Kansas Attorney General Opinion 1986-041

1986-041Kanag

Gesamter Gesetzestext

ROBERT T. STEPHAN
ATTORN EY GEN ERAL
March 17, 1986
ATTORNEY GENERAL OPINION NO. 86- 41
Bill Seaman
Chairman of the Board
Osage County Rural Water District No. 4
Route 1
Waverly, Kansas 66871
Re: State Departments; Public Officers and Employees --
Conflict of Interests -- Public Officers and
Employees Prohibited From Making Certain Contracts;
Inapplicable Where Governmental Unit is Employer
Synopsis: A director of a rural water district may be
employed by the district in a position which does
not involve an exercise of the sovereign power of
the district. Neither K.S.A. 75-4304, relating to
conflicts of interests, nor the common law doctrine
of incompatibility of offices would preclude such
employment. Cited herein K.S.A. 75-4303a; 75-4304.
Dear Mr. Seaman:
As Chairman of the Board of Osage County Rural Water
District No. 4, you request our opinion concerning the
eligibility and qualifications of the board of directors.
Specifically, you inquire whether an officer and director of
the water district may serve as a district employee without
creating a conflict of interest. The specific jobs involved
include bookkeeper and operator of a pumping station.
Generally, "a public officer owes an undivided duty to the
public whom he serves and is not permitted to place himself in
a position that will subject him to conflicting duties or
cause him to act other than for the best interests of the
public. If he acquires any interest adverse to those of the
public, without a full disclosure it is a betrayal of his
trust and a breach of confidence." Anderson v. City of
Parsons, 209 Kan. 337, 341 (1972); United States v. Carter,
217 U.S. 286 (1908). An attempt to exercise public powers
improperly is null and void. 63A Am.Jur.2d Public Officers
and Employees, 5319 (1985).
Kansas has codified these general rules on conflicts of
interests. See K.S.A. 75-4301 et seq. Specifically,
K.S.A. 75-4304 states:
"No public officer or employee shall in
his or her capacity as such officer or
employee, make or participate in the
making of a contract with any person or
business by which he or she is employed or
in whose business he or she has a
substantial interest, and no such person
or business shall enter into any contract
where any public officer or employee,
acting in such capacity, is a signatory to
or a participant in the making of such
contract and is employed by or has a
substantial interest in such person or
business. A public officer or employee
does not make or participate in the making
of a contract if he or she abstains from
any action in regard to the contract."
(Emphasis added.)
A public officer or employee is any person holding public
office in the state of Kansas or an employee of the state or
any municipal or quasi-municipal corporation. A rural water
district board member is a public officer, and any person
working for the district would be deemed to be an employee.
Whether such officers or employees fall under the conflicts of
interests statutes depends upon whether the rural water
district is a 'person or business" which employes the director
or is a "business" in which he or she has a "substantial
interest."
This question has been presented on several different
occasions to the Kansas Public Disclosure Commission and its
predecessor, the Kansas Governmental Ethics Commission. By
statute, the commission is empowered to issue advisory
opinions on the application of the conflict of interests law.
K.S.A. 75-4303a. In at least four prior opinions, the
commission has found that governmental entities are not
persons or businesses as these terms are used in K.S.A. 75-
4304. As a result, a person is not precluded by this statute
from being employed by a unit of government, while at the same
time serving on the governing commission, council or board.
Opinion Nos. 75-64, 79-12, 80-10, 84-7.
Since the commission has concluded that no statutory conflict
of interest is presented by an employee serving as a member of
a governing board, this opinion may be focused on possible
common law principles which may preclude such action. To our
knowledge, the applicable common law principle is the doctrine
of incompatibility of offices. In applying the doctrine,
courts have traditionally held that a person is barred from
holding two incompatible public offices. The general rule
has been stated thusly:
"The prohibition against one person
holding more than one office at the same
time has reference to offices, as
distinguished from positions in the
public service that do not rise to the
dignity of office. It does not extend to
a position which is a mere agency or
employment." (Emphasis added.) 63
Am.Jur.2d Public Officers and Employees
§64, pp. 669, 670.
Although some courts have now enlarged this doctrine to
include both public offices and public employment (see 70
A.L.R. 3d 1188), the majority of states follow the traditional
rule. (See 63 Am.Jur.2d Public Officers and Employees §64,
pp. 669, 670.) Unfortunately, the Kansas Supreme Court has
not had occasion to address this issue. For that reason, we
will not speculate whether our court would deviate from the
traditional common law rule and expand it so as to include
positions of public employment, as well as public offices.
Thus, the determination of what is a "public office" and who
is a "public officer," are relevant to your inquiry. These
questions were directly in issue in Sowers v. Wells 150 Kan.
630 (1934). There the court said:
"While the authorities are not in complete
harmony in defining the term 'public
office,' or 'public officer,' it
universally has been held that the right
to exercise some definite portion of
sovereign power constitutes an
indispensable attribute of 'public
office.' (Cites omitted.)" (Emphasis
added.) Id. at 633.
Under this definition, there can be no question but that a
member of the board of directors or an officer of the district
is a public officer. However, as important to the workings of
the district as a bookkeeper or a pump station operator may
be, such positions cannot be said to exercise some definite
portion of sovereign power. In this context, an office
exercising "sovereign power" refers to a position which has a
definite term of office, either through election or
appointment, which is created by statute or otherwise, and
which exercises authority to make decisions or otherwise
determine how public policy is to be shaped. Thus, one who is
employed in such positions does not hold public office.
Consequently, the common law doctrine of incompatibility of
offices does not apply, as only one public office is involved.
In conclusion, a director of a rural water district may be
employed by the district in a position which does not involve
an exercise of the sovereign power of the district. Neither
K.S.A. 75-4304, relating to conflicts of interests, nor the
common law doctrine of incompatibility of offices would
preclude such employment.
Very truly yours,
ROBERT T. STEPHAN
ATTORNEY GENERAL OF KANSAS
JeffreyS.	Southard
Deputy Attorney General
RTS:JSS:crw

Setzen Sie Ihre Recherche in ChatGPT oder Claude fort

Verbinden Sie Omnilex, um den Rechtskorpus über Ihren KI-Assistenten zu durchsuchen.