CourtListener 10121070•Anoke v. Twitter
Texte intégral
Filed 8/27/24; Modified and Certified for Pub. 9/18/24 (order attached)
IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA
FIRST APPELLATE DISTRICT
DIVISION FIVE
SARAH ANOKE et al.,
Plaintiffs and Appellants,
A168675
v.
TWITTER, INC., et al., (City and County of San Francisco
Super. Ct. No. CPF23518034)
Defendants and Respondents.
To discourage delays in arbitrations, Code of Civil
Procedure section 1281.971 provides a remedy when a company’s
share of the initial arbitration fees “are not paid within 30 days”
of the invoice. (§ 1281.97, subds. (a)(1), (b).) In an employment-
related arbitration, counsel for appellant employees mistakenly
paid initial fees that should have been paid by the employer,
respondents Twitter, Inc., X Holdings I, Inc., X Holdings Corp., X
Corp., and Elon Musk (collectively “X”). Upon receipt of that
payment, the arbitration provider marked the invoice “[c]losed”
and “[p]aid” in its online payment system. In response to the
payment snafu, the arbitration provider refunded the mistaken
payment to the employees and issued a new invoice to X, which X
paid within 30 days. Appellants petitioned the superior court for
an order compelling X to pay their arbitration-related attorney
1 Undesignated statutory references are to the Code of Civil
Procedure.
1
fees and costs pursuant to section 1281.97, arguing that X’s
payment was untimely because it was not made within 30 days of
the first invoice. (§ 1281.97, subds. (a)-(b).) The superior court
denied the petition. We affirm.
BACKGROUND
A.
Appellants Sarah Anoke and other current or former
employees (collectively “Anoke”) initiated arbitration proceedings
with Judicial Arbitration and Mediation Services (“the
arbitrator”) to resolve employment-related disputes with X.
Anoke’s employment contract with X provides for arbitration of
such disputes.
On March 7, 2023, the arbitrator emailed an invoice for
$27,200, X’s share of the initial fees for the 15 individual
arbitrations here, to all counsel. The invoice stated that
“[p]ayment is due upon receipt.” Anoke’s counsel mistakenly paid
the invoice the same day. As a result, when X’s counsel accessed
the arbitrator’s online portal on March 8, the system listed the
status of the invoice as “[c]losed” and indicated that $27,200 had
been “[p]aid” on the invoice.
Anoke’s counsel notified the arbitrator of the error on
March 8, and the arbitrator issued a refund check on March 21.
Anoke’s counsel apparently did not notify X that it had paid the
fees or requested a refund. Notwithstanding the refund, when
the arbitrator emailed counsel for both parties near the end of
March to schedule an initial administrative call, the arbitrator
represented that “ ‘[t]he initial filing fees . . . have now been paid.’
”
On April 11, the arbitrator emailed counsel for both parties,
stating that “[i]t appears [the] billing department may have
nulled the original invoice” for the case-opening fees. The email
included, as an attachment, a second invoice for X’s share of the
2
case initiation fees, $27,200. The new invoice, dated April 7,
indicated that “[p]ayment is due upon receipt.” The arbitrator’s
online portal continued to list the earlier invoice as “[c]losed” and
“[p]aid.”
On May 5, X remitted payment on the April 7 invoice.
B.
In the superior court, Anoke filed a motion to compel an
arbitration in which X is liable for her reasonable attorney fees
and costs, a remedy for untimely payment under section 1281.97,
subdivision (b)(2).
After a hearing, the court denied relief. The court reasoned
that, because the arbitrator nullified the first invoice after
Anoke’s attorney mistakenly paid it, and X timely paid the
second invoice, X met the statutory deadline.
DISCUSSION
Anoke argues that X failed to timely pay the arbitration
fees as required by section 1281.97. We disagree.
Given that the facts are undisputed, we review de novo the
trial court’s interpretation and application of section 1281.97.
(See De Leon v. Juanita’s Foods (2022) 85 Cal.App.5th 740, 749.)
