CourtListener 10014301•Cintron v. Lizarraga CA4/1
Texte intégral
Filed 7/25/24 Cintron v. Lizarraga CA4/1
NOT TO BE PUBLISHED IN OFFICIAL REPORTS
California Rules of Court, rule 8.1115(a), prohibits courts and parties from citing or relying on opinions not certified for
publication or ordered published, except as specified by rule 8.1115(b). This opinion has not been certified for publication
or ordered published for purposes of rule 8.1115.
COURT OF APPEAL, FOURTH APPELLATE DISTRICT
DIVISION ONE
STATE OF CALIFORNIA
RICARDO CINTRON, D082524
Respondent,
v. (Super. Ct. No. 23FDV01703S)
LAYDA LIZARRAGA,
Appellant.
APPEAL from an order of the Superior Court of San Diego County, Tim
Nader, Judge. Affirmed.
Layda Lizarraga, in pro. per., for Appellant.
No appearance for Respondent.
MEMORANDUM OPINION1
Layda Lizarraga appeals from the trial court’s order granting a one-
year domestic violence restraining order (DVRO) against her for the
1 This case is appropriate for resolution by memorandum opinion
because it raises “no substantial issues of law or fact.” (Cal. Stds. Jud.
Admin., § 8.1; see People v. Garcia (2002) 97 Cal.App.4th 847.)
protection of Ricardo Cintron and his parents. Because Lizarraga has failed
to meet her appellate burden of affirmatively demonstrating reversible error,
we affirm the court’s order.
BACKGROUND
On April 18, 2023, Cintron filed a request for a DVRO against
Lizarraga. They share a son who was then 17 years old. Cintron asked to
include their son and his parents as additional protected parties. He further
requested an order that he be awarded sole legal and sole physical custody of
their son, with no visitation for Lizarraga.
In his supporting declaration, Cintron averred his son called to tell him
Lizarraga “was being abusive” and he was afraid of her. Cintron then “filed
for custody,” which made problems he had with Lizarraga “worse.” After
Cintron’s wife, Denise Cintron, tried to serve Lizarraga with the “paperwork”
for their custody hearing, Lizarraga called Cintron and told him he was a
“ ‘bitch’ ” and his wife was a “ ‘fat bitch.’ ” Lizarraga then “escalated things.”
Cintron asked her to leave him alone. When she did not, he blocked her
telephone number. Lizarraga then began calling his wife and family instead.
Lizarraga “threatened” his parents by “following them to work and home,”
and was calling them from “unknown numbers with threats to call the border
patrol.” On April 9, 2023, Lizarraga called Denise and was “very unhappy”
Cintron had requested custody. Lizarraga told Denise they were going to
“ ‘regret’ ” doing that. She “threatened” Denise and called her a “ ‘bitch.’ ”
She told Cintron his “wife is no good for [him].” Then a week later, on April
15, the passenger and front side windows of Cintron’s car “were smashed.”
Cintron “believe[d Lizarraga] was responsible for this.”
The same day Cintron filed his request, the trial court issued a
temporary restraining order (TRO) against Lizarraga. The court included
2
Cintron’s parents but not the son as protected parties, and declined to issue
any child custody and visitation orders pending an evidentiary hearing.
On May 24, 2023, Lizarraga, with legal representation, filed a
response. In her declaration, Lizarraga denied Cintron’s allegations of abuse.
She averred Denise’s request for a permanent civil restraining order, based
on “the same [alleged] facts,” had been denied on May 8. The parties’ son had
been living “solely” with her and had only recently “reconnect[ed]” with
Cintron. Denise “encouraged” Cintron to file a motion to modify the parties’
custody of their son, but Lizarraga was “not upset or angry” about it. It was
only after the Family Court Services mediator recommended that Lizarraga
maintain primary custody of their son that Cintron filed his DVRO request.
Lizarraga denied making any threats, damaging Cintron’s property, calling
from blocked numbers, or sending negative texts.
Lizarraga lodged several exhibits2 with her response, including
“documentation from [her] telephone’s call-log” to show the only texts from
April 9, 2023 were from Cintron to her; a report card showing their son was
failing school and a school letter expelling their son since he was living with
2 We do not have copies of these exhibits in the record on appeal.
Lizarraga requested the clerk to include only the “Notice of Lodgment,” but
not the actual exhibits. Although it may be inadvertent, Lizarraga did not
check the box indicating she was requesting the clerk to include her exhibits.
