Kansas Attorney General Opinion 1985-179

1985-179Kanag

Gesamter Gesetzestext

December 19, 1985
ATTORNEY GENERAL OPINION NO. 85- 179
William R. Kauffman
General Counsel
Kansas Board of Regents
400 SW 8th, Suite 609
Topeka, Kansas 66603
Re: Taxation -- Kansas Retailers Sales Tax -- Exempt
Sales to Educational Institutions
Synopsis: Regents' institutions are governed by subsections
(c) and (d), but not subsection (b), of K.S.A.
79-3606. The sales tax exemption provided in
K.S.A. 79-3606(c) does not apply to materials used
in extraordinary "repair" of housing facilities at
educational institutions, but does include minor
items involved in the routine maintenance of such
facilities. Cited herein: K.S.A. 79-3606, as
amended by L. 1985, Ch. 331, Sec. 1; L. 1967, Ch.
500, Sec. 1; L. 1970, Ch. 389, Sec. 4; L. 1971, Ch.
321, Sec. 3.
*
Dear Mr. Kauffman:
As General Counsel to the Kansas Board of Regents, you request
our opinion concerning certain provisions of K.S.A. 79-3606,
as amended by L. 1985, Ch. 331, Sec. 1. Specifically, you
inquire which subsection of that statute applies to
institutions governed by the regents, and whether under the
applicable subsection(s) a sales tax exemption is provided for
materials used in maintaining or making minor repairs to
housing facilities operated by such institutions.
K.S.A. 79-3606, as amended, provides in relevant part that the
following shall be exempt from the tax imposed by the Kansas
Retailers' Sales Tax Act:
"(b) all sales of tangible personal
property or service, including the renting
and leasing of tangible personal property,
purchased directly by the state of Kansas,
a political subdivision thereof, other
than a school or educational institution,
or purchased by a public or private
nonprofit hospital or nonprofit blood bank
and used exclusively for state, political
subdivision, hospital or nonprofit blood
bank purposes, . . . .
"(c) all sales of tangible personal
property or services, including the
renting and leasing of tangible personal
property, purchased directly by a public
or private elementary or secondary school
or public or private nonprofit
educational institution and used primarily
by such school or institution for
nonsectarian programs and activities
provided or sponsored by such school or
institution or in the erection, repair or
enlargement of buildings to be used for
such purposes. The exemption herein
provided shall not apply to erection,
construction, repair, enlargement or
equipment of buildings used primarily for
human habitation;
"(d) all sales of tangible personal
property or services purchased by a
contractor for the purpose of
constructing, equipping, reconstructing,
maintaining, repairing, enlarging,
furnishing or remodeling facilities for
any public or private nonprofit
hospital, public or private elementary or
secondary school or a public or private
nonprofit educational institution, which
would be exempt from taxation under the
provisions of this act if purchased
directly by such hospital, school or
education institution; " (Emphasis
added.)
Although the regents' institutions are recognized as
independent state agencies, we have no hesitancy in concluding
that subsection (b) is inapplicable due to the express
language excluding "educational institutions." While this
term is not defined in the Kansas Retailers' Sales Tax Act,
that term clearly includes regents' institutions.
Accordingly, it is the expressed legislative intent that
subsection (b) does not apply to sales of tangible personal
property or service purchased directly by an educational
institution. However, such sales are specifically addressed
in subsection (c).
Therefore, regents' institutions are governed by subsection
(c) if the materials are purchased directly by the educational
institution, or by subsection (d) if the materials are
purchased by a contractor for use at an educational
institution. The former subsection allows a tax exemption for
all sales of tangible personal property or services purchased
directly by an educational institution and used primarily by
such institution in the repair of buildings used for
nonsectarian programs and activities provided or sponsored by
such institution. However, subsection (c) is made expressly
inapplicable to the "repair" of buildings used primarily for
human habitation.
Subsection (d) allows a similar exemption for all sales of
tangible personal property or services purchased by a
contractor for the purpose of "maintaining" or "repairing"
facilities for any educational institution, which would be
exempt from taxation if purchased directly by that educational
institution. However, a difficulty arises because the
subsection which sets forth those sales which are exempt from
taxation if purchased directly by an educational institution
[subsection (c)] makes no reference to "maintenance," but
instead denies an exemption for "repairs" to housing
facilities.
In our opinion, the issue is whether the legislature intended
that the term "repairs" in subsection (c) would encompass or
be synonymous with routine maintenance. If so, sales for the
purpose of maintaining a housing facility at an educational
institution would be taxable under the Kansas Retailers' Sales
Tax Act. The legislative history is of some assistance in
resolving this question.
Prior to 1970, K.S.A. 79-3606 expressly denied a tax exemption
for materials purchased by an educational institution and used
