Kansas Attorney General Opinion 1987-156

1987-156Kanag

Gesamter Gesetzestext

ROBERT T. STEPHAN
ATTORNEY GENERAL October 26, 1987
ATTORNEY GENERAL OPINION NO. 87- 156
The Honorable Duane A. Goossen
State Representative, Seventieth District
Box 97
Goessel, Kansas 67053
Re: Schools -- Special Education; Exceptional Children
-- Gifted Education
Synopsis: Special education services for gifted students must
be provided at public expense. "Services" include
transportation to and from educational classes and
activities. Therefore, the parents or guardians of
a gifted student cannot be required to pay any of
the costs incurred in providing the special
education program specified in the gifted student's
individualized education program (IEP). Cited
herein: K.S.A. 72-962; 72-966; 72-967; K.S.A.
72-968, as amended by L. 1987, ch. 269, §1; K.A.R.
1986 Supp. 91-12-22; K.A.R. 91-12-23; 91-12-41;
K.A.R. 91-12-50; 20 U.S.C. §1401; §1412.
Dear Representative Goossen:
As State Representative for the Seventieth District, you ask
our opinion on two questions concerning the Marion County
Special Education Cooperative. Specifically, you ask whether
the manner in which educational programs are selected for
gifted students denies less affluent students an education and
whether the school district must pay all the costs of gifted
education programs.
Kansas law requires all school districts to provide special
education services for gifted students:
"The Board of education of every school
district shall provide special education
services for all exceptional children in
the school district . . . ." K.S.A.
72-966(a).
"Exceptional children" is defined to include gifted children.
K.S.A. 72-962(f), (g); K.A.R 1986 Supp. 91-12-22 (j). School
districts may enter into interlocal cooperative agreements
to provide special education services. K.S.A. 72-967(a)(4);
K.S.A. 72-968, as amended by L. 1987, ch. 269, §1; K.A.R
91-12-50. Special education services provided by a school
district must meet the standards and criteria set in the state
plan and are subject to approval by the State Board of
Education. K.S.A. 72-967 (b); K.A.R 91-12-23. In Attorney
General Opinion No. 81-99 we stated:
"If a local board of education refuses to
provide special education services to a
child who has been determined to be an
exceptional child . . ., the State Board
of Education may enforce a decision
rendered by it under the provisions of
K.S.A. 72-974 by suing the local school
board and requesting the court to issue an
order requiring the local board to comply
with the decision of the State Board."
K.A.R. 1986 Supp. 91-12-41 (a) provides that "[a]n
individualized education program (IEP) shall be developed
for each child in need of special education services." The
IEP must be written and reviewed annually at a meeting which
is to include a representative of the local education agency,
the child's teacher(s), one or both of the child's parents,
and others who may be necessary to complete the IEP. K.A.R.
1986 Supp. 91-12-41(b). Each IEP must include the
following:
"(1) A statement of the child's present
level of educational performance . . . ;
"(2) a statement of annual goals . . . ;
"(3) a statement of short-term objectives . . .;
"(4) objective criteria, evaluation
procedures, and data collection schedules
for determining, at least every 12 weeks,
whether the short-term objectives are
being achieved;
"(5) a statement of the specific special
education services and related services
needed by the child, even if not all of
these services currently are available in
the local education agency preparing the
IEP. Any unique instructional media not
ordinarily available to all students, but
needed by this particular child for
learning, shall be listed;
"(6) a description of the extent to which
the child will participate in regular
classroom instruction . . .;
"(7) the projected date for the initiation
of the prescribed services and anticipated
duration of the services; and
"(8) a listing of the names and positions
of the individuals responsible for
implementation of the IEP." K.A.R. 1986
Supp. 91-12-41(f).
See also K.A.R. 91-12-52 (provisions concerning
intellectually gifted children). Transportation must be
provided for special education students:
"(a) Each board, in order to comply with
the requirements of [the Act] shall have
the authority to:
"(6) Provide transportation for
exceptional children, whether such
children are residents or nonresidents of
such school district, to and from special
education services attended. In lieu of
paying for transportation, the board of
the school district in which an
exceptional child resides may pay all or
