CourtListener 10045125•Rotter v. Bauer CA2/6
Texte intégral
Filed 8/19/24 Rotter v. Bauer CA2/6
NOT TO BE PUBLISHED IN THE OFFICIAL REPORTS
California Rules of Court, rule 8.1115(a), prohibits courts and parties from citing or relying on opinions
not certified for publication or ordered published, except as specified by rule 8.1115(b). This opinion
has not been certified for publication or ordered published for purposes of rule 8.1115.
IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA
SECOND APPELLATE DISTRICT
DIVISION SIX
SAM ROTTER, 2d Civ. No. B322981
(Super. Ct. No. 56-2021-
Plaintiff and Appellant, 00553372-CU-MC-VTA)
(Ventura County)
v.
ALEXANDRA BAUER, etc.,
Defendant and Respondent.
Sam Rotter filed an action against “Alexandra Bauer, In
her Official Capacity as Acting Director of the County of Los
Angeles . . . Child Support Services Department,” hereafter
“respondent.” Proceeding in propria persona, Rotter appeals from
the judgment entered after the trial court sustained respondent’s
demurrer without leave to amend. Appellant contends the trial
court erroneously concluded that his action is barred because he
failed to comply with the Government Claims Act. (Gov. Code,
§ 900 et seq.)
Respondent moved to dismiss the appeal because appellant
was declared a vexatious litigant and had failed to comply with a
prefiling order. We deny the motion, but affirm the judgment.1
Motion to Dismiss Appeal
On November 29, 2022, the Ventura County Superior Court
declared appellant a vexatious litigant. The superior court
entered a prefiling order prohibiting appellant “from filing any
new litigation in the courts of this state in propria persona
without first obtaining leave of the presiding justice . . . of the
court where the litigation is proposed to be filed.” (Code Civ.
Proc., § 391.7, subd. (a).) “‘Litigation’ for purposes of vexatious
litigant requirements . . . includes proceedings initiated in the
Courts of Appeal by notice of appeal . . . .” (McColm v. Westwood
Park Assn. (1998) 62 Cal.App.4th 1211, 1219, disapproved on
other grounds in John v. Superior Court (2016) 63 Cal.4th 91, 99,
fn. 2.)
Code of Civil Procedure section 391.7, subdvision (b)
provides that, if a prefiling order has been entered, “[t]he
presiding justice . . . shall permit the filing of [new] litigation only
if it appears that the litigation has merit and has not been filed
for the purposes of harassment or delay. The presiding
justice . . . may condition the filing of the litigation upon the
furnishing of security for the benefit of the defendants . . . .”
Respondent contends appellant violated the prefiling order
because “[a]fter [he] was declared a vexatious litigant, on June 1,
2023, [he] filed [the instant] Appeal” without first obtaining “this
Court’s permission.” Thus, respondent has moved to “dismiss
1 We grant respondent’s motion to augment the record filed
October 3, 2023.
2
this Appeal.” If it is not dismissed, respondent has requested
that appellant “furnish security in the amount of $10,000.”
Respondent erroneously asserts that this appeal was filed
on June 1, 2023. On that date appellant filed his opening brief.
The record shows that an amended notice of appeal was filed on
September 7, 2022, more than two months before he was declared
a vexatious litigant. In an order dated November 2, 2022, this
court stated: “It appears appellant intends to appeal the
judgment entered July 29, 2022, as stated in his amended notice
of appeal filed September 7, 2022.”
Accordingly, appellant did not violate the prefiling order
because he filed his notice of appeal before he was declared a
vexatious litigant. We therefore deny respondent’s motion. (See
Forrest v. Department of Corporations (2007) 150 Cal.App.4th
183, 196, disapproved on other grounds in Shalant v. Girardi
(2011) 51 Cal.4th 1164, 1172, fn. 3 [“In the context of this
statutory scheme, the word ‘new’ [in Code of Civil Procedure
section 391.7, subdivision (a)] plainly refers to a civil lawsuit filed
after entry of the prefiling order”].)
Appellant’s Second Amended Complaint
The operative pleading is appellant’s second amended
complaint (SAC), which consists of the following four causes of
action:
First cause of action: Respondent failed to perform a
mandatory duty in violation of Family Code sections 4951,
subdivision (a) and 5700.605. Section 4951 was repealed effective
January 1, 2016. (Stats. 2015, ch. 493, § 2.) Section 5700.605,
subdivision (a) provides, “When a support order or income-
withholding order issued in another state . . . is registered, the
3
registering tribunal of this state shall notify the nonregistering
party.”
Second cause of action: Respondent made negligent
misrepresentations that she was “empowered with enforcement
authority to intercept payments” to appellant made by Social
Security and the Employment Development Department (EDD).
