CourtListener 10005525•People v. Casity CA3
Texte intégral
Filed 7/17/24 P. v. Casity CA3
NOT TO BE PUBLISHED
California Rules of Court, rule 8.1115(a), prohibits courts and parties from citing or relying on opinions not certified for
publication or ordered published, except as specified by rule 8.1115(b). This opinion has not been certified for publication
or ordered published for purposes of rule 8.1115.
IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA
THIRD APPELLATE DISTRICT
(Amador)
----
THE PEOPLE, C097719
Plaintiff and Respondent, (Super. Ct. No. 22CR31815)
v.
RICHARD DOUGLAS CASITY,
Defendant and Appellant.
Defendant Richard Douglas Casity appeals from his convictions for stalking,
stalking in violation of a court order, disobeying a domestic relations court order, and
making criminal threats. According to Casity, he should have been convicted of only one
count of stalking because both counts involved the same conduct. He further argues his
punishment for the disobeying a domestic relations court order count should have been
stayed under Penal Code section 654.1 Finally, Casity contends part of his sentence is
1 Undesignated statutory references are to the Penal Code.
1
unauthorized because the trial court imposed the wrong midterm sentence. We agree that
Casity should only have been convicted of one count of stalking and that section 654
applies. We thus reverse the conviction on count I and will remand the matter for
resentencing.
FACTUAL AND PROCEDURAL BACKGROUND
Casity has two adult daughters, N. and R.2 R. is permanently disabled and has a
full-time caregiver. N. is in the military and has a son who is a minor. N. started dating
M. in 2020 and the two married in April 2022.
In October 2021, N., N.’s son, M., R., and R.’s caregiver were all living in N.’s
house. N. was deployed to the Middle East that month for four months, and M. had
temporary custody of N.’s son. Casity also stayed in the home for about three weeks in
October and November 2021. N.’s son and M. eventually went to stay at his parents’
house.
While N. was in the Middle East, Casity seemed “angry” with M. At one point,
Casity sent a text to R.’s caregiver that contained threats against M. Casity repeatedly
told N. he did not like M. and sent hundreds of messages to N. threatening and
disparaging M. Casity also made over 20 Facebook posts disparaging M. N. feared for
M.’s safety, especially since she interpreted Casity’s comments to mean he might harm
M. after she returned from deployment. Casity also told N.’s mother he planned to
commit murder-suicide with R., R.’s caregiver, and himself.
In November 2021, Casity sent text messages to N.’s mother complaining about
his lack of contact with N.’s son. Casity also complained about M., saying M. had
disrespected him. Casity messaged: “You better talk to your daughter because I am not
playing. What I will do will make the paper and that is a promise. Keep him from me. I
2 To protect their privacy, we refer to the victims with the first initial of their first
names only. (Cal. Rules of Court, rule 8.90.)
2
am blood. When I am done, she is not going to want to come back here.” He also
messaged: “I am pissed. I can’t take my grandson anywhere. It is okay. If he was
smart, he would get [a] restraining order on me. But he has no idea what I might do.
Fucking little disrespectful . . . . I don’t give a fuck about his dad or going to jail. You
should tell him he better watch his ass because when I make a move, he is going to wish I
hadn’t for sure.”
N.’s mother feared for everyone’s safety. She forwarded the messages to N. and
to M. M. began to fear for his own and his father’s safety.
On November 15, 2021, M. filed for a domestic violence restraining order for
himself. A trial court issued a temporary restraining order, and it was served on Casity in
early December 2021.
Although M. had no contact with Casity during December, Casity continued
sending messages that threatened M. At one point, Casity messaged N.’s mother:
“[Y]ou might even want to warn him. . . . [¶] . . . [¶] . . . I say on my life, he will learn a
lesson and that is all I got to say. . . . Don’t worry, I am not going to kill him. But when
I am done, you watch, he will never be the same. [¶] . . . I have got tumors in my
head. . . . I have got nothing to lose.” Casity also sent Facebook messages to N.
complaining about the restraining order and telling her he had bought two rifles. In N.’s
experience, Casity did not normally own firearms. Casity also told N. he would offer his
motorcycle, which was stored at N.’s home, to anyone willing to hurt M.
N. returned home in February 2022, and her son and M. both moved back into the
house. Later that month, M. met with Casity in a bar to try to resolve the tension. While
there, Casity called M. a homosexual and “possibly a child molester.” Casity also said he
had previously pointed a rifle with a scope at M. at N.’s house. M. said he was not afraid
to fight Casity, but he never threatened to harm Casity. Casity stormed out of the bar.
That same day, Casity also exchanged text messages with M., with Casity warning he
was not to be messed with. Casity threatened to attempt to frame M. for child
3
pornography. He also had “Hells Angel friends,” and he might give out the address of
M.’s father.
Later that month, Casity sent Facebook messages to N. threatening to post flyers
saying M. was a homosexual and a child molester.
On March 22, 2022, the court issued a restraining order, prohibiting Casity from
contacting M. directly or through a third party for three years.
