CourtListener 10045080•In re I.D. CA2/5
Texte intégral
Filed 8/15/24 In re I.D. CA2/5
NOT TO BE PUBLISHED IN THE OFFICIAL REPORTS
California Rules of Court, rule 8.1115(a), prohibits courts and parties from citing or relying on opinions
not certified for publication or ordered published, except as specified by rule 8.1115(b). This opinion
has not been certified for publication or ordered published for purposes of rule 8.1115.
IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA
SECOND APPELLATE DISTRICT
DIVISION FIVE
In re I.D., a Person Coming B333797
Under the Juvenile Court Law. (Los Angeles County
Super. Ct. No.
18CCJP00557B)
LOS ANGELES COUNTY
DEPARTMENT OF
CHILDREN AND FAMILY
SERVICES,
Plaintiff and Respondent,
v.
C.D. et al.,
Defendants and Respondents.
APPEAL from a judgment of the Superior Court of Los
Angeles County, Jean M. Nelson, Judge. Conditionally affirmed
and remanded.
Liana Serobian, under appointment by the Court of Appeal,
for Defendant and Appellant C.D.
Paul A. Swiller, under appointment by the Court of Appeal,
for Defendant and Appellant D.D.
Dawyn R. Harrison, County Counsel, Kim Nemoy,
Assistant County Counsel, Tracey Dodds, Principal Deputy
County Counsel, for Plaintiff and Respondent.
________________________
I. INTRODUCTION
In a prior appeal in this matter (In re I.D. (May 17, 2022,
B311124))1, C.D. and D.D., mother and father of now 11 year old
I.D. (the child), contended the juvenile court erred when it
terminated their visitation with the child; mother also contended
the court erred when it denied her Welfare and Institutions Code
section 3882 petition that sought to change the court’s order
terminating her family reunification services. We affirmed the
court’s orders. Following further proceedings on remand, the
court terminated mother’s and father’s parental rights to the
child pursuant to section 366.26. Mother and father appeal,
contending the court erred in denying them visitation and the
court and the Los Angeles County Department of Children and
Family Services (Department) failed to satisfy their inquiry
1 On our own motion, we take judicial notice of the prior
opinion. (Evid. Code, § 452, subd. (d).)
2 All further statutory references are to the Welfare and
Institutions Code unless otherwise noted.
2
duties under the Indian Child Welfare Act of 1978 (ICWA; 25
U.S.C. § 1901 et seq.) and related California statutes (§ 224 et
seq.).3 We conditionally affirm and remand.
II. BACKGROUND
A. Prior Appeal
The following background facts are taken from the prior
opinion in this matter, In re I.D., supra, B311124:
“A. First Amended Section 300 Petition
“On April 24, 2018, the Los Angeles County Department of
Children and Family Services (Department) filed a first amended
section 300 petition that alleged, as ultimately sustained, that on
or about January 14, 2012, mother and father engaged in
domestic violence and a protective restraining order was issued
against father; on numerous occasions, the parents violated the
3 Mother and father purport to join each other’s arguments.
“Joinder may be broadly permitted (Cal. Rules of Court, rule
8.200(a)(5)), but each appellant has the burden of demonstrating
error and prejudice (People v. Coley (1997) 52 Cal.App.4th 964,
972 . . . ; Paterno v. State of California (1999) 74 Cal.App.4th 68,
106 . . . [‘Because of the need to consider the particulars of the
given case, rather than the type of error, the appellant bears the
duty of spelling out in his brief exactly how the error caused a
miscarriage of justice[]’][.])[ ]” (People v. Nero (2010) 181
Cal.App.4th 504, 510, fn. 11.) Neither parent “spells out” how the
other parent’s arguments apply to them and thus their “joinders”
are deficient.
3
restraining order requiring law enforcement intervention. It
further alleged that mother had a history of alcohol abuse and
was a current user of alcohol and marijuana; on prior occasions
mother used alcohol and marijuana while caring for the
children4; and mother had passed out from alcohol intoxication in
the children’s presence and the children were unable to wake her.
“B. Jurisdiction/Disposition Report and Hearing
“In its April 16, 2018, Jurisdiction/Disposition Report, the
Department reported that A.P. and I.D. were placed with
maternal aunt E.H. A.P. told a social worker that mother drank
too much alcohol. Mother sometimes became drunk. On two
occasions, she passed out.
“The juvenile court removed the child from the parents’
care. It ordered reunification services for mother and father.
Mother was ordered to participate in a full drug and alcohol
program with weekly random or on demand testing. She was
also to participate in a 12-step program, developmentally
appropriate parenting education, and individual counseling to
address case issues including domestic violence and anger
management. The court granted mother monitored visitation
with the child for a minimum of two to three hours, two to three
times per week. Mother was not permitted to visit the child with
father.
“The juvenile court ordered father to participate in a 52-
week domestic violence program and a developmentally
appropriate parenting program. He was to comply with criminal
“4 The first amended petition was filed with respect to the
child and her sibling, A.P. A.P. is not a subject of this appeal.
4
court orders. The court granted him monitored visitation with
the child for a minimum of two to three hours, two to three times
per week. He was not to visit the child with mother.
“C. Six-Month Review Report and Hearing
“In its January 10, 2019, Status Review Report for the six-
month review hearing, the Department reported that mother was
working diligently to complete her court-ordered services.
Mother and the child had had ‘consistent [and] meaningful’ visits
during which they bonded. The child appeared to enjoy the visits,
singing, ‘“I love my mommy.”’ The visits appeared to have had ‘so
much impact’ on the relationship between mother and the child
that E.H. scheduled additional time for them to be together.
