CourtListener 10005758•Moran v. Palacios CA2/7
Texte intégral
Filed 7/17/24 Moran v. Palacios CA2/7
NOT TO BE PUBLISHED IN THE OFFICIAL REPORTS
California Rules of Court, rule 8.1115(a), prohibits courts and parties from citing or relying on opinions
not certified for publication or ordered published, except as specified by rule 8.1115(b). This opinion has
not been certified for publication or ordered published for purposes of rule 8.1115.
IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA
SECOND APPELLATE DISTRICT
DIVISION SEVEN
MICHAEL MORAN, B321062
Appellant, (Los Angeles County
Super. Ct. No. PD052806)
v.
VICTORIA PALACIOS,
Respondent.
APPEAL from an order of the Superior Court of
Los Angeles County, Robert E. Sanchez DuFour, Judge.
Affirmed.
Michael Moran, in pro. per., for Appellant.
No appearance by Respondent.
________________________
INTRODUCTION
Michael Moran (Father) appeals from a postjudgment
custody order modifying a previous custody order regarding his
daughter, Jessica. The order from which Father appeals granted
Victoria Palacios (Mother) sole physical custody of Jessica and
sole legal custody for the purpose of making decisions regarding
Jessica’s medical and mental health needs. Father has not met
his burden of demonstrating the family law court erred, and we
affirm.
FACTUAL AND PROCEDURAL BACKGROUND
Jessica was born in 2007. In 2011, Father filed for
dissolution of his marriage with Mother. The parties then
engaged in an extended custody dispute, in which the family law
court observed that “the Parties have been in conflict since the
birth of the Minor Child, and have demonstrated a complete
inability to co-parent or co-exist.”
In the 2014 judgment of dissolution, Father was awarded
sole physical and legal custody of Jessica with visitation for
Mother. Throughout her elementary school years, Jessica lived
with Father during the school week and visited with Mother on
weekends and certain holidays. Mother and Father each sought
modification of the custody order after the 2014 judgment at
various times. In 2017, Mother sought joint physical and legal
custody of Jessica. In 2018, Father requested permission to move
to Oregon. In 2019, Mother again sought modification of the
custody orders, seeking sole physical custody of Jessica. The
family court granted Mother temporary physical custody in 2020
and made this order permanent in 2022. These orders are the
subject of this appeal.
2
A. December 2020 Hearing
On December 15, 2020, the court (Judge Joshua Wayser)
conducted an evidentiary hearing regarding Mother’s request for
modification of the custody order for Jessica, who was then
13 years old and in middle school. A court-appointed interviewer
testified regarding her conversations with Jessica and a social
worker from the Los Angeles County Department of Children and
Family Services (Department).
Jessica told the interviewer she no longer wanted to live
with Father due to his angry outbursts. Once, Father pulled her
hair, yelled at her, and pushed her against the wall. According to
Jessica, Father sometimes threw her phone into the neighbor’s
yard, threw her clothes on the roof of their home, locked her
things in his car, and used scissors to destroy her clothing when
he was angry with her. She informed the interviewer, “when he
gets mad, he throws stuff or he kicks the wall, and he throws
containers of food at me or water bottles.” Jessica stated she
cried and felt scared when he acted like this. When asked what
Father did in response to her crying, Jessica responded, he would
yell “‘a lot more,’” demand she stop crying, and throw out more of
her things.
Jessica recounted an incident when Father tried to take her
phone, “grabbing both of [her] arms, and [she] ended up getting
cuts and scratches on [her] hands from his nails.” In the previous
two months, Jessica stated she called the police twice about
Father, and Mother also called the police twice.
Jessica reported that Father disparaged her and Mother,
questioned their intelligence, and referred to them using ugly
epithets. Jessica further related: “‘he will say stuff like, quote,
your mom ruined my life, unquote.’” Jessica stated that Father
believed Mother was “crazy and will never care about [Jessica]
like [he] do[es].” Jessica declared at the end of the interview,
3
“‘I’m not going back to my dad’s house. I refuse to go back to my
dad’s house.’”
