Kansas Attorney General Opinion 1987-016

1987-016Kanag

Gesamter Gesetzestext

ROBERT T. STEPHAN
ATTORNEY GENERAL January 29, 1987
ATTORNEY GENERAL OPINION NO. 87- 16
The Honorable Edward F. Reilly, Jr.
Senator, Third District
Capitol Building, 255-E
Topeka, Kansas 66612
Re: Constitution of the State of Kansas --
Miscellaneous -- Multi-State Lotteries
Synopsis: The constitutional provisions allowing for a
state owned and operated lottery would allow the
state to enter into an agreement to provide a
multi-state lottery. Cited herein: Kan.
Const., Art. 2, § 30; Art. 15, § 3c; L. 1986,
ch. 414.
Dear Senator Reilly:
As Chairperson of the Senate Federal and State Affairs
Committee you ask our opinion about multi-state
lotteries. Specifically, your question centers on the
enforceability of agreements with other states to form a
multi-state lottery.
Before we answer your specific question, a more fundamental
question must first be answered. Does the constitution
allow for multi-state lotteries? Article 15, Section 3c
of the Kansas Constitution provides in pertinent part, "the
legislature may provide for a state-owned and operated
lottery." In construing constitutional provisions the
Supreme Court of Kansas has stated in State, ex rel. v.
Highwood Services, Inc., 205 Kan. 821, 825 (1970):
"[A] constitution is not to be narrowly or technically
construed but its language should be held to mean what
the words imply to the common understanding of men;
that in ascertaining the meaning of constitutional
provisions courts should consider what appears to have
been the intendment and understanding of the people at
their adoption." (Citations omitted.)
The legislature did not specifically preclude multi-state
lotteries with the language used in 1986 Senate Concurrent
Resolution 1609, L. 1986, ch. 414. The concept of
multi-state lotteries was in fact mentioned in the
minutes of the Federal and State Affairs Committee.
Minutes of the House Federal and State Affairs Committee,
January 21, 1986, testimony of Kansas Alliance for the
Lottery, Patrick J. Hurley, Attachment C.
The intent and understanding of both the legislature and
the people seems to have been to have a government
controlled lottery as a revenue raising measure. Minutes
of the House Federal and State Affairs Committee, January
21, 1986, testimony of Secretary of Revenue Harley
Duncan, Attachment A. We must now determine whether a
multi-state lottery meets this intent. A multi-state
lottery would still be state-owned. The governments of
the several states would own and operate this lottery in
much the same fashion as a single state operates a
lottery. A multi-state lottery would also meet the
revenue raising aspect. A multi-state lottery would
raise money similar to a lottery in a single state. Some
would argue that sparsely populated states could raise more
in a multi-state lottery than one run by a single state.
It appears that the intent of the voters in approving the
lottery was to allow closely regulated gambling and to
raise money for the state. A multi-state lottery would
not be repugnant to the intent of the constitutional
provisions.
Having determined that multi-state lotteries are
permissible, we can now turn to your primary question
dealing with enforceability of an interstate agreement.
Article 2, Section 30 of the Kansas Constitution provides:
"The legislature may confer legislative powers upon
interstate bodies, comprised of officers of this state
or its political subdivisions acting in conjunction
with officers of other jurisdictions, relating to the
functions thereof. Any such delegation, and any
agreement made thereunder shall be subject to
limitation, change or termination by the legislature,
unless contained in a compact approved by the
congress." (Emphasis supplied.)
Thus, the legislature may provide for powers to negotiate
such agreements as multi-state lotteries, subject to the
constitutional limitations stated above. The general rule
dealing with compacts between states was stated in 81A
C.J.S. States §32(b) (1977). "Generally, contracts
between states are made by the acts of their respective
legislatures." This, coupled with the language cited
above, leads us to conclude that the legislature can
delegate to an agency the powers to negotiate a contract
between this state and another, but the legislature itself
must approve such a contract. This approval could be in
the form of enacting the agreement as law, such as is done
with other compacts to which this state is a party.
In conclusion, a multi-state lottery would not be
contrary to constitutional provisions. The legislature may
delegate power to enter into interstate agreements subject
to the approval of the legislature.
Very truly yours,
Robert T. Stephan
Attorney General
Brenda L. Braden
Deputy Attorney General
RTS:BLB:may

Setzen Sie Ihre Recherche in ChatGPT oder Claude fort

Verbinden Sie Omnilex, um den Rechtskorpus über Ihren KI-Assistenten zu durchsuchen.