CourtListener 10031545•In re N.Z. CA2/2
Texte intégral
Filed 8/5/24 In re N.Z. CA2/2
NOT TO BE PUBLISHED IN THE OFFICIAL REPORTS
California Rules of Court, rule 8.1115(a), prohibits courts and parties from citing or relying on opinions
not certified for publication or ordered published, except as specified by rule 8.1115(b). This opinion
has not been certified for publication or ordered published for purposes of rule 8.1115.
IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA
SECOND APPELLATE DISTRICT
DIVISION TWO
In re N.Z., a Person Coming B330384
Under the Juvenile Court Law. (Los Angeles County
Super. Ct. No.
23CCJP00368A)
LOS ANGELES COUNTY
DEPARTMENT OF CHILDREN
AND FAMILY SERVICES,
Plaintiff and Respondent,
v.
A.M.,
Defendant and Appellant;
B.Z.,
Defendant and Respondent.
APPEAL from orders of the Superior Court of Los Angeles
County. Daniel Zeke Zeidler, Judge. Affirmed.
Janelle B. Price, under appointment by the Court of
Appeal, for Defendant and Appellant.
Dawyn R. Harrison, County Counsel, Kim Nemoy,
Assistant County Counsel, and Melania Vartanian, Deputy
County Counsel, for Plaintiff and Respondent.
Megan Turkat Schirn, under appointment by the Court of
Appeal, for Defendant and Respondent.
Lelah S. Forrey-Baker, under appointment by the Court of
Appeal, for Minor.
__________________________________________
At the disposition hearing below, the juvenile court placed
four-year-old N.Z. (son) with his previously noncustodial father
B.Z. (father), entered a final custody order, and terminated
dependency jurisdiction. On appeal, son’s mother, A.M. (mother),
challenges the juvenile court’s order terminating jurisdiction.
For several reasons, mother argues the juvenile court should
have continued its jurisdiction over son after being placed with
father, who lives in Alaska. Mother also claims the court
committed prejudicial error when it failed to make express
findings regarding its order terminating jurisdiction.
We find no reversible error and affirm.
BACKGROUND
1. The Family
Mother and father met when father was 17 years old and
mother was 19 years old. They dated for nine or ten years.
While together, both used drugs. Son was born in early 2019 and
is their only child together.
2
For a few years, mother and father lived with father’s
parents (paternal grandparents). Paternal grandmother
described mother and father’s relationship as “toxic” and said
mother stole from her. On one occasion, before son was born,
mother and father engaged in “an intense argument,” both
slapped and shoved the other, and father pushed mother out of a
car. Both mother and father filed police reports. Father was
convicted of domestic battery. At some point after son was born,
mother and father lived with a paternal aunt, who believed
mother was using marijuana.
Father ended his relationship with mother in 2020, when
son was about two years old. According to father, he ended the
relationship because “mother did not want to stop using meth”
and “he did not like the road mother had him going down.”
Around the same time, father’s family business failed and mother
began taking son to Mexico for extended periods of time to visit
her father (maternal grandfather). Father became depressed
and, for approximately one year after the break-up, he abused
alcohol and cocaine to “cope.” Eventually, in March 2022, father
moved to Alaska for work and “to get away from the negative
influences around him.” He saw son in person when he was home
and if mother made son available. Paternal relatives visited son
when mother allowed.
After breaking up with father, mother and son moved in
with mother’s mother (maternal grandmother). Maternal
grandmother was son’s primary caregiver. Mother said there is
no family law order pertaining to son and father never has
provided financial assistance for son.
3
2. Events Preceding Petition
In December 2022, mother gave birth to her second child, a
girl. At the time, both mother and her newborn daughter tested
positive for TCH and methamphetamine. The Department was
notified, and a Department social worker arrived to speak with
mother at the hospital. Mother told the social worker she had
been raped in Mexico by an uncle, which resulted in her becoming
pregnant. While at the hospital, mother arranged for her
daughter to be adopted.1 Mother denied using
methamphetamine while pregnant but admitted she smoked
marijuana during her pregnancy. She said she did not know she
was pregnant until one month before she gave birth. Mother told
the social worker she was homeless and had been “couch surfing,”
staying with her sister and friends. Mother also said maternal
grandmother lived in Mexico, as did most of her maternal
relatives. Mother denied having any other children or
pregnancies. When asked about son, mother said she did not
know who son was.