“As a result, [appellant] lost approximately $12,747 to date from
Social Security and approximately $4,800 to date from EDD.”
Third cause of action: Respondent “negligently interfered
with a relationship between [appellant] and at least 3
architectural employers” by “improperly garnish[ing]” his wages.
Fourth cause of action: We cannot ascertain the nature of
appellant’s fourth cause of action.
Fifth cause of action: Respondent violated Civil Code
section 1798.24 because she provided “personal information to
other agencies; in state, out of state, and federal.” Section
1798.24 provides, “An agency shall not disclose any personal
information in a manner that would link the information
disclosed to the individual to whom it pertains unless the
information is disclosed” as specified in section 1798.24.
Appellant sought to recover his lost income. He claimed,
“Grand totals of out-of-pocket losses including lost income and
EDD and [social security] amount to approximately $2,376,000.”
Appellant also sought injunctive and declaratory relief as well as
punitive damages.
Respondent’s Demurrer
In her demurrer to the SAC, respondent contended that the
first, second, third, and fifth causes of action are barred because
appellant failed to comply with the Government Claims Act. As
4
to the fourth cause of action, respondent asserted that it “is
uncertain [because] it is ambiguous and unintelligible.”
Trial Court’s Ruling
As to the fourth cause of action, the trial court sustained
respondent’s demurrer for uncertainty without leave to amend.
As to the other causes of action, the court sustained respondent’s
demurrer without leave to amend because appellant had “fail[ed]
to allege compliance with the claims presentation requirements
of the Government Claims Act.” Judgment was entered in favor
of respondent and against appellant.
Standard of Review
“‘In reviewing a judgment of dismissal after a demurrer is
sustained without leave to amend, we assume the truth of all
properly pleaded facts. We examine the complaint's factual
allegations to determine whether they state a cause of action on
any available legal theory regardless of the label attached to a
cause of action. [Citation.] We do not assume the truth of
contentions, deductions, or conclusions of fact or law, and may
disregard allegations that are contrary to the law or to a fact that
may be judicially noticed.’ [Citation.] We review de novo a trial
court's ruling on a demurrer and examine the operative
complaint to determine whether it alleges facts sufficient to state
a cause of action under any legal theory. [Citations.]”
(Summerfield v. City of Inglewood (2023) 96 Cal.App.5th 983,
992.) Where, as here, “‘“a demurrer is sustained without leave to
amend, ‘we decide whether there is a reasonable possibility that
the defect can be cured by amendment: if it can be, the trial court
has abused its discretion and we reverse; if not, there has been no
abuse of discretion and we affirm.’”’” (Ibid.)
5
The Government Claims Act
“Suits for money or damages filed against a public entity
are regulated by statutes contained in division 3.6 of the
Government Code, commonly referred to as the Government
Claims Act.[2] . . . ‘Claims for personal injury and property
damage must be presented within six months after accrual; all
other claims must be presented within a year. (§ 911.2.) “[N]o
suit for money or damages may be brought against a public entity
on a cause of action for which a claim is required to be
presented . . . until a written claim therefor has been presented to
the public entity and has been acted upon . . . or has been deemed
to have been rejected . . . .” (§ 945.4.) “. . . [F]ailure to timely
present a claim for money or damages to a public entity bars a
plaintiff from filing a lawsuit against that entity.”. . .’”
(DiCampli-Mintz v. County of Santa Clara (2012) 55 Cal.4th 983,
989-990 (DiCampli-Mintz).)
The “‘purpose of the claims statutes is not to prevent
surprise, but “to provide the public entity sufficient information
to enable it to adequately investigate claims and to settle them, if
appropriate, without the expense of litigation. [Citations.] It is
well-settled that claims statutes must be satisfied even in face of
the public entity's actual knowledge of the circumstances
surrounding the claim.”. . .’” (DiCampli-Mintz, supra, 55 Cal.4th
at p. 991.)
Appellant Has Failed to Carry His Burden on Appeal
“[I]t is settled that: ‘A judgment or order of the lower court
is presumed correct. . . .’” (Denham v. Superior Court (1970) 2
2 Unless otherwise stated, all further statutory references
are to the Government Code.
6
Cal.3d 557, 564.) “‘[A]ppellant bears the burden of overcoming
the presumption of correctness.’” (Hearn v. Howard (2009) 177
Cal.App.4th 1193, 1207.)
Appellant has failed to carry his burden on appeal. In the
SAC appellant alleged: “This challenge [i.e., the claim that he did
not comply with the Government Claims Act] is resolved through
the consideration of [his] notification of an Injunction Hearing
scheduled for 4-30-21 which was served on [respondent] on 2-19-
21 (exhibit 6). [The service date was two months before the April
19, 2021 filing of his original complaint in the instant action.] . . .
