Kansas Attorney General Opinion 1985-151

1985-151Kanag

Gesamter Gesetzestext

November 6, 1985
ATTORNEY GENERAL OPINION NO. 85- 151
Charles E. Simmons
Chief Legal Counsel
Department of Corrections
Jayhawk Towers
700 Jackson
Topeka, Kansas 66603
Re: Crimes and Punishments -- Code; Principles
of Criminal Liability -- Use of Deadly
Force by Correctional Officers.
Synopsis: A correctional officer at a state penitentiary
is not prohibited from using deadly force to
prevent the escape of an inmate incarcerated
for a felony, when such force is necessary to
prevent or terminate the escape. Cited herein:
K.S.A. 21-3215.
Dear Mr. Simmons:
You request our opinion as to whether the decision of the
United States Supreme Court in Tennessee v. Garner, 471
U.S. , 105 S.Ct. , 85 L.Ed.2d 1 (1985) is
applicable to a prison setting. Specifically, you ask
whether a correctional officer may use deadly force to
prevent an inmate who is escaping from a Kansas prison or
to retake an inmate who has previously escaped.
In Garner, the Court stated that the use of deadly force
by a police officer to prevent the escape of an apparently
unarmed, nondangerous, suspected felon violates the
Fourth Amendment. In that case, two police officers
responded to a report of a prowler at a residence. As he
proceeded to the rear of the house, one officer noticed a
young male suspect, approximately 5'4" tall, 100-110 pounds
and 15 years of age (later shown to be Edward Garner).
Shining his flashlight on the youth, the officer could see
that the suspect was apparently unarmed. The officer
ordered him to "halt." Ignoring the warning, the suspect
attempted to climb a six-foot-high fence. The officer
shot him once in the back of the head, and he later died.
The Supreme Court balanced the nature and quality of the
intrusion on the individual's Fourth Amendment rights
against the importance of the governmental interests
alleged to justify the intrusion. The Court concluded that
unless "the officer has probable cause to believe that the
suspect poses a serious threat of physical harm, either to
the officer or others," deadly force may not be used simply
to prevent the escape of an unarmed, nondangerous,
suspected felon. 85 L.Ed.2d at 9-10.
In contrast to Garner, the United States District Court
for the Western District of Michigan considered the issue
you have raised, i.e., whether deadly force may be used
in the prison setting to stop a fleeing felon, in Newby
v. Services, 590 F.Supp. 591 (1984). In Newby,
correctional officers attempted to stop two inmates from
escaping from a Michigan prison, first by verbal warnings,
then by warning shots. When the inmates failed to heed the
warnings, an officer shot at Newby, hitting him in the
neck. The court stated:
"Garner addressed the issue of when deadly
force may be used against a suspect. In
contrast, the instant case presents the
situation where the escapee has already been
found guilty of one felony and is in the
process of committing another.
Additionally, many prisoners in the Michigan
Training Unit have already been found guilty
[of] the commission of a violent felony.
Prison guards have no way of distinguishing
which inmates have committed violent
crimes. Additionally, guards and prison
officials have probable cause to believe
that any given escapee may be armed or pose
a danger to others in the community. An
escapee, by virtue of his escape, is a
desperate individual and is in the process
of committing a felony. I am persuaded that
the prevention of a prison escape comes
within the circumstances where the Sixth
Circuit stated that deadly force may be
justified.
"Applying the principles enunciated in
Garner, I am convinced that an escaping
convicted felon has no constitutional right
to be free from the use of deadly force,
when deadly force is necessary to prevent or
terminate his escape." Id. (Emphasis in
original.)
We are of the opinion that Kansas correctional officers may
be guided by the decision in Newby and may use deadly
force to prevent an inmate incarcerated for a felony from
escaping or to recapture the inmate when necessary.
However, we caution correctional officers that the facts
and circumstances surrounding each incident must be
evaluated in determining whether deadly force should be
used. While it will admittedly be difficult to make such a
balancing determination in the split-seconds during which
an escape or recapture occurs, officers can and should be
trained to anticipate such situations before they arise.
See also K.S.A. 21-3215.
Very truly yours,
ROBERT T. STEPHAN
Attorney General
Brenda L. Braden
Deputy Attorney General
RTS:BLB:may

Setzen Sie Ihre Recherche in ChatGPT oder Claude fort

Verbinden Sie Omnilex, um den Rechtskorpus über Ihren KI-Assistenten zu durchsuchen.