The same day, the Department social worker also spoke
with maternal grandmother, who (contrary to what mother had
said) lived in Los Angeles with two of her brothers. Maternal
grandmother told the social worker mother had given her verbal
permission to be son’s guardian, maternal grandmother provided
son’s basic care and necessities, son primarily lived with her and
looked to her as his caregiver. Maternal grandmother said
mother “comes and goes.” Maternal grandmother last saw
mother two weeks earlier. She did not know where mother was
when she was not at the home. Maternal grandmother said
1 The adoption was finalized soon after daughter’s birth.
4
father was not involved in son’s life. The social worker asked
maternal grandmother to encourage mother to call the social
worker, which maternal grandmother agreed to do.
One month later, in early January 2023, the social worker
again spoke with maternal grandmother at her home. Maternal
grandmother reported mother left for Mexico two weeks earlier to
visit maternal grandfather, who was sick. Mother took son with
her to Mexico. Maternal grandmother did not know when they
would return and was unable to contact them. Maternal
grandmother was not worried about son and said mother was a
good mother. A few days later, maternal grandmother told the
social worker mother planned to stay in Mexico with son until the
summer, at least.
On several occasions, the social worker asked maternal
grandmother to tell mother to call the social worker. Maternal
grandmother repeatedly said she gave mother the message to
call, and mother said she would call. Nonetheless, mother had
not contacted the social worker.
In late January 2023, the social worker spoke with father,
who lived in Alaska. Father told the social worker he moved to
Alaska almost one year earlier, in March 2022, for work. He had
a stable job, housing, and a girlfriend, who was employed and
had three children of her own. Before Alaska, father was living
with paternal grandparents in Los Angeles and, when mother
and son were not visiting maternal grandfather in Mexico, he
saw son consistently. Father indicated he had a good
relationship with son. Father and mother had informally agreed
that, after father moved to Alaska, son would continue to visit
with paternal grandparents.
5
It had been approximately five months since father last
saw son in person. Father visited son in August 2022 in Los
Angeles. At that time, according to father, “mother ‘did not look
good’ ” and appeared to be on drugs. Father said, “mother’s drug
of choice is crystal meth.” Father also communicated with son
through FaceTime in October 2022, at which time paternal
grandparents reported mother did not look well and appeared to
be pregnant. Father also had heard from some of mother’s
friends who believed mother was using drugs. In early 2023,
father was in Los Angeles and tried unsuccessfully to visit son at
maternal grandmother’s home. It does not appear father knew
mother recently had given birth to her daughter, then left with
son for Mexico.
Father told the social worker he drank alcohol occasionally
but did not “use any substances.” He had a history of minor legal
infractions and was arrested for the domestic violence incident
with mother before son was born. He said he completed his
classes and community service related to that arrest and has no
other history of or current issues with domestic violence.
Father wanted son placed with him. He said he had been
planning to seek custody of son before the Department became
involved. If, however, the Department did not want son to
relocate to Alaska, son could stay with paternal grandparents
and father would visit and send money to support son. Father
recently had been served with child support documents.
The social worker also spoke with paternal grandparents,
who reported having frequent contact with son prior to mother
taking him to Mexico. Paternal grandfather stated son liked to
visit them.
6
3. Petition
On January 31, 2023, the Department filed a two-count
Welfare and Institutions Code section 300 petition on behalf of
son (petition).2 The petition alleged mother’s history and current
use of methamphetamine and marijuana put son at risk, father
knew of mother’s substance abuse but failed to protect son, and
father’s history of substance abuse put son at risk.
