Kansas Attorney General Opinion 1985-140

1985-140Kanag

Gesamter Gesetzestext

October 15, 1985
ATTORNEY GENERAL OPINION NO. 85-140
W. R. Brenner, M.D.
Mayor, City of Larned
P.O. Box 70, 417 Broadway
Larned, Kansas 67550
Re: State Departments; Public Officers, Employees--Tort
Claims Act--Defense of Governmental Entity or
Employee; Requests to Provide Defense
Synopsis: Under the provisions of K.S.A. 75-6116 (as amended
by L. 1985, ch. 293, 11), the obligation of a city
to pay attorneys fees incurred by a city officer
in defending a civil rights action is subject to the
conditions and limitations prescribed by K.S.A.
75-6108. Those conditions include the filing of a
written request (within 15 days after service of
process upon the employee) that the city provide for
the defense of the employee. K.S.A. 75-6108(d) and
(e). Where no such request is filed, a city is not
liable for attorneys fees incurred by the employee;
however, the city governing body may, in its
discretion, pay attorneys fees notwithstanding the
failure to file a written request. Cited herein:
K.S.A. 75-6102, 75-6108; 75-6116; L. 1985, ch. 293,
§1.
Dear Mr. Brenner:
You request our interpretation of K.S.A. 75-6116 (as amended by
L. 1985, ch. 293, §1). Specifically, you ask whether a city is
obligated to pay the attorneys fees incurred by a city officer in
defending a civil rights action, where the officer failed to file
a written request that the city provide for his defense.
You advise that a civil rights action filed by the former city
manager of Larned was recently settled by the city's liability
insurance carrier, and that you and four council members incurred
attorneys fees as a result of the lawsuit. You indicate that
the city attorney claimed "from the outset" of the lawsuit that
the individual defendants (the mayor and four council members)
were not acting within the scope of their employment, and that he
would not be in a position to provide a defense for said
individuals, due to a conflict of interest between the City of
Larned and the individual defendants. You advise that no request
for the city to provide a defense was filed because the "City
Attorney had already denied a defense."
K.S.A. 75-6116 (as amended by L. 1985, ch. 293, §1) imposes an
obligation upon governmental entities (which term includes
cities) to provide for the defense of a city officer in a civil
rights action, with subsection (a) providing as follows:
"If an employee of a governmental entity is or
could be subject to personal civil liability
on account of a noncriminal act or omission
which is within the scope of the employee's
employment and which allegedly violates the
civil rights laws of the United States or of
the state of Kansas, the governmental entity
shall provide for the defense of any civil action
or proceeding which arises out of the act or
omission and which is. brought against the
employee in the employee's official or
individual capacity or both to the extent and
under the conditions and limitations provided
by K.S.A. 75-6108 and amendments thereto for
the defense of actions and proceedings under
the Kansas tort claims act. If the employee's
act or omission giving rise to the action or
proceeding was not the result of actual fraud
or actual malice and the employee reasonably
cooperates in good faith in defense of the
action or proceeding, the governmental entity,
subject to any procedural requirements imposed
by statute, ordinance, resolution or written
policy, shall pay or cause to be paid any
judgment or settlement of the claim or
suit, including any award of attorney fees,
and all costs and fees incurred by the
employee in defense thereof." (Emphasis
added.)
As the underscored portion of the above-quoted statutory excerpt
indicates, the obligation of a city to pay attorneys fees
incurred by a city officer in defending a civil rights action is
subject to the conditions and limitations prescribed by K.S.A.
75-6108. That statute provides that a governmental entity
may refuse to provide for the defense of an action if it
determines:
"(1) The act or omission was not within the
scope of such employee's employment;
"(2) such employee acted or failed to act
because of actual fraud or actual malice;
"(3) the defense of the action or proceeding
by the governmental entity would create a
conflict of interest between the governmental
entity and the employee; or
"(4) the request was not made in accordance
with subsection (e)." (Emphasis added.)
Under the above-quoted statutory excerpt, it is the governing
body of the city, not the city attorney, which decides to
refuse to provide a defense for any of the above-stated reasons.
We would note that the complaint filed by the former city manager
alleges, quite repetitively, that the defendants' actions were
