Kansas Attorney General Opinion 1987-177

1987-177Kanag

Gesamter Gesetzestext

ROBERT T. STEPHAN
ATTORNEY GENERAL December 1, 1987
ATTORNEY GENERAL OPINION NO. 87- 177
Mr. David K. Markham
Labette County Counselor
P.O. Box 611
Parsons, Kansas 67357
Re: Counties and County Officers--County
Commissioners--Powers and Duties
Counties and County Officers--General Provisions--
Home Rule Powers
Synopsis: Pursuant to general authority granted by K.S.A.
19-212 Sixth and K.S.A. 19-101a, a board of
county commissioners may pass a resolution
prohibiting certain elected officials from bidding
upon and purchasing property at a tax foreclosure
sale, as long as the resolution is passed according
to statutory requirements and the elected official
so prohibited occupies a position that makes his
individual interests as a purchaser inconsistent
with his official duties. Such a resolution would
merely codify the already existing common law
prohibitions against such an elected official
bidding and purchasing at tax foreclosure sales.
Cited herein: K.S.A. 19-101; K.S.A. 1986 Supp.
19-101a; 19-212 Sixth; 60-1007; 79-2804.
Dear Mr. Markham:
As Labette County Counselor you request our opinion on
whether elected officials of the county can bid on property
sold at a tax foreclosure sale. Additionally, you ask whether
a county could pass a resolution preventing certain elected
officials from bidding at a tax sale.
Kansas statutes do not expressly prohibit elected county
officials from purchasing at a tax sale. However, Kansas case
law and general legal principles appear to discourage such a
practice.
In Norton v. Friend, 13 Kan. 395 (1874) the Kansas
Supreme court held a tax sale void when the county treasurer
bought the property for the county. The court stated "the
county had no authority to enter the list as a competitor
against private parties for the purchase of land sold for
taxes." Id. at 397. The rationale for this rule was to
secure competition in bidding and to protect the rights of the
owner. See also, Sponable v. Woodhouse, 48 Kan.
173 (1892); Spicer v. Rowland, 39 Kan. 740 (1888).
K.S.A. 79-2804 now permits a county to bid at a tax
foreclosure sale in the name of the county, within prescribed
limitations. This statute does not address the question of
elected county officials purchasing in their private capacity.
72 Am.Jur.2d, State and Local Taxation, §940 (1974) states
the general rule regarding who may purchase at a tax sale:
"In general, any person legally qualified
to contract may become the purchaser at a
tax sale unless he has some duty to
perform in reference to the sale
inconsistent with his character as
purchaser, or occupies a position in
reference to the property that will make
his individual interest as a purchaser
inconsistent with his duties. There are,
however, many persons who, by reasons of
their interest in the premises and their
relationship to others interested therein,
may not, for equitable reasons, become
purchasers. (Emphasis added.)
When holding a tax sale certain elected and county officials
act in a fiduciary capacity towards the general public. In
regard to fiduciaries bidding at tax sales, Am.Jur. states:
"[I]t seems well established that subject
to certain exceptions one who holds
property in a fiduciary capacity cannot
purchase that property for his own
account, irrespective of his good faith or
the fairness of the transaction, even at a
judicial sale of such property if the sale
is conducted and directed by the
fiduciary, or at a sale made at his
instance or at the instance of the
beneficiary, or because of the fiduciary's
default or neglect. The rationale of the
rule is to remove the temptation to abuse
power for selfish purposes and to prevent
an abuse of confidence." 47 Am.Jur.2d,
Judicial Sales §212, (1969).
In Shell Oil Co. v. Board of County Commissioners, 171
Kan. 159 (1951), the Kansas Supreme Court affirmed the
decision of the lower court, declaring a county commissioner,
as a private individual, an invalid purchaser at a tax
foreclosure sale:
"The law and ethics of a situation such as
this should not rest upon the principle of
actual fraud, but are founded on the
theory that fraud in such cases is best
prevented by removing all temptation. In
other words, the rule rests on prevention
of fraud and is based upon the moral
obligation of everyone, and particularly a
public official, to refrain from placing
himself in a position which ordinarily
creates or excites a conflict between
self-interest and integrity. We think it
is better that the danger and cause of the
evil should be prohibited in all cases
than that courts should be relied upon to
apply the remedy by inquiring into the
facts of a particular case to ascertain
whether there has been fraud in fact.
Fullness of price, absence of fraud, and
fairness of purchase, are not sufficient
to overcome this rule of policy. Entirely
aside from any element of actual fraud,
the only adequate remedy is to declare one
occupying the position of defendant an
ineligible purchaser at such a sale."
Id. at 165, 166, (emphasis added.)
In Shell the Kansas Supreme Court cites two other cases
where a county treasurer was similarly prohibited from bidding
on property at a tax foreclosure sale. Thus, while 60-2412
and K.S.A. 60-1007 prohibit a sheriff or his staff from
bidding at certain sales, Kansas statutes do not specifically
prohibit participation in tax sales by elected officials.
Kansas case law and general legal principles have long frowned
upon certain elected officials purchasing at a tax sale and
the proposed resolution would merely codify the common law
rule.
K.S.A. 19-212, Sixth states that the county commissioners of
each county:
"[S]hall have the power, at any meeting,
[t]o represent the county and have the
care of the county property, and the
management of the business and concerns of
the county, in all cases where no other
provision is made by law."
K.S.A. 1986 Supp. 19-101a grants counties the power of home
rule, subject to the statutory limitations contained therein.
Absent a uniform enactment of the legislature inconsistent
with prohibiting an elected county official from purchasing at
a tax sale, we see no reason why a county may not adopt a
resolution providing for such prohibition pursuant to its home
rule powers. Elected officials choose to run for office, and
in doing so, become something different than private
citizens. With the elected position goes certain powers and
restrictions inherent in the office.
To summarize, a board of county commissioners may pass a
resolution prohibiting certain elected officials from
purchasing at a tax sale when done pursuant to the statutory
requirements for passing such a resolution and when the
elected official occupies a position that makes his individual
interests as a purchaser inconsistent with his official duties.
Very truly yours,
ROBERT T. STEPHAN
ATTORNEY GENERAL OF KANSAS
Theresa Marcel Nuckolls
Assistant Attorney General
RTS:JLM:TMN:bas

Setzen Sie Ihre Recherche in ChatGPT oder Claude fort

Verbinden Sie Omnilex, um den Rechtskorpus über Ihren KI-Assistenten zu durchsuchen.