CourtListener 10005648•People v. Jimenez CA4/1
Texte intégral
Filed 7/17/24 P. v. Jimenez CA4/1
NOT TO BE PUBLISHED IN OFFICIAL REPORTS
California Rules of Court, rule 8.1115(a), prohibits courts and parties from citing or relying on opinions not certified for
publication or ordered published, except as specified by rule 8.1115(b). This opinion has not been certified for publication
or ordered published for purposes of rule 8.1115.
COURT OF APPEAL, FOURTH APPELLATE DISTRICT
DIVISION ONE
STATE OF CALIFORNIA
THE PEOPLE, D081746
Plaintiff and Respondent,
v. (Super. Ct. No. SCE410943)
RAUL MARTINEZ JIMENEZ,
Defendant and Appellant.
APPEAL from a judgment of the Superior Court of San Diego County,
Polly H. Shamoon, Judge. Affirmed in part; reversed in part; remanded with
directions.
Jan B. Norman, under appointment by the Court of Appeal, for
Defendant and Appellant.
Rob Bonta, Attorney General, Lance E. Winters, Chief Assistant
Attorney General, Charles C. Ragland, Assistant Attorney General, Melissa
Mandel, and Anne Spitzberg, Deputy Attorneys General, for Plaintiff and
Respondent.
A jury convicted Raul Martinez Jimenez of possession of a firearm in a
school zone (Pen. Code,1 § 626.9; count 1); two counts of assault with a
firearm (§ 245, subd. (a)(2); counts 2 and 4); child abuse (§ 273a, subd. (a);
count 3); making a criminal threat (§ 422; count 5); possession by a felon
(§ 29800, subd. (a)(1); count 6); unlawfully carrying a loaded firearm in a
vehicle while in a public place (§ 25850, subd. (a); count 7); and evading an
officer with reckless driving (Veh. Code, § 2800.2, subd. (a); count 8). The
jury also found true as to count 2 that the victim was a person defined in
Family Code section 6211 and within the meaning of Penal Code
section 1203.097, subdivision (a). Regarding count 5, the jury found true that
Jimenez personally used a firearm (§ 12022.5, subd.(a)) and was armed with
a firearm (§ 12022, subd. (a)(1)). Concerning count 7, the jury found true that
Jimenez previously had been convicted of a felony (§ 25850, subd. (c)).
The court sentenced Jimenez to prison for a total of 10 years.
Jimenez appeals, raising two primary issues. First, he argues the case
must be remanded to clarify certain inconsistencies between the court’s oral
pronouncement of the sentence and the abstract of judgment. Second,
Jimenez contends the court erred by failing to stay the sentences for
counts 4, 6, and 7 under section 654.
The People concede and we agree that the trial court erred in failing to
stay Jimenez’s sentence for count 4. The People also acknowledge that
counts 6 and 7 are based on a single act. They ask us to stay the sentence on
count 7; however, it is within the trial court’s discretion to determine whether
to stay Jimenez’s sentence for count 6 or count 7. We cannot make that
determination on appeal. In addition, on a point not raised by Jimenez, the
People note that the trial court improperly sentenced Jimenez under both
1 Statutory references are to the Penal Code unless otherwise specified.
2
section 12022.5, subdivision (a) and section 12022, subdivision (a)(1). Thus,
the concurrent one-year enhancement under section 12022 should be stayed
under section 654 as well. Accordingly, we reverse the judgment and remand
the matter to the superior court for resentencing consistent with this opinion.
In all other respects, the judgment is affirmed.
FACTUAL BACKGROUND2
The victims lived with Jimenez in a large RV. Jimenez, a convicted
felon, owned a small revolver that he kept in the RV. On the night of
February 1, 2022, Jimenez became angry and choked his 16-year-old
daughter, A.J., in the car while driving home from a 99 Cent store.
When they got home, Jimenez threatened to kill 18-year-old L.C., who
is A.J.’s boyfriend. Jimenez was holding his revolver at the time of the
threat. Jimenez pointed the gun at L.C.’s head and pushed L.C.’s head with
the gun. Jimenez also put the gun to his 12-year old daughter’s head.
The next morning, A.J., L.C., and a friend left the RV to take A.J. to
her high school. On the way, A.J. got a call from Jimenez who sounded angry
because someone had called Child Protective Services (CPS) about the
previous night’s events. A.J. became afraid for her younger siblings because
they were at their elementary school and she feared Jimenez would pick
them up and harm them. A.J. called family members for help, who then
called CPS, the elementary school, and the police. In response, the
elementary school was placed on lock down.
2 Because the facts of each of Jimenez’s offenses are not pertinent to the
issues to be resolved, we provide a brief overview of the underlying facts
taken largely from the People’s brief, which presents an accurate and concise
summary of the salient facts. To the extent we need to discuss additional
facts, we shall do so while considering the issues raised.