“Although father had not visited the child consistently,
when he did visit, the visits were ‘meaningful.’ The child
appeared to enjoy visits with father.
“In a Last Minute Information for the Court for the six-
month review hearing, the Department reported that father’s last
face-to-face contact with the child was on October 29, 2018. As of
January 10, 2019, father had not started his parenting class.
Father told the social worker that he was attending domestic
violence classes, but refused to provide contact information or the
class’s location.
“In a second Last Minute Information for the Court, the
Department informed the juvenile court that on
December 19, 2018, E.H. reported that mother was sending her
threatening messages and was being aggressive on the phone.
She did not feel comfortable giving mother additional visitation.
5
“The child’s counselor stated that the child was
‘experiencing many trauma-related symptoms including anxiety,
depression, intrusive thoughts, avoidance, arousal, and
disassociation.’ E.H. reported to the counselor an ‘improvement
in functioning’ when the child did not have visitation with
mother. Among other things, the child was calmer, listened
better, and did not show defiance.
“The counselor stated that the ‘stressor of visitation with
her mother is likely contributing to trigger trauma
symptomology. It is of concern that with these triggers [the child]
continues to exhibit an acute trauma state. Should this continue
this can result in a very guarded prognosis and potential
significant neurodevelopmental consequences. The negative
impact of continuing visitation should be considered in light of
functional status concerns.’
“The juvenile court granted mother unmonitored visitation
with the child for a minimum of two to three hours, two to three
times per week in a public setting. Father was not to be present
for the visits. Mother was not to threaten E.H.
“D. The Department’s February 19, 2019, Section 388 Petition
“On February 19, 2019, the Department filed a section 388
petition requesting the juvenile court to change its order for
unmonitored visits for mother. Instead, it requested an order
that visitation take place in a therapeutic setting, mother’s
educational rights be given solely to E.H., and mother participate
in a full psychological evaluation.
“E.H. was worried about the quality of mother’s visits with
the child due to the child’s behavior after the visits. After visits,
6
the child had a ‘“nasty attitude,”’ did not listen, and hit her
cousin. It took a couple of days for the child’s behavior to ‘get
back on track.’
“On January 24, 2019, E.H. told the social worker that the
child said she spoke with father on the phone during a visit with
mother. The child disclosed to E.H. that she always spoke with
father during visits with mother. E.H. also told the social worker
that the child’s school principal informed her that mother had
called the school making threats, using derogatory language, and
requesting the child be kicked out of school because she was not
being taken care of and not doing her homework.
“On February 5, 2019, the social worker spoke with the
child privately. The child said she and mother ‘share secrets that
[mother] doesn’t want her to share.’ The social worker asked the
child how visits with mother went. The child responded,
‘“[G]ood.’” She reported that she spoke with father during visits.
“On February 8, 2019, the social worker spoke with the
child’s school principal. The principal stated that mother called
the school yelling and screaming that the child was not doing her
homework and should be kicked out of school. Mother ‘“appeared
erratic and was possibly under the influence.”’
“The child’s therapist recommended that visitation with
mother and father be reevaluated in light of the child’s reported
‘re-traumatization.’
“On April 18, 2019, the juvenile court granted the
Department’s section 388 petition. It ordered mother’s visitation
with the child be monitored in a therapeutic setting. E.H. was
appointed the child’s educational rights holder. Mother was to
participate in a psychological evaluation.
7
“E. May 3, 2019, Last Minute Information for the Court
“In a May 3, 2019, Last Minute Information for the Court,
the Department reported that father had provided proof that he
had completed a domestic violence program. Father had not
attempted to visit the child—his last visit was on
October 29, 2018.
“F. May 3, 2019, Six-Month Review Hearing
“At the May 3, 2019, six-month review hearing, the juvenile
court continued reunification services for mother, but terminated
reunification services for father.
“G. Mother’s July 1, 2019, Walk On Request
“On July 1, 2019, mother filed a walk on request concerning
her lack of visitation. She noted the juvenile court ordered her
visits be in a therapeutic setting, but she had not had any visits
with the child as of June 27, 2019. The court ordered the
Department to ensure that mother’s visits with the child took
place in a therapeutic setting.
“H. Eighteen-Month Status Review Report
“In its August 28, 2019, Status Review Report for the 18-
month review hearing, the Department reported that the child
remained placed with E.H. Father had been consistent with
visits with the child. The child enjoyed visits with father, her
half-brothers, and paternal grandmother. She also enjoyed her
8
one visit with mother on August 3, 2019, and looked forward to
future visits and phone calls with her.
“Mother had completed an in-patient drug treatment
program at Cri-Help. Mother completed seven of 18 scheduled
drug tests. On July 1, 2019, mother tested positive for opiates
and Hydrocodone. She told the social worker the positive test
was the result of medication given to her at the hospital for her
gallbladder. The social worker requested hospital records
concerning mother’s claim.
“Mother claimed to be attending Alcoholics Anonymous and
Narcotics Anonymous and to be working on her 12-step program.
Mother did not provide proof of attendance during the recent
period of supervision and last gave proof of attendance on
August 4, 2018. Mother claimed she completed a psychological
evaluation on July 18, 2019, but did not provide documentation
for her claim. The Department gave mother several referrals for
low cost and no cost individual counseling. Mother stated she
was working on having her Medi-Cal reinstated so she could
resume counseling.
“The Department recommended that mother’s reunification
services be terminated and the matter be set for a section 366.26
hearing.
“The juvenile court continued the 18-month review hearing
ultimately to January 29, 2020.