The interviewer also spoke with a social worker from the
Department, who at the time was investigating a referral
relating to Father’s reported emotional abuse and general
neglect. The social worker informed the interviewer that she
spoke with Mother and Father at their respective homes. Father
admitted to the social worker he took Jessica’s shoes and clothes
and threw her things on the roof. Father also admitted he
slapped Jessica once. The social worker stated she believed
Father’s behavior towards Jessica was “immature” and “an
inappropriate parenting style.”
Father testified at the hearing that Jessica had only
recently changed her mind about living with him. He suggested
he had recordings of her saying she was glad she went with him.
He believed Mother had been leading Jessica to mistrust him for
years. He nevertheless admitted to the court he threw Jessica’s
phone in the neighbor’s yard and threw her clothes on the roof.
He told the court Jessica had said she would lie about him to get
him to stop taking her things.
The court acknowledged the long history of the case,
including that a child evaluator made adverse findings against
Mother in 2013, which led to Father gaining custody of Jessica.
The court noted the parents’ long-standing animosity and the
resulting “messy” record in which Mother and Father each
accused the other of abuse.
The court temporarily granted Mother sole physical custody
because Jessica needed time away from the conflict between the
parents and from her conflict with Father. Legal custody
remained joint. Father was granted visitation on Saturdays. The
court further ordered the parties to return in six months for a
4
status hearing and for the court to consider further changes to
the custody order.
B. May 2021 and September 2021 Hearings
On May 18, 2021, the parties appeared before Judge Robert
Sanchez DuFour for the scheduled status hearing. Father
explained his circumstances had changed since December so he
was less stressed and better able to care for Jessica. He was
accepted to a master’s degree program for landscape architecture
and had found work. Father contended Mother was keeping
Jessica from visiting or speaking with him.
Mother’s counsel confirmed there had been very little
visitation with Father in the intervening five months due to
Jessica’s refusal to speak to or visit with Father. Mother testified
Jessica told her of suicidal ideation while she lived with Father
but indicated Jessica did not feel the same after moving in with
Mother. Mother also reported Father obstructed her attempts to
seek gynecological care and mental health services for Jessica.
The court appointed minor’s counsel to represent Jessica’s
interests, and it ordered the parties to coordinate therapy for
Jessica by providing the names of two psychologists or
psychiatrists to minor’s counsel. The court also ordered Mother
to encourage Jessica to visit with Father but did not otherwise
change the existing visitation schedule. During the court’s
ruling, Father began to call Mother names in open court and
accused her of lying. The court noted Father’s outburst for the
record and observed the court bailiff had to stand between Father
and Mother. Although Father did not leave his seat, he was
pointing and yelling at Mother.
The parties appeared before Judge DuFour again on
September 14, 2021. Minor’s counsel confirmed the dysfunction
between the parents and explained the process of getting Jessica
5
into therapy was in the preliminary stages. Father again stated
Mother was keeping Jessica from him. The court continued the
hearing to January 25, 2022 to allow Jessica to begin therapy.
C. January 2022 Hearing
On January 25, 2022, the parties again appeared before
Judge DuFour for the evidentiary hearing. The court noted
Mother and Father had both filed requests for orders to modify
child custody and visitation, and Father had filed a request for an
order for Jessica to attend therapy in the interim. The court
indicated it would issue permanent custody and visitation orders
after the hearing.
Minor’s counsel advised the court that “for about eight
months now we have been going around in circles trying to find a
therapist for this child.” On November 1, 2021, minor’s counsel
informed the parties by email that he had selected a therapist
pursuant to the authority granted to him by the court. Although
he had confirmed with the therapist that she would accept the
case before sending the email to the parties, counsel later
received an email the same day from the therapist indicating she
was no longer comfortable working on the case. The therapist
said: “I got two long voice mails from Michael Moran today
stating that he does not want Jessica to work with me. He was
very adamant about this for a multitude of reasons. He sounded
very upset and agitated. I know I need the respect and
cooperation of both parents to successfully treat a child.”
Jessica’s counsel described Father as “incessant” and
agreed with Jessica’s description that he was “intense.” Counsel
stated Jessica was “over this” and “fed up.” She did not want to
see Father or speak with him. For these reasons, minor’s counsel
believed it was in Jessica’s best interest for Mother to receive sole
legal custody for the purpose of selecting and implementing
6
therapy for Jessica. Minor’s counsel additionally recommended
permanent orders be issued without another evidentiary hearing
to avoid further disturbing Jessica.