3
Sheriff’s deputies arrived at the elementary school anticipating
Jimenez’s arrival. Jimenez showed up and saw multiple sheriff’s deputies
and police cars. Jimenez immediately sped away and led the deputies on a
high-speed chase through residential streets. Jimenez finally crashed into
another car and sheriff’s deputies were able to take him into custody.
A search of Jimenez’s car revealed that he had his revolver with him,
within arm’s reach, and it was loaded with five rounds of ammunition. An
additional bullet was found underneath the gun.
DISCUSSION
I
SECTION 654
A. Jimenez’s Contentions
Jimenez argues that the court was required to stay the sentences under
counts 4, 6, and 7 pursuant to section 654. The People correctly concede that
the sentence on count 4 should have been stayed under section 654.
However, the People disagree that the sentences for both counts 6 and 7
should be stayed. Rather, they maintain that those two counts are based on
the same act, and thus, we should modify the judgment to stay the sentence
as to count 7. Although we agree with the People that counts 6 and 7 are
based on a single act, it is well within the trial court’s purview to determine
which sentence to stay. It is not our role to make that selection on appeal.
Therefore, we must remand this matter for resentencing consistent with this
opinion.3
3 Jimenez’s first argument on appeal is that we must remand the matter
to the superior court to correct inconsistencies between the oral
pronouncement of Jimenez’s sentence and the abstract of judgment. Because
we are remanding the matter back for resentencing on the section 654 issue,
we conclude that Jimenez’s first argument is moot.
4
B. Background
1. The Oral Pronouncement of Jimenez’s Sentence
The court sentenced Jimenez to prison for 10 years. In calculating the
10-year term, the court began by selecting count 5 as the principal count.
The court explained:
“As to count five, the Court is selecting the middle term of
two years. Two years state prison will be ordered in that
case with the middle term of four years on the [section]
12022.5 [enhancement]. That is a total of six years with
one year consecutive for the [section] 12022[,]
[subdivision] (a)(1) [enhancement]. In that count alone, it’s
a total of six years. That’s a state prison commit.”
The court added consecutive one-third the middle-term sentences on
both counts 1 and 2, which equaled one year for each of those counts. Thus,
the sentence was increased to eight years.
For count 3, the court sentenced Jimenez to one-third the middle-term
of four years, which added another one year four months to the sentence.
And regarding count 8, the court selected one-third the middle-term of two
years for an additional eight months. The eight months added to the year
four month sentence on count 3 added two more years to Jimenez’s sentence
for a total of 10 years.
Concerning count 4, the court imposed a sentence of three years to run
concurrently. For counts 6 and 7, the court sentenced Jimenez to two years
for each count to be served concurrently to the 10-year sentence as well.
2. Counts 4 and 5
On February 3, 2022, one day after the charged crimes occurred, a
forensic social worker interviewed Jimenez’s 16-year-old daughter, A.J.
A.J. told the social worker that Jimenez got his gun, pointed it at L.C.’s head
and said, “if you snitch, I’ll kill you” and then “was going like this, like that.
5
My boyfriend’s head was going like that.” A.J. told Jimenez to leave L.C.
alone.
The video recording of that interview was played for the jury and in
that video, A.J. demonstrated how Jimenez placed his gun against L.C.’s
head after threatening to kill L.C. The prosecutor asked A.J. if L.C. said or
did anything “when [Jimenez] came to him and held the gun to his head and
pushed his head to the side with the gun?” and A.J. said she did not
remember. A.J. also said she did not remember if L.C. said or did anything
when Jimenez pointed the gun at L.C. and told him, “[i]f you snitch I’ll kill
you.” When she testified, A.J. recanted portions of her prior statements to
the social worker and police officer.
During closing argument, the prosecutor mentioned that A.J.
demonstrated how Jimenez held the gun to the side of L.C.’s head and
pushed his head “physically to the side using the gun” in a video-recorded
forensic interview. The prosecutor argued that this act fulfilled the elements
for count 4 (assault with a firearm). The prosecutor later argued that
Jimenez’s threats to kill L.C. if he snitched, while holding the gun, fulfilled
the elements for count 5, criminal threats, while personally using a firearm.
At the sentencing hearing, defense counsel argued that the assault
with a firearm term should be stayed pursuant to section 654 because it was
a single event along with the criminal threats. The prosecutor disagreed and
argued that Jimenez’s acts were divisible because he first entered with the
gun and threatened to kill L.C. and then, after having an opportunity to stop
and leave, decided to walk toward L.C., put the gun to his head and pushed
his head to the side. The trial court did not address the section 654 argument
but imposed concurrent terms for counts 4 and 5.
