Kansas Attorney General Opinion 1989-139

1989-139Kanag

Gesamter Gesetzestext

ROBERT T. STEPHAN
ATTORNEY GENERAL
November 20, 1989
ATTORNEY GENERAL OPINION NO. 89- 139
Mr. Michael K. Schmitt
Horton City Attorney
P.O. Box 240
117 South Sixth Street
Hiawatha, Kansas 66434-0240
Re: Cities and Municipalities--Buildings, Structures
and Grounds; Public Building Commission--Authorized
Constitution of the State of Kansas--Corporations--
Cities' Powers of Home Rule
Synopsis: K.S.A. 1988 Supp. 12-1758, as amended by L. 1989,
ch. 62, S 2, K.S.A. 12-1759 (as amended) and K.S.A.
12-1763 (as amended) are part of an enactment (L.
1989, ch. 62) which is not uniformly applicable to
all cities. Accordingly, a city may by charter
ordinance exempt itself from the provisions of
those statutes and adopt substitute and additional
provisions on the same subject, in accordance with
article 12, section 5 of the Kansas Constitution.
However, substitute and additional provisions in
charter ordinance no. 10 of the city of Horton,
which would authorize a public building commission
to lease and operate a correctional facility for
one thousand inmates, have a substantial impact on
residents outside the territorial limits of the
city of Horton. Recognizing that impact, it is
our opinion that the substitute and additional
provisions prescribed by charter ordinance no. 10
of the city of Horton do not fit within the
"local affairs and government" language of article
12, section 5 of the Kansas Constitution and are
outside the authority granted by that
constitutional provision. Cited herein: K.S.A.
12-1757; K.S.A. 1988 Supp. 12-1758; K.S.A. 12-1759;
12-1763; L. 1989, ch. 62, § 2; L. 1989, ch. 62, §
4; Kan. Const., Art. 12, § 5.
Dear Mr. Schmitt:
You request our opinion as to whether the Horton
Correctional Facility Commission is authorized, under K.S.A.
12-1757 et seq., as modified by charter ordinances of
the city of Horton, to lease and operate a correctional
facility for approximately one thousand inmates. You indicate
that a substantial amount of the inmates will come from
governmental agencies located outside the state of Kansas, but
that it is anticipated that the state of Kansas and its
political subdivisions will eventually be significant
suppliers of inmates for the correctional facility.
K.S.A. 12-1757 et seq. authorize any city to create a
public building commission for certain purposes prescribed
therein. The city of Horton has exempted itself, by charter
ordinance nos. 9 and 10, from the provisions of K.S.A. 1988
Supp. 12-1758, as amended by L. 1989, ch. 62, § 2, K.S.A.
12-1759 (as amended) and K.S.A. 12-1763 (as amended), and has
adopted substitute and additional provisions relating to its
public building commission. The substitute provisions
authorize the Horton Correctional Facility Commission to
lease and operate a prison within the city of Horton, or no
more than five miles outside the territorial limits of the
city of Horton. The commission is also authorized to charge
service fees or inmate per diem rates to any federal, state or
county governmental agency, or any municipal corporation,
wherever located, within or without Brown County or the state
of Kansas.
All the statutes, enumerated above, from which the city of
Horton has exempted itself by charter ordinance are part of
an enactment (L. 1989, ch. 62) which is not uniformly
applicable to all cities by virtue of section 4 thereof. That
section places use restrictions on buildings located in cities
having a population of more than 50,000 which are not
applicable to buildings in other cities. Accordingly, it is
our opinion that a city may by charter ordinance exempt itself
from the provisions of the above-referenced statutes and adopt
substitute and additional provisions on the same subject, in
accordance with article 12, section 5 of the Kansas
Constitution. However, it is necessary to consider whether
the substitute and additional provisions set forth in charter
ordinance no. 10 of the city of Horton are in harmony with
the home rule powers granted by article 12, section 5.
The home rule amendment grants cities the power to determine
"their local affairs and government." While the Kansas
Supreme Court has adopted the position that the constitutional
language was never intended to restrict city home rule power
to matters of strictly local concern, City of Junction City
v. Griffin, 227 Kan. 332, 337 (1980), it is clear that
there are some cases where the extraterritorial impact of a
home rule ordinance will result in a finding that it is
outside the authority granted by article 12, section 5 of the
Kansas Constitution. This conclusion was reached by Professor
Barkley Clark of the University of Kansas in State Control
of Local Government in Kansas: Special Legislation and Home
Rule, 20 U. Kan. L. Rev. 631, 676-677 (1972). In that
article, which was quoted with approval in the Griffin
case, supra, Professor Clark offers the following guidance
to the Kansas Supreme Court in interpreting the home rule
amendment:
"[T]he court should . . . be wary of
ordinances which may not 'conflict' with
statutory law but which have a substantial
impact on interests outside the. boundaries
of the municipality. After all, these
interests may not be represented in city
legislative deliberations, and municipal
parochialism should not, in the name of
home rule, be allowed to trample over
adversaries unable to protect themselves."
Id. at 677.
Additionally, in the above-quoted article, Professor Clark
suggests that "ordinances involving . . . substantial
extraterritorial impact do not fit within the 'local affairs
and government' language of article 12, section 5." Id.
It seems clear that the portion of charter ordinance no. 10
which authorizes the operation of a one thousand inmate prison
has a substantial extraterritorial impact on county and
township residents living outside the city of Horton.
Specifically, there may be a perceived compromise of their
personal security from the threat of inmates escaping from the
prison. Further, inmates will be transported in and out of
the city of Horton on county and local roads, and "friends"
and "business associates" of convicted felons will converge on
the area for visitation at the prison. Under the charter
ordinance, the prison may even be established outside the city
limits and in the midst of the county and township residents.
For these reasons, it is our opinion that the substitute and
additional provisions prescribed by charter ordinance no. 10
of the city of Horton do not fit within the "local affairs
and government" language of article 12, section 5 of the
Kansas Constitution, and are outside the authority granted by
that constitutional provision.
Very truly yours,
ROBERT T% STEPHAN
Attorney General of Kansas
Terrence R. Hearshman
Assistant Attorney General
RTS:JLM:TRH:jm

Setzen Sie Ihre Recherche in ChatGPT oder Claude fort

Verbinden Sie Omnilex, um den Rechtskorpus über Ihren KI-Assistenten zu durchsuchen.