in the "construction, reconstruction, repair, maintenance
or remodeling "of buildings used primarily for human
habitation." L. 1967, Ch. 500, .51(b)(4). (Emphasis added.)
The legislative intent to distinguish between the terms
"repair" and "maintenance" was clear, as was the intent that
the materials used in either action be denied a tax exemption.
In 1970, the legislature amended the statute to state simply
that the exemption provided in subsection (c) for erection,
repair or enlargement of buildings "shall not apply to
buildings used primarily for human habitation." L. 1970, Ch.
389, §4. Under the 1970 statute, the legislative intent was
clear that no sales tax exemption be granted to an educational
institution for materials used in maintenance or repair or
any other action to a structure used primarily for human
habitation.
The statute was amended the following year to include the
language contained in the current version of the statute.
That language, added in 1971, states "That the exemption
[provided in subsection (c)] shall not apply to erection,
construction, repair, enlargement, or equipment of buildings
used primarily for human habitation." L. 1971, Ch. 321, Sec.
3(c). This narrow language demonstrates the legislative
intent that the denial of a tax exemption should apply only to
sales for certain actions to a structure used primarily for
human habitation. It may therefore be inferred that the
legislature intended that sales for other actions to housing
facilities could be tax exempt.
In our judgment, sales for maintenance to a housing facility
of an educational institution are such other actions. The
legislative history demonstrates that, had the legislature
wished to deny a tax exemption for sales for maintenance, it
clearly knew how to do so. We believe the last sentence of
K.S.A. 79-3606(c) denies a sales tax exemption to materials
used in "repairs" to housing facilities of an educational
institution, but allows such an exemption for materials used
in "maintenance" of such facilities. The practical problem is
in determining whether, in a given situation, the action to be
undertaken constitutes "repairs" rather than "maintenance."
Reference to dictionary definitions of "repair" or "maintain"
is not particulary helpful. The American Heritage
Dictionary (New College Edition, 1976) provides the following:
repair: "to restore to sound condition after damage or
injury; fix." p. 1102.
maintain: "to keep in a condition of good repair or
efficiency." p. 787.
Relevant definitions by the Kansas appellate courts
demonstrate the similarity rather than the distinction between
the two terms. See e.g., School District v. Robb, 150
Kan. 402, 404-405 (1939) (Recognizing a distinction between
the "erection" of public improvements and the "maintenance or
repair " of them); State, ex rel. v. City of Pittsburg,
188 Kan. 612, 621 (1961) ("Maintenance" held to be synonymous
with "taking proper care of," "repairing," or the like); In
Re Tax Appeal of R. & R. Janitor Service, 9 Kan.App.2d 500,
505 (1984) ("Maintaining" is keeping in repair or replacing,
and is not synonymous with "cleaning").
Few cases in other jurisdictions have sought to distinguish
between "maintenance" and "repair." In In Re Bowden's
Will, 143 N.Y.S. 2d 125 (1956), a will authorized trustees to
pay for "repairs" to a homestead but did not authorize payment
for "maintenance" to the homestead. The court held, without
any discussion of its rationale, that the "necessary and
reasonable painting and decorating of the premises within and
without constitute repairs," while the "putting up and taking
down of storm windows and screens, and keeping the grounds in
order are not repairs, but rather acts of maintenance
. . . ." 153 N.Y.S. 2d at 126. In People v. Chicago, B. &
Q. R. Co., 107 N.E. 222 (Ill. 1914), a statute required that
when a tax was levied for several purposes, the amount for
each purpose be separately stated. In holding that a tax levy
for "repairs upon, and care, support, and maintenance of the
courthouse" met the separate itemization requirement, the
court stated "the word 'maintenance' might include ordinary
repairs for the building, as it might also include the care of
the building." The court thus distinguished between ordinary
repairs such as are required every year in a building, and
extraordinary repairs on buildings which would require more
than the usual annual expense for repairs for ordinary wear in
holding that only extraordinary repairs need be separately
itemized.
In our judgment, the word "repairs" in the context of the last
sentence of K.S.A. 79-3606(c) should be interpreted to mean
extraordinary repairs requiring large expenditures and not
ordinary repairs essential for the routine maintenance of
housing operations. Accordingly, materials used to preserve
the original nature of the housing facility by fixing minor
damage resulting from normal wear and tear are tax exempt
under K.S.A. 79-3606(c). However, materials used to restore a
housing facility to its original form and structure after
major or extensive damage to it from a source other than
normal wear and tear are not tax exempt.
Very truly yours,
ROBERT T. STEPHAN
ATTORNEY GENERAL OF KANSAS
Kathryn Gardner
Assistant Attorney General
RTS:JSS:KG:crw

Setzen Sie Ihre Recherche in ChatGPT oder Claude fort

Verbinden Sie Omnilex, um den Rechtskorpus über Ihren KI-Assistenten zu durchsuchen.