Father, under oath, explained to the court he opposed the
therapist selected by minor’s counsel because Jessica would
attend sessions virtually, not in person. Father believed Mother
would interfere with the therapy sessions, as she had in the past,
and tell Jessica what to say. Father set out the reasons for his
rejection of the therapists suggested by Mother or minor’s
counsel, including that they were not licensed and he could not
afford them. Father believed he should have custody because
Jessica had told him Mother gets angry more easily than he did.
During cross-examination by Mother’s counsel, Father admitted
allegations of emotional abuse were substantiated against him by
the Department.
Mother testified, also under oath, that Father refused to
cooperate to get Jessica medical attention for an ovarian cyst and
delayed her treatment by one month, telling Mother she should
be seeing a natural health expert. Mother also testified Father
would agree to pay for a therapist, leading Mother to gather the
necessary information, but he ultimately would renege on the
promise. Although the court had ordered the therapist’s rate
could not exceed $175 per hour, Father refused to pay more than
$120 per hour. Father cross-examined Mother extensively about
her claims against him, focusing on what documentary evidence
Mother had to support her claims and her attempts to keep
Jessica away from him. Father argued Mother did not care about
Jessica’s health because Mother cancelled Jessica’s umbilical cord
storage.
Relying on the findings made by Judge Wayser after the
December 15, 2020 hearing, Father’s conduct at the May 18, 2021
hearing, and the testimony described above, the court made the
7
following permanent custody order on April 13, 2022: (1) it
granted Mother sole legal custody for the purpose of making
decisions regarding Jessica’s medical and mental health needs;
(2) it ordered Jessica to be seen by a psychologist or licensed
mental health professional at a cost of no more than $175 per
session; (3) it granted joint legal custody for all other purposes;
and (4) it granted Mother sole physical custody of Jessica.
Father timely appealed on April 29, 2022.1
DISCUSSION
Father primarily challenges the sufficiency of the evidence
supporting the court’s custody ruling. He also contends the trial
court denied him a full and fair opportunity to present his case at
the January 25, 2022 evidentiary hearing. Mother, through
counsel, advised this Court she would not file a respondent’s
brief. We decide the appeal based on the record, the opening
brief, and any oral argument by Father. (Cal. Rules of Court,
rule 8.220(a)(2); see In re Marriage of Mathews (2005)
133 Cal.App.4th 624, 626.) Although Mother did not present
arguments supporting the challenged order, as the appellant
1 Father also appealed from Judge Wayser’s December 16,
2020 minute order issued after the December 15 hearing. We
dismiss the appeal from the December 16, 2020 minute order
because this order is a nonappealable temporary custody order.
(See Smith v. Smith (2012) 208 Cal.App.4th 1074, 1090; see also
Walker v. Los Angeles County Metropolitan Transportation
Authority (2005) 35 Cal.4th 15, 20 [“‘When a party appeals from
both appealable and nonappealable orders, courts in this state
regularly dismiss the appeal from the latter order.’”].)
8
Father has the burden to demonstrate the court committed error
and that such error prejudiced him. (See In re Marriage of Knox
(2022) 83 Cal.App.5th 15, 40; see also Century Surety Co. v.
Polisso (2006) 139 Cal.App.4th 922, 963.)
A. The Law Governing Child Custody
“Under California’s statutory scheme governing child
custody and visitation determinations, the overarching concern is
the best interest of the child.” (Montenegro v. Diaz (2001)
26 Cal.4th 249, 255 (Montenegro); Fam. Code, §§ 3011, 3040.)2 In
determining the best interest of the child, section 3011 directs the
court to consider “all relevant factors, including the child’s
health, safety, and welfare, any history of abuse by one parent
against any child or the other parent, and the nature and amount
of the child’s contact with the parents.” (In re Marriage of Brown
& Yana (2006) 37 Cal.4th 947, 955-956; § 3011.) The court must
also consider and give due weight to the wishes of a child
regarding custody and visitation when the child has reached a
“sufficient age and capacity to reason so as to form an intelligent
preference.” (§ 3042, subd. (a).)