“I. October 16, 2019, Last Minute Information for the Court
“In an October 16, 2019, Last Minute Information for the
Court, the Department reported the therapist who served as the
visitation monitor opined that mother could safely have
9
unmonitored visitation with the child under certain conditions:
mother had to provide proof of a valid driver’s license and car
insurance; visits should not exceed three to four hours; mother
had to provide a clean drug and alcohol test to document sobriety;
and visits should be scheduled on days when mother had
adequate rest.
“In a second October 16, 2019, Last Minute Information for
the Court, the Department reported that mother and the child
had monitored visits on August 25, 2019, and on September 7, 15,
and 22, 2019. The therapist monitored phone calls between
mother and the child on September 4, 11, and 18, 2019. The
visits and phone calls were uneventful and appropriate except for
one visit when mother became agitated and discussed case issues
with the social worker in front of the child. During the
September 15 visit, the child and mother appeared to have a
‘good interaction and the hugs and kisses seemed natural and
reciprocal.’
“Father had visits with the child on September 4, 11, 18,
and 25. He canceled a visit on October 2, 2019.
“On September 1, 2019, the child was placed with maternal
uncle R.D. and aunt R.D. The caregivers requested the juvenile
court make a no-contact order for mother and father. They
expressed their unwillingness to have any contact with the
parents.
“J. Father’s December 12, 2019, Section 388 Petition
“On December 12, 2019, father filed a section 388 petition
requesting the juvenile court reinstate family reunification
services, return the child to him, grant him unmonitored visits,
10
and approve mother to monitor visits with the child. Father
stated that he had consistently and meaningfully visited with the
child and had completed parenting and domestic violence classes.
“The Department filed a response to father’s section 388
petition. It stated that father had visited the child nearly every
week for two to three hours since June 12, 2019. Father and the
child shared a strong father-daughter bond. Father was always
appropriate during visits. The child stated on several occasions
that she loved visiting father and frequently became upset when
visits ended. Father also had completed his court-ordered case
plan. The Department recommended that the juvenile court
reinstate family reunification services for father and grant him
unsupervised visits not to exceed five hours; mother was not to be
present during father’s unsupervised visits. It further
recommended the court not place child with father.
“K. January 29, 2020, Last Minute Information for the Court
“In a January 29, 2020, Last Minute Information for the
Court, the Department reported that mother’s discharge plan
from Exodus Recovery Urgent Care Center stated that mother
had been diagnosed with adjustment disorder. She was advised
to follow up with treatment at BAART Community Healthcare.
Mother did not follow up with treatment because further
treatment was recommended, but not required.
“Mother completed a residential alcohol dependence
program at Cri-Help and a parent education course. Mother was
participating in individual counseling and had completed seven
sessions. According to mother’s counselor, she appeared to
11
understand her past mistakes and to be facing them honestly and
engagingly.
“Mother had six negative drug tests from December 12,
2019, to January 21, 2020. From December 15, 2019, to
January 22, 2020, mother had nine monitored visits with the
child and one visit mother canceled.
“In a January 3, 2020, telephone conversation with a social
worker mother appeared to be under the influence. Mother was
slurring her words, speaking very slowly, and not making sense.
Mother denied she was under the influence. The same day,
maternal aunt E.E. told the social worker that mother had
appeared to be under the influence during a telephone
conversation on December 22, 2019. E.E. stated that mother
slurred her words and spoke slowly and had threatened to report
her to the IRS for filing false tax returns.
“On January 17, 2020, mother exchanged text messages
with the child’s foster mother5 concerning an upcoming visit.
When the foster mother told mother she was unable to monitor a
visit both to a movie and a pizza restaurant, mother responded,
‘“That is my daughter. You get paid for her so what I want to do,
I should be able to. Don’t tell me pizza only.”’ The social worker
spoke with mother about how she communicated with the child’s
foster mother.
“The Department recommended the juvenile court
terminate mother’s reunification services.
“5 The child had been re-placed from maternal uncle and
aunt’s home.
12
“L. January 29, 2020, Eighteen-Month Review Hearing
“At the January 29, 2020, eighteen-month review hearing,
the juvenile court terminated mother’s reunification services. It
granted part of father’s December 12, 2019, section 388 petition,
reinstating reunification services.
“M. Mother’s July 13, 2020, Walk On Request
“On July 13, 2020, mother filed a walk on request for,
among other things, monitored visits in her home. The juvenile
court ordered the Department to assess monitored visitation in
mother’s home and provide any change in recommendation in its
next report. It set the matter for a permanency planning review
hearing on September 29, 2020.
“N. Permanency Planning Status Review Report
“In its September 29, 2020, Status Review Report for the
permanency planning review hearing, the Department reported
that on July 14, 2020, mother reported that she and father had
recent verbal altercations and ‘they had the police called’ due to
father coming to mother’s residence unannounced.
“The social worker contacted father about the incident
mother described. Father said mother was lying and she was the
one who was being aggressive. He helped mother financially
with her residence and was the primary lessee on mother’s home.
Father admitted he was in an “‘on again, off again’” relationship
with mother. Mother and father reported that their relationship
was tumultuous, but they remained in constant communication
and contact.
13
“Due to COVID-19 state protocols, father’s visits with the
child were held by video from March 17, 2020, to May 13, 2020.
Thereafter, they had weekly visits for a minimum of four hours.
The child reported that father allowed mother to call and video
chat during their unmonitored in-person visits. When the social
worker spoke with father about the need to comply with court
orders, he agreed not to allow mother access to the child during
his visits.
“The child reported that visits with father lacked substance
and meaningful contact. The child wanted to have more of an
opportunity to bond with father as he rarely spent the visitation
time with her. After her September 13, 2020, visit with father,
the child told the social worker that her visits with father were
‘not very good.’ She reported that father would leave for an hour
or two every visit to buy food and routinely slept for several hours
during visits.