Our task in construing the statute is to effectuate the
Legislature’s intent, beginning with the statute’s words and
giving the text its ordinary meaning. (See Moran v. Murtaugh
Miller Meyer & Nelson, LLP (2007) 40 Cal.4th 780, 783.)
The purpose of section 1281.97 is “[t]o avoid delay” from
nonpayment of the fees needed at the outset of an arbitration,
encouraging efficient and prompt resolution of disputes subject to
arbitration. (See § 1281.97, subd. (a)(2); see also Stats. 2019, ch.
870, § 1(c).) Our Legislature recognized that “[a] company’s
strategic non-payment of [arbitration] fees and costs severely
prejudices the ability of employees or consumers to vindicate
3
their rights,” particularly when the company refusing to pay the
fees is the party who insisted on arbitration in the first place.
(See Stats. 2019, ch. 870, § 1(d); see also Williams v. West Coast
Hospitals, Inc. (2022) 86 Cal.App.5th 1054, 1073-1074
(Williams).) By “provid[ing] employees and consumers remedies
if a drafting party refuses to pay,” the statute seeks “[t]o ensure
that a drafting party cannot unilaterally prevent a party from
adjudicating their claims” in arbitration. (Assem. Com. on Jud.,
Analysis of Sen. Bill No. 707 (2019-2020 Reg. Sess.) as amended
May 20, 2019, p. 8.)
Accordingly, section 1281.97 establishes a 30-day time
frame for payment of the fees required to initiate an employment
or consumer arbitration. As the party that imposed the
arbitration clause, the statute refers to X as the “drafting party.”
(§§ 1280, subd. (e), 1281.97, subd. (a)(1).) If the fees “are not paid
within 30 days after the due date the drafting party is in material
breach of the arbitration agreement, is in default of the
arbitration, and waives its right to compel arbitration[.]” (§
1281.97, subd. (a)(1).) When the drafting party is in default, the
employee or consumer may (as applicable here) compel an
arbitration in which the drafting party is liable for reasonable
attorney fees and costs. (§ 1281.97, subd. (b)(2).)2
Importantly, the “due date” that triggers the 30-day grace
period is set by an invoice from the arbitration provider. Once an
employee or consumer initiates an arbitration, the arbitration
provider must “immediately provide an invoice for any fees and
costs required before the arbitration can proceed to all of the
2 Like section 1281.97, which concerns payment of fees to
initiate an arbitration, section 1281.98 contains an analogous
framework for payment of arbitration fees necessary to continue
an arbitration; because the analysis under these provisions is
parallel, we rely on case law interpreting both provisions. (See,
e.g., Cvejic v. Skyview Capital, LLC (2023) 92 Cal.App.5th 1073,
1077 (Cvejic); Williams, supra, 86 Cal.App.5th at pp. 1065-1066.)
4
parties to the arbitration.” (§ 1281.97, subd. (a)(2).) “To avoid
delay” the arbitration provider must issue the invoices “to the
parties as due upon receipt,” unless the agreement states
otherwise. (Ibid.) In sum, a default occurs when the arbitration
fees go unpaid for 31 days after “the due date” (§ 1281.97, subd.
(a)(1)) set by an arbitration provider’s “invoice.” (§ 1281.97, subd.
(a)(2).)
That never happened here. After the arbitrator issued the
first invoice, properly marked due upon receipt, Anoke’s counsel
immediately paid the invoice in full. When the arbitrator issued
a new invoice, also marked due upon receipt, X paid the fees
within 30 days. Neither invoice was ever past due for 31 days, as
the statute requires for a default.
Anoke makes several arguments. None has merit.
First, she argues that the statute requires payment of the
fees, not the invoice. That’s true, as far as it goes. But the
invoice sets the “due date,” and thus also the 30-day grace period
that determines whether a payment is late. (§ 1281.97, subds.
(a)(1)-(2).) Here, there were two invoices, two due dates, and two
payments—and both payments were within the statutory grace
period set by the relevant invoices.
