Kansas Attorney General Opinion 1988-003

1988-003Kanag

Gesamter Gesetzestext

ROBERT T. STEPHAN
ATTORNEY GENERAL.	
January 8, 1988
ATTORNEY GENERAL OPINION NO. 88-3
The Honorable Alfred G. Schroeder
Kansas Racing Commission
128 N. Kansas Avenue
Topeka, Kansas 66603
Re: Laws, Journals and Public Information -- Records
Open to Public -- Kansas Racing Commission;
Applications for Licensure
Synopsis: The application form submitted to the Kansas Racing
Commission (Commission) by entities and persons
seeking licensure to conduct and manage
parimutuel horse and greyhound races and own
racetrack facilities is a public record subject to
disclosure under the Kansas Open Records Act. The
Commission has discretion under K.S.A. 1987 Supp.
45-221(a)(4) to keep confidential the names of
prospective employees listed on the application.
In addition, security information supplied with the
application is exempt from mandatory disclosure
under K.S.A. 1987 Supp. 45-221(a)(12). Further,
the Commission is prohibited from disclosing
applicants' tax returns required to be submitted
with the applications. Cited herein: K.S.A.
2-1202; 16-715; 39-709b; 45-215; 45-216; 45-217;
K.S.A. 1987 Supp. 45-221; K.S.A. 47-502; K.S.A.
1987 Supp. 65-436; K.S.A. 65-1831; 66-1220a;
74-8801; 74-8802; 74-8813; K.S.A. 1987 Supp.
75-4318; 79-3234; K.A.R. 112-3-7; 112-3-8;
112-3-11; 112-3-12, as proposed.
Dear Mr. Chief Justice Schroeder:
On behalf of the Kansas Racing Commission, Janet A. Chubb,
Assistant Attorney General for the Commission, has requested
our opinion on two questions concerning the Kansas Open
Records Act, K.S.A. 45-215 et sec: (1) Whether the
application for licensure to conduct and manage parimutuel
horse and greyhound racing and own racetrack facilities may be
closed to the public before the license is granted; (2) if the
application cannot be closed, whether the names of key,
prospective employees listed on the application may be kept
confidential before licensure is granted.
The 1987 session of the Kansas legislature enacted the Kansas
Parimutuel Racing Act, which provides for the regulation and
taxation of parimutuel wagering on horse and greyhound
racing. K.S.A. 1987 Supp. 74-8801 et seq. The Kansas
Racing Commission (Commission) was established to carry out
the provisions of the parimutuel racing statutes and
regulations adopted by the Commission. It is the Commission's
duty to license nonprofit organizations, granting them the
authority to conduct races and parimutuel wagering. Such
licensed, nonprofit organizations, "organization licensees,"
may also be licensed to construct or own racetrack
facilities. K.S.A. 1987 Supp. 74-8802(o). If the racetrack
facility will not be owned by the organization licensee, the
proposed racetrack owner must obtain licensure as a "facility
owner licensee." K.S.A. 1987 Supp. 74-8802(g). In
addition, if the organization licensee contracts for the
management of the racetrack facility, the proposed manager
must obtain licensure as a "facility manager licensee."
K.S.A. 1987 Supp. 74-8802(f). Thus, a potential of three
entities and/or persons may need to be licensed by the
Commission to operate, manage, and own a parimutuel
racetrack facility.
Applicants for an organization license must meet the
requirements specified by the legislature in K.S.A. 1987
Supp. 74-8813, and the requirements of administrative rules
and regulations promulgated by the Commission pursuant to
statute. These requirements are being incorporated into an
application form which all applicants must complete and submit
to the Commission. If the nonprofit organization will not
manage or own the racetrack, the prospective facility manager
and facility owner must apply for licensure by completing
pertinent sections of the application form. Your first
question is whether applications for licensure submitted to
the Commission are public records which must be open to the
public.
