Kansas Attorney General Opinion 1988-046

1988-046Kanag

Gesamter Gesetzestext

ROBERT T. STEPHAN
ATTORNEY GENERAL April 1, 1988
ATTORNEY GENERAL OPINION NO. 88- 46
Mr. Norman E. Gaar
Burke, Williams, Sorensen & Gaar
Lighton Plaza
7300 College Boulevard, Suite 220
Overland Park, Kansas 66210
Re: Cities and Municipalities--Local Residential
Housing--Mortgage Credit Certificate Program
Synopsis: The local residential housing act, K.S.A. 12-5219
et seq., does not through its provisions
authorize participation in a mortgage credit
certificate program as established by section 25
of the Internal Revenue Code of 1986, as amended.
Neither does the local residential housing act
preclude participation in a mortgage credit
program. Kansas cities may, therefore, by the
exercise of their constitutional powers of home
rule as provided in Article 12, Section 5 of the
Kansas Constitution, join in a mortgage credit
program of the type organized by Geary County and
Riley County. Cited herein: K.S.A. 1987 Supp.
12-5219 to 12-5235; Kan. Const., Art. 12,
Sec. 5.
Dear Mr. Gaar:
As special counsel to Geary county and Riley county you
have requested an opinion from this office regarding the
authority of Kansas cities and counties to issue "mortgage
credit certificates" as defined in the federal qualified
mortgage certificate program authorized by section 25 of the
Internal Revenue Code of 1986, as amended. The questions you
raise are: (1) Whether Kansas cities and counties can use
K.S.A. 1987 Supp. 12-5231 or any other authority to cooperate
in putting together a program area across the state for a
qualified mortgage certificate program as authorized by the
code; and (2) assuming compliance with the Internal Revenue
Code and supporting federal income tax regulations, can
Geary county and Riley county issue "mortgage credit
certificates" under existing Kansas law?
The statute you cite as a mechanism for allowing Kansas cities
and counties to cooperate in a mortgage certificate program
(the program) is a part of the local residential housing act
(the act), K.S.A. 12-5219 et seq. K.S.A. 1987 Supp.
12-5231, the interlocal cooperation provision, allows for a
joint exercise of the powers granted by the act. In order to
utilize this provision, it is first necessary to determine if
the act in its entirety provides authorization for the
implementation of a mortgage credit certificate program. Such
a program would provide for the allowance of a credit against
federal income tax through the issuance of mortgage credit
certificates.
K.S.A. 1987 Supp. 12-5219 sets forth the legislature's
findings with respect to the scope and purposes for the act.
Relevant sections provide:
"(g) [I]n order to remedy the existing
shortage of residential housing within the
financial means of persons and families of
low and moderate income and to realize the
social, economic and other benefits which
will result therefrom, it is necessary and
desirable for the implementation of public
programs designed to provide alternative
means of financing the acquisition,
rehabilitation, improvement and purchase
of safe, decent and sanitary housing by
persons and families of low and moderate
income;
"(h) it is necessary and desirable that
the state's cities and counties be
authorized to issue revenue bonds to
provide funds necessary, in whole or in
part, to reduce the costs of financing the
acquisition, rehabilitation, improvement
and purchase of safe, decent and sanitary
housing by persons and families of low and
moderate income;
"(i) the implementation of such programs
and the issuance of revenue bonds
pursuant to this act are in the public
interest and constitute essential
governmental functions of cities and
counties of the state. - " (Emphasis added.)
It is a fundamental tenet of statutory construction that all
parts of a legislative act must be read and construed in
pari materia. Matter of Guardianship and Conservatorship
of Stremel, 233 Kan. 136 (1983). Where a statute is
plain and unambiguous, courts must give effect to the
intention of the legislature as expressed. Johnston v.
Tony's Pizza Service, 232 Kan. 848 (1983). If the
language of the statute is ambiguous, however, courts may
properly look to extrinsic evidence for aid in construction.
State v. Bagemehl, 213 Kan. 210 (1973). It is our
opinion that in considering the applicable statutes in
pari materia, there is sufficient ambiguity as to whether
the legislature intended to provide for the authorization of
financing under the provisions of the act other than through
the issuance of mortgage revenue bonds. Therefore, we have
looked to extrinsic evidence of the legislature's intent for
aid in construction.
An examination of the legislative history evidences that the
act was intended to provide only for the issuance of mortgage
revenue bonds as a method of financing low cost housing
programs. The act is discussed as providing authorization for