Where, as here, the family court has entered a final custody
order reflecting the best interest of the child, the court should
preserve “‘the established mode of custody unless some
significant change in circumstances indicates that a different
arrangement would be in the child’s best interest.’” (Montenegro,
supra, 26 Cal.4th at p. 256.) The party seeking the modification
2 All further section references are to the Family Code unless
otherwise specified.
9
bears the burden to demonstrate the change in circumstances.
(See ibid.)
We review a family court’s custody and visitation orders,
including modification orders, for abuse of discretion. (See
Montenegro, supra, 26 Cal.4th at p. 255.) We apply the
substantial evidence standard to the court’s factual findings.
(See In re Marriage of Burgess (1996) 13 Cal.4th 25, 32; In re
Marriage of Fajota (2014) 230 Cal.App.4th 1487, 1497.)
B. Substantial Evidence Supports the Court’s Order
Father’s opening brief sets out the extensive history of the
proceedings and the events underlying the parents’ custody
dispute. Father only briefly addresses his principal argument
that insufficient evidence supports the family court’s April 2022
permanent custody order, and does not provide record citations
supporting his argument. By way of example, Father contends
that, “[r]ecent therapist summaries and respondent emails show
mother[’s] continuing uncooperativeness, deceitfulness, and
negligence in Minor’s treatment. They show mother unwilling to
bring the minor to therapy or pay for it. They show her lying
about taking the minor to therapy unilaterally; that she whispers
to the minor during phone therapy. It shows her unwilling to
share a therapist summary she attained illegally against court
order which contradicts with the official summary. This list goes
on.” But there are no citations to the record, dates, or other
information that would allow us to identify the documents Father
relies upon.3 (See In re S.C. (2006) 138 Cal.App.4th 396, 406
3 In the factual section of his opening brief, Father specifies
that therapist summaries may be found in 13 pages of the clerk’s
10
[“When an appellant’s brief makes no reference to the pages of
the record where a point can be found, an appellate court need
not search through the record in an effort to discover the point
purportedly made.”]; Cal. Rules of Court, rule 8.204(a)(1)(C)
[appellate brief must “[s]upport any reference to a matter in the
record by a citation to the volume and page number of the record
where the matter appears”].)
Father cites four cases regarding the substantial evidence
standard of review. (See People v. Fudge (1994) 7 Cal.4th 1075,
1100 [the appellate court’s review for sufficiency of evidence
requires that all reasonable inferences be drawn in support of the
judgment, but the court must also consider the entire record,
including evidence unfavorable to the judgment]; People v.
Johnson (1980) 26 Cal.3d 557, 577 [the appellate court must
review the whole record to determine whether there is
substantial evidence to support the trial court’s findings]; In re
Marriage of Mix (1975) 14 Cal.3d 604, 614 [the appellate court
must consider all the evidence, not just that which supports the
respondent’s case, and must affirm the judgment if it is
transcript. The cited pages include 10 letters from various
treatment programs that have provided mental health services to
Jessica from 2012 to 2021. These letters do not support Father’s
contention that Mother was negligent, deceitful, or
uncooperative.
During oral argument, Father cited additional pages in the
record to support his contention that Mother refused to pay for
Jessica’s therapy and interfered with his relationship with
Jessica. But our review of these documents indicates they do not
support Father’s contentions.
11
supported by substantial evidence].)4 But Father’s opening brief
does not present any cognizable argument showing the evidence
before the family court was insufficient to support its custody
order, nor does he demonstrate prejudicial error that would allow
us to reverse the family court’s order. (See F.P. v. Monier (2017)
3 Cal.5th 1099, 1107 [the California Constitution permits
reversal only if an error “‘resulted in a miscarriage of justice’”];
Cal. Const., Art. VI, § 13.)
