Kansas Attorney General Opinion 1988-174

1988-174Kanag

Gesamter Gesetzestext

ROBERT T. STEPHAN
ATTORNEY GENERAL December 28, 1988
ATTORNEY GENERAL OPINION NO. 88-174
The Honorable Sam K. Bruner
District Judge, Division No. 2
Johnson County Courthouse
Olathe, Kansas 66061
Re: Minors -- Interstate Compact on Placement of
Children -- Enactment of Compact; Enforcement of
Compact; Limitations
Probate Code -- Probate Procedure; Adoption
Proceedings -- Nonresident Mother
Synopsis: K.S.A. 38-1202 and K.S.A. 1987 Supp. 59-2278b do
not require a pregnant woman who is not a Kansas
resident, but whose child is born in Kansas, to
comply with the procedures of the interstate
compact on placement of children. Cited herein:
K.S.A. 38-1202; K.S.A. 1987 Supp. 59-2278b; K.S.A.
65-509.
Dear Judge Bruner:
You request our opinion on whether the interstate compact on
placement of children applies in the case of a pregnant
nonresident mother giving birth in Kansas who, before
returning to her home state, consents to the adoption of the
baby by a resident Kansan couple. You inform us that both the
mother's home state and Kansas have enacted the interstate
compact on placement of children.
Enacted in 1985, K.S.A. 1987 Supp. 59-2278b states:
"Interstate placements of children shall
comply with the procedures contained in
the interstate compact on placement of
children as set forth in K.S.A. 38-1202
and amendments thereto."
Enacted in 1976, K.S.A. 38-1202 provides in pertinent part:
"ARTICLE II. Definitions.
"As used in this compact: (a) 'Child'
means a person who, by reason of minority,
is legally subject to parental,
guardianship or similar control.
"(b) 'Sending agency' means a party
state, officer or employee thereof; a
subdivision of a party state, or officer
or employee thereof; a court of a party
state; a person, corporation,
association, charitable agency or other
entity which sends, brings, or causes to
be sent or brought any child to another
party state.
"(c) 'Receiving state' means the state
to which a child is sent, brought, or
caused to be sent or brought, whether by
public authorities or private persons or
agencies, and whether for placement with
state or local public authorities or for
placement with private agencies or persons .
"(d) 'Placement' means the arrangement
for the care of a child in a family free
or boarding home or in a child-caring
agency or institution but does not include
any institution caring for the mentally
ill, mentally defective or epileptic or
any institution primarily educational in
character, and any hospital or other
medical facility.
•
"ARTICLE VIII. Limitations.
"This compact shall not apply to: (a)
The sending or bringing of a child into a
receiving state by his parent,
step-parent, grandparent, adult brother or
sister, adult uncle or aunt, or his
guardian and leaving the child with any
such relative or nonagency guardian in
the receiving state.
• • •
"ARTICLE III. Conditions for Placement.
"(a) No sending agency shall send, bring,
or cause to be sent or brought into any
other party state any child for placement
in foster care or as a preliminary to a
possible adoption unless the sending
agency shall comply with each and every
requirement set forth in this article and
with the applicable laws of the receiving
state governing the placement of children
therein. . . ." (Emphasis added).
Thus, Kansas has attempted to insure that children brought
into Kansas are afforded some protection. See K.S.A. 1987
Supp. 59-2278(c); K.S.A. 65-509; State ex rel. v. Heart
Ministries, Inc., 227 Kan. 244 (1980); Matter of Adoption
of Hobson, 8 Kan. App. 2d 772 (1983). See also "The
Interstate Placement of Children: A Preliminary Report",
Council of State Governments (1978); J. Hall, "The
Out-of-State Placement of Children: A National Survey 2"
(Major Issues in Juvenile Justice Information and Training,
1982). Clearly, if a governmental agency places the child in
an out-of-state institution, the procedures contained in the
interstate compact on placement of children become
applicable. See Sinhogar v. Parry, 427 N.Y.S. 2d 216
(1980), app. dism., 431 N.Y.S. 2d 813, modified on other
grounds, 442 N.Y.S. 2d 438.
The situation presented concerns what is essentially a private
adoption involving a pregnant nonresident mother. K.S.A. 1987