cities and counties to issue mortgage revenue bonds for the
purpose of providing moneys for persons of low or moderate
income to acquire a home at interest rates significantly less
than interest rates offered by lending institutions for
conventional home loans.
In our opinion, the legislature provided only for the issuance
of mortgage revenue bonds through the provisions of this act.
Sections 12-5222 to 12-5225, inclusive, deal with the terms
and conditions concerning the issuance of the bonds.
We now address your second question, whether, assuming
compliance with the Internal Revenue Code and supporting
federal income tax regulations, Geary county and Riley
county may issue "mortgage credit certificates" under existing
Kansas law. Although in our opinion the act does not afford
authorization for the implementation of a mortgage credit
certificate program, we are not concluding that cities do not
have the power and authority to participate in such a
program. K.S.A. 1987 Supp. 12-5233 clearly provides that the
act is not exclusive, stating in particular part:
"The powers conferred by this act are in
addition to, and the limitations imposed
by this act shall not affect, the powers
conferred upon municipalities under the
provisions of the constitution or laws of
the state of Kansas. . . . Nothing in
this act shall be deemed or construed to
prohibit the exercise of the powers
conferred upon municipalities in
connection with the financing of federally
assisted housing for persons of low and
moderate income." (Emphasis added.)
The act acknowledges that other types of alternative finance
programs may be made available. The language of the act
clearly indicates that the act is not intended to provide the
exclusive procedure for the provision of low cost financing,
but instead prescribes through its terms one way in which a
financing program may be implemented. Nothing in the act
suggests that additional programs established to provide
similar benefits to persons of low and moderate income would
be incompatible with or in contravention of the terms of the
act.
The act carefully recognizes that the powers which it confers
are in addition and supplemental to those powers conferred
upon municipalities under the provisions of the constitution
and the laws of the state of Kansas. In our opinion, nothing
in the act would preclude Kansas cities from participating in
the mortgage credit program by utilizing the cities
constitutional powers of home rule as provided in Article 12,
Section 5 of the Kansas Constitution.
The home rule amendment provides in significant part:
"Cities are hereby empowered to determine
their local affairs and government . . .
by ordinance passed by the governing body
. . . subject only to enactment of the
legislature of statewide concern
applicable uniformly to all cities, to
other enactments of the legislature
applicable uniformly to all cities, to
enactments of the legislature applicable
uniformly to all cities of the same class
limiting or prohibiting the levying of any
tax, excise, fee, charge or other exaction
and to enactments of the legislature
prescribing limits of indebtedness."
Kan. Const., Art. 12, §5(b).
The Kansas Supreme Court has stated that the home rule
amendment grants cities the power to determine their local
affairs and government without legislative authorization in
the form of an enabling statute. In certain circumstances,
home rule powers are subject to legislative limitations, but
the powers are to be liberally construed to allow cities the
largest measure of self government. Claflin v. Walsh,
212 Kan. 1 (1971); City of Junction City v. Lee, 216
Kan. 495, 498 (1975). In our opinion, participation in a
mortgage credit certificate program as defined in section 25
of the Internal Revenue Code is within the cities
constitutional powers of home rule and is not precluded by any
of the limitations stated in Article 12, §5.
We conclude, therefore, that while the local residential
housing act does not provide the requisite authorization for
implementation of the mortgage credit certificate program,
cities, nevertheless, would be able to participate in such a
program through the valid exercise of their constitutional
powers of home rule as set forth in Article 12, §5 of the
Kansas Constitution. Thus, Cities may join in the program
established by Geary county and Riley county pursuant to
home rule authority. In our judgment participation in the
mortgage credit certificate program through the exercise of
the cities constitutional home rule powers is not prohibited
by any limitations found in the local residential housing act,
K.S.A. 12-5219 et seq. or any limitations imposed by
Article 12, §5 of the Kansas Constitution.
Very truly yours,
ROBERT T. STEPHAN
Attorney General of Kansas
Rebecca E. Floyd
Assistant Attorney General
RTS:JLM:REF:jm

Setzen Sie Ihre Recherche in ChatGPT oder Claude fort

Verbinden Sie Omnilex, um den Rechtskorpus über Ihren KI-Assistenten zu durchsuchen.