Because the trial court’s order is presumptively correct (see
Jameson v. Desta (2018) 5 Cal.5th 594, 609), and Father failed to
provide any reasoned argument challenging the court’s order,
supported by citations to the record and applicable legal
authorities, he has forfeited or abandoned his arguments.5 (See
In re Sade C. (1996) 13 Cal.4th 952, 954 [if appellant fails to raise
4 Father also cites In re Michael G. (1988) 44 Cal.3d 283 for
the proposition that “the failure to consider all relevant evidence
is an abuse of discretion and can be grounds for reversal on
appeal.” But In re Michael G. does not stand for this proposition.
Instead, that case decided whether a minor made a ward of the
court may be punished with confinement in a secured facility
during non-school hours for willful disobedience of a juvenile
court order to attend school. (See id. at p. 287.) In re Michael G.
does not contain a reference to an abuse of discretion standard.
5 We recognize Father is self-represented, and whenever
possible, we will not strictly apply technical rules of procedures or
substantive law to deprive a self-represented litigant of a
hearing. Nevertheless, we must apply the procedural and
substantive principles and rules of appellate review to a self-
represented litigant’s arguments on appeal, just as we would to
arguments by litigants represented by attorneys. (See
Rappleyea v. Campbell (1994) 8 Cal.4th 975, 984-985; In re
Marriage of Furie (2017) 16 Cal.App.5th 816, 824.)
12
claims of reversible error, supported by argument and authority,
he may be deemed to have abandoned his appeal]; Lee v. Kim
(2019) 41 Cal.App.5th 705, 721 [“our review is limited to those
issues that have been adequately raised and supported in the
appellant’s brief”]; see Cal. Rules of Court, rule 8.204(a)(1)(B)
[appellate brief must “support each point by argument and, if
possible, by citation of authority”].)
But even examining Father’s arguments on the merits, the
record before us demonstrates there is substantial evidence
supporting the family court order. The record supports the
family court’s conclusion that a significant change in
circumstances indicates that a different custody arrangement
would be in Jessica’s best interest. (See Montenegro, supra,
26 Cal.4th at p. 256.) Even accepting Father’s generally positive
description of his relationship with Jessica during her elementary
school years, there is ample evidence in the record that this
relationship changed when she entered middle school. The
record contains Father’s concessions that he took out his personal
frustrations and stress on Jessica. This included throwing her
phone into the neighbor’s backyard, throwing her clothes on to
the roof, and slapping Jessica once. The Department, after its
investigation, determined the emotional abuse allegations
against Father were substantiated. The social worker found that
Father’s behavior was “immature” and “inappropriate.”
Additionally, Mother testified that Father delayed her attempts
to obtain medical attention for Jessica’s ovarian cyst. Minor’s
counsel described to the court how Father disrupted his selection
of a therapist for Jessica.
Further, 13-year-old Jessica made her wishes known to the
court-ordered interviewer in December 2020: she did not want to
13
live with Father. In January 2022, minor’s counsel confirmed
that Jessica did not want to speak to or visit with Father. Jessica
had reached a sufficient age and capacity to form an intelligent
preference under section 3042, which the trial court was required
to take into account. This is substantial evidence of a significant
change of circumstances and of Jessica’s best interests to support
the family court’s order granting Mother sole physical custody of
Jessica and sole legal custody for the purpose of making decisions
regarding Jessica’s medical and mental health needs.
C. The Record Reflects the Family Court Provided Father a
Full and Fair Opportunity to Present His Case
Father also argues that he did not have the opportunity to
present his case on January 25, 2022 because the court changed
the hearing time from 1:30 p.m. to 9:30 a.m., depriving him of the
ability to call his witnesses or to “organize.”6 In particular,
Father argues the family court: did not allow him to submit
6 Father also contends the court erred when it refused to
grant Father a continuance. But the record does not reflect
Father asked for a continuance, nor does he demonstrate on
appeal that good cause existed for a continuance. (Cal. Rules of
Court, rule 3.1332(b) [a continuance may be granted only upon a
showing of good cause, including the excusable unavailability of a
party, witness, or trial counsel, or a party’s excused inability to
obtain evidence, or a significant unanticipated change in the
status of the case occurred].) Father appeared to believe the
court would continue the hearing on its own and without any
request from the parties because “we haven’t had a therapy [for
Jessica] yet.” But, as noted, when the court stated it would
proceed with the evidentiary hearing, Father did not ask for a
continuance.