The Kansas Open Records Act (KORA) declares it to be the
policy of this state that public records of public agencies
"shall be open for inspection by any person. . . ." K.S.A.
45-216(a). The KORA further provides that the act is to be
liberally construed and applied to promote the public policy
of openness. K.S.A. 45-216(a); Harris Enterprises, Inc. v.
Moore, 241 Kan. 59, 63 (1987). The Kansas Racing
Commission is a public agency as it meets the definition
stated in K.S.A. 45-217(e)(1):
"'Public agency' means the state or any
political or taxing subdivision of the
state, or any office, officer, agency or
instrumentality thereof, or any other
entity receiving or expending and
supported in whole or in part by public
funds appropriated by the state or by
public funds of any political or taxing
subdivision of the state."
A "public record" is "any recorded information, regardless of
form or characteristics, which is made, maintained or kept by
or is in the possession of any public agency." K.S.A.
45-217(f)(1). Public records do not include
"records which are owned by a private
person or entity and are not related to
functions, activities, programs or
operations funded by public funds or
records which are made, maintained or kept
by an individual who is a member of the
legislature or of the governing body of
any political or taxing subdivision of the
state." K.S.A. 45-217(f)(2).
Pursuant to these definitions, the application form submitted
to the Commission by prospective licensees is a public record.
Not all public records are required to be open for public
inspection. K.S.A. 1987 Supp. 45-221(a)(1) provides that
records, the disclosure of which is prohibited or restricted
by law, are not subject to disclosure under the KORA. In
addition, K.S.A. 1987 Supp. 45 - 221(a)(2)-(36) lists records
which a public agency has discretion to keep confidential. We
are not aware of any state or federal law which prohibits
disclosure of the application form. In addition, it does not
appear that any of the exceptions to mandatory disclosure are
applicable.
We shall examine several exceptions listed under K.S.A. 1987
Supp. 45-221(a). Exception (10) provides that criminal
investigation records are not required to be disclosed.
"Criminal investigation records" are records of "an
investigatory agency or criminal justice agency. . . compiled
in the process of preventing, detecting or investigating
violations of criminal law. . . ." K.S.A. 45-217(b). The
information supplied on the application forms is used to
investigate an applicant's background. However, the
Commission is not an investigatory agency and the information
is compiled for purposes of obtaining licensure.
Under K.S.A. 1987 Supp. 45-221(a)(11), a public agency is
not required to disclose the following records:
"Records of agencies involved in
administrative adjudication or civil
litigation, compiled in the process of
detecting or investigating violations of
civil law or administrative rules and
regulations, if disclosure would interfere
with a prospective administrative
adjudication or civil litigation or reveal
the identity of a confidential source or
undercover agent."
This exception does not exempt the application form from
disclosure as the Commission is not involved in an
administrative adjudication, the information was not compiled
to detect violations of law, and disclosure would not reveal a
confidential source or undercover agent.
A public agency also has discretion whether to disclose
"records pertaining to prospective location of a business or
industry. . . ." K.S.A. 1987 Supp. 45-221(a)(31). At first
glance, this exception may seem applicable to the present
situation. However, the exception only applies when "no
previous public disclosure has been made of the business' or
industry's interest in locating in, relocating in or expanding
within the state." The Commission's grant or denial of a
license must be done in an open meeting. See K.S.A. 1987
Supp. 75-4318(a). Exception (31) further provides:
"This exception shall not include those
records pertaining to application of
agencies for permits or licenses
necessary to do business or to expand
business operations within this state."
(Emphasis added).
Since licensure is required to conduct parimutuel racing and
wagering, this provision is not applicable to exempt the
application from disclosure. In the absence of a statutory
provision prohibiting disclosure or permitting the Commission
to keep the document confidential, the application form as a
public record is open for public inspection upon request by
any person.