[T]he notification did provide each element of the specific
information required in § 910 . . . .”3
3 Section 910 provides:
“A claim shall be presented by the claimant or by a person
acting on his or her behalf and shall show all of the
following:
(a) The name and post office address of the claimant.
(b) The post office address to which the person presenting
the claim desires notices to be sent.
(c) The date, place and other circumstances of the
occurrence or transaction which gave rise to the claim
asserted.
(d) A general description of the indebtedness, obligation,
injury, damage or loss incurred so far as it may be known
at the time of presentation of the claim.
(e) The name or names of the public employee or employees
causing the injury, damage, or loss, if known.
(f) The amount claimed if it totals less than ten thousand
dollars ($10,000) as of the date of presentation of the claim,
including the estimated amount of any prospective injury,
damage, or loss, insofar as it may be known at the time of
the presentation of the claim, together with the basis of
7
Exhibit 6 to appellant’s SAC is a pleading entitled
“Complaint for Injunction,” which was filed in the Glendale
courthouse of the Los Angeles County Superior Court. Appellant
is the plaintiff, and the defendant is “Cheryl Strange, in her
official capacity as Secretary of the [Washington State]
Department of Social and Health Services.” The Complaint for
Injunction alleges: “Agents working on behalf (i.e. CSSD [Los
Angeles County Child Support Services Department]) of the
defendant [Cheryl Strange] . . . are threatening to withhold
Unemployment insurance funds payable to [appellant] beginning
on or about 1-17-21.” “As a result of defendants’ (and agent
CSSD . . .) wrongful conducted against [sic] plaintiff will be
damaged in the amount of $350 each month . . . .”
Appellant has not shown how the service of the Complaint
for Injunction on respondent satisfied the requirements of the
Government Claims Act. In view of appellant’s allegations in the
SAC concerning the Complaint for Injunction, we reject his
contention that, for purposes of the demurrer, he adequately
showed compliance with the Government Claims Act by the
following statement in his opposition to the demurrer: “Plaintiff
hereby forthrightly alleges that he has complied with the
requirements of the [c]laims [a]ct in a timely manner by
submitting a claim to the public entity.”
Appellant argues that he “is excluded from Government
Claim requirements for non-monetary relief sought,” i.e., his
computation of the amount claimed. If the amount claimed
exceeds ten thousand dollars ($10,000), no dollar amount
shall be included in the claim. However, it shall indicate
whether the claim would be a limited civil case.”
8
request in the SAC for injunctive and declaratory relief. As a
general rule, the Government Claims Act does not “impose any
requirements for nonpecuniary actions, such as those seeking
injunctive, specific or declaratory relief.” (Loehr v. Ventura
County Community College Dist. (1983) 147 Cal.App.3d 1071,
1081.) “This exception does not apply, however, where the
demand for nonmonetary relief is merely incidental or ancillary
to a prayer for damages. [Citation.]” (Hart v. Alameda County
(1999) 76 Cal.App.4th 766, 782; see also Gatto v. County of
Sonoma (2002) 98 Cal.App.4th 744, 762 [“The claims filing
requirement remains applicable to actions in which money
damages are not incidental or ancillary to any specific relief that
is also sought, but the primary purpose of the action”].)
Appellant’s request for injunctive and declaratory relief is
incidental or ancillary to his prayer for damages. The primary
purpose of the SAC is to obtain monetary relief. Appellant
sought compensatory damages of approximately $2,376,000 as
well as punitive damages. Pursuant to Civil Code section 3345,
subdivision (b), he sought “to levy treble damages against
[respondent]; totaling $7,127,214.”
Disposition
The judgment is affirmed. Respondent shall recover costs
on appeal.
NOT TO BE PUBLISHED.
YEGAN, J.
We concur:
GILBERT, P. J. BALTODANO, J.
9
Jeffrey G. Bennett, Judge
Superior Court County of Ventura
______________________________
Sam Rotter, in propria persona, for Plaintiff and
Appellant.
Peterson, Bradford, Burkwitz, Gregorio, Burkwitz,
and Su, and Avi Burkwitz, Lusine Arshakyan, for Defendant and
Respondent.
Vous vous demandez comment ce texte s’applique à votre situation ?
Consultation gratuite, sans engagement
Décrivez votre situation. Notre équipe vous recontactera par e-mail pour votre consultation.
Poursuivez vos recherches dans ChatGPT ou Claude
Connectez Omnilex pour rechercher dans le corpus juridique depuis votre assistant IA.