In April 2022, Amador County Social Services Adult Protective Services (APS)
visited N.’s house regarding R. On April 28, 2022, Casity told R.’s caregiver that he
blamed N. and M. for the APS visit, and he threatened to “ruin a lot of lives” if APS took
R. He also said he would “kick[ ] any door and plan on the shooting.” The caregiver
showed the messages to N. and M. During trial, M. testified he could not remember
exactly when he received the messages, but it might have been in May 2022, soon after
Casity sent them to the caregiver.
On May 3, 2022, Casity was served with the three-year restraining order issued on
March 22, 2022.
Later in May 2022, N. was deployed to Europe, and her son and M. accompanied
her.
On June 4, 2022, Casity posted on Facebook that he did not like M., saying, “you
think I’m going to let this go on much more? If you guys were here, I would end this real
quick.” He posted three other similar threats later that month, saying he would push M.
off the Grand Canyon, that a piece of paper was not going to keep him away, and he
could not wait until M. returned from Germany. N. blocked Casity on Facebook.
In July 2022, while N. and her family were still in Europe, Casity sent multiple e-
mails to N. He said he was “bi[d]ing his time” until they got back, and he was full of
hate and would “teach [M.] a lesson.” He promised to “make it hell for [M.],” and said
he would “show up out there.” Casity had posted pictures of a passport application,
leading N. to fear he intended to come to Europe to harm her family.
4
Casity also made threats against an APS social worker.
In October 2022, a jury found Casity guilty of stalking M. from November 11,
2021, through May 3, 2022 (§ 646.9, subd. (a); count I), stalking M. in violation of a
court order from June 4 through July 10, 2022 (§ 646.9, subd. (b); count II), disobeying a
domestic violence restraining order from May 3 through July 10, 2022 (§ 273.6, subd.
(a); count III), and making criminal threats as to the APS social worker (§ 422, subd. (a);
count IV). As to counts I, II, and IV, the jury also found the crimes involved great
violence, threat of great bodily harm, or other acts disclosing a high degree of cruelty,
viciousness, or callousness.
In November 2022, the trial court sentenced Casity to state prison for an aggregate
term of four years four months, as follows: three years for count I (the middle term),
eight months for count II (one-third the middle term), eight months for count IV, and one
year concurrent for count III. The court stayed execution of the sentence and ordered
four years of probation. The following month, Casity admitted violating probation, and
the trial court revoked probation and executed the sentence.
DISCUSSION
I
Stalking Convictions
Casity contends he should only be convicted of one count of stalking because his
conduct was continuous with no interruption. The People respond there was a substantial
time break between the conduct underlying each stalking conviction and that Casity’s
conduct can be separated into two time periods separated by the distinct event of having
been served with a restraining order. We agree with Casity.
Casity was convicted of two counts of stalking. In count I, Casity was found
guilty of stalking between November 11, 2021, and May 3, 2022 (§ 646.9, subd. (a)), and
in count II he was found guilty of stalking in violation of a court order between June 4
and July 10, 2022 (§ 646.9, subd. (b)).
5
“Any person who willfully, maliciously, and repeatedly follows or willfully and
maliciously harasses another person and who makes a credible threat with the intent to
place that person in reasonable fear for his or her safety, or the safety of his or her
immediate family is guilty of the crime of stalking.” (§ 646.9, subd. (a).) The statute
defines “ ‘harasses’ ” as engaging in a “knowing and willful course of conduct directed at
a specific person that seriously alarms, annoys, torments, or terrorizes the person, and
that serves no legitimate purpose.” (§ 646.9, subd. (e).) “ [C]ourse of conduct’ ” is
defined as “two or more acts occurring over a period of time, however short, evidencing a
continuity of purpose.” (§ 646.9, subd. (f); see also People v. Chilelli (2014)
225 Cal.App.4th 581, 586 [stalking is a continuous course of conduct crime].)
As courts have explained, the stalking statute defines a single offense but provides
different penalties for simple stalking (§ 646.9, subd. (a)) versus stalking in violation of a
protective court order (§ 646.9, subd. (b)) or the other aggravated stalking offenses set
out in section 646.9, subdivision (c). (People v. Muhammad (2007) 157 Cal.App.4th 484,
490-492, 494.) As such, typically a defendant cannot be convicted of multiple counts of
stalking when the counts are based on the same behavior.
For example, in Muhammad, the defendant was convicted of stalking (§ 646.9,
subd. (a)), stalking in violation of a restraining order (§ 646.9, subd. (b)), stalking with a
prior terrorist threats conviction (§ 646.9, subd. (c)(1)), and stalking with a prior felony
stalking conviction (§ 646.9, subd. (c)(2)). (People v. Muhammad, supra,
157 Cal.App.4th at p. 486.) Each of the four counts was based on the same course of
harassing conduct the defendant committed against the victim between December 17,
2003, and December 10, 2004. (Id. at p. 489.) The appellate court agreed with the
defendant that he could only be convicted of one count of stalking because subdivisions
(b) and (c) are “penalty provisions triggered when the offense of stalking as defined in
subdivision (a) of that section is committed by a person with a specified history of
6
misconduct.” (Muhammad, at p. 494.) As such, he only committed a single stalking
offense.