6
3. Counts 1, 6, 7
On the morning of February 2, 2022, A.J. called her family members for
help after Jimenez said he had a gun with him and wanted to kill “them”
because of someone calling CPS. CPS called and warned the elementary
school where Jimenez’s younger two children attended, and the school
principal called 911. Because Jimenez had a gun, the school went into
lockdown; all students were evacuated from the playground into safe areas.
Multiple sheriff’s deputies arrived at the school. Deputy Daniel Nevitt saw
Jimenez driving into the school and made eye contact with Jimenez. Jimenez
sped up and drove past the deputies and the school. The deputies got into
their patrol cars and chased Jimenez. Jimenez was eventually apprehended
and a search of his car revealed a loaded revolver within arm’s reach of the
driver’s seat.
At the February 17, 2023 sentencing hearing, the trial court imposed a
one-year sentence on count 1 (possession of a firearm in a school zone) and
imposed concurrent sentences on counts 6 (possession of a firearm by a felon)
and 7 (unlawfully carrying a loaded firearm in a vehicle while in public).
C. Pertinent Law
The purpose of section 654 is to ensure a defendant is punished
“ ‘commensurate with his [or her] culpability.’ [Citation.]” (People v.
Harrison (1989) 48 Cal.3d 321, 335.) The defendant’s intent and objective,
not the temporal proximity of his offenses, determines whether multiple
punishment is permissible. (Ibid.) When section 654 prohibits multiple
punishments, the trial court must stay execution of sentence on the
7
convictions that implicate multiple punishments. (People v. Correa (2012)
54 Cal.4th 331, 337.)4
“Whether a defendant may be subjected to multiple punishment under
section 654 requires a two-step inquiry, because the statutory reference to an
‘act or omission’ may include not only a discrete physical act but also a course
of conduct encompassing several acts pursued with a single objective.
[Citations.] We first consider if the different crimes were completed by a
‘single physical act.’ [Citation.] If so, the defendant may not be punished
more than once for that act. Only if we conclude that the case involves more
than a single act—i.e., a course of conduct—do we then consider whether that
course of conduct reflects a single ‘ “intent and objective” ’ or multiple intents
and objectives. [Citations.] At step one, courts examine the facts of the case
to determine whether multiple convictions are based upon a single physical
act. [Citation.] When those facts are undisputed . . . the application of
section 654 raises a question of law we review de novo.” (People v. Corpening
(2016) 2 Cal.5th 307, 311–312.)
If the pertinent facts are in dispute, “[i]ntent and objective are factual
questions for the trial court, which must find evidence to support the
existence of a separate intent and objective for each sentenced offense.”
(People v. Jackson (2016) 1 Cal.5th 269, 354.) Where the trial court does not
make an explicit ruling, “we infer that the court made the finding appropriate
to the sentence it imposed, i.e., either applying section 654 or not applying it.”
(People v. Mejia (2017) 9 Cal.App.5th 1036, 1045.) Ultimately, the court’s
4 It is error for a trial court to impose even a concurrent sentence, such
as the sentences imposed here, if section 654 prohibits multiple punishments,
despite that there is little practical difference between a concurrent sentence
and a sentence that is stayed. (People v. Jones (2012) 54 Cal.4th 350, 353
(Jones).)
8
implicit or express determination in that respect will be upheld on appeal if
supported by substantial evidence. (People v. Lopez (2011) 198 Cal.App.4th
698, 717.) In this regard, we must “ ‘ “presume in support of the order the
existence of every fact the trier could reasonably deduce from the
evidence.” ’ ” (Ibid.)
D. Analysis
1. Counts 4 and 5
Jimenez contends, and the People concede, that counts 4 (assault with
a firearm) and 5 (making a criminal threat) are based on a single course of
action and thus the sentence under count 4 should be stayed. We agree.
As the People point out, Jimenez threatened to kill L.C. while holding
the gun before leaving the room. A.J.’s description of these events was too
vague and brief to determine whether Jimenez completed two separate acts,
one for threatening L.C. while brandishing a gun and the other for pushing
L.C.’s head with the barrel of the gun, or one continuous act of threatening
L.C. with the gun and its use as incidental to the threat. A.J.’s statement
could be interpreted as describing acts that happened in immediate
succession with no meaningful temporal separation such that Jimenez had no
opportunity to reflect and renew his intent. Thus, on this record, we conclude
that Jimenez’s sentence for count 4 should have been stayed under
section 654.
2. Counts 1, 6, 7
Relying on Jones, supra, 54 Cal.4th 350, Jimenez argues that the
sentences on counts 6 (possession of a firearm by a felon) and count 7
(carrying a loaded firearm in a vehicle while in a public place) must be stayed
under section 654 because those two counts “were alleged to have occurred on
February 2, 2022.” Thus, Jimenez implies that counts 6 and 7 are based on
9
the same act that gave rise to count 1 (possession of a firearm in school zone).