This brings us to Anoke’s second argument: she contends
the arbitrator had no authority to issue a second invoice. By
issuing a second invoice, she says, the arbitrator extended the
grace period on the due date beyond 30 days. Arbitrators cannot
cure a default by extending the statutory 30-day grace period.
(See Hohenshelt v. Superior Court (2024) 99 Cal.App.5th 1319,
1324-1325, review granted June 12, 2024, S284498; Cvejic, supra,
92 Cal.App.5th at pp. 1075, 1078.)
Here, however, the arbitrator did not try to cure a default
or extend a 30-day grace period. There was no missed payment.
Anoke fails to accept responsibility for the fact that it was her
5
attorney who timely paid the first invoice. The statute did not
bar the arbitrator from accepting that payment. At that point, as
far as the statute goes, the arbitrator had nothing more to do.
The arbitration could proceed without delay, which it did. The
arbitrator marked the invoice “paid” and “closed,” which it was.
When Anoke’s counsel then demanded a refund, her counsel put
the arbitrator back to square one. The statute does not tell the
arbitrator what to do when a timely payment is refunded. The
arbitrator made a rational decision to issue a new invoice “due
upon receipt,” which X paid within the statutory grace period. (§
1281.97, subds. (a)(1)-(2).) The circumstances are unusual (and
unlikely to be repeated, surely), but we cannot fault the
arbitrator. Even if it could have somehow reinstated the first
invoice after it had been paid and closed, Anoke does not
persuade us that the statute required it to do so.
Third, Anoke contends her attorney never “paid” the
invoice within the meaning of the statute. Only a payment by X
would satisfy the statute, she says, because it was responsible for
paying the fees.
In these unique circumstances, we conclude that Anoke’s
counsel “paid” the first invoice. As Anoke acknowledges, the
reasons for a late payment are irrelevant. (See Espinoza v.
Superior Court (2022) 83 Cal.App.5th 761, 775-776; Williams,
supra, 86 Cal.App.5th at p. 1074.) In our view, the reasons for a
timely payment are likewise irrelevant. The statute employs
passive voice for the critical language (“if the fees or costs . . . are
not paid within 30 days”). (§ 1281.97, subd. (a)(1)).) When the
Legislature uses passive voice, it suggests the condition turns on
whether the event occurs, not how or why it occurs. (See Rey v.
Madera Unified School Dist. (2012) 203 Cal.App.4th 1223, 1233;
Dean v. United States (2009) 556 U.S. 568, 572.) Indeed, when
the Legislature elects to use passive voice for some statutory
requirements and active voice for others, that contrast
6
underscores the Legislature’s intent that some actions must be
personally taken by the actor while others need not be. (See Capo
for Better Representation v. Kelley (2008) 158 Cal.App.4th 1455,
1462.)
Here, section 1281.97, subdivision (a)(1) uses passive voice
to describe the condition (“if the fees or costs . . . are not paid”)
but active voice to describe the consequences (“the drafting party
is in material breach . . . , is in default . . . , and waives its right
to compel arbitration”). The switch in voices indicates that, if the
fees are not paid—regardless of how or why—the drafting party
bears the consequences. But for purposes of determining
whether a breach has occurred, section 1281.97 turns on whether
the fees were paid within 30 days of the invoice’s due date—not
how they were paid or why.
In fact, at oral argument, Anoke conceded that an employee
might choose to pay the fees—to accelerate the arbitration
process, for example—and that the drafting party would then be
off the hook for the fees. In that case, she says the drafting party
is responsible for paying the fees (according to the due date in the
first invoice) only when the employee mistakenly paid the fees
and obtained a refund. This undercuts Anoke’s position that the
statute assigns sole responsibility for paying the fees to the
drafting party. It also would expose the process to
gamesmanship where, for example, the employee delays
obtaining the refund until the 30-day deadline has almost run.