Supp. 59-2278b mandates the applicability of the interstate
compact to adoption proceedings. The required procedures are
set forth at K.S.A. 38-1202. Independent adoptions in Kansas
historically have occurred without the assistance of a
licensed agency. L. Elrod, "The Kansas Family Law
Handbook," 6-3, 6-4 (1983). Nationwide estimates show that
independent placements exceed agency placements two-to-one.
Evans, "Independent Adoptions: In Whose Best Interests?", 53
OK. B.J. 1805 (1982).
Other states' courts involved with adoptions and enforcing
procedural requirements contained in the interstate compact
focus on the activities of persons other than the natural
parents of a child. Those courts have indicated that failure
to comply with the procedures of the interstate compact on
placement of children may jeopardize independent adoptions.
The Montana supreme court removed a child from the prospective
adoptive parents' care and placed the child in foster care
because the compact procedures were not followed. The
Adoption of T.M.M., 608 P. 2d 130 (1980). In T.M.M. the
prospective adoptive couple went to another state and picked
up the child. The court recognized that the compact did not
apply to "the sending or bringing of a child into a receiving
state by his parent . . . and leaving the child with any such
relative or nonagency guardian in the receiving state."
However, the court stated that because the prospective
adoptive parents are not relatives of the natural mother, or
nonagency guardians, they were required to comply with the
requirements of the compact. Id. at 133. The Arizona
supreme court found that a juvenile court was without
authority to allow foster parents to take a minor out of the
state for placement unless the terms of the compact were
complied with. Pima v. Fisher, 610 P.2d 64 (Az. 1980).
Assuming, arguendo, that limitations contained in Article
VIII(a) of K.S.A. 38-1202 do not apply to parents and that
K.S.A. 1987 Supp. 59-2278b therefore precludes a mother who
does not comply with the compact from bringing her child into
Kansas for the purpose of independently placing that child for
adoption, if the child is as yet unborn at the time the mother
enters the state the applicability of the compact is limited.
Under K.S.A. 38-1202, Article II(a), child means "a person
who, by reason of minority, is legally subject to parental,
guardianship or similar control." While an unborn child is
subject to a certain degree of parental control, the term
"child" within the adoption statutes means a living child who
can receive attention. In re Adoption of Nelson, 202 Kan.
663 (1969). "We do not ordinarily use the term child to mean
an unborn child." Id. at 666. See also Wisdom v.
Norton, 507 F. 2d 750 (Conn. 1974); Poole v.
Endsley, 371 F. Supp. 1370 (5th Circ. 1974).
Transporting expectant mothers to another jurisdiction until
the baby is born appears to represent a creative circumvention
of the terms of the compact. Note, "Independent Adoption:
Regulating the Middleman," 24 W.L.J. 327, 334 at note 64
(1985). Such circumvention is properly addressed by the
legislative body possessing the authority to regulate such
matters.
In summary, K.S.A. 1987 Supp. 59-2278b mandates the
applicability of procedures contained in the interstate
compact on placement of children to adoption proceedings.
These required procedures are set forth at K.S.A. 38-1202.
Article VIII(a) expressly limits the applicability of the
compact to certain persons and situations. There is some
question whether these limitations operate to allow a parent
to bring his or her child into the state for private adoption
purposes. Nevertheless, if a woman is pregnant at the time
she enters Kansas she has not, for purposes of the compact,
brought a "child" into the state. It is therefore our opinion
that the procedures contained in the interstate compact on
placement of children and K.S.A. 1987 Supp. 59-2278(b) do not
apply to a pregnant woman who enters Kansas and then gives
birth.
Very truly yours,
ROBERT T. STEPHAN
ATTORNEY GENERAL OF KANSAS
RTS:JLM:TMN:bas
Theresa Marcel Nuckolls
Assistant Attorney General

Setzen Sie Ihre Recherche in ChatGPT oder Claude fort

Verbinden Sie Omnilex, um den Rechtskorpus über Ihren KI-Assistenten zu durchsuchen.