Kansas Attorney General Opinion 1986-104

1986-104Kanag

Gesamter Gesetzestext

ROBERT T. STEPHAN
ATTORNEY GENERAL July 18, 1986
ATTORNEY GENERAL OPINION NO. 86- 104
Sally Davis Pokorny
Montgomery County Attorney
Montgomery County Courthouse
Independence, Kansas 67301
Re: Taxation--Miscellanous Provisions--Creation of
Indebtedness in Excess of Budget
Synopsis: The Kansas budget law provides in part that any
indebtedness incurred by a governing body or any
other officer or officers of such taxing
subdivision or municipality in excess of the amount
budgeted shall be void as against such taxing
subdivision or municipality. In our opinion the
term void in this context means null or of no
effect. Prosecutorial discretion may be used in
determining whether such a penalty should be sought
in view of the purposes to be accomplished by the
budget law. Cited herein: K.S.A. 10-1113; K.S.A.
1985 Supp. 77-201; K.S.A. 79-2935.
*
Dear Ms. Pokorny:
As the Montgomery County Attorney, you have requested our
opinion regarding the meaning of the word "void," as it is
used in the budget law in K.S.A. 79-2935. Your request is
made on behalf of a citizen who has raised concerns over
alleged violations of the Kansas Budget Law by Independence
Community College. This matter has been brought to the
attention of the Municipal Accounting Division of the
Department of Administration and the State Department of
Education. It was the opinion of the former agency that the
problems for the 1984 fiscal year resulted from severe
underestimations of certain funds in the budget process. Due
to the poor estimates the college apparently found it
necessary to transfer funds from its general fund to make up
for the deficiencies in other funds. The Municipal Accounting
division was of the opinion that there was no misuse of public
money involved; moreover, the college has pursued corrective
measures to avoid similar difficulties in the future.
Turning now to your question regarding the interpretation of
the penalty provisions of K.S.A. 79-2935 we note that the
rules of statutory construction mandate that "[w]ords and
phrases shall be construed according to the context . . . of
the language. . . ." K.S.A. 1985 Supp. 77-201. It is,
therefore, simply untenable for us to provide you with a
definition of "void" without first examining the statute
itself.
K.S.A. 79-2935 provides, in part:
"It shall be unlawful for the governing body of any
taxing subdivision or municipality in any budget
year to create an indebtedness in any manner or in
any fund after the total indebtedness created
against such fund shall equal the total amount of
the adopted budget of expenditures for such fund
for that budget year. Any indebtedness incurred
by the governing body or any officer or officers of
such taxing subdivision or municipality in excess
of said amount shall be void as against such taxing
subdivision or municipality:" (Emphasis added.)
This law was enacted during the same legislative session as
the cash-basis law and, therefore, the two laws must be
construed together. Shouse v. Cherokee County Comm'rs,
151 Kan. 458, 462, (1940). The cash-basis law provides,
in part, that, unless otherwise provided, it is unlawful for
any member of a governing body of a municipality to knowingly
vote for any motion creating an indebtedness in excess of the
amount of funds actually on hand in the treasury, or to
knowingly vote to pay such indebtedness. K.S.A. 10-1113.
At the time of these enactments, many taxing subdivisions had
outstanding obligations, which they had incurred during
previous years to such a large and varied extent that the
governing bodies of these subdivisions no longer were aware of
their true financial condition. Gulick, Revised Budget Law
of 1941, 14 J.B.K. 100 (1945). To meet this indebtedness,
the governing bodies would levy additional taxes on the
people. See Shouse, 151 Kan. 458; Gridley High
School Dist. v. Woodson County Comm'rs, 155 Kan. 407,
(1942). The cash-basis and budget laws were designed to
lift this burden from the taxpayers by providing a systematic,
intelligent, and economical administration of the affairs of
municipalities so as to avoid waste and extravagance, and yet
to permit such units of government to function efficiently.
State, ex rel. v. Republic County Commissioner, 148 Kan.
376, 383, (1938). In fact, in 1939, the Legislative Committee
on Assessment and Taxation liberalized the then-existing
budget law, recognizing that such a law, if applied too
strictly, could severely inhibit the efficient management of
government. Gulick at 101. It would thus seem to be
contrary to the legislature's intent to demand a reading of
the budget law which would only serve to oppressively burden
the taxpayers and their governing bodies.
Assuming for the sake of discussion that Independence
Community College did violate the budget law, K.S.A. 79-2935
provides that any indebtedness incurred in excess of the
budgeted amount shall be void as against the municipality or
taxing subdivision. We are of the opinion that, in this
context, the term "void" should be given its ordinary meaning,
and be read to mean "to nullify or to cause to be of no
effect." See Shouse, 151 Kan. at 466; Gridley High
School Dist, 155 Kan. at 407. However, it is our opinion
that the imposition of this penalty in this case would
seriously contravene the intent of the budget law and that the
prosecution of Independence Community College would not serve
the best interests of the community as a whole. See State,
ex rel. Miller v. Richardson, 229 Kan. 234 (1981) (giving a
prosecuting attorney the discretion to refrain from
prosecuting whenever he believes that a prosecution would not
serve the best interests of the state).
According to the Municipal Accounting Division of the
Department of Administration, the governing body of
Independence Community College was not guilty of wasteful or
extravagant spending; they simply erred in estimating their
budget. While such errors in budget estimations should not be
ignored, we are satisfied that Independence Community College
is taking positive measures to ensure that such
miscalculations do not continue to occur. Presently, the
governing body of Independence Community College is working
with the State of Kansas Department of Administration,
Division of Accounts and Reports, to improve their management
and internal controls systems. In our opinion the budget and
cash basis laws have served the purpose for which they were
enacted. 'The Community College is working to avoid similar
problems in the future and it does not appear that any public
funds were misused or appropriated to a non-public purpose.
Clearly, where Independence Community College had sufficient
money in its treasury to compensate for the budget errors and
did not need to levy an additional tax to meet its
indebtedness, the voiding of such obligations would be unfair
and absurd. It is well-settled that a statute should never
be given construction that leads to uncertainty, injustice or
confusion, or that leads to an absurd result. State v.
Roudybush, 235 Kan. 834, (1984).
In conclusion, The Kansas budget law provides in part that any
indebtedness incurred by a governing body or any other officer
or officers of such taxing subdivision or municipality in
excess of the amount budgeted shall be void as against such
taxing subdivision or municipality. In our opinion the term
void in this context means null or of no effect.
Prosecutorial discretion may be used in determining whether
such a penalty should be sought in view of the purposes to be
accomplished by the budget law.
Very truly yours,
ROBERT T. STEPHAN
Attorney General of Kansas
Julene L. Miller
Deputy Attorney General
RTS:JLM:jm

Setzen Sie Ihre Recherche in ChatGPT oder Claude fort

Verbinden Sie Omnilex, um den Rechtskorpus über Ihren KI-Assistenten zu durchsuchen.