At the detention hearing held the next day, the juvenile
court ordered son (who presumably still was in Mexico) detained
from mother and released to father over the Department’s
objection. The court ordered father either to reside in California
or to arrange for son to stay with paternal grandparents. The
court also required father to submit to drug testing and the
Department to conduct unannounced home visits. The juvenile
court granted the Department’s request for a protective custody
warrant for son and an arrest warrant for mother.
4. Further Investigation; Mother and Son’s Return
In February 2023, the Department reported mother had
called a Department social worker the same day the petition was
filed. In that phone call, mother told the social worker she was
not trying to hide from the social worker but was caring for
maternal grandfather in Mexico. Son was with her and was fine.
Mother confirmed maternal grandmother “had been telling her”
to call the social worker. Mother did not have a telephone and
was using maternal grandfather’s phone to make the call.
Initially, mother denied saying (when at the hospital after giving
birth to her daughter) she did not know who son was.
Eventually, however, mother explained she denied knowing son
2 Undesignated statutory references are to the Welfare and
Institutions Code.
7
“because she did not want [son] to be involved because he had
nothing to do with the situation.” The social worker told mother
a dependency case had been opened and encouraged mother to
return home with son so he could be assessed. Mother said she
understood and would return home within the next couple of
weeks, after maternal grandfather had a scheduled surgery and
was well enough for her to leave. Mother did not return home
with son in the next couple of weeks and did not maintain contact
with the Department.
Also in February 2023, a Department social worker spoke
with father by telephone. He stated his goal had been to raise
son and coparent with mother, but mother made that difficult.
Father admitted that, approximately two years earlier, he had
abused substances such as cocaine and alcohol. Father became
depressed after his business failed and mother moved with son to
Mexico. He said son was not in his care while under the
influence and, since moving to Alaska, he was “sober.” Father
agreed to submit to drug testing. In February 2023, father tested
negative for all substances.
Father told the social worker that after mother’s friends
told him mother appeared to be using drugs, he asked paternal
grandparents to check on son. Father was willing and able to
care for son and maintained consistent contact with the
Department. Father’s girlfriend also spoke with the social
worker. She had three children, ages 15, 11, and 7, and no
history of dependency cases or investigations involving her
children. The Department contacted a protective services
specialist in Alaska to inquire about a “courtesy home
assessment.”
8
A Department social worker also spoke with paternal
grandparents and a paternal aunt. Paternal grandparents were
able and willing to care for son. Paternal grandmother stated
mother did not allow paternal relatives to have regular contact
with son. Paternal grandmother believed son was attached to
mother. According to paternal grandmother, father was doing
very well in Alaska and his girlfriend was responsible and caring.
Paternal grandfather and the paternal aunt both stated paternal
relatives consistently sought contact with son, but mother was
not always available.
By March 2023, the Department had approved paternal
grandparents’ home in Los Angeles and recommended an
expedited home assessment or courtesy home visit for father’s
home in Alaska. The Department recommended, if son was
located, that he be placed with paternal grandparents until
father’s home in Alaska could be assessed. If father’s home was
determined to be safe, son could be placed with father in Alaska.
In late April, mother (who was still in Mexico) again
contacted a Department social worker. The social worker again
advised mother of the pending dependency case and that it was
important mother return home with son. Mother stated she
planned to return home within one to two weeks.
On May 7, 2023, mother and son returned home. In light of
the protective custody and arrest warrants, mother and son were
taken to a sheriff’s department station, where they were met by a
Department social worker. The responding sheriff’s deputy
reported “mother was very cooperative and [son] appeared to be
healthy and well nourished.” Mother noted she had told the
Department she was in Mexico caring for maternal grandfather.
She did not know she had done anything wrong and was willing
9
to cooperate with the Department. The social worker also
reported son “appeared healthy and well nourished.” Son was
placed with paternal grandparents. Father arrived in Los
Angeles two days later and was willing to stay “as long as
needed.”
