontactera par e-mail pour votre consultation.
Poursuivez vos recherches dans ChatGPT ou Claude
Connectez Omnilex pour rechercher dans le corpus juridique depuis votre assistant IA.