14
transcripts of recordings indicating Mother made Jessica hang up
on him; could not find his declaration and the exhibits attached
to his July 16, 2021 request for order, which he asserts were
timely filed; and did not give him the opportunity to cross-
examine Mother or minor’s counsel “after new allegations and
subjects were brought up after lunch.”
As the California Supreme Court has recognized, although
“a party’s opportunity to call witnesses to testify and to proffer
admissible evidence is central to having his or her day in court”
(Elkins v. Superior Court (2007) 41 Cal.4th 1337, 1357 (Elkins)),
a court has broad authority and a statutory duty to control the
proceedings before it, including the introduction and exclusion of
evidence. (See Evid. Code, §§ 320, 352.) It is only when the court
abuses this discretion “‘in such manner as to prevent a full and
fair opportunity to the parties to present all competent, relevant,
and material evidence bearing upon any issue properly presented
for determination’” that a litigant’s due process rights are
implicated. (Elkins, at p. 1357, italics omitted.) Absent the
denial of a party’s due process rights, “‘[n]o form of civil trial
error justifies reversal . . . where in light of the entire record,
there was no actual prejudice to the appealing party.’” (Cassim v.
Allstate Ins. Co. (2004) 33 Cal.4th 780, 801.)
Father has forfeited this issue because he failed to present
any cognizable argument demonstrating the family court erred or
that such error prejudiced him. (See In re Sade C., supra,
13 Cal.4th at p. 994; Lee v. Kim, supra, 41 Cal.App.5th at p. 721.)
Father, for example, does not identify which, if any, witnesses
were available to testify in the afternoon of January 25, 2022 but
not available in the morning. The record also indicates that
when the court asked Father whether he had any witnesses to
15
testify at the hearing, Father said “no” and Father did not at that
time state that any witnesses were unavailable due to the change
in time.7 Nor does Father specify what new allegations were
raised that he was prevented from addressing at the hearing, or
what evidence was contained in his July 16, 2021 request for
order that was material to the issues before the court in January
2022.
But even reviewing Father’s arguments on the merits, the
record reflects that Father received his day in court. At the
beginning of the hearing, the court told Father, “[i]f you need a
minute to organize your thoughts, it’s perfectly fine.” Later in
the proceeding, the court gave Father additional time to make his
case, accepted his time estimate for cross-examination of Mother,
and later allowed him an additional 20 minutes to cross-examine
her. It also did not hold Father to technical rules of procedure: it
reviewed and marked Father’s exhibits even though minor’s
counsel and Mother’s counsel did not have copies of them (it
allowed counsel to review the documents); it told Father he could
call witnesses upon an offer of proof even though the docket did
not show Father submitted a witness list; and it helped to clarify
7 For the first time at oral argument, Father named three
witnesses he represented would have been available to testify.
But we decline to consider the availability of these witnesses
because Father did not notify the trial court of their availability
in January 2022, and because Father failed to identify them in
his appellate briefing. (See In re Marriage of Falcone & Fyke
(2008) 164 Cal.App.4th 814, 826 [“Kathey had ample opportunity
to raise the objection below. Her failure to do so deprived
Richard of the chance to argue the issue or cure the alleged error
and prevented the trial court from making any ruling on the
point.”]; see also In re Sade C., supra, 13 Cal.4th at p. 994.)
16
Father’s questions during his cross-examination of Mother to
elicit relevant and admissible testimony. Based on the record
before us, we cannot say the family court did not provide Father a
full and fair opportunity to present his case.
DISPOSITION
The postjudgment custody order dated April 13, 2022 is
affirmed. Father’s appeal from the temporary custody order
dated December 16, 2020 is dismissed.
MARTINEZ, P. J.
We concur:
SEGAL, J.
STONE, J.
17
Vous vous demandez comment ce texte s’applique à votre situation ?
Consultation gratuite, sans engagement
Décrivez votre situation. Notre équipe vous recontactera par e-mail pour votre consultation.
Poursuivez vos recherches dans ChatGPT ou Claude
Connectez Omnilex pour rechercher dans le corpus juridique depuis votre assistant IA.