At a hearing held a few days later, mother made her first
appearance in the case and requested that son be released to her
and to father. She also requested that son not be allowed to
relocate to Alaska, “as this would present a near insurmountable
hardship on visitation and reunification.” Counsel for son noted
son was “extremely bonded to his mother and would like to reside
with her,” however, at that time, counsel could not recommend
release to mother. At the hearing, the juvenile court ordered
mother and father to stay away from each other and mother to
stay away from paternal relatives. The court also ordered the
Department to facilitate visits with son for mother and maternal
relatives as often as possible and, if son moved to Alaska, to
facilitate frequent remote contact for mother with son. At the
hearing, the juvenile court recalled both the protective custody
warrant and arrest warrant.
In a June 2023 report, the Department stated father and
son were residing temporarily with paternal grandparents. The
Department reported son was shy with Department social
workers but appeared comfortable with father and paternal
grandparents. Son had medical and dental appointments that
month. He had five cavities and required a “small root canal.”
Department social workers spoke with father, who
indicated he wanted to return to Alaska with son but would
remain in Los Angeles to ensure son was comfortable with him
and paternal grandparents as well as to “see what will happen
10
with court.” He did not want to leave without son. Father said
he wanted the dependency case to remain open as long as he was
in Los Angeles and appreciated the support he was receiving with
respect to monitored visits for mother. Father expressed concern
that mother might make allegations against him. On May 12,
2023, father again tested negative for substances.
A Department social worker also spoke with mother. The
social worker stated mother was “emotional,” “cooperative,
coherent, receptive during the interview and did not appear to be
under the influence of drugs or alcohol.” Mother was worried
about son, stating, “I know he misses me. I know he’s sad.” She
said this was the first time son was in father’s care. However,
she was not concerned for son’s safety because paternal
grandparents were helping. Mother did not want son to live in
Alaska. She denied restricting paternal grandparents’ ability to
see son. Mother said she had been staying with her brother in
Los Angeles but needed to leave that home in two days.
Mother believed she was a good mother to son, always took
care of him, and never neglected him. She wanted son returned
to her care and stated, “No more drug mistakes.” Mother
reported she started using marijuana when she was 16 years old
and methamphetamine when she was 21 years old. Mother said
she last used marijuana in April 2023 (i.e., during the most
recent time she was in Mexico with son) and methamphetamine
in December 2022. She used both drugs while pregnant with her
daughter. Mother said she and father both used drugs when they
were together but not at the same time and they would deny
their drug use to each other, which “ ‘caused problems.’ ”
According to mother, father used methamphetamine and cocaine.
She said a paternal aunt told her father “was sent to live in
11
Alaska due to his ongoing substance abuse issues.” She said
father knew of her drug use. During May and June 2023, mother
twice tested positive for marijuana, failed to show for one test,
and tested negative once. By June 2023, mother had enrolled in
an inpatient program and agreed to participate in the
Department’s “Drug Court program.”
Mother had monitored visits with son several times a week
for two hours. A Department social worker reported that, at a
June 2023 visit, son refused to get out of the car to see mother.
Eventually, however, son participated in the visit. According to
father, son said he did not want to visit with mother.
Maternal grandmother stated mother and son “ ‘have a
good bond’ ” and son was “ ‘attached to’ ” mother. Maternal
grandmother continued to deny mother had substance abuse
issues. She believed father had a temper and was worried
paternal relatives might “brainwash” son.
The Department noted mother had “been using substances
for approximately 14 years.” The Department believed mother
would benefit from individual therapy and a substance abuse
program. Although mother recently had enrolled in a substance
abuse program, it was too early to consider releasing son back to
her care. As to father, the Department stated “there is no
indication of any recent use of substances” and he had tested
negative twice, with another test pending. Based on father’s past
use of substances, the Department believed he should participate
in random drug testing. The Department did not see a need for
domestic violence counseling despite his earlier altercation with
mother, but recommended parenting education. The Department
recommended son be placed with father under Department
supervision.