You ask whether the names of key, prospective employees listed
on the applications may be kept confidential before licensure
is granted. Proposed K.A.R. 112-3-11(c) requires an applicant
for an organization license to "list those persons within the
applicant organization who will be supervising the conduct and
operation of the horse races or greyhound races, or both, and
the operation of the pari-mutuel system of wagering. . . ."
Applicants for an organizational license or facility manager
license in which the applicant proposes to manage a racetrack
facility are required by proposed K.A.R. 112-3-12(b) to list
their management personnel on the application form.
The KORA provides that, if a public record contains material
not subject to disclosure, the public agency shall separate or
delete the material and make available to the requestor the
information in the public record which is subject to
disclosure. K.S.A. 1987 Supp. 45-221(d). In our opinion,
the Commission may keep confidential the names of prospective
employees listed on the application as an exception to
mandatory disclosure is applicable:
"[A] public agency shall not be required
to disclose:
• • •
(4) Personnel records, performance
ratings or individually identifiable
records pertaining to employees or
applicants for employment, except that
this exemption shall not apply to the
names, positions, salaries and lengths of
service of officers and employees of
public agencies once they are employed
as such." K.S.A. 1987 Supp. 45-221(a).
(Emphasis added).
The above exception provides that the names of applicants for
employment are not required to be disclosed. This exception
is generally invoked in instances concerning public agency
employees and applicants for such employment. See Tew v.
Topeka Police and Fire Civ. Service Comm'n., 237 Kan.
96, 103-04 (1985). However, it also extends to applicants and
employees of private entities when an individually
identifiable record becomes a public record, such as the
application form in the present case. The individuals named
in the application are not yet employed by the organization
but are potential employees. Therefore, it is our opinion
that the Commission has discretion to keep confidential the
names of such individuals. The exception further provides
that, once they are employed by a public agency, the names of
public agency employees must be disclosed to the public.
No such requirement is placed on persons employed by a private
entity.
We note that proposed K.A.R. 112-3-7(e) and proposed K.A.R.
112-3-8(c) require applicants for an organization license,
facility owner license, and facility manager license to
include with the application a copy of the applicant's tax
returns from the previous three years or all tax returns if
the applicant has been organized for less than three years.
State law prohibits tax returns and tax return information
from being disclosed by any state officer or employee:
"(b) Except [as otherwise provided] it
shall be unlawful for the director, any
deputy, agent, clerk or other officer,
employee or former employee of the
department of revenue or any other state
officer or employee or former state
officer or employee to divulge, or to
make known in any way, the amount of
income or any particulars set forth or
disclosed in any report, return, federal
return or federal return information
required under this act. . . ." K.S.A.
79-3234. (Emphasis added).
Thus, the Commission is prohibited from disclosing tax returns
submitted with the application forms.
We understand the Commission is concerned that applicants are
required to submit on the application detailed information
regarding their security plans and financing mechanisms.
K.S.A. 1987 Supp. 45-221(a)(12) gives a public agency
discretion to close the following records:
"Records of emergency or security
information or procedures of a public
agency, or plans, drawings, specifications
or related information for any building
or facility which is used for purposes
requiring security measures in or around
the building or facility or which is used
for the generation or transmission of
power, water, fuels or communications, if
disclosure would jeopardize security of
the public agency, building or facility."
(Emphasis added).