malicious and wanton. Such allegations raise a question (which
could only be answered by a trier of fact) as to whether the
individual defendants were acting within the scope of their
employment. See Murphy v. City of Topeka, 6 Kan.App.2d 488,
493-494 (1981).
Subsection (e) of K.S.A. 75-6108 prescribes the procedure for
requesting a city which to provide for the defense of an employee
[which term includes officers - see K.S.A. 75-6102(d)]:
"An employee's request for a governmental
entity to provide for the defense of the
employee shall be made in writing within
fifteen (15) days after service of process
upon the employee in the action. In actions
involving employees of the state, such request
shall be filed in the office of the attorney
general. In actions involving employees of a
municipality, such request shall be filed with
the governing body thereof or as otherwise
provided by such governing body. A
governmental entity, in its discretion, may
provide requested defense for any of its
employees who failed to make a request within
the time prescribed by this subsection."
(Emphasis added.)
Subsection (d) of K.S.A. 75-6108 prescribes the circumstances
under which a city which refuses to provide an employee with a
defense is liable for the employee's attorneys fees:
"(d) If after a timely request in accordance
with subsection (e), a governmental entity
fails or refuses to provide an employee with a
defense and the employee retains his or her
own counsel to defend the action or
proceeding, such employee is entitled to
recover from the governmental entity such
reasonable attorney's fees, costs and expenses
as are necessarily incurred in defending the
action or proceeding if the action or
proceeding arose out of an act or omission in
the scope of employment as an employee of the
governmental entity, but such employee is not
entitled to such reimbursement if the trier of
fact finds that such employee acted or failed
to act because of actual fraud or actual
malice.
"Nothing in this section shall be construed to
deprive an employee of the right to petition a
court of competent jurisdiction to compel the
governmental entity or the governing body or
an employee thereof to perform the duties
imposed by this section." (Emphasis added.)
As the underscored portion of the above excerpt indicates, a
timely request for defense under subsection (e), and refusal of
the governmental entity to provide a defense, are conditions-
precedent to city liability for attorneys fees incurred by
an employee. As there was neither a request for defense,
nor a refusal thereof by the governing body under the
circumstances you describe, it is our opinion that the City of
Larned is not liable for the subject attorneys fees. However,
under the provisions of subsection (e) K.S.A. 75-6108, the
governing body may, in its discretion, pay attorneys fees
incurred by its members.
In the event the city governing body does vote on a motion to pay
attorneys fees incurred by its members, you ask whether the fee
for legal services should be presented as one "combined bill," or
whether a separate bill should be presented for the legal services
incurred by each member. In our opinion, as long as the legal
services were actually incurred by the members, the city has
authority to pay for the same, regardless of whether the bill is
presented in one lump sum or segregated as to the legal fees
incurred by each member. However, as indicated in Attorney
General Opinion No. 141, a council member is disqualified from
making or voting on a motion concerning the payment of attorneys
fees which he or she has incurred in a civil action.
Accordingly, if a bill is presented in one lump sum for services
incurred by the mayor and four council members, those five
individuals would be disqualified from making or voting on a
motion to pay the bill.
In summary, under the provisions of K.S.A. 75-6116 (as amended
by L. 1985, ch. 293, 11), the obligation of a city to pay
attorneys fees incurred by a city officer in defending a civil
rights action is subject to the conditions and limitations
prescribed by K.S.A. 75-6108. Those conditions include the
filing of a written request (within 15 days after service of
process upon the employee) that the city provide for the defense
of the employee. K.S.A. 75-6108(d) and (e). Where no such
request is filed, a city is not liable for attorneys fees
incurred by the employee; however, the city governing body may,
in its discretion, pay attorneys fees notwithstanding the
failure to file a written request.
Very truly yours,
ROBERT T. STEPHAN
Attorney General of Kansas
Terrence R. Hearshman
Assistant Attorney General
RTS:JSS:TRH:jm

Setzen Sie Ihre Recherche in ChatGPT oder Claude fort

Verbinden Sie Omnilex, um den Rechtskorpus über Ihren KI-Assistenten zu durchsuchen.