Kansas Attorney General Opinion 1986-077

1986-077Kanag

Gesamter Gesetzestext

ROBERT T. STEPHAN
ATTORNEY GENERAL
May 27, 1986
ATTORNEY GENERAL OPINION NO. 86- 77
Allen T. Kimmell, DVM
Livestock Commissioner
Animal Health Department
217 East 4th, 4th Floor
Topeka, Kansas 66603-3501
Re: Livestock and Domestic Animals -- Public Livestock
Markets -- Contractual Arrangements Between
Veterinarian Inspector and Public Livestock Market
Operator
Synopsis: The potential of compromise of veterinarian
inspectors by livestock market operators is
precluded by proper application of K.S.A. 47-1008.
K.S.A. 47-1008 mandates that veterinarians shall
inspect all livestock of market operators prior to
sale, and that the employment contract between the
veterinarian and the operators must be approved by
the Livestock Commissioner. To avoid a potential
compromise of the veterinarian-employee by the
operator-employer, the Commissioner may approve
contracts which allow for veterinarian dismissal
only for cause and with the Commissioner's
approval. Cited herein: K.S.A. 47-1008; L. 1973,
ch. 2, §22.
*
Dear Dr. Kimmell:
As Livestock Commissioner of the Animal Health Department for
the State of Kansas, you request our opinion on a question
concerning K.S.A. 47-1008. Specifically, you inquire as to
possible compromise of veterinarian inspectors by livestock
market operators resulting from the contractual schematics of
K.S.A. 47-1008.
K.S.A. 47-1008 states in part:
"All livestock consigned and delivered on
the premises of any licensed public
livestock market, before being offered for
sale, shall be inspected by an authorized
veterinarian who shall examine or test
each animal consigned to such market, for
the purpose of determining its condition
of health and freedom from infectious or
contagious animal diseases. Such
veterinary services shall be contracted
for by market operators, under contracts
approved by the livestock commissioner,
and such 'services shall be performed under
the direction of the commissioner. . . . A
copy of any agreement or contract shall be
on file with the commissioner."
Considered in isolation, the foregoing portion of K.S.A.
47-1008 is in itself evidence of legislative intent. It is a
fundamental rule of statutory construction that where no
ambiguity exists, it is presumed conclusively that the clear
and explicit terms of the statute expressing legislative
intent and the plain terms of the statute are to be applied
and given effect. Johnson v. General Motors Corp., 199 Kan.
720 (1967) and State v. Bagemehl, 213 Kan. 210 (1973). No
exceptions or meanings may be added not suggested by the
statute's language. Southwestern Bell Telephone Company v.
Employment Security Board of Review, 210 Kan. 403 (1972).
However, to ascertain legislative intent, courts are required
to construe all parts of legislation in pari materia
Brown v. Keill, 224 Kan. 195 (1978). Thus, the
legislative history of a statute often reveals legislative
intent, as demonstrated by L. 1973, ch. 2, §22:
"K.S.A. 1972 Supp. 47-1008 is hereby
amended to read as follows: 47-1008. All
livestock consigned and delivered on the
premises of any licensed public livestock
market, before being offered for sale,
shall be inspected by an authorized
veterinarian who shall examine or test
each animal consigned to such market, for
the purpose of determining its condition
of health and freedom from infectious or
contagious animal diseases. Such
veterinarian shall be employed by or under
the direction o€ the commissioner and may
be empIoyed at one r more sales-
Such veterinary services shall be
contracted for by market operators, under
contracts approved by the livestock
commissioner, and such services shall be
performed under the direction of the
commissioner. Such veterinarian shall be
authorized to make all required
examinations and tests, and to issue
certificates of inspection at the public
livestock market where he is employed.
Sues veterinarian shall be in the
enelassifiedserviceifandwhenempIoyed
by the state, and shall not be subject to
the Kansas civiI service act, when
employed by r ender the direction et the
commissioner, pay for his services
from funds received by the public
Iivestock market operator toe seep
purposes and from funds supplied by sueh
operator under the direction o€ the
commissioner, and when the statutory
inspection fees for seek sale are not
sufficient to provide the amount required
for the minimum per diem service charge of
said veterinarian.
"Such operator shall not discharge seep
veterinary inspector during the Iicense
year, except far cause, and with the
approval o€ the commissioned, and except
when sueh operator and the employed
veterinary inspector mutually agree or
seep inspector resigns serves."
Three accomplishments of the 1973 amendment were deletion,
creation and intent. The legislature deleted the employment
of the veterinarian by the Commissioner and placed the power
to contract for veterinary services with the market
operators. The legislature also deleted the restriction upon
the market operators to discharge veterinarians only for cause
and with commission approval. Then, in the same bill, the
legislature gave the Commissioner power to approve such
contracts, and to direct the veterinarian services.
The intent behind the amendments appears primarily to be to
remove the veterinarian from State employ, and to place the
veterinarian employ with another party. In this case, the
other party happens to be the market operators.
In other words, the deletions and additions appear to
contradict each other unless read in toto with the change
in employer. The intent was not to allow operators to control
the veterinarian who is to inspect and approve the operators'
livestock. This would contradict the essence of having a
veterinarian's approval in the first place. The intent of the
legislature was to create a self-supporting market, not a
self-directing market. This conclusion is buttressed by the
fact that the Commissioner retained power to approve employment
contracts entered into by a market operator and a veterinarian.
Any misuse of contractual rights by the operators against the
veterinarians may be remedied by the Commissioner. The
Commissioner may approve contracts between operators and
veterinarians only when the contracts have a clause stating
the veterinarian may be discharged only for cause and with the
Commissioner's approval.
Reading the statutory changes in this way preserves the
integrity of the inspector-inspectee relationship, while
explaining the removal of the veterinarian from the state
payroll and the power of the Commissioner to approve
contracts entered into pursuant to K.S.A. 47-1008.
In conclusion, proper application of K.S.A. 47-1008 as drafted
precludes any potential of compromise by operators in excess
of legislative intent.
Very truly yours,
ROBERT T. STEPHAN
ATTORNEY GENERAL OF KANSAS
Thomas Lietz
Assistant Attorney General
RTS:JLM:TL:crw

Setzen Sie Ihre Recherche in ChatGPT oder Claude fort

Verbinden Sie Omnilex, um den Rechtskorpus über Ihren KI-Assistenten zu durchsuchen.