“Mother’s visits with the child had been consistent, but the
‘appropriateness’ of mother’s visits concerned the Department.
Mother continued to need redirection to provide emotionally
positive feedback to the child during visits. Mother encouraged
the child to have visits with her and father together.
“The child stated that she loved mother, but she did not
like that mother lied. When asked what mother lied about, the
child responded that mother told her to listen only to mother and
not to her caregiver or the social worker. The child loved her
parents, but wished they could ‘“be good and listen to the rules.”’
14
“O. Mother’s December 29, 2020, Section 388 Petition
“On December 29, 2020, mother filed a section 388 petition
seeking to change the juvenile court’s order terminating her
family reunification services. Instead, mother wanted the court
to return the child to her custody, reinstate family reunification
services, or grant unmonitored and overnight visits.
“Mother contended a change of circumstances supported
the petition because she attended individual counseling twice a
month, was sober, and was willing to prove her sobriety through
random testing but could not afford it. She spoke with her
sponsor daily and visited the child when the Department
arranged visits and called to talk about the child’s well-being
weekly. Finally, she had completed a residential treatment
program and a psychological evaluation at Exodus.
“Mother contended the requested order would be in the
child’s best interest because the child ‘was a seven year old girl
who ha[d] a close and bonded relationship with her mother. She
ha[d] been quoted as saying she love[d] her mother in [the
Department’s] reports filed with the Court. It [was] in [the
child’s] best interest to be returned to her mother’s care and have
the least amount of restrictions and interference on the quality of
time she [could] spend bonding with her mother.’ The juvenile
court set mother’s section 388 petition for a hearing.
“In its February 16, 2021, response, the Department stated
that mother did not want the child to attend individual therapy
and also did not want to attend conjoint therapy with the child.
The child and her caregiver consistently reported to the social
worker that mother appeared under the influence of drugs and/or
alcohol during video/telephone calls. Mother attempted to
15
intimidate the child, caregiver, and social worker by yelling or
being aggressive.
“On December 31, 2020, the child told the social worker
that she felt scared to be around mother for in-person visits
because mother would become angry and yell at everyone.
Mother told her to lie if anyone asked about mother or father
doing anything bad. Then, mother lied and said the child was not
telling the truth. The child was willing to have one monitored
telephone call with mother per week. She did not want to have
in-person visits with mother as mother was always mean and
angry.
“P. January 5, 2021, Last Minute Information for the Court
“In its January 5, 2021, Last Minute Information for the
Court, the Department reported, ‘During this period of
supervision, mother’s quality of visits has significantly changed.’
The child reported she did not enjoy mother’s calls or visits
because mother was overly aggressive and excessively agitated
during contact with her. When mother missed her scheduled
calls with the child, she tended to yell at or continuously call the
caregiver and the social worker. Mother’s demeanor and inability
to work with the Department saddened and upset the child.
“Mother asked the child to lie and not listen to the
Department or her caregiver. The Department, caregiver, and
child were concerned that mother called the child when mother
was under the influence of drugs and alcohol. The child and
caregiver created a safe word that allowed calls to end
prematurely. During the recent period of supervision, most calls
ended early.
16
“As of December 31, 2020, the child requested to not have
in-person visits with mother because she did not feel safe with
mother’s behavior. The child also did not want to have video calls
with mother. Mother smoked cigarettes and drank alcohol
during video calls. The child requested one monitored telephone
call per week with mother.
“Father continued to violate the juvenile court’s order by
allowing mother to participate in his visits with the child. He
took the child to mother’s home and encouraged the child to lie
about the unauthorized contact with mother.
“The child reported that father did not talk to her very
much and displayed little to no affection during visits. She did
not spend much time alone with father. Father could be very
easy going, but got angry easily and scared her. Father yelled
often, causing the child to cry. She described multiple times
when father did not pay attention to her or her safety. In their
most recent visit, father made her feel bad about revealing that
her parents were visiting her together. She reported that father
was angry and yelled at her because she told the truth. The child
believed father was angrier when he was with mother. She
stated she wanted to have visits with father, but only with a
monitor for one or two hours per week “‘if he is nice and listens.’”
“Q. Mother’s January 21, 2021, Emergency Walk On Request
“On January 21, 2021, mother filed an emergency walk on
request to restore her FaceTime visits with the child. The
Department opposed mother’s request. It stated the child had
consistently refused to have FaceTime or video chats with mother
since December 25, 2020. The child was not comfortable with
17
such visits as mother smoked and drank alcohol during them.
Mother also asked the child to walk away from the caregiver so
that the visits could be unmonitored.
“On February 16, 2021, the juvenile court granted mother’s
request to restore her FaceTime visits with the child. It ordered
the Department to have a staff member monitor the visits.
“R. February 16, 2021, Last Minute Information for the Court
“In a February 16, 2021, Last Minute Information for the
Court, the Department reported that there was no in-person or
video contact between mother and the child from
January 6, 2021, to February 10, 2021, because the child refused
to visit with mother. During roughly the same period, there were
no visits with father, apparently because father refused to accede
to the child’s request that visits be monitored.
“The child did not want in-person visitation with mother or
father. Mother and father yelled and fought a lot when the child
was present. She felt like she was in the middle when her
parents fought. The child and the caregiver reported to the social
worker that mother drank alcohol and smoked cigarettes during
the video calls. The caregiver stated that mother appeared under
the influence of alcohol during video calls.
“S. March 8, 2021, Last Minute Information for the Court
“In a March 8, 2021, Last Minute Information for the
Court, the Department reported that mother and father had
existing visitation schedules, but the child refused visitation.
