Kansas Attorney General Opinion 1989-134

1989-134Kanag

Gesamter Gesetzestext

ROBERT T. STEPHAN
ATTORNEY GENERAL November 7, 1989
ATTORNEY GENERAL OPINION NO. 89- 134
Robert Orth, Chairman
Kansas Board of Emergency Medical Services
P.O. Box 980
Sublette, Kansas 67877
Re: Public Health--Emergency Medical Services--Powers
and Duties of Emergency Medical Services Board;
Rules and Regulations; Implementation of Policy
Statutes; Administrative Rules and Regulations and
Procedure--Rules and Regulations--Definitions
Synopsis: A regulatory agency cannot promulgate a policy
statement in lieu of a regulation if the policy
statement is intended to create or affect rights
and obligations of persons subject to the agency's
control. Additionally, all amendments or
modifications of a regulation are subject to the
filing and publishing requirements in article 4,
chapter 77 of the Kansas Statutes Annotated. Cited
herein: K.S.A. 1988 Supp. 65-6129; K.S.A. 77-415;
K.S.A. 1988 Supp. 77-421; 77-436.
* * *
Dear Mr. Orth:
As Chairman of the Kansas Emergency Medical Services Board you
make several inquiries regarding the promulgation of
regulations. First, you inquire whether the Board can
implement and enforce policies in those areas not specifically
required by statute to be covered by rules and regulations.
You indicate that you would like to promulgate statements of
policy in regard to areas specifically identified by statute
as requiring approval or prescription by the Board. See,
e.g., K.S.A. 1988 Supp. 65-6129.
Initially we note that whether a statute specifically
"requires" the promulgation of a regulation is not
determinative of whether a regulation is necessary nor is it
determinative of whether a policy statement will suffice.
Thus your inquiry is whether the Board can promulgate and
enforce policy in lieu of regulations.
Generally regulations differ from policy statements in both
procedure and effect. Procedurally, a regulation is subject
to the filing act, K.S.A. 77-415 et seq., that includes
a publishing requirement. A policy statement (which is not a
regulation) is not subject to this procedure. Substantively,
a regulation imposes rights and obligations and has the force
and effect of law, and a statement of policy does not. See
Attorney General Opinion 89-114 (enclosed) setting forth the
criteria to determine whether a directive issued by an agency
is a statement of policy or a regulation; see also, State
of Alaska v. U.S. Dept. of Transportation, 868 F.2d 441,
445-447 (D.C. Cir. 1989) and Limerick Ecology Action v.
U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission, 869 F.2d 719, 733-735
(3rd Cir. 1989). Thus, while a regulatory agency such as
the Emergency Medical Services Board may promulgate general
statements of policy, such statements are not enforceable as
rules and regulations that affect rights or create obligations
upon those affected. See K.S.A. 77-425 "any rule and
regulation not filed and published as required by this act
shall be of no force or effect. . . ."
The distinction between statements of policy and regulations
is confusing in that most regulations are statements of policy
whereas clearly not all statements of policy are regulations.
This clouded distinction is evidenced by the statutory
definition of a rule or regulation found in subsection (4) of
K.S.A. 77-415:
"(4) 'Rule and regulation,' rule,'
'regulation' and words of like effect mean
a standard, statement of policy or general
order, including amendments or revocations
thereof, of general application and having
the effect of law, issued or adopted by a
state agency to implement or interpret
legislation enforced or administered by
such state agency or to govern the
organization or procedure of such state
agency."
Subsection (4) also provides, in paragraphs (a) through (s),
circumstances where a regulation is not a regulation within
the definition provided. It states in part:
"A rule and regulation as herein defined
shall not include any rule and regulation
which: (a) Relates to the internal
management or organization of the agency
and does not affect private rights or
interest; (b) is an order directed to
specifically named persons or to a group
which does not constitute a general class
and the order is served on the person or
persons to whom it is directed by
appropriate means. The fact that the
named person serves a group of unnamed
persons who will be affected does not make
such an order a rule or regulation; . . .
(o) is a form, the content or substantive
requirements of which are prescribed by
regulation or statute; (p) is a pamphlet
or other explanatory material not intended
