Kansas Attorney General Opinion 1984-012

1984-012Kanag

Gesamter Gesetzestext

February 9, 1984
ATTORNEY GENERAL OPINION NO. 84- 12
The Honorable Ronald R. Hein
State Senator, Twentieth District
Room 120-S, State Capitol
Topeka, Kansas 66612
Re: Taxation--Kansas Retailers' Sales Tax--Tax
Imposed
Taxation--Kansas Compensating Tax--Imposition
of Tax
Synopsis: The removal of a new or used vehicle from a stock
of vehicles (held for resale) by a licensed vehicle
dealer, and registration of the vehicle in the
dealership name, does not constitute a sale at
retail under the provisions of K.S.A. 1983 Supp.
79-3602(e). However, where such registration
of a vehicle occurs, compensating tax is due
pursuant to the provisions of K.S.A. 79-3703,
K.A.R. 92-20-3, and K.A.R. 1983 Supp. 92-19-43.
Also, in computing said tax, the dealer may not
claim credit for a trade-in allowance given by
the dealer in the transaction whereby the dealer
acquired the vehicle. Cited herein: K.S.A. 8-136,
K.S.A. 1983 Supp. 79-3602, 79-3603, K.S.A. 79-3618,
79-3702, 79-3703, 79-3704, 79-3705a, K.A.R. 92-19-11,
92-19-25, K.A.R. 1983 Supp. 92-19-43, K.A.R. 92-20-3.
Dear Senator Hein:
You request our opinion as to whether Kansas retailers' sales
tax is imposed upon registration of a vehicle, by a licensed
vehicle dealer, under certain circumstances. Specifically,
you inquire as to whether the tax is imposed where a dealer
"exchanges vehicles," i.e. where the dealer takes a vehicle
which is presently registered, places it back into his inventory,
and registers another vehicle with the same license plate. Your
specific questions are as follows:
"1. When a dealer removes a new or used
vehicle from his stock of vehicles (all held
for resale) and registers and tags the same
in the dealership name, is there a sale at
retail?
"2. From whom does the dealer purchase the
new vehicle in a retail sale--when he pays no
consideration to his dealership?
"3. Why isn't the dealer to be given credit
for a trade-in allowance if in fact there is
a retail sale under the above given set of
facts?"
The above-stated questions must be answered by referring to
the pertinent sales tax and compensating use tax statutes and
regulations of this state. Subsection (a) of K.S.A. 1983 Supp.
79-3603 levies a "tax at the rate of 3% upon gross receipts
received from the sale of tangible personal property at retail"
within the state of Kansas. The term "sale" is defined (in
part) as including "the exchange of tangible personal property,
as well as the sale thereof for money, and every transaction,
conditional or otherwise, for a consideration, constituting
a sale." K.S.A. 1983 Supp. 79-3602(c). The term "sale at
retail" is defined as "all sales m ade within the state of
tangible personal property . . . for use or consumption and not
for resale." K.S.A. 1983 Supp. 79-3602(e).
Pursuant to authority granted by K.S.A. 79-3618, the Secretary
of Revenue has adopted regulations for administration of the
Kansas Retailers' Sales Tax Act. In this regard, two regulations
of the Department of Revenue are pertinent to your inquiry. K.A.R.
92-19-11 relates to property purchased for resale, but used by
the purchaser, and provides as follows:
"If a wholesaler or retailer takes tangible
personal property from a stock of goods to
use for personal consumption or for gifts,
he shall enter on his books the amount of
the cost of all tangible personal property
so removed from stock for his personal
consumption or as gifts, and, as the ultimate
consumer, shall pay the tax thereon." (Emphasis
added.)
K.A.R. 1983 Supp. 92-19-43 relates to vehicles acquired by a
vehicle dealer for resale, which vehicles are subsequently
registered by the dealer. Said regulation provides as follows:
"(a) The registration of a vehicle by a
licensed vehicle dealer pursuant to the
provisions of article 1 of chapter 8 of
Kansas Statutes Annotated shall consti-
tute the taking of tangible personal
property from a stock of goods within
the meaning of K.A.R. 92-19-11 and amend-
ments thereto. Except as provided in
subsections (b) and (c), sales tax shall
be due and payable to the county treasurer
at the time the dealer makes application
for the registration of the vehicle.
"(b) Nothwithstanding the provisions of
subsection (a), whenever a vehicle is regis-
tered by a licensed vehicle dealer for the
purpose of subsequently leasing the vehi-
cle, sales tax shall be collected by the
licensed vehicle dealer on each lease pay-
ment made by the lessee. At the time of
making application for registration, the
dealer shall provide the county treasurer
with a resale exemption Certificate pursuant
to K.A.R. 92-19-25.
"(c) Whenever a vehicle which has been
registered by a licensed vehicle dealer,
and upon which the sales tax has been paid,
is sold or is otherwise transferred in a
taxable transaction within 15 days from the
date the vehicle was registered by the dealer,
the taking of the vehicle from a stock of
goods and the subsequent transfer shall be
deemed to constitute a single transaction
for sales tax purposes. Upon the subsequent
transfer, the dealer shall collect the sales
tax from the ultimate consumer and may apply
for credit from the director of taxation
for the tax paid by the dealer to the
county treasuer." (Emphasis added.)