The child reported, “‘I don’t feel that my mom and dad are doing
18
what they are supposed to during visits. . . . My mom and dad
will always have visits together at my mom’s house, and they are
not supposed to do that . . . . My parents always tell me not to
tell on them.”’
“The child continued, ‘“My mom and dad scare me. I feel
like they are going to be mad because now everyone knows the
truth. And I am tired of lying for them. And now they are calling
me the liar and making me look like I’m the bad one.”’ According
to the child, mother and father drank alcohol and smoked during
video calls. The child had begun to display ‘anxious’ behaviors on
or around the time of her phone calls with mother and father.
“During a February 24, 2021, phone call, mother asked the
child why she was refusing to visit. Mother repeatedly called the
child a liar, said she was mean for refusing to visit, and yelled
and used profanity. The caregiver had to intervene.
“In a March 3, 2021, phone call, mother called the child a
liar and said ‘“this was all [the child’s] fault for telling on them.”’
The child asked mother why she was in child care if mother loved
and took good care of her. Mother yelled and screamed at the
child.
“The next day, the child told the social worker that she
thought mother would try to do something bad to her, her
caregiver, or the social worker. She believed that if her parents
could not get her back through juvenile court proceedings, they
would make it hard for her to be with anyone else.
“The child refused visits with mother and father from the
middle of February to the beginning of March 2021.
“Around December 2020, the Department connected the
child with Wraparound services. Mother and father were
19
contacted and asked to participate with the team on the child’s
behalf. They refused.
“T. March 11, 2021, Hearing on Mother’s Section 388 Petition
and Review of Permanent Plan
“At the March 11, 2021, hearing on mother’s section 388
petition and review of permanent plan, mother testified that
since the juvenile court sustained the section 300 petition, there
had been no domestic violence incidents with father or anyone
else, she was sober, and she had not used any illegal drugs or
alcohol. She was attending a virtual Alcoholics Anonymous-like
program.
“Mother had been unable to drug test for the prior six
months because she could not afford to and due to the Corona
virus. If the juvenile court granted her additional reunification
and ordered drug testing, she would be willing to drug test.
“On July 10, 2018, mother completed the Cri-Help
residential substance abuse program. She had been attending
individual counseling once a week and was currently attending
once a month.
“Mother denied that she ever yelled at the child during a
visit. When asked if she accused the child of lying during a visit,
mother responded that when the child said that father brought
the child to mother during visits—which never happened—she
told the child to ‘“tell mommy the truth,”’ and the child confessed
that she had lied. Mother asked the child why she had lied and
the child responded that she thought she would get to come home
faster.
20
“Mother denied that she used alcohol or smoked during
virtual visits with the child. Mother was concerned that the
social worker was telling her to say those things. In addition to
requesting visitation and family reunification services, mother
wanted a new social worker who would not intimidate the child
or speak ill of the child’s parents.
“Mother believed it was in the child’s best interest to
reunify with her because they had a good bond, the child knew
how much mother loved her, and the child called mother her best
friend.
“The juvenile court asked mother about her participation in
her 12-step program. Mother responded, ‘I am working currently
always 8 through 12.’ The court asked if mother could explain
step seven as she must have completed it recently. Mother
responded, ‘I have been working on it, but I haven’t read the
step.’ Mother spoke with her sponsor twice a day.
“Mother’s counsel argued the juvenile court should grant
mother’s section 388 petition because there had been a change in
circumstances as ‘mother was able to articulate today her tools
for sobriety. She does the A.A. online meetings. She is in 12-
steps. She speaks with a sponsor twice a day. She articulated
her support system. And she has done the Cri-Help residential
program. She is sober at this time.’ Mother had not been testing
only because she could not afford it. She took responsibility for
the domestic violence with father.
“Mother’s counsel argued that the changes requested in
mother’s section 388 petition were in the child’s best interest
because the child had said in the past that she loved mother,
mother testified the child loved and was excited to see her, and
mother and the child had a strong bond. Mother had been
21
fighting for the child, and it was in the child’s best interest to be
removed from foster care and placed in mother’s home.
“The juvenile court denied mother’s section 388 petition.
The court acknowledged that mother had participated in services,
but found that she had not benefited from them. Mother believed
that everyone was lying about her—the child, the caregiver, and
the social worker. The court found the child and social worker
were credible, but mother was not.
“Further, the juvenile court was concerned, based on the
caregiver’s reports, that mother was showing up ‘under the
influence.’ It also found that mother and father had not made
progress ‘in the domestic violence’ as they continued to violate the
court’s orders about separate and monitored visits and argued in
front of the child.
“The juvenile court found that there had not been a change
in circumstances—mother had continued in programs, but she
had not changed. It further found that the proposed order was
not in the child’s best interest as the visits were causing the child
a lot of anxiety.
“After addressing mother’s section 388 petition, the
juvenile court asked whether it had to address father’s
reunification services. The Department’s counsel responded,
‘Your Honor, I don’t believe that is on calendar today. I believe it
is just the R.P.P. [(review of permanent plan)] and mother’s
services and mother’s 388.’ The court acknowledge that the
matter had been called for a review of permanent plan hearing,
but stated that at such a hearing it appropriately could address
whether to terminate the services it ordered as part of father’s
successful section 388 petition. The Department’s counsel
agreed. Father’s counsel objected, stating that family
22
reunification and mother’s section 388 petition were on calendar,
but whether to terminate father’s reunification services was not.
“The juvenile court then turned to ‘the visitation issue’ and
asked the child’s counsel for her position. The child’s counsel
asked the court to make a detriment finding as to both parents
regarding visitation based on her argument in connection with
mother’s section 388 petition and the most recent Last Minute
Information for the Court. She argued that the child did not
enjoy the visits and recently had refused visits as they were ‘so
anxiety inducing.’