Jimenez’s reliance on Jones is misplaced.
In Jones, the California Supreme Court considered whether the
defendant could be “punished separately for the crimes of possession of a
firearm by a felon, carrying a readily accessible concealed and unregistered
firearm, and carrying an unregistered loaded firearm in public.” (Jones,
supra, 54 Cal.4th at p. 352.) The defendant had been found with a
loaded .38–caliber revolver in his car and the gun was not registered to him.
(Ibid.) The defendant had purchased the gun three days earlier “ ‘for
protection,’ ” and he had kept the gun at his grandmother’s house before that
day. (Ibid.) The court determined that under the circumstances, the
defendant had committed “a single act” that could only be punished once. (Id.
at p. 360.)
Our high court noted that the defendant’s “guilt on all three charges
was premised solely on his having the gun in his car when arrested” and that
“the jury convicted defendant of each crime due to his being caught with the
gun in the car on [the day of his arrest], not due to any antecedent
possession.” (Jones, supra, 54 Cal.4th at p. 359.) The court declined to
express an opinion “on what the outcome might be under other facts” and did
not decide whether “keeping the gun at the house and carrying it in the car
were separate acts.” (Ibid.)
The instant action is factually distinguishable from Jones. The act that
led to Jimenez’s possession of a firearm in a school zone (count 1) occurred
earlier in the day and in a different location than the act underlying his
conviction for felon in possession of a firearm (count 6) and possession of a
loaded firearm in a vehicle (count 7), which occurred after Jimenez attempted
to evade pursuing patrol cars and crashed his car. Further, during closing
10
argument, the prosecutor emphasized that counts 6 and 7 were based on
different conduct than count 1. Therefore, unlike the defendant in Jones, the
record here does not support the conclusion that counts 1, 6 and 7 were based
on a single act.
Additionally, Jimenez does not argue that counts 1, 6, and 7 are part of
a single objective. Nor could he persuasively do so. Count 1 is based on
Jimenez’s possession a firearm in a school zone. When he arrived in the
school zone with his firearm, the crime was completed. He then tried to
evade law enforcement, a separate objective than traveling to a school zone,
and crashed his car. Upon inspection of the vehicle, the firearm was
discovered. Accordingly, we conclude that counts 6 and 7 should not have
been stayed under section 654 based on count 1.
That said, counts 6 and 7 are based on a single act. Thus, one of the
sentences associated with those two counts must be stayed. (See Jones,
supra, 54 Cal.4th at p. 359.) On remand, we offer no opinion as to which
sentence should be stayed.
3. The Firearm Enhancements
Regarding count 5, the trial court imposed a sentence under both
firearm enhancements―the four-year enhancement under section 12022.5,
subdivision (a) and the one-year enhancement under 12022,
subdivision (a)(1). Although not raised by Jimenez, the People point out that
the court had to stay one of those sentences under section 12022.53,
subdivision (f). We agree.
Section 12022.53, subdivision (f) provides:
“Only one additional term of imprisonment under this
section shall be imposed per person for each crime. If more
than one enhancement per person is found true under this
section, the court shall impose upon that person the
enhancement that provides the longest term of
11
imprisonment. An enhancement involving a firearm
specified in Section 12021.5, 12022, 12022.3, 12022.4,
12022.5, or 12022.55 shall not be imposed on a person in
addition to an enhancement imposed pursuant to this
section. An enhancement for great bodily injury as defined
in Section 12022.7, 12022.8, or 12022.9 shall not be
imposed on a person in addition to an enhancement
imposed pursuant to subdivision (d).”
Thus, under this subdivision, the trial court was required to stay the one-year
enhancement under 12022, subdivision (a)(1). (See People v. Gonzalez (2008)
43 Cal.4th 1118, 1126–1130 [the word “impose” in section 12022.53,
subdivision (f) means that the prohibited enhancements must be “imposed
and then stayed”].) It was error not to do so. Accordingly, the trial court can
correct this issue on remand.
DISPOSITION
The judgment is reversed and remanded for resentencing consistent
with this opinion. In all other respects, the judgment is affirmed. After
resentencing Jimenez, the superior court shall forward the amended abstract
of judgment to the Department of Corrections and Rehabilitation.
HUFFMAN, Acting P. J.
WE CONCUR:
BUCHANAN, J.
KELETY, J.
12
Vous vous demandez comment ce texte s’applique à votre situation ?
Consultation gratuite, sans engagement
Décrivez votre situation. Notre équipe vous recontactera par e-mail pour votre consultation.
Poursuivez vos recherches dans ChatGPT ou Claude
Connectez Omnilex pour rechercher dans le corpus juridique depuis votre assistant IA.