12
5. Adjudication, Disposition, and Termination of
Jurisdiction
On June 29, 2023, approximately two months after mother
and son returned from Mexico, the juvenile court held a combined
adjudication and disposition hearing. At the start of the hearing,
the juvenile court stated it “was leaning towards” conducting the
adjudication and, assuming the court sustained the petition,
allowing father and son to go to Alaska. Then, at a later-held
disposition hearing, the court would consider closing the case
with a custody order. After the court so advised the parties,
counsel for father and for the Department confirmed the
Department already had authorized father to move to Alaska
with son.
After hearing argument, the court dismissed the
allegations of the petition against father and found father was
nonoffending. The court sustained the allegations against
mother and declared son a dependent of the court under
subdivision (b) of section 300.
Despite what it had contemplated at the start of the
hearing, and without objection, the court then moved directly to
disposition. Counsel for father argued further court supervision
was not necessary because son was safe with father. Father’s
counsel asked the court to terminate its jurisdiction, noting
mother could “continue to make progress and work to regain
custody without court supervision.” Son’s attorney joined father’s
request for termination of jurisdiction and entry of a custody
order. Counsel believed son was safe with father and court
supervision was not necessary. Counsel for son also argued
father should have sole legal custody. Counsel stated father and
13
mother had difficulty coparenting and mother denied father
contact with son when she took him to Mexico for months.
On the other hand, counsel for mother objected to an order
terminating jurisdiction and closing the case. Mother’s counsel
requested a home of parents order or, in the alternative,
unmonitored visits for mother at her inpatient program.
Mother’s counsel reminded the court mother had been the
previous custodial parent and she denied “abscond[ing] with [son]
to Mexico.” Counsel for mother also argued father’s drug use,
awareness of mother’s drug use, and domestic violence outburst
were “not so distant.” Mother believed the case should be kept
open not only to ensure son’s safety but to allow her an
opportunity to reunite with son. However, if the court
terminated its jurisdiction over mother’s objection, mother’s
counsel requested mother be granted joint legal custody of son
and at least six hours of weekly visitation. Mother’s counsel did
not otherwise address visitation.
Counsel for the Department also argued the juvenile court
should keep the case open. Recognizing the length of time
mother had cared for son, the Department asked the court to
grant services for mother to give her an opportunity to reunify
with son, which the Department believed was in son’s best
interest. The Department also noted father previously had asked
for the case to remain open so he could receive support from the
Department. Finally, if the court chose to terminate jurisdiction
over the Department’s objection, the Department did not object to
the proposed custody order.
After hearing argument, the juvenile court removed son
from mother’s custody and care and placed him with father. Over
the objections of the Department and mother, the court
14
terminated jurisdiction with a custody order granting father sole
legal and sole physical custody of son. The court granted mother
monitored visits or contact with son for a minimum of six hours
each week. The court also ordered mother and father to
communicate exclusively through “Talking Parents or another
app.” The court explained it required monitored visits because
mother had not made substantial progress in or completed a
substance abuse treatment program, domestic violence for
victims program, individual counseling, or a 12-step program.
Finally, the court noted the custody order would be filed in the
family law court, where parents could seek modifications of the
order.
The juvenile court signed and entered the final custody
order that same day.
Mother appealed.
DISCUSSION
1. Termination of Dependency Jurisdiction
Mother argues the juvenile court erred when, after placing
son with father, it terminated dependency jurisdiction. Mother
claims, rather than terminate jurisdiction, the juvenile court
should have maintained jurisdiction for a minimum of six months
while the parents engaged in services under Department
supervision.3 Although mother’s preferred outcome was one
option the juvenile court could have chosen under the applicable
statutory scheme, we conclude the juvenile court did not abuse its
3 Mother does not challenge the juvenile court’s order
placing son with father. Thus, although briefed by the
Department, we do not address that issue.
