Question juridique clé
Whether the appeal in public law matters was admissible against non-renewal of the residence permit and the removal order.
Solution extraite
The appeal was inadmissible because no federal or international right to renewal existed, and appeals against removal orders are excluded.
Motifs extraits
Under the applicable old law, the applicant no longer lived with her husband; the marital cohabitation had lasted less than three years, so no entitlement under Art. 17(2) ANAG arose. Without a protected right, neither the ordinary appeal nor a subsidiary constitutional complaint was available.