part of the cost of room and board for
such exceptional child at the place where
the special education services attended
are located." K.S.A. 72-967.
We are informed that the Marion County Special Education
Cooperative (Cooperative) provides programs for gifted
students which include field trips, cultural events, and
mentorships. As a result of these programs, costs are
incurred for tickets, registrations, project materials,
lodging, and transportation. Each child's IEP, which
describes his or her particular program, states that the
parents must bear these extra costs. Most transportation is
provided by the local education agency. However,
transportation for evening and weekend activities is often the
parents' responsibility. In addition, it is stated in the
IEPs that parents must bear the transportation costs of a
trip to Washington, D.C. We understand that during the
meeting at which the IEP is written, parents are informed as
to the costs involved. If the parents can not, or choose not
to be involved in any activity or project, other options are
available for the gifted child's program.
The first question is whether the Cooperative's procedure in
selecting a program for a gifted student is appropriate,
i.e. whether the IEP may include alternatives depending on
who can pay the costs. The interlocal agreement entered
into by five school districts establishing the Cooperative
provides that each school district is responsible for
transporting students of that district. Your second question
is whether the school district is responsible for
transportation costs if the IEP provides that the parent
must bear this cost.
The Kansas Special Education for Exceptional Children Act,
K.S.A. 72-961 et seq., was adopted pursuant to, and in
accordance with, the Education of the Handicapped Act (EHA),
20 U.S.C. §1400 et seq. This federal legislation provides
federal funding for state and local school systems to assist
them in educating handicapped children. The Act requires
recipients of its money to "[have] in effect a policy that
assures all handicapped children the right to a free
appropriate public education." 20 U.S.C. §1412. The EHA
applies only to handicapped children, gifted children are not
included. 20 U.S.C. §1401(1). Twenty states, including
Kansas, have adopted legislation mandating special education
for gifted students. The laws of twenty-four other states are
permissive in that funds are available for gifted programs if
such programs are established. Comment, Legal Rights of
Gifted Students: Special Education Law at the "Other End", 19
Conn. L. Rev. 143, 152-53 (1986).
Kansas has limited case law concerning its special education
laws. Other states which have statutes similar to Kansas
mandating gifted education also have not addressed the
questions presented to us in this opinion. However, the
language in Kansas' special education statutes is very similar
to the language in the EHA. "[T]he analysis under the
Kansas special education laws is virtually identical to that
under the [EHA] . . . ." Akers v. Bolton, 531 F. Supp.
300, 314 (D.Kan. 1981). Kansas law mandates special education
for gifted students in the same manner as for handicapped
students. It follows, then, that the requirements under the
EHA which must be met for special education for the
handicapped are helpful in determining the requirements
applicable to gifted education.
Under the EHA, "free appropriate public education" is
defined as follows:
"The term 'free appropriate public
education' means special education and
related services which (A) have been
provided at public expense,under
public supervision and direction, and
without charge, (B) meet the standards of
the State educational agency, (C) include
an appropriate preschool, elementary, or
secondary school education in the State
involved, and (D) are provided in
conformity with the individualized
education program . . . ." 20 U.S.C.
§1401(18). (Emphasis added).
"Special education" means"specially designed instruction, at
no cost to parents or guardians, to meet the unique needs of
a handicapped child . . . ." 20 U.S.C. §1401(16). (Emphasis
added). "Related services" are defined as "transportation,
and such developmental, corrective, and other supportive
services . . . as may be required to assist a handicapped
child to benefit from special education." 20 U.S.C.
§1401(17). (Emphasis added).
The seminal case interpreting the EHA is Board of Educ.,
Etc. v. Rowley, 458 U.S. 176, 102 S.Ct. 3034, 73 L.Ed.2d 690
(1982).. The United States Supreme Court examined
congressional intent in enacting the legislation:
"[I]n seeking to provide . . . access to
public education, congress did not impose