15
discretion when it chose a different option under the same
scheme.
a. Applicable Law
Section 361.2 is applicable here.4 Subdivision (a) of that
section provides: “If a court orders removal of a child pursuant to
Section 361, the court shall first determine whether there is a
parent of the child, with whom the child was not residing at the
time that the events or conditions arose that brought the child
within the provisions of Section 300, who desires to assume
custody of the child. If that parent requests custody, the court
shall place the child with the parent unless it finds that
placement with that parent would be detrimental to the safety,
protection, or physical or emotional well-being of the child.”
(§ 361.2, subd. (a).)
After placing son with father under subdivision (a) of
section 361.2, subdivision (b) of that same section gave the court
the following three options: “(1) Order that [father] become legal
and physical custodian of the child. The court may also provide
reasonable visitation by [mother]. The court shall then terminate
its jurisdiction over the child. The custody order shall continue
unless modified by a subsequent order of the superior court. The
order of the juvenile court shall be filed in any domestic relation
proceeding between the parents. [¶] (2) Order that [father]
assume custody subject to the jurisdiction of the juvenile court
and require that a home visit be conducted within three months.
. . . [¶] (3) Order that [father] assume custody subject to the
supervision of the juvenile court. In that case the court may
4 On appeal, father cites to section 364. However, that
section is inapplicable here, where the juvenile court placed son
with father, a previously noncustodial parent.
16
order that reunification services be provided to [mother], or the
court may order that services be provided solely to [father] in
order to allow [father] to retain later custody without court
supervision, or that services be provided to both parents, in
which case the court shall determine, at review hearings held
pursuant to Section 366, which parent, if either, shall have
custody of the child.” (§ 361.2, subd. (b) (subdivision (b)).)
Thus, subdivision (b) “vests the court with the discretion
either to deny or offer reunification services when the children
are placed in the physical custody of the formerly noncustodial
parent.” (In re Nada R. (2001) 89 Cal.App.4th 1166, 1179.) “The
question is whether juvenile court services and ongoing
supervision were necessary to protect the child from harm.” (In
re D.B. (2020) 48 Cal.App.5th 613, 624; see also In re Destiny D.
(2017) 15 Cal.App.5th 197, 211 [“Jurisdiction should not be
terminated unless the court concludes services and ongoing
supervision are not necessary to protect the child.”].) Of course,
underlying this is the “fundamental premise of dependency law,”
which is “to serve the best interests of the dependent child.” (In
re Samuel G. (2009) 174 Cal.App.4th 502, 510.)
b. Standard of Review
We apply the abuse of discretion standard of review to the
juvenile court’s decision to place son with father and terminate
jurisdiction. (In re K.B. (2015) 239 Cal.App.4th 972, 981; In re
Nada R., supra, 89 Cal.App.4th at p. 1179.) Under this standard
of review, we will not reverse the juvenile court’s determination
“ ‘ “unless the trial court has exceeded the limits of legal
discretion by making an arbitrary, capricious, or patently absurd
determination.” ’ ” (In re Stephanie M. (1994) 7 Cal.4th 295, 318.)
“ ‘The appropriate test for abuse of discretion is whether the trial
17
court exceeded the bounds of reason. When two or more
inferences can reasonably be deduced from the facts, the
reviewing court has no authority to substitute its decision for
that of the trial court.’ ” (Id. at pp. 318–319.)
c. No Abuse of Discretion
After placing son with father (the previously noncustodial
parent) under section 361.2, subdivision (a), the juvenile court
chose to proceed under the first option afforded by subdivision (b).
In other words, the court chose not to offer reunification services
but, instead, granted father sole legal and physical custody of
son, provided visitation for mother, and terminated its
jurisdiction over son. (§ 361.2, subd. (b)(1).)
Mother does not and did not object to son’s placement with
father. Indeed, no one objected to son’s placement with father.
Rather, mother argues the juvenile court erred in terminating its
jurisdiction over son. For several reasons, mother claims it was
in son’s best interest—both for his safety and to provide an
opportunity to reunify with mother—to keep the case open and
continue the court’s supervision under either of the other two
options afforded by subdivision (b).