Proposed K.A.R. 112-3-14 requires applicants who wish to
manage a racetrack facility to submit public safety and
security information. In pertinent part, the regulation
provides:
"(b) The application shall describe a
complete security plan for the race period
and the non-race period, including:
(1) The number and deployment of
security personnel;
(2) the perimeter;
(3) the stable and the kennel
compound;
(4) the cash room;
(5) the vault;
(6) the method of money transfer
between wagering windows, cash
room and any other location to
which money will be transferred;
(7) the number of sworn law
enforcement personnel assigned
to any local law enforcement
offices and the types of
incidents to which the law
enforcement personnel may be
expected to respond;
(8) the coordination between the
racetrack facility security and
the local law enforcement
personnel, including the
location of the local law
enforcement office and the
approximate response time;
(9) any video monitoring equipment,
including the type and location;
(10) any alarms, including the type
and location;
(11) the testing or detention barn or
paddock for horses;
(12) the greyhound paddock;
(13) the parking lot
(14) the backside and the frontside;
(15) any emergency procedures,
including ambulance, first aid
or evacuation, and the location
of any local emergency medical
services and approximate
response time;
(16) the exclusion and expulsion
rules:
(17) the security force equipment;
(18) the policy and procedure for
admittance of persons to any
locations at the racetrack
facility; and
(19) the control of traffic at the
racetrack facility."
Clearly, regulations drafted by the Commission pursuant to the
Parimutuel Racing Act require security measures for
racetrack facilities. Therefore, it is our opinion that the
Commission may, in accordance with K.S.A. 1987 Supp. 45-221
(a)(12), refuse to disclose security information submitted
with the application.
In regard to applicants' financing mechanisms, the
parimutuel wagering statutes do not contain a provision
protecting the confidentiality of this information and we do
not find any statute exempting it from mandatory disclosure.
K.S.A. 1987 Supp. 45-221(a)(34) only exempts financial
information of a contractor "who has submitted a bid or is
negotiating for a contract on a public improvement project."
Frederickson, Letting the Sunshine in: An Analysis of the
1984 Kansas Open Records Act, 33 U. Kan. L. Rev. 205, 261
(1985). Financial information contained in the applications,
therefore, must be disclosed to the public.
As we have shown, in order for information contained in or
supplied with the application form to be withheld from
disclosure, a specific statute must exist. In other areas of
the law, the legislature has enacted statutes exempting from
disclosure certain information required to be filed with
public agencies. See, e.g., K.S.A. 2-1202 (fertilizer
blender's reports required to be submitted for licensure);
K.S.A. 16-715(e) (pawnbrokers and precious metal dealers'
reports); K.S.A. 39-7096 (information concerning applicants
for and recipients of SRS assistance); K.S.A. 47-502
(ingredients in livestock remedies required to be submitted on
application for registration); K.S.A. 65-436 (records of
licensing agency concerning medical care facilities which
identify individuals or facilities); K.S.A. 65-1831
(applications submitted for registration by the Board of
Barber Examiners); K.S.A. 66-1220(a) (trade secrets of
entities regulated by the Kansas Corporation Commission). In
addition, the KORA grants public agencies discretion to keep
confidential certain documents required to be filed with the
agency. See, e.g., K.S.A. 1987 Supp. 45-221(a)(17)
(student financial assistance applications); 45-221(a)(19)
(well samples, logs, or surveys required to be filed with the
state corporation commission); 45-221(a)(28) (sealed bids).
In summary, the application form submitted to the Kansas
Racing Commission (Commission) by entities and persons seeking
licensure to conduct and manage parimutuel horse and
greyhound races and own racetrack facilities is a public
record subject to disclosure under the Kansas Open Records
Act. The Commission has discretion under K.S.A. 1987 Supp.
45-221(a)(4) to keep confidential the names of prospective
employees listed on the application. In addition, security
information supplied with the application is exempt from
mandatory disclosure under K.S.A. 1987 Supp. 45-221(a)(12).
Further, the Commission is prohibited from disclosing
applicants' tax returns required to be submitted with the
applications.
Very truly yours,
ROBERT T. STEPHAN
ATTORNEY GENERAL OF KANSAS
Janet A. Chubb
Assistant Attorney General
Rita L. Noll
Assistant Attorney General
RTS:JLM:JAC:RLN:bar

Setzen Sie Ihre Recherche in ChatGPT oder Claude fort

Verbinden Sie Omnilex, um den Rechtskorpus über Ihren KI-Assistenten zu durchsuchen.