Moreover, to adopt Anoke’s position would require us to
ignore the Legislature’s scheme for setting, and putting parties
on notice of, the statutory deadline. As explained, the statute ties
the 30-day deadline to an invoice from the arbitrator. (§ 1281.97,
subd. (a)(2).) The Legislature could have set a deadline based on
some other fixed event, like the date the employee met the initial
filing requirements. (See ibid.) By instead tying the 30-day
deadline to an arbitrator’s invoice, it leveraged the existing
7
business practice by which companies bill each other. Here, a
mistaken payment resulted in a second invoice, which is
consistent with ordinary business billing practices. We are not
going to rewrite the statute to say that, in the event one invoice is
mistakenly paid, a second invoice is improper.
We affirm the superior court’s order. Accordingly, we do
not reach X’s alternative arguments.
DISPOSITION
The order denying Anoke’s motion to compel arbitration is
affirmed.
BURNS, J.
WE CONCUR:
SIMONS, ACTING P.J.
CHOU, J.
Anoke et al. v. Twitter et al. (A168675)
8
Filed 9/18/24
CERTIFIED FOR PUBLICATION
IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA
FIRST APPELLATE DISTRICT
DIVISION FIVE
SARAH ANOKE et al., A168675
Plaintiffs and Appellants,
(City and County of San Francisco
v. Super. Ct. No. CPF23518034)
TWITTER, INC., et al.,
ORDER CERTIFYING
Defendants and Respondents.
OPINION FOR PUBLICATION
AND MODIFYING OPINION
[NO CHANGE IN JUDGMENT]
THE COURT:
The opinion in the above-entitled matter, filed on August 27,
2024, was not certified for publication in the Official Reports. On
September 16, 2024, a request for publication was received from
respondents pursuant to California Rules of Court, rule 8.1120(a). We
accepted the request for publication for filing.
For good causing appearing, this court grants the publication
request and orders the opinion (as modified below) certified for
publication pursuant to California Rules of Court, rule 8.1105(b), (c).
The opinion filed on August 27, 2024, shall be MODIFIED as
follows:
1. In the last paragraph on page six, the fifth sentence is
modified to read as follows: “When the Legislature uses
1
passive voice, it may suggest the condition turns on
whether the event occurs, not how or why it occurs.”
2. In the same paragraph, the sixth sentence, which begins at
the bottom of page six and continues into page seven, is
modified to read as follows: “Indeed, in some contexts when
the Legislature elects to use passive voice for some
statutory requirements and active voice for others, that
contrast may reflect the Legislature’s intent that some
actions must be personally taken by the actor while others
need not be.”
3. On page seven, the parenthetical citation following the
sentence modified in item 2 above is modified to read as
follows: “(See Capo for Better Representation v. Kelley
(2008) 158 Cal.App.4th 1455, 1462; but see Cohen v.
Superior Court (2024) 102 Cal.App.5th 706, 722.)”
4. On page seven, in the second full paragraph, the second
and third sentences are modified to read as follows: “In that
case, she says the drafting party is responsible for paying
the fees (according to the due date in the first invoice) only
if the employee later obtains a refund. This contradicts
Anoke’s position that only a payment by the drafting party
can satisfy the statute.”
The modifications make no change to the judgment.
BURNS, J.
WE CONCUR:
SIMONS, ACTING P.J.
CHOU, J.
Anoke et al. v. Twitter et al. (A168675)
2
Superior Court of the City and County of San Francisco, No.
CPF23518034, The Hon. Richard B. Ulmer, Jr.
Ethan Jacobs Law Corporation, Ethan Jacobs, for Plaintiffs and
Appellants.
Morgan, Lewis & Bockius LLP, Eric Meckley and Michael E.
Kenneally, for Defendants and Respondents.
3
Vous vous demandez comment ce texte s’applique à votre situation ?
Consultation gratuite, sans engagement
Décrivez votre situation. Notre équipe vous recontactera par e-mail pour votre consultation.
Poursuivez vos recherches dans ChatGPT ou Claude
Connectez Omnilex pour rechercher dans le corpus juridique depuis votre assistant IA.