First, mother claims the juvenile court improperly failed to
evaluate either father’s need for services or the appropriateness
of father’s home. Mother points to father’s previous arrest for
domestic violence, father’s history of substance abuse, and the
lack of any assessment of father’s home in Alaska. Initially, we
note father was nonoffending and there was no objection to son’s
placement with him while the case was pending. We also note
the record is devoid of evidence that father was ever
inappropriate or unsafe with son. There is no evidence father
had ongoing domestic violence issues with mother and no
18
indication father had domestic violence issues with anyone else.
Since being alerted to the proceedings below, father was
responsive, cooperative, and testing negative. Additionally, the
Department not only recommended placing son with father but
also, by the time of the June 2023 adjudication and disposition
hearing, had authorized father to move with son to Alaska. Also,
although mother implies father had not been a custodial parent
of son, he and mother both raised son until son was about one
and a half years old. Although the juvenile court certainly could
have ordered services and an assessment of father’s home in
Alaska, on this record, it was not an abuse of the court’s
discretion not to do so.
Second, mother claims the juvenile court abused its
discretion when it denied her the opportunity to participate in
services and, therefore, also the potential to reunify with son.
Mother notes she was son’s custodial parent, shared a bond with
son, had begun drug testing, recently had entered an inpatient
treatment program, and agreed to participate in “Drug Court.”
Certainly, the juvenile court could have opted to keep the case
open and provide mother with services, which might have
improved her relationship with son and her odds of reunifying
with him, but the court was not required to do so. Given the facts
of this case, we see no abuse of discretion in the court’s decision
not to accommodate mother’s request. Son was comfortable with
father. Father was ready and willing to care for son. Although
mother tried to minimize it, her history of substance abuse was
longstanding and, only recently, had she begun to address it.
Mother had, and still has, avenues available to her not only to
continue addressing the issues that brought son before the court,
but also eventually to seek modification of the custody order. As
19
the case has now moved into family court, mother can petition
that court to modify the custody order. (§§ 302, subd. (d), 362.4.)
Finally, mother claims the juvenile court’s visitation order
is arbitrary and capricious, and not in son’s best interests. Given
father and son’s out of state location, the apparent discord
between the parents, and the lack of detail in the order, mother
believes the “visitation order is virtually unworkable.” Mother
worries father might not accommodate her visitation requests,
including choosing a monitor or method of visitation. Although
it seems mother and father could improve communication with
each other, the record does not indicate father did or would go out
of his way to impede mother’s relationship with son. If, however,
father obstructs mother’s visitation with son, mother can seek
enforcement or request modification of the order in family court.
(§§ 302, subd. (d), 362.4; In re D.B., supra, 48 Cal.App.5th at
p. 627.) Finally, at disposition and in anticipation the court
might terminate jurisdiction, counsel for mother requested a
minimum of six hours a week of visitation, which the court
granted. Mother made no objections and suggested no
modifications to the court’s visitation order when discussed in
court below. Having not raised her objections below, mother
cannot now complain of them here. (In re Christopher B. (1996)
43 Cal.App.4th 551, 558.)
To be sure, mother persuasively argues it would have been
reasonable for the juvenile court to keep the case open, offer
services to mother and father, and assess father’s home. Had the
court chosen that path, it would not have been an abuse of
discretion. (See In re Austin P. (2004) 118 Cal.App.4th 1124.)
However, the court had a variety of options from which to choose.
We conclude the option it did choose—termination of jurisdiction
20
with a custody order—also was not an abuse of discretion. On
the record before us, the juvenile court’s decision neither
exceeded the bounds of reason nor was patently absurd. (In re
Stephanie M., supra, 7 Cal.4th at p. 318–319.) We are not
authorized to substitute one reasonable decision for another.
(Ibid.)
2. Failure to Make Express Findings
Mother also argues the juvenile court erred when it failed
to make express findings supporting its decision to terminate
jurisdiction under subdivision (b). Counsel for son correctly
agrees this was error. The parties disagree, however, whether
this error was prejudicial to mother. We conclude it was
harmless error and, therefore, not a ground for reversal.
a. Applicable Law
Section 361.2, subdivision (c) provides in full, “The court
shall make a finding, either in writing or on the record, of the
basis for its determination under subdivisions (a) and (b) [of that
section].”