upon the States any greater substantive
educational standard than would be
necessary to make such access meaning-
ful. . . . Thus, the intent of the Act
was more to open the door of public
education to handicapped children on
appropriate terms than to guarantee any
particular level of education once
inside." Board of Educ., Etc., v.
Rowley, 102 S.Ct. at 3043.
The court reasoned that Congress did not intend to require
"the furnishing of every special service necessary to
maximize each handicapped child's potential . . . ." Id. at
3047. Therefore, the court concluded that "the 'basic floor
of opportunity' provided by the Act consists of access to
specialized instruction and related services which are
individually designed to provide educational benefit to the
handicapped child." Id. The Supreme Court held that the
requirements of the EHA are as follows:
"Insofar as a State is required to provide
a handicapped child with a 'free
appropriate public education,' we hold
that it satisfies this requirement by
providing personalized instruction with
sufficient support services to permit the
child to benefit educationally from that
instruction. Such instruction and
services must be provided at public
expense, must meet the State's
educational standards, must approximate
the grade levels used in the State's
regular education, and must comport with
the child's IEP." Id. at 3049.
(Emphasis added.)
Several courts since the Rowley decision have commented on
the cost factor involved in providing special education
services:
"Whatever the precise definition of 'free
appropriate public education' is, the term
certainly does not mean the best
education possible." Colin K. v.
Schmidt, 536 F. Supp. 1375, 1386,
aff'd. 715 F.2d 1 (1982). (Emphasis
in original).
"Cost is a proper factor to consider since
excessive spending on one handicapped
child deprives other handicapped
children." Roncker on Behalf of Roncker
v. Walter, 700 F.2d 1058, cert. denied
464 U.S. 864, 104 S.Ct. 196, 78 L. Ed.2d.
171 (1983).
"[Clost can be a legitimate
consideration when devising an appropriate
program for individual students.
Nevertheless, cost considerations are only
relevant when choosing between several
options, all of which offer an
'appropriate' education. When only one is
appropriate, then there is no choice."
Clevenger v. Oak Ridge School Board, 744
F.2d 514 (1984).
As part of "special education services," K.S.A. 72-967
requires school districts to provide transportation for
students in special education programs. Case law makes it
clear that transportation to classes and events listed in the
IEP is a service which must be provided at no cost to the
students and parents. Alamo Hgts. Ind. Sch. Dist. v. State
Bd. of Educ., 790 F.2d 1153 (5th Cir. 1983) (reasonable
to require school district to provide one mile out-of-district
transportation to accommodate working mother); Pinkerton v. -Moye,509F.Supp.107(W.D.Va.1981)(schooldistrict
required to reimburse parents for transporting child to
neighboring school for special education program not provided
by the home district); Woodland Hills School v. Com ., Dept.
of Educ., 516 A.2d 875 (Pa. Cmwlth. 1986) (school district
required to furnish free transportation to nonpublic
students participating in its gifted education program);
Pires By Pires v. Com ., Dept. of Educ., 467 A.2d 79 (Pa.
Cmwlth. 1983) (school district must reimburse parents for
child's transportation expense to a private school which
provided the child's special education).
Under Kansas law, the requirements school districts must meet
to provide special education services for gifted students are
the same as the requirements for special education for
handicapped students. Given the language of the Kansas
statutes and cases interpreting the federal law, we think it
is clear that special education services for gifted students
must be provided at public expense. "Services" include
transportation to and from the educational classes and
activities. School districts are not required to provide the
best possible education. Rather, the IEP for each gifted
student must be individually designed to provide educational
benefit to meet the needs of that student within means of the
school district. Therefore, the parents or guardians of a
gifted student cannot be required to pay any of the costs
incurred in providing the special education program specified
in the student's IEP.
Very truly yours,
ROBERT T. STEPHAN
Attorney General of Kansas
Rita L. Noll
Assistant Attorney General
RTS:JLM:RLN:ma

Setzen Sie Ihre Recherche in ChatGPT oder Claude fort

Verbinden Sie Omnilex, um den Rechtskorpus über Ihren KI-Assistenten zu durchsuchen.