or designed as interpretation of
legislation enforced or adopted by a state
agency but is merely informational in
nature."
Presumably if a policy statement comes within any of these
exceptions (a) through (s) (note we cite only a partial list),
it's promulgation does not trigger the filing and publishing
requirements under K.S.A. 1988 Supp. 77-420 and 77-421.
(However, subsection (c) of K.S.A. 1988 Supp. 77-436 requires
all rules and regulations specifically excluded from the
definition of a rule and regulation be reviewed by the Joint
Committee on Administrative Rules and Regulations.) While not
within the statutory definition of a regulation, policy
statements within these exceptions may be valid. See Clark
v. Ivy, 240 Kan. 195 (1986) involving an original mandamus
action wherein the Kansas Supreme Court found that in spite of
the failure to file and publish the policy in question as a
regulation, the policy was nonetheless valid against
petitioner because he had received actual notice of its
adoption. But cf. Aircraft Steel and Supply Co. v.
State Commission of Revenue and Taxation, 173 Kan. 524, 531
(1952) (in dicta the court questions whether a policy not
filed with the revisor of statutes is legally enforceable.)
Thus, if the policy statement is intended to affect the rights
and obligations of persons subject to the Board's control, it
must be promulgated as a regulation pursuant to K.S.A. 77-415
et seq. Conversely, if the policy statement is not
intended to affect such rights and obligations or fits within
one of the exceptions in K.S.A. 77-415, the policy statement
is not subject to the filing and publishing requirements in
K.S.A. 77-415 et sea.; it is however subject to
subsection (c) of K.S.A. 1988 Supp. 77-436, review by the
Joint Committee on Administrative Rules and Regulations.
Therefore, while there is nothing to preclude you from
promulgating statements of policy generally, in our opinion
they cannot be promulgated in lieu of regulations that affect
the rights of and place obligations on licensees under your
jurisdiction.
Your second question is whether a regulation adopting a
national association standard may be drafted without a date
specific, thus obviating the need to change the regulation
every time the Board desires to modify the standard adopted.
You cite the example of K.A.R. 109-10-1. It states in part:
"(a) the approved curriculum for first responder programs
shall be the department of transportation curriculum H.S. 900
025 as modified by the board and as in effect on January 1,
1989." You indicate you would like to change it to: "(a)
the approved curriculum for first responder programs shall be
the department of transportation curriculum H.S. 900 026 as
annually approved by the board."
Reduced to simple terms, your inquiry is whether an amendment
or modification of a regulation is subject to the rules and
regulations procedure in K.S.A. 77-415 et seq. In
short, amendments or modifications of regulations are subject
to this act. K.S.A. 1988 Supp. 77-416 requires every state
agency file with the secretary of state every rule and
regulation adopted by it and every amendment and revocation
thereof. See K.S.A. 1988 Supp. 77-421 notice and comment
requirements applicable to an amendment of a regulation.
See also North American Safety Valve Industries v.
Wolgast, 672 F.Supp. 488, 493 (1987) (changes in inspection
code previously adopted from private group as regulations not
effective as amended regulations until submitted to state
officials.) Thus, it is our opinion that adopting a
regulation without a date specific would not obviate the need
to change the regulation because any modification of the
standard adopted by the regulation would require amending the
regulation and thus trigger the filing and publishing
requirements in article 4, chapter 77 of Kansas Statutes
Annotated. (We note your question may also pose an unlawful
delegation of legislative authority question that we have not
addressed. See Attorney General Opinion No. 87-41.)
In conclusion, it is our opinion that a policy statement
cannot be promulgated in lieu of a regulation if the policy
statement is intended to impose rights and create obligations
on persons subject to the Board's control. In addition, any
amendment or modification of a regulation is subject to the
filing and publishing requirements in article 4, chapter 77 of
Kansas Statutes Annotated.
Very truly yours,
ROBERT T. STEPHAN
Attorney General of Kansas
Guen Easley
Assistant Attorney General
RTS:JLM:GE:jm

Setzen Sie Ihre Recherche in ChatGPT oder Claude fort

Verbinden Sie Omnilex, um den Rechtskorpus über Ihren KI-Assistenten zu durchsuchen.