“An express finding on a contested issue—or a statement of
reasons for a judicial decision—can shape and improve the
adjudicatory process through either or both [of] two mechanisms.
First, it can directly influence the trial court’s actual reasoning
process by compelling it to consciously consider and resolve
specified issues. Second, it can enhance appellate review of the
trial court’s reasoning by making that reasoning explicit and
reducing, if not eliminating, the role of inference on appeal.
Ordinarily, of course, appellate courts will indulge all reasonable
inferences favorable to the judgment. But this familiar doctrine
becomes potentially subversive where the Legislature requires
the trial court to make an express finding. Such a requirement
21
may be deprived of all force if appellate courts feel free to infer a
supporting finding where the trial court has left the record silent.
For that reason the doctrine of implied findings may be given
limited scope where an express finding is required.” (In re J.S.
(2011) 196 Cal.App.4th 1069, 1078.)
“The same cannot be said, however, of another familiar
barrier to appellate reversal: the rule of harmless error. Before
any judgment can be reversed for ordinary error, it must appear
that the error complained of ‘has resulted in a miscarriage of
justice.’ (Cal. Const., art. VI, § 13.) Reversal is justified ‘only
when the court, “after an examination of the entire cause,
including the evidence,” is of the “opinion” that it is reasonably
probable that a result more favorable to the appealing party
would have been reached in the absence of the error.’ ” (In re
J.S., supra, 196 Cal.App.4th at p. 1078.)
b. The error was harmless.
The juvenile court failed to articulate its basis for
terminating jurisdiction and issuing its custody order. This was
error. (§ 361.2, subd. (c).) Nonetheless and contrary to mother’s
position, we conclude the court’s error was not prejudicial and not
a ground for reversal.
As we discussed above, the juvenile court’s decision to
terminate jurisdiction under subdivision (b) was reasonable and
appropriate. Based on the record before us, we see no reason why
the court would have come to a different decision had it complied
with the statutory requirement to express the basis for its
decision. Immediately before terminating jurisdiction and
issuing the custody order, the juvenile court heard argument on
why it should or should not terminate jurisdiction. The court was
persuaded son was safe with father and its jurisdiction was no
22
longer necessary. Although, as mother mentions, the juvenile
court began the adjudication and disposition hearing by noting it
was “leaning towards” addressing jurisdiction and delaying
disposition so father could move to Alaska with son, this was
simply the court’s inclination before hearing from counsel. The
court then heard, for example, that the Department already had
authorized father to move to Alaska with son and no one opposed
placement with father. As is apparent, after hearing argument
from all counsel, the court changed its mind, which of course it is
permitted to do. (In re J.S., supra, 196 Cal.App.4th at p. 1081.)
Additionally, at the close of that hearing, the court made
comments indicating it understood what it was doing and would
not have come to a different decision had it made express
findings. Specifically, the court briefly mentioned an earlier case
in which the Court of Appeal reversed the juvenile court’s order
placing a child with an out-of-state parent. The juvenile court
distinguished the instant case, noting mother and father both can
seek modifications of the custody order because it will be filed in
family court and given a “family law number.”
We decipher no reasonable probability that, had the
juvenile court made express findings as it was required to do, the
court would have reached a different conclusion more favorable to
mother.
23
DISPOSITION
The juvenile court’s June 29, 2023 orders are affirmed.
NOT TO BE PUBLISHED.
LUI, P. J.
We concur:
ASHMANN-GERST, J.
HOFFSTADT, J.
24
Vous vous demandez comment ce texte s’applique à votre situation ?
Consultation gratuite, sans engagement
Décrivez votre situation. Notre équipe vous recontactera par e-mail pour votre consultation.
Poursuivez vos recherches dans ChatGPT ou Claude
Connectez Omnilex pour rechercher dans le corpus juridique depuis votre assistant IA.