Kansas Attorney General Opinion 1987-035

1987-035Kanag

Gesamter Gesetzestext

ROBERT T. STEPHAN
ATTORNEY GENERAL February 24, 1987
ATTORNEY GENERAL OPINION NO. 87- 35
The Honorable Susan Roenbaugh
State Representative
One Hundred Fourteenth District
State Capitol, Room 170-W
Topeka, Kansas 66612
Re: Constitution of the State of Kansas--Finance and
Taxation--Exemption of Property for Economic
Development Purposes
Corporations--Agricultural Corporations--Swine and
Poultry Confinement Facilities
Synopsis: The passage of 1987 House Bill No. 2076, a proposed
amendment to the corporate farming law, would not
serve to make swine and poultry confinement
facilities eligible for property tax exemptions
pursuant to Article 11, Section 13 of the Kansas
Constitution. Cited herein: K.S.A. 1986 Supp.
17-5904; K.S.A. 84-9-109; Kan. Const., Art. 11,
513; 1987 House Bill No. 2076.
Dear Representative Roenbaugh:
As Representative for the One Hundred Fourteenth District, you
have. requested our opinion concerning Article 11, Section 13
of the Kansas Constitution and its relation to 1987 House Bill
No. 2076. Specifically, you question whether swine and
poultry confinement facilities, if exempted from the
proscription on corporate farming, would be eligible for a tax
abatement pursuant to Article 11, Section 13 of the Kansas
Constitution.
Kansas' corporate farming law provides that "[n]o corporation,
trust, limited partnership or corporate partnership, other
than a family farm corporation, authorized farm corporation,
limited agricultural partnership, family trust, authorized
trust or testamentary trust shall, either directly or
indirectly, own, acquire or otherwise obtain or lease any
agricultural land in this state." K.S.A. 1986 Supp.
17-5904(a). 1987 House Bill No. 2076, if passed, would exempt
swine confinement facilities and poultry confinement
facilities from this general proscription. 1987 House Bill
No. 2076, §2(a)(8). "Swine confinement facility" and "poultry
confinement facility" are defined in Section 1 of the bill as
follows:
"(p) 'Swine confinement facility' means
the structures and related equipment used
for housing, breeding, farrowing or
feeding of swine in an enclosed
environment. The term includes within its
meaning only such agricultural land as is
necessary for proper disposal of liquid
and solid wastes and for isolation of the
facility to reasonably protect the
confined animals from exposure to disease.
"(q) 'Poultry confinement facility' means
the structures and related equipment used
for housing, breeding, laying of eggs or
feeding of poultry in a restricted
environment. The term includes within its
meaning only such agricultural land as is
necessary for proper disposal of liquid
and solid wastes and for isolation of the
facility to reasonably protect the
confined poultry from exposure to
disease. As used in this subsection,
'poultry' means chickens, turkeys, ducks,
geese or other fowl."
Thus, if passed, 1987 House Bill No. 2076 would allow certain
corporate hog and poultry operations to do business in Kansas.
Article 11, Section 13(a) of the Constitution of the State of
Kansas provides as follows:
"The board of county commissioners of any
county or the governing body of any city
may, by resolution or ordinance, as the
case requires, exempt from all ad valorem
taxation all or any portion of the
appraised valuation of: (1) All
buildings, together with the land upon
which such buildings are located, and all
tangible personal property associated
therewith used exclusively by a business
for the purpose of: (A) Manufacturing
articles of commerce; (B) conducting
research and development; or (C) storing
goods or commodities which are sold or
traded in interstate commerce, which
commences operations after the date on
which this amendment is approved by the
electors of this state; or (2) all
buildings, or added improvements to
buildings constructed after the date on
which this amendment is approved by the
electors of this state, together with the
land upon which such buildings or added
improvements are located, and all tangible
personal property purchased after such
date and associated therewith, used
exclusively for the purpose of: (A)
Manufacturing articles of commerce; (B)
conducting research and development; or
(C) storing goods or commodities which are
sold or traded in interstate commerce,
which is necessary to facilitate the
expansion of any such existing business,
if as a result of such expansion, new
employment is created."
The question to be determined is whether swine and poultry
confinement facilities manufacture articles of commerce,
conduct research and development, or store goods or
commodities which are sold or traded in interstate commerce.
It is clear that such operations do not conduct research and
development. It is equally clear, in our opinion, that the
corporate swine and poultry confinement facilities to be
authorized by 1987 House Bill No. 2076 do not manufacture
articles of commerce. In general, a constitutional provision
"is not to be narrowly or technically construed, but its
language 'should be held to mean what the words imply to the
common understanding of men,'" and "in ascertaining the
meaning of constitutional provisions courts should consider
what appears to have been the intendment and understanding of
the people at their adoption." State v. Highwood Service,
Inc., 205 Kan. 821, 825, 826 (1970), citing Higgins v.
Cardinal Manufacturing Co., 188 Kan. 11 (1961). Thus,
words used in constitutional provisions should be given their
ordinary meanings. However, constitutional and statutory
provisions exempting property from taxation are to be strictly
construed and all doubts resolved against the exemption.
Thus, the property to be exempted must clearly be of the type
contemplated by the exempting provision and the burden of
establishing exemption from taxation is on the one claiming
