Kansas Attorney General Opinion 1985-176

1985-176Kanag

Gesamter Gesetzestext

December 16, 1985
ATTORNEY GENERAL OPINION NO. 85- 176
Laurence R. Hollis, P.A.
Petroleum Building, Suite 701
Wichita, Kansas 67202-4293
Re: Cities and Municipalities -- Code for Municipal
Courts; General Provisions -- Municipal Court;
Place of Courtroom
Synopsis: K.S.A. 12-4109 requires each city to provide a
suitable courtroom for the municipal court, and
states that the court shall be held at such time
and places designated by city ordinance. Nothing
in the statute, or in the Code of Procedure for
Municipal Courts of which it is a part, prohibits a
city from designating a location outside the city
limits as the site of the municipal court.
However, if appearing at a designated site imposes
a burden on defendants which is unreasonable, such
action of a city may be found to be a violation of
due process under the United States Constitution.
Given the location of the City of Eastborough and
the lack of any suitable courtroom facility within
the city limits, the designation of a courtroom in
the Sedgwick County Courthouse is not
unreasonable. Cited herein: K.S.A. 12-4109; Kan.
Const., Art. 12, §5; U.S. Const., Fourteenth
Amendment.
Dear Mr. Hollis:
As Municipal Judge for the City of Eastborough, you request
our opinion concerning the location which has been designated
by the city for the business of the municipal court.
Specifically, you inform us that Eastborough, a city of the
third class, is entirely surrounded by Wichita, and that there
are no businesses or public buildings within the city. As
this is the case, the city has designated the Sedgwick
County Courthouse as the site for the municipal court. In
that questions have been raised from time to time concerning
the legality of this practice, you desire to obtain our
opinion.
The municipal court for Eastborough is governed by the Code
of Procedure for Municipal Courts which is found in the
statutes at K.S.A. 12-4101 et seq. Although the code has
been held to be non-uniform, and so subject to alteration
under a city's power of home rule [City of Junction City v.
Griffin, 227 Kan. 332, 337 (1980)1, we have no indication
that changes have been made by the city in any respect
relevant here. The applicable section of the code, K.S.A.
12-4109, states:
"Each city shall provide at the expense of
the city a suitable courtroom for the
municipal court, together with all
necessary supplies and records. Municipal
court shall be held at such time and
places designated by ordinance."
The city has in accordance with this language designated the
Sedgwick County Courthouse as the location of the court.
The courthouse is located on the north side of downtown
Wichita, and is no more than 5 to 6 miles from Eastborough,
which is located on the east side of the metropolitan area.
Although you do not so state, we assume from the circumstances
that a majority of the persons appearing in municipal court
are residents of Wichita, rather than Eastborough, and that
the offenses are almost exclusively traffic violations.
In our opinion, nothing in the Code of Procedure for Municipal
Courts precludes the ordinance in question, whereby municipal
court sessions are held in the Sedgwick County Courthouse.
Neither in K.S.A. 12-4109 nor elsewhere in the code is it
stated that a city's municipal court must be held within the
city limits of that city. Even if this were the case, the
city could, as was noted earlier, amend the code by charter
resolution to provide for such a location, in that the code is
non-uniform and so is subject to the city's power of home
rule under Article 12, Section 5 of the state constitution.
Of course, it should not be assumed that a city's power in
this regard is without limits, for it is possible to imagine
facts under which a designation of a municipal court site in
another city would be so burdensome on defendants as to be a
denial of due process. In general, the right of due process
provided by the Fourteenth Amendment requires that state
action not be unreasonable, arbitrary or capricious, and that
the means selected have a real and substantial relation to the
objective sought to be obtained. Cardarella v. City of
Overland Park, 228 Kan. 698 (1980). In the context of a
judicial proceeding, due process mandates that an individual
receive a fair and impartial hearing before an unbiased
tribunal. State v. Sherry, 233 Kan. 920 (1983). The
determination of due process is made upon the particular facts
present in each case. Jones v. Marquez, 526 F.Supp. 870
(D. Kan. 1981).
In the present situation, we do not believe that due process
is offended by the holding of the Eastborough Municipal
Court in the Sedgwick County Courthouse. Eastborough is
located within Sedgwick County, and for many defendants,
attending court at the courthouse would require them to travel
a lesser distance than would going to a location within the
city. Clearly, the designation of a site outside the county,
or even at some sites within the county, could raise due
process questions. However, under the facts here, we do not
believe that a due process challenge could be successfully
brought. See, e.g. Mohon v. Harkreader, 18 Kan. 383
(1877) (civil trial held: in law office instead of courtroom;
defendant waived right to object through his attendance and
participation in proceedings; court found nothing to indicate
that change of location impaired right to fair hearing).
In conclusion, K.S.A. 12-4109 requires each city to provide a
suitable courtroom for the municipal court, and states that
the court shall be held at such time and places designated by
city ordinance. Nothing in the statute, or in the Code of
Procedure for Municipal Courts of which it is a part,
prohibits a city from designating a location outside the city
Very tJeffreyours,
ROBERT T. STEPAN
ATTORNEY GENERAL OF KANSAS
limits as the site of the municipal court. However, if
appearing at a designated site imposes a burden on defendants
which is unreasonable, such action of a city may be found to
be a violation of due process under the United States
Constitution. Given the location of the City of Eastborough
and the lack of any suitable courtroom facility within the
city limits, the designation of a courtroom in the Sedgwick
County Courthouse is not unreasonable.
effretruly yoursd
Deputy AtSTEPHAN General
RTS:JSS:crw

Setzen Sie Ihre Recherche in ChatGPT oder Claude fort

Verbinden Sie Omnilex, um den Rechtskorpus über Ihren KI-Assistenten zu durchsuchen.