“The child’s counsel stated she had earlier addressed
mother’s detrimental visits with the child. As for visits with
father, the child refused visits on February 28 and March 7,
crying because she feared visiting with father. The child’s fear
was related to the parents violating court orders, telling the child
to lie, and becoming upset with her when she told the truth. The
child had been ‘extremely clear’ that visits with father were not
good for her and she did not want to participate in them. Also,
father refused to participate in Wraparound services and the
child’s Wraparound team made clear that visits needed to be
limited or stopped.
“Mother’s counsel asked the juvenile court to deny the
child’s counsel’s request to terminate visitation. Counsel stated
that the social worker had not been helping mother and the court
should disregard the social worker’s reports about mother’s visits.
Instead, the court should accept mother’s testimony about the
visits ‘and the fact that none of this is true and that this child is
being brainwashed and is caught in the middle of the
[Department]. And this is what is causing [the child’s] issues, not
. . . mother’s behavior.’ According to mother’s counsel, the
23
Department was ‘actively thwarting’ mother’s contact with the
child and coaching the child about what to say about her desire
for contact with mother.
“Father’s counsel agreed with mother’s counsel, stating
that the Department had done ‘everything to sabotage this
family.’ He argued that the Department had inappropriately
delegated to the child whether visits would take place. There had
been no indication from a psychiatrist or social worker that the
visits were detrimental and no physical evidence of detriment
such as the child shaking or breaking out in hives.
“The Department’s counsel asked that father’s family
reunification services be terminated. Counsel noted that father
was entitled to six months of family reunification, the juvenile
court had ordered family reunification on January 29, 2020, over
a year prior, and the child had not been returned to father.
Because reunification had not occurred within six months, family
reunification had to be terminated. The court stated, ‘That is
part of an R.P.P. hearing,’ and asked the Department’s position
on terminating mother’s and father’s visitation.
“The Department’s counsel argued that there was
detriment to the child—she had expressed numerous times that
she did not want to visit either parent. The child had been
‘astute enough’ to tell when mother had been under the influence.
“The juvenile court terminated visitation for mother and
father, finding by clear and convincing evidence that the visits
were detrimental as the parents continued to traumatize and re-
traumatize the child. The court stated, ‘The parents are
continuing to engage in the very conduct that was sustained
initially in the original petition, and they are re-traumatizing
[the child.] [¶] I don’t have to find that [the child’s] mental
24
health is deteriorated to the degree that she has to be
hospitalized or needs to be medicated or things like that. She is a
fairly resilient little girl. There are many other children who
wouldn’t be this resilient. She’s on the cusp. She is on the brink
of really being pushed too far mentally and emotionally. [¶] This
isn’t a case of just unruliness because the child decided she
doesn’t want to visit.’
“The juvenile court found father and mother were not
credible. It further found it implausible that the child would
make up statements about how mother acted during visits, that
she was afraid of father, or that mother and father fought in front
of her.
“Moreover, father violated the juvenile court’s order by
allowing mother to have unmonitored visits.” (In re I.D., supra,
B311124.)
B. Facts After Mother and Father Filed Their Appeals in In re
I.D., supra, No. B311124
On April 6, 2021, the juvenile court terminated father’s
reunification services (it terminated mother’s reunification
services on January 29, 2020) and set the matter for a section
366.26 permanency planning hearing.
On July 28, 2021, the child told a social worker, “‘I want to
talk to my parents, but I am afraid they will yell and be mad at
me.’” On August 10, 2021, the social worker attended a meeting
with the child’s mental health team to discuss telephone visits
between the child and mother and father. The team would not
provide a recommendation, but reported that “since the
25
termination of contact with parents, the team has seen much
progress with [the child’s] goals.”
On August 24, 2021, mother filed a section 388 petition
asking the juvenile court to reinstate her visitation with the
child. The court denied the request.
On December 10, 2021, father filed a section 388 petition
asking the juvenile court to reinstate his visitation with the child.
The court denied the request.
On December 15, 2021, the juvenile court ordered the
appointment of an independent evaluator pursuant to Evidence
Code section 730 to evaluate the “need and importance” of visits
between the child and mother and father.
On March 2, 2022, the social worker asked the child if she
wanted to visit with mother. The child responded she would be
interested in visiting with mother, but not alone. She stated she
was afraid to visit with the parents alone, but would not disclose
why she was afraid. She would be comfortable with monitored
visits. The child had last visited with her parents the previous
Thanksgiving, she missed them, and would love to see them.
On June 2, 2022, the Department filed in the juvenile court
the Evidence Code section 730 evaluator’s report. The evaluator
reported the child “made conflicting statements regarding her
thoughts about visitation and feelings towards her parents. She
initially stated that she loved and missed them and wanted to see
them, but later expressed feeling nervous, afraid, uncomfortable,
and reluctant to restart visitations with them.”
According to the evaluator, the child did not “seem to have
a stable, strong, or close relationship with her parents” and
appeared to have “both positive and negative feelings towards
them.” Though the child “remain[ed] uncertain, the fact that she
26
ha[d] continued to express interest in visiting with her parents to
multiple people indicate[d] that visitations with her parents
should be further explored and considered.” (Emphasis omitted.)
The evaluator recommended that visits between mother
and the child begin after mother’s therapist and the child’s
therapist agreed that mother and the child were ready for visits.
She recommended that visits between father and the child begin
after the child’s therapist had spent a few sessions with the child
preparing her for visits. The evaluator recommended that
someone with whom the child felt safe and secure monitor the
visits.
At a section 366.26 permanency planning hearing on
June 10, 2022, the juvenile court stated it had reviewed the
evaluator’s report. The court then denied mother’s and father’s
request to reinstate visits with the child.
