Question juridique clé
Whether the right to be heard was violated by insufficient reasoning regarding incomplete origin declarations
Solution extraite
No violation occurred, because the appellant had been given a chance to comment on the new draft decision and on the classification of the defects, but did not raise the alleged lack of clarity or request file inspection.
Motifs extraits
The duty to state reasons requires only that the party can understand and challenge the decision; here the customs authority's draft and tables identified the contested items and the appellant remained silent on the relevant explanations.