California Rules of Court, rule 8.122(b), provides the clerk’s transcript “must”
include “[a]ny . . . document filed . . . in the case in superior court” pertaining
to the issues on appeal (rule 8.122(b)(3)(A)); and “[a]ny exhibit admitted in
evidence, refused, or lodged” (id., (b)(3)(B)). However, because we do not
reweigh the evidence, the omission of the exhibits does not change the
analysis. (See Reynaud v. Technicolor Creative Services USA, Inc. (2020) 46
Cal.App.5th 1007, 1015 [A reviewing court does “not reweigh evidence or
reassess the credibility of witnesses,” as it is “not a second trier of fact.”
(Cleaned up.)].)
3
Cintron; and an audio recording of Cintron’s threatening voicemail of March
23, 2023. Last, Lizarraga averred Cintron was “subject to a restraining order
several years ago when he threatened [her] and [their son] with a knife.”
The trial court held an evidentiary hearing on May 30, 2023. Cintron
appeared as a self-represented litigant, while Lizarraga appeared with her
attorney. A court reporter was not requested and the hearing was not
reported. The court’s minutes state, “The [c]ourt finds the Petitioner
[Cintron] has met the burden of proof by preponderance of the evidence,
demonstrating recent acts of domestic violence to support the request for a
restraining order. [¶] The [c]ourt grants the Petitioner’s request for a
restraining order for a period of (1) year; restraining order will expire
5/30/24.” Consistent with the court’s minutes, a DVRO was issued against
Lizarraga for one year and it included Cintron and his parents as additional
protected parties. The court also issued a child custody and visitation order,
awarding the parties joint legal custody and Lizarraga with primary physical
custody and visitation to Cintron.
DISCUSSION
Lizarraga appeals the trial court’s order granting the DVRO, asserting
various errors: (1) the court “made a mistake” in taking her exhibits to be
Cintron’s evidence; (2) her attorney, who appeared “remotely” was not
permitted to clarify the court’s mistake; (3) she “was not allowed to speak at
all during the entire hearing”; (4) Cintron did not file any evidence to support
his allegations; and (5) the court “refused to hear valid evidence that supports
[her] innocence of false allegations.” She asserts, “In conclusion, all these
allegations were exaggerated and false.” She specifically contends
substantial evidence does not support the trial court’s finding that she
threatened Cintron or broke his car windows.
4
The difficulty with Lizarraga’s arguments on appeal is that she has not
provided us with an adequate record to evaluate her claims of error. As
noted, there is no reporter transcript of the evidentiary hearing. She has not
provided us with a settled statement of the hearing. Neither the trial court’s
minutes nor the order after hearing contain any factual determinations or
legal analysis explaining the court’s decision to grant Cintron’s request for a
DVRO. As the party challenging that order, Lizarraga has the burden to
provide an adequate record for meaningful review and affirmatively
demonstrate error. She has not done this.
It is a well-established foundational premise that on appeal, “a
judgment or order of the lower court is presumed correct. All intendments
and presumptions are indulged to support it on matters as to which the
record is silent, and error must be affirmatively shown. This is not only a
general principle of appellate practice but an ingredient of the constitutional
doctrine of reversible error.” (Denham v. Superior Court (1970) 2 Cal.3d 557,
564 [cleaned up].) “Consequently, appellant has the burden of providing an
adequate record. Failure to provide an adequate record on an issue requires
that the issue be resolved against appellant. Without a record, either by
transcript or settled statement, a reviewing court must make all
presumptions in favor of the validity of the judgment.” (Randall v. Mousseau
(2016) 2 Cal.App.5th 929, 935 [cleaned up].)
Because we are unable to fairly evaluate Lizarraga’s contentions in
light of the inadequate record, we must affirm. (Aguilar v. Avis Rent A Car
System, Inc. (1999) 21 Cal.4th 121, 132 [rejecting defendant’s claim based on
failure to provide an adequate record].)
5
DISPOSITION
The May 30, 2023 order granting the domestic violence restraining
order is affirmed.
DO, J.
WE CONCUR:
O’ROURKE, Acting P. J.
RUBIN, J.
6
Vous vous demandez comment ce texte s’applique à votre situation ?
Consultation gratuite, sans engagement
Décrivez votre situation. Notre équipe vous recontactera par e-mail pour votre consultation.
Poursuivez vos recherches dans ChatGPT ou Claude
Connectez Omnilex pour rechercher dans le corpus juridique depuis votre assistant IA.