The People argue that unlike Muhammad, Casity’s two stalking convictions were
based on Casity’s harassing behavior during two periods, one before and the other after
service of the restraining order on May 3, 2022. They contend that count I addresses the
time period before service of the restraining order (November 11, 2021, through May 3,
2022), and count II addresses conduct occurring after service of the restraining order
(June 4 through July 10, 2022). The evidence showed Casity sent threatening texts to
R.’s caregiver on April 28, 2022. The caregiver showed the messages to N. and M. soon
after, although M. could not remember exactly when he saw them. Then, on May 3,
2022, the three-year protective order was served on Casity. And, later that month, N.
moved to Europe with her son and M. There was no evidence Casity engaged in any
additional harassing conduct until he made threatening Facebook posts starting on June 4,
2022, and then his harassing e-mails in July 2022. However, while the three-year
restraining was not served on Casity until May of 2022, a temporary restraining order had
been in place since December of 2021, yet Cassity’s conduct remained unabated. In both
time periods, Casity’s harassing messages referenced and expressed hostility toward the
orders. In a message dated December 14, 2021, or December 15, 2021, Casity states:
“Family filing a f****** restraining order on me f****** retarded are you all it is a piece
of paper you think it’s going to scare me away a piece of f****** paper or for real f*** I
done bought two rifles.” Similarly, in a February 15, 2022, message Casity states:
“Bottom line is u broke the restraining order not me ok . . . .” Then on June 17, 2022,
subsequent to service of the three-year restraining order, Casity sent the following
message: “And I hope you never come back because I’ll be waiting I know not to say
nothing I raise my voice or anything that punk could go get another restraining order take
a piece of paper is going to keep me away.” And again on July 10, 2022: “I’m a teach
him a lesson not going to say what I’m going to do cuz like a little b**** he’ll go get
7
another restraining order but I’m going to teach him a f***** lesson . . . .” Thus, it
appears that the conduct was consistent, irrespective of the act of service of the three-year
order in May of 2022.
The People also contend that a nearly five-week break in Casity’s harassing
behavior between the end of April 2022 and June 2022 was significant and indicated that
one continuous course of stalking had ended and a new one had begun. We do not
conclude the same.
We do not believe that the absence of harassing communications in May 2022
suffices to show that there were two distinct courses of conduct. “[B]y its nature,” a
continuous course of conduct “may stop and start.” (People v. Rae (2002)
102 Cal.App.4th 116, 124.) Rather, the nature and apparent objective of Casity’s
harassing behavior—expressing hostility to M.—were the same over the course of both
time periods charged. (See § 646.9, subd. (f) [defining “ ‘course of conduct’ ” as “two or
more acts occurring over a period of time, however short, evidencing a continuity of
purpose” (italics added)].) These facts thus reflect a single, uninterrupted course of
conduct spanning from November 2021 through July 2022. We will thus reverse the
conviction on count I.
II
Application of Section 654
Casity next argues the violation of the court order charged in count III was part of
the same course of conduct as was charged in count II, and therefore his punishment for
the offense in count III must be stayed pursuant to section 654. The People properly
concede that section 654 applies but ask us to remand the matter for resentencing. We
agree with the People.
Section 654 prohibits multiple punishments for a single criminal act (People v.
Jones (2012) 54 Cal.4th 350, 360) and for multiple acts that comprise an “indivisible
course of conduct” (People v. Hester (2000) 22 Cal.4th 290, 294). “ ‘[A] court acts in
8
“excess of its jurisdiction” and imposes an “unauthorized” sentence when it erroneously
stays or fails to stay execution of a sentence under section 654.’ ” (People v. Rodriguez
(2015) 235 Cal.App.4th 1000, 1004, fn. 2.)
Both parties acknowledge counts II and III both involve a single criminal act,
namely Casity violating the protective order served on May 3, 2022. There is no
evidence that Casity’s course of conduct during these offenses was motivated by a
separate intent or objective. The appropriate remedy is to vacate his sentence and remand
the matter for a full resentencing. (See People v. Buycks (2018) 5 Cal.5th 857, 893.)
Given that we are remanding the matter for a full resentencing, we need not
address Casity’s argument that part of his sentence is unauthorized because the trial court
incorrectly imposed (1) a three-year middle term sentence on count I when the middle
term is actually two years, and (2) an eight-month sentence on count II when one-third of
the middle term is actually one year.
DISPOSITION
Casity’s conviction on count I is reversed. We will vacate Casity’s sentence and
remand the matter for a full resentencing hearing, consistent with this opinion. The trial
court is directed to prepare an amended abstract of judgment following the new
sentencing hearing and to forward a certified copy to the Department of Corrections and
Rehabilitation. The judgment is otherwise affirmed.
/s/
EARL, P. J.
We concur:
/s/
ROBIE, J.
/s/
FEINBERG, J.
9
Vous vous demandez comment ce texte s’applique à votre situation ?
Consultation gratuite, sans engagement
Décrivez votre situation. Notre équipe vous recontactera par e-mail pour votre consultation.
Poursuivez vos recherches dans ChatGPT ou Claude
Connectez Omnilex pour rechercher dans le corpus juridique depuis votre assistant IA.