Question juridique clé
Whether the insured showed a material worsening justifying a new review and disability pension
Solution extraite
The insured did not prove a relevant deterioration of health or work capacity; the 36% disability rate remained unchanged.
Motifs extraits
The court held that the decisive comparison was between the 2003 opposition decision and the 2008 decision. The orthopedic expertise and SMR assessment were probative, and no objectively verifiable new medical element undermined them.