it. Topeka Presbyterian Manor v. Board of County
Commissioners, 195 Kan. 90, 93, 94 (1965).
Black's Law Dictionary 869 (5th ed. 1979) defines
"manufacture" in verb form as follows:
"From Latin words manus and factura,
literally, put together by hand. Now it
means the process of making products by
hand or machinery. United States v.
Anderson, D.C.Cal., 45 F.Supp. 943,
946. Meaning of word 'manufacture,' which
is defined as the making of goods or wares
by manual labor or by machinery,
especially on a large scale, has expanded
as workmanship and art have advanced, so
that now nearly all artificial products of
human industry, nearly all such materials
as have acquired changed conditions or new
and specific combinations, whether from
the direct action of the human hand, from
chemical processes devised and directed by
human skill, or by the employment of
machinery, are commonly designated as
'manufactured.'"
The noun "manufacture" is defined as:
"The process or operation of making goods
or any material produced by hand, by
machinery or by other agency; anything
made from raw materials by the hand, by
machinery, or by art. The production of
articles for use from raw or prepared
materials by giving such materials new
forms, qualities, properties or
combinations, whether by hand labor or
machine. Cain's Coffee Co. v. City of
Muskogee, 171 Okl. 635, 44 P.2d 50, 52.
"In patent law, any useful product made
directly by human labor, or by the aid of
machinery directed and controlled by human
power, and either from raw materials, or
from materials worked up into a new form.
Also the process by which such products
are made or fashioned."
In view of these definitions and the construction rules
espoused above, it is our opinion that neither the housing,
breeding, farrowing or feeding of swine, nor the housing,
breeding, laying of eggs or feeding of poultry would be
considered as "manufacturing" articles of commerce.
The question of whether swine and poultry containment
facilities store goods or commodities which are sold or traded
in commerce is more difficult to answer. It appears that this
language is intended to reach inventory held for imminent
sale. The definitions of goods and inventory in the Uniform
Commercial Code (UCC), K.S.A. 84-1-101 et seq., may
therefore be of assistance in determining whether swine and
poultry are considered as inventory while in the possession of
a containment facility. K.S.A. 84-9-109 provides that:
"Goods are
"(3) 'farm products' if they are crops or
livestock or supplies used or produced in
,farming operations or if they are products
of crops or livestock in their
unmanufactured states (such as ginned
cotton, wool-clip, maple syrup, milk and
eggs), and if they are in the possession
of a debtor engaged in raising, fattening,
grazing or other farming operations. If
goods are farm products they are neither
equipment nor inventory;
"(4) 'inventory' if they are held by a
person who holds them for sale or lease or
to be furnished under contracts of service
or if he has so furnished them, or if they
are raw materials, work in process or
materials used or consumed in a business.
Inventory of a person is not to be
classified as his equipment."
The Official UCC Comment provides further insight into these
definitions:
"2. The classes of goods are mutually
exclusive; . . . the principal use to
which the property is put should be
considered as determinative.
"3. The principal test to determine
whether goods are inventory is that they
are held for immediate or ultimate sale.
Implicit in the definition is the
criterion that the prospective sale is in
the ordinary course of business.
"4. Goods are 'farm products' only if
they are in the possession of a debtor
engaged in farming operations. Animals in
a herd of livestock are covered whether
they are acquired by purchase or result
from natural increase. Products of crops
or livestock remain farm products so long
as they are in the possession of a debtor
engaged in farming operations and have not
been subjected to a manufacturing
process. . . . 1 [F]arming operations'
includes raising livestock as well as
crops; similarly, since eggs are products
of livestock, livestock includes fowl.
"When crops or livestock or their products
come into the possession of a person not
engaged in farming operations they cease
to be 'farm products.' If they come into
the possession of a marketing agency for
sale or distribution or of a manufacturer
or processor as raw materials, they become
inventory." K.S.A. 84-9-109, Official
UCC Comment.
The courts have held that cattle in the possession of a cattle
feeder are "farm products" rather than "inventory," Security
Natl. Bank v. Belleville Livestock, 619 F.2d 840, 850
(10th Cir. 1979), but that cattle placed in a feedlot
and no longer in the possession of the individual engaged in
farming operations constitute "inventory," Garden City
Production Credit Association v. International Cattle
Systems, 32 U.C.C.Rep. 1207 (D.Kan. 1981).
Swine and poultry, while in confinement facilities, are more
like farm products than inventory. The primary business of
the confinement facility is breeding and reproduction rather
than holding for slaughter and sale. Again, insofar as tax
exemptions are to be strictly construed, we cannot say that
swine and poultry confinement facilities are eligible for the
exemption provided in Kan. Const., Art. 11, §13(1)(C).
In conclusion, the passage of 1987 House bill No. 2076, a
proposed amendment to the corporate farming law, would not
serve to make swine and poultry confinement facilities
eligible for property tax exemptions pursuant to Article 11,
Section 13 of the Kansas Constitution.
Very truly yours,
ROBERT T. STEPHAN
Attorney General of Kansas
JuleneL.Miller
Deputy Attorney General
RTS:JLM:jm

Setzen Sie Ihre Recherche in ChatGPT oder Claude fort

Verbinden Sie Omnilex, um den Rechtskorpus über Ihren KI-Assistenten zu durchsuchen.