The juvenile court explained the evaluator’s report did not
present new evidence, it only recommended that visits take place
when future conditions were met. The court found compelling the
evaluator’s conclusion that neither mother nor father was “self-
aware about the problems. And that has always been the court’s
issue in this case. So I find the detriment continues. There is no
change in circumstances. The mere fact that a child, at times,
indicates that she want[s] visits is not compelling evidence to
order visits. . . . I can rely on the attorneys’ request on behalf of
her client that visits not begin. Further, I find it compelling that
there has been an improvement in her behavior since she stopped
visiting with parents. Also, the court gives extraordinary weight
to the need to continue stability for [the child.] That means that
she remain in a current placement. This current placement is
excellent. I’m very concerned, especially as [the child] starts to
27
head into puberty, that the placement could be sabotaged or
disrupted . . . if her improvement is interrupted by visits with
parents.”
On September 16, 2022, the juvenile court ordered the
Department to discuss with the child’s Wraparound team
visitation between the child and mother and father. In its
November 23, 2022, Status Review Report, the Department
reported that “[a]s of September 2022, [the child’s] former
Wraparound . . . team indicated that [the child] is not ready to
resume visitation with either of her parents.”
In its June 7, 2023, section 366.26 report, the Department
reported that on May 11, 2023, the child’s therapist informed a
social worker that the child stated she was not ready to resume
contact and visitation with her parents.
At a June 9, 2023, section 366.26 permanency planning
hearing, the juvenile court ordered the Department to assess
whether mother could have in-person or phone visits with the
child. The Department was to interview the child only once.
In a September 7, 2023, Last Minute Information for the
Court, the Department informed the juvenile court that the
child’s therapist had indicated on several occasions that the child
had not expressed an interest in resuming telephone calls with
mother. Also, a social worker had interviewed the child about
having telephone calls or visits with mother. The child
responded, “‘I’'ll let you know when I’m ready.’”
In a December 5, 2023, Last Minute Information for the
Court, the Department informed the juvenile court that the child
continued to decline any contact with mother and father and
would “say when she [was] ready to have any contact with them.”
28
In a December 6, 2023, Last Minute Information for the
Court, the Department reported that the child was not interested
in receiving letters from mother or father.
At a December 8, 2023, section 366.26 hearing, the juvenile
court terminated mother’s and father’s parental rights.
C. ICWA Facts
The Indian Child Inquiry Attachment to the Department’s
January 26, 2018, section 300 petition stated the child had no
known Indian ancestry. The attachment identified maternal
aunt L.H. as the “Person(s) questioned” and the apparent source
of that information. The Department’s Detention Report of the
same date stated ICWA did not apply.
Mother’s January 28, 2018, Parental Notification of Indian
Status form stated mother had no Indian ancestry as far as she
knew.
At the January 29, 2018, detention hearing, at which
mother appeared but father did not, the juvenile court asked
mother if she knew if father had or might have American Indian
ancestry. Mother responded, “[N]ot that I know of.” The court
found it did not have a reason to know the child was an Indian
child and ordered mother and father to keep their attorneys, the
Department, and the court aware of any new information relating
to possible ICWA status.
At a March 10, 2023, section 366.26 permanency planning
hearing, the juvenile court ordered the Department to “[a]ddress
in re Caden C. [(In re Caden C. (2021) 11 Cal.5th 614)] analysis[
and] ICWA ancestry inquiries . . . .”
29
In its November 15, 2023, status review report, the
Department reported contact with maternal aunt E.E. on
November 2, 2023. E.E. “stated that to her knowledge, she and
her siblings [did] not have any affiliations nor are they registered
with any Indian American tribe.”
The record identifies other maternal extended family
members whom the Department contacted but did not ask about
the child’s possible Indian ancestry: maternal aunts E.H. and
R.D., maternal uncle R.D., maternal grandmother M.D.6, and
maternal cousin B.D.
The record does not contain a Parental Notification of
Indian Status form for father or evidence the Department asked
father about the child’s possible Indian ancestry. The record also
reflects that the Department had contact with paternal
grandmother A.H., who lived with paternal grandfather (no name
provided), and two paternal uncles (both with the initials D.D.)
but did not ask any of these relatives about the child’s possible
Indian ancestry. The record also reflects that father had another
brother, with the initials D.D., but did not provide contact
information for him.
III. DISCUSSION
A. Visitation
On March 11, 2021, the juvenile court terminated mother’s
and father’s visitation with the child. We affirmed that ruling.
(In re I.D., supra, B311124.) In this appeal, mother and father
6 Maternal grandmother apparently passed away during the
pendency of the proceedings in the juvenile court.
30
contend the juvenile court abused its discretion and violated their
“rights to familial association and fair and meaningful access to
the courts under the First and Fourth Amendments of the United
States Constitution” when it denied them visitation with the
child in the period after it terminated visitation. They argue the
court improperly delegated the visitation decision to third
parties, and its denial of visitation violated their due process
right to prove the parental-benefit exception to adoption
(§ 366.26, subd. (c)(1)(B)(i)). The court did not err.
Section 366.21, subdivision (h) provides, in part, “In any
case in which the court orders that a hearing pursuant to Section
366.26 shall be held, it shall also order the termination of
reunification services to the parent or legal guardian. The court
shall continue to permit the parent or legal guardian to visit the
child pending the hearing unless it finds that visitation would be
detrimental to the child.” We review a juvenile court’s visitation
order for an abuse of discretion. (In re R.R. (2010) 187
Cal.App.4th 1264, 1284.)
