Kansas Attorney General Opinion 1987-111

1987-111Kanag

Gesamter Gesetzestext

ROBERT T. STEPHAN
ATTORNEY GENERAL July 27, 1987
ATTORNEY GENERAL OPINION NO. 87- 111
W. Lee Fowler
Chase County Attorney
302 Broadway, P.O. Box 640
Cottonwood Falls, Kansas 66845
Re: Intoxicating Liquors and Beverages -- Cereal Malt
Beverages -- Sunday Carry Out Sales
Synopsis: K.S.A. 41-2704, as amended by L. 1987, ch. 182, §
100, and as further amended by L. 1987, ch. 183,
§ 4, authorizes Sunday sales of cereal malt
beverages for on premises consumption in licensed
establishments which meet the 30% food sale
conditions and the local ordinance requirements of
Section 4(b)(2), of L. 1987, ch. 183. Sunday
carry out sales of cereal malt beverages are not
authorized by the specific language contained in
Section 4(b)(2). Cited herein: K.S.A. 41-2704, as
amended by L. 1987, ch. 182, § 100, and by L.
1987, ch. 183, § 4; L. 1937, ch. 213, 214;
Kan. Const., Art. 15, § 10.
Dear Mr. Fowler:
As Chase County Attorney, you have requested our opinion as to
whether 1987 House Substitute for Substitute for Senate Bill
No. 141 and 1987 House Bill No. 2615 (hereinafter referred to
as L. 1987, ch. 182 and 183 respectively) will allow for
Sunday carry out sales of cereal malt beverages when not
Prohibited by city ordinance and when sold by a business which
holds a retailer's license allowing on premise consumption as
well as carry out sales.
Historically, legislation in the State of Kansas has either
restricted or totally disallowed the sale of cereal malt
beverages. This restriction or regulation of sales of cereal
malt beverages has its roots in the original language of
Article 15, § 10 of the Kansas Constitution adopted in 1880.
At that time all sales of beverages containing alcohol were
prohibited in the State of Kansas. In 1937, beverages which
contained 3.2% or less alcohol by weight were given the
classification of cereal malt beverages pursuant to L. 1937,
ch. 213, §§ 1 and 2. L. 1937, ch. 214 was also enacted at
that time, authorizing the licensed sale of cereal malt
beverages. However, L. 1937, ch. 214, § 4 provided that,
"no cereal malt beverages may be sold . . . on Sunday. . .
(Emphasis added). This general legislative ban on Sunday
sales of cereal malt beverages prevailed from 1937 until the
effective date of the two statutes in question.
L. 1987, ch. 183, section 4 provides in part:
"K.S.A. 41-2704, as amended by section 100
of 1987 House Substitute for Substitute
for Senate Bill No. 141, is hereby amended
to read as follows: 41-2704. (a) In
addition to and consistent with the
requirements of this act, the board of
county commissioners of any county or the
governing body of any city may prescribe
hours of closing, standards of conduct and
rules and regulations concerning the
moral, sanitary and health conditions of
places licensed pursuant to this act and
may establish zones within which no such
place may be located.
"(b) Except as provided by subsection
(g), no cereal malt beverages may be sold:
"(1) Between the hours of 12:00 midnight
and 6:00 a.m.;
"(2) on Sunday, except in a place of
business which is licensed to sell cereal
malt beverage for consumption on the
premises and, which derives not less
than 30% of its gross receipts from the
sale of food for consumption on the
licensed premises. . . ."
Section 4(b)(2) only authorizes Sunday sales of cereal malt
beverages, "in a place of business which is licensed to sell
cereal malt beverages for consumption on the premises, which
derives not less than 30% of its gross receipts from the sale
of food on the licensed premises. . . ." (Emphasis added).
This language does not specifically address the issue of
whether Sunday carry out sales of cereal malt beverages are
authorized.
Section 4(b)(2), of 1987 House Bill No. 2615, is an
exception to the general disallowance of Sunday sales of
cereal malt beverages, and it should therefore be construed
narrowly. A plain reading of Section 4(b)(2) would seem to
authorize only sales of cereal malt beverages for "on premises
consumption." All other Sunday sales of cereal malt beverages
not specifically authorized by the Section 4(b)(2) exception
are still prohibited. Strained interpretations of the
exception found in Section 4(b)(2) should not be applied in
order to circumvent or elude the plain meaning of the bill.
Further, we believe a narrow interpretation of the exception
found in Section 4(b)(2) is appropriate given the long history
of restrictions placed on alcoholic beverages in the State of
Kansas. Until there is statutory language which specifically
authorizes Sunday carry out sales of cereal malt beverages,
those types of cereal malt beverage sales should not be
allowed based on the existing language contained in Section
4(b)(2).
Interpreting Section 4(b) (2) as excluding carry out sales of
cereal malt beverages on Sunday is also supported by the
legislative history surrounding the introduction of L. 1987,
ch. 182. In a final report on Kansas alcoholic beverage
control laws presented to Governor Carlin in December of
1986, the Kansas Liquor Law Review Commission recommended that
sales and consumption of cereal malt beverages should be
permitted on Sundays in all types of on-premise
establishments. This recommendation speaks only of allowing
Sunday sales of cereal malt beverages in "on-premise"
establishments, meaning that the cereal malt beverage is to be
consumed on the premises of the establishment. It does not
specifically recommend "carry out" sales. See Attachment #1
of the January 21, 1987, Senate Federal and State Affairs
Committee minutes. Also, Senator Edward F. Reilly, Jr.,
Chairman of the Senate Federal and State Affairs Committee
which first introduced the bill, wrote in a memorandum dated
February 2, 1987, that although off-premise Sunday sales
were discussed by the committee, they were not included in the
bill. See Attachment #2 of the February 3, 1987, Senate
Federal and State Affairs Committee minutes. Finally, if the
legislature had intended to allow carry-out sales of cereal
malt beverages, there would have been no need to confine those
sales to establishments licensed for on-premises consumption
which meet the 30% food sales requirement.
In conclusion, L. 1987, ch. 183, amending L. 1987, ch.
182, contains a specific exception to the general legislative
disallowance of Sunday sales of cereal malt beverages. That
exception, found in Section 4, of L. 1987, ch. 183, does not
contain language specifically authorizing Sunday carry out
sales of cereal malt beverages. Also, legislative history and
indications of legislative intent support the premise that
Sunday carry out sales of cereal malt beverages are not
authorized by either L. 1987, ch. 182, or L. 1987, ch.
183. Thus, it is our opinion that L. 1987, ch. 183, § 4
does not allow Sunday carry out sales of cereal malt beverages.
Very truly yours,
ROBERT T. STEPHAN
ATTORNEY GENERAL OF KANSAS
JuleneL.Miller
Deputy Attorney General
RTS:JLM:bas

Setzen Sie Ihre Recherche in ChatGPT oder Claude fort

Verbinden Sie Omnilex, um den Rechtskorpus über Ihren KI-Assistenten zu durchsuchen.