513 IK 120/05•Trustee remuneration in consumer insolvency with an unusually large estate
513 IK 120/05Tribunal de première instance4 déc. 2007Droit de l'insolvabilitéAdmis
Extrait par Omnilex
In this consumer insolvency proceeding, Düsseldorf Local Court fixed the trustee’s remuneration at EUR 60,000 plus EUR 11,400 VAT, for a total of EUR 71,400. It held that where the insolvency estate is unusually large, the stepped scale under § 2(1) InsVV, rather than the linear scale under § 13(1) InsVV, should serve as the standard basis. Adjustment factors may be applied to that baseline. The court also fixed expenses at EUR 5,250 plus EUR 997.50 VAT, totaling EUR 6,247.50.
InsVV Art. 13 para. 1 and Art. 2 para. 1; remuneration of the trustee in consumer insolvency proceedings involving an unusually large estate. The linear remuneration under Art. 13 para. 1 InsVV is not the proper standard where the estate is unusually large. Instead, the stepped remuneration scale under Art. 2 para. 1 InsVV applies as the standard remuneration. On that basis, increases or reductions may be made by applying adjustment factors (relative capping).
Entscheidungsdatum: 2007-12-04
Aktenzeichen: 513 IK 120/05
ECLI: ECLI:DE:AGD:2007:1204.513IK120.05.00
Dokumenttyp: Beschluss
Spruchkörper: Rechtspfleger
Normen: InsO § 63 InsVV § 13, § 2
In Verbraucherinsolvenzverfahren mit ungewöhnlich hoher Masse ist anstelle der linearen Vergütung des § 13 Abs. 1 InsVV die Staffelvergütung des § 2 Abs. 1 InsVV als Regelvergütung zugrundezulegen.Ausgehend davon kommt die Zumessung von Erhöhungs- und Minderungsfaktoren in Betracht (relative Deckelung).
wird die Vergütung des Treuhänders auf 60.000 EUR zuzüglich der gesetzlichen Umsatzsteuer i.H.v. 11.400,-- und damit auf insgesamt 71.400,-- EUR festgesetzt.
Die Auslagen werden auf 5.250,-- zuzüglich der gesetzlichen Umsatzsteuer i.H.v. 997,50 EUR und damit auf insgesamt 6.247,50 EUR festgesetzt.
How should the trustee’s remuneration be calculated in a consumer insolvency proceeding with an unusually large estate?
The stepped remuneration under § 2(1) InsVV is the standard basis; adjustment factors may then be applied.
The linear remuneration under § 13(1) InsVV is not the appropriate standard for an unusually large estate; the stepped scale under § 2(1) InsVV provides the basis for relative capping through increases or reductions.
What expenses should be allowed to the trustee?
Expenses were fixed at EUR 5,250 plus statutory VAT of EUR 997.50.
Connectez Omnilex pour rechercher dans le corpus juridique depuis votre assistant IA.