“Where a juvenile court orders visitation, the court shall
specify the frequency and duration of visits. [Citation.] The
time, place, and manner of visitation may be left to the legal
guardians, but the guardians shall not have discretion to decide
whether visitation actually occurs. [Citations.] A juvenile court
likewise may not improperly delegate decisions over whether
visitation will occur to a [third party].” (In re Grace C. (2010) 190
Cal.App.4th 1470, 1478.)
The juvenile court did not abuse its discretion in declining
to reinstate visitation between the child and mother and father.
The court appointed an Evidence Code section 730 evaluator to
assess the benefits of visitation. Based on the evaluator’s report,
31
the court found there was a continuing detriment to visitation—
both parents were still not “self-aware about the problems” in the
case, the child did not want to visit her parents, and the court
was concerned that visitation would disrupt the improvement in
the child’s behavior since she stopped visiting with the parents.
Also, the juvenile court did not delegate visitation decisions
to a third party. Instead, based on input from social workers, the
child’s therapist, and the Evidence Code section 730 evaluator, it
denied mother’s and father’s requests to reinstate visitation.
B. ICWA
Mother and father contend the juvenile court and the
Department failed to satisfy their inquiry duties under ICWA
and related California statutes to interview father and known
and available maternal and paternal extended family members
about the child’s possible Indian ancestry. We agree.
From its initial contact with a minor and the minor’s
family, the Department has a duty of inquiry to ask all involved
persons whether the child might be an Indian child. (In re H.V.
(2022) 75 Cal.App.5th 433, 437, citing § 224.2, subds. (a), (b).)
Section 224.2, subdivision (b) “specifies that once a child is placed
into the temporary custody of a county welfare department, such
as the [Department], the duty to inquire includes, but is not
limited to, asking the child, parents, legal guardian, Indian
custodian, extended family members,[7] others who have an
7 Under ICWA, “extended family member” includes “the
Indian child’s grandparent, aunt or uncle, brother or sister,
brother-in-law or sister-in-law, niece or nephew, first or second
cousin, or stepparent.” (25 U.S.C. § 1903(2).)
32
interest in the child, and the party reporting child abuse or
neglect, whether the child is, or may be, an Indian child.
[Citation.] [Citation.] [¶] We review claims of inadequate
inquiry into a child’s Indian ancestry for substantial evidence.”
(In re H.V., supra, 75 Cal.App.5th at pp. 437–438, internal
quotation marks and citations omitted.)
We agree with mother and father that this case involves
reversible error because there was noncompliance with the
inquiry requirements of ICWA and related California law. (In re
H.V., supra, 75 Cal.App.5th at p. 438.) Specifically, the
Department did not interview the child’s maternal extended
family members aunts E.H. and R.D., uncle R.D., or cousin B.D.,
or father or paternal extended family members grandmother
A.H., grandfather, or uncles D.D. about whether the child had
Indian ancestry. We therefore conditionally affirm the order
terminating mother’s and father’s parental rights and remand for
further proceedings to ensure compliance with ICWA and related
California law.
33
IV. DISPOSITION
The juvenile court’s orders terminating mother’s and
father’s parental rights under section 366.26 are conditionally
affirmed and remanded for proceedings required by this opinion.
On remand, the court shall order the Department to make
reasonable efforts to interview father and available extended
maternal and paternal family members about the possibility of
the child’s Indian ancestry and to report on the results of the
Department’s investigation. Nothing in this disposition
precludes the court from ordering additional inquiry of others
having an interest in the child. Based on the information
reported, if the court determines at a noticed hearing that no
additional inquiry or notice to tribes is necessary, the orders
terminating mother’s and father’s parental rights shall be
reinstated. If additional inquiry or notice is warranted, the court
shall make all necessary orders to ensure compliance with ICWA
and related California law.
NOT TO BE PUBLISHED IN THE OFFICIAL REPORTS
KIM, J.
I concur:
MOOR, J.
34
In re I.D.
B333797
BAKER, Acting P. J., Concurring
I agree with much of the opinion for the court.
C.D. and D.D.’s challenge to the juvenile court’s denial of
visitation is an argument that admittedly has some force. But I
am persuaded the juvenile court’s visitation orders were not
error. The expert evaluator appointed by the court believed
restarting visits between I.D. and the parents should be
“considered,” but only after I.D.’s therapist confirmed the child
was ready for such visits. That day never came before the
juvenile court was compelled to make a permanency
determination, however, and in light of the evidence about the
adverse effect of prior visits on I.D., the court’s visitation decision
was justified.
As to the parents’ Indian Child Welfare Act (ICWA)
argument, I agree there was error because the juvenile court
never made ICWA-related inquiry of D.D. I disagree, however,
with the broad ICWA-related directions the majority fashions for
the juvenile court to follow on remand. I would remand with
directions that require asking only D.D. whether he has any
Indian ancestry and leave the juvenile court free to undertake
additional inquiry that it believes appropriate under the
circumstances. (See, e.g., In re A.C. (2022) 86 Cal.App.5th 130,
145 (dis. opn. of Baker, J.) [“Social services agencies should take
seriously the potential sources of tribal membership information
specified in section 224.2 and inquire of parents and other family
members likely to have relevant information. But the juvenile
courts must manage that process in the first instance and our
review should be appropriately deferential, looking at the
sufficiency of the evidence for a juvenile court’s determination
that an adequate inquiry has been made to determine whether a
child is an Indian child”].)
BAKER, Acting P. J.
2
Vous vous demandez comment ce texte s’applique à votre situation ?
Consultation gratuite, sans engagement
Décrivez votre situation. Notre équipe vous recontactera par e-mail pour votre consultation.
Poursuivez vos recherches dans ChatGPT ou Claude
Connectez Omnilex pour rechercher dans le corpus juridique depuis votre assistant IA.