Kansas Attorney General Opinion 1985-054

1985-054Kanag

Gesamter Gesetzestext

ROBERT T. STEPHAN
ATTORNEY GENERAL
May 17, 1985
ATTORNEY GENERAL OPINION NO. 85- 54
Gerald Woolwine
Clark County Attorney
120 West 7th Street
P.O. Box 565
Ashland, Kansas 67831
Re: Fences -- Legal Enclosures -- Legal and Sufficient
4' Fences
Synopsis: Kansas fence laws designate the board of county
commissioners of each county as "fence viewers."
When acting as fence viewers the board of county
commissioners has the authority to declare legally
sufficient all constructions which in their judgment
are equivalent to sufficient fences as described by
statute. The fence viewers possess the authority to
deem electric fences legally sufficient if, in their
judgment, the fence is equivalent to other legally
sufficient fences. Cited herein: K.S.A. 29-101;
29-102; 29-104.
Dear Mr. Woolwine:
As Clark County Attorney, you have requested our opinion
regarding the designation of legally sufficient fences under the
Kansas statutes pertaining to fences, K.S.A. 29-101 et seq.
You inform us that the Board of Clark County Commissioners are
considering adopting a resolution which would deem electric
fences meeting certain specifications to be legally sufficient
fences. You inquire as to the authority of the Board to adopt such
a resolution, and ask whether an electric fence is of a type
which may be deemed equivalent to the fences specified by statute
as legally sufficient.
As you are aware, K.S.A. 29-102 contains certain specifications
for sufficient fences and states that "all such fences shall be
substantially built and sufficiently close to prevent stock from
going through." It also provides that all hedge fences shall be
of such height and thickness as will protect the field or
enclosure, presumably from wandering livestock. The Kansas Court
of Appeals has noted that one of the purpose of the fence laws is
to prevent damage to property and crops by fencing animals out. See
Lindsay v. Cobb, 6 Kan.App.2d 171, 173 (1981). The Kansas
statute and the Lindsay case are in accord with the common law
definition of a sufficient fence as one which will turn ordinary
stock. See 36A C.J.S., Fences §14, 35 Am.Jur.2d, Fences §17.
The Kansas fence laws designate the county commissioners of each
county as fence viewers. As fence viewers, the commissioners
serve as a tribunal of limited jurisdiction within the confines
of the statutes prescribing their functions. K.S.A. 29-104
addresses the role of the fence viewers in determining what is a
legally sufficient fence and provides:
"Fences of the material and of the height and
sufficiency aforesaid, and all brooks, rivers,
creeks, ditches and constructions which shall
be equivalent thereto, in the judgment of the
fence viewers within whose jurisdiction the
same may be, shall be deemed legal and
sufficient fences." (Emphasis added.)
In our opinion, this statute grants the discretionary authority
to determine the factual question of whether a fence is
sufficient "to prevent stock from going through" to a board of
county commissioners, acting in their capacity as fence viewers.
Thus, we can perceive no barrier to the board of county
commissioners, acting as fence viewers, declaring that an
electric fence of a prescribed type is an equivalent
"construction" to those described in K.S.A. 29-102. In passing,
we note that 1985 House Bill No. 2148 amends K.S.A. 29-104 to
specifically grant fence viewers the authority to declare
electric fences equivalent to sufficient fences. That bill,
however, was not reported out of the House Committee on
Agriculture and Small Business during the 1985 legislative
session. Nevertheless, it appears that the authority to declare
electric fences as equivalent constructions exists in the statute
as it presently reads.
We note, however, that the authority to declare certain
constructions equivalent to statutorily prescribed "sufficient
fences" belongs to the fence viewers. Thus, it appears that any
exercise of that authority should be in the form of an order
issued by the fence viewers and rather than an ordinary resolution
of the board of county commissioners.
Very truly yours,
ROBERT T. STEPHAN
ATTORNEY GENERAL OF KANSAS
Mary V. Carson
Assistant Attorney General
RTS:JSS:MFC:crw

Setzen Sie Ihre Recherche in ChatGPT oder Claude fort

Verbinden Sie Omnilex, um den Rechtskorpus über Ihren KI-Assistenten zu durchsuchen.