K.S.A. 79-3703 imposes compensating tax upon using or consuming,
within the state of Kansas, any article of tangible personal
property (whether purchased within or without the state of
Kansas). K.S.A. 79-3702 defines the term "use" as "the exercise
within this state by any person of any right or power over
tangible personal property incident to the ownership of that
property, except that it shall not include processing, or the
sale of property in the regular course of business, and except
storage as hereinafter defined." Pursuant to K.S.A. 79-3704,
any article of tangible personal property, the sale or use of
which has already been subjected to a tax equal to or in excess
of the compensating tax, is exempt from said tax. K.S.A. 79-3705a
provides, in part, that the person using, consuming or storing
tangible personal property in this state shall pay the compensating
tax where the same is not collected or collectible by the retailer.
Finally, under the provisions of K.A.R. 92-20-3, sales tax rules
and regulations also apply to compensating tax.
Responding, now, to your first question, it is our opinion that
when a dealer removes a new or used vehicle from his stock of
vehicles (all held for resale) and registers the same in the
dealership name, such action does not constitute a sale at retail
under the provisions of K.S.A. 1983 Supp. 79-3602(e), for the
reason that a sale cannot occur without the participation of two
parties (a seller and a buyer). However, it is necessary to
consider whether the registration of such a vehicle constitutes
a taxable use under the Kansas Compensating Tax Act.
It is well settled that the Kansas Retailers' Sales Tax Act
and the Kansas Compensating Tax Act are complementary and
supplemental to one another, and must be construed together.
Consumers Cooperative Ass'n v. State, 174 Kan. 461 (1953).
Additionally, it is a basic principle of the sales tax act
that the tax is borne by the ultimate consumer and that no
article should have to carry more than one sales tax.
Southwestern Bell Tel. Co. v. State, 168 Kan. 227, 233 (1949).
In this regard, it must be recognized that where a motor vehicle
dealer acquires a vehicle for resale, no sales tax is imposed
on said transaction because the dealer represents that the
sale is not for use or consumption, and because the dealer claims
a resale exemption (see K.A.R. 92-19-25). However, where a
dealer registers and tags the vehicle in the dealership name,
it is clear that such action establishes that the vehicle was
not acquired for resale, but for use or consumption, since
such registration is not required to demonstrate and display
the vehicle for purposes of resale. See K.S.A. 8-136. Ac-
cordingly, where such registration occurs, it is our opinion
that compensating tax is due under the provisions of K.S.A.
79-3703, 79-3705a, K.A.R. 1983 Supp. 92-19-43, K.A.R. 92-19-25
and K.A.R. 92-20-3.
In regard to your second question, the taxable event giving
rise to imposition of the compensating tax is not the sale of
tangible personal property, but the use of such property within
the state of Kansas. As stated above, the registration of a
vehicle by a motor vehicle dealer establishes such a use, and
the tax is imposed upon the consideration paid by the taxpayer
for the property. Although a dealer pays no consideration to
his dealership when he removes a vehicle from inventory, the
vehicle was undoubtedly acquired by the dealer for a consideration
(either cash or trade-in allowance), and it is the latter
consideration upon which the tax is levied.
Finally, in response to your third question, both the Kansas
Retailers' Sales Tax Act and the Kansas Compensating Tax Act
permit the deduction of a trade-in allowance from the tax base.
See K.S.A. 1983 Supp. 79-3602(h) and K.A.R. 92-20-4. However,
in our judgment, these laws and regulations cannot be reasonably
interpreted as permitting such a deduction where a dealer is
dealing with himself, i.e. where a dealer takes a vehicle which
is presently registered, places it back into his inventory, and
registers another vehicle with the same license plate.
Additionally, in our judgment, where a dealer is removing
(from inventory) a vehicle taken as a trade-in, the dealer may
not claim such a deduction based upon any trade-in allowance
given by the dealer in the transaction whereby the dealer
acquired the vehicle. Presumably, the dealer would have
already claimed the deduction in a previous month's report
of gross receipts [see K.S.A. 1983 Supp. 79-3602(h)], and in
our opinion, the dealer may not claim a second deduction based
upon the same trade-in allowance. Further, in our judgment,
the allowance of a deduction under the circumstances you describe
would violate the basic principle upon which the sales tax and
compensating use tax are based, i.e. that the ultimate consumer
bears the tax. In our opinion, a licensed vehicle dealer is the
ultimate consumer, with respect to a vehicle which is registered
by the dealer, and is liable for payment of sales or compensating
tax upon registration of a vehicle.
Very truly yours,
ROBERT T. STEPHAN
Attorney General of Kansas
Terrence R. Hearshman
Assistant Attorney General
RTS:BJS:TRH:jm

Setzen Sie Ihre Recherche in ChatGPT oder Claude fort

Verbinden Sie Omnilex, um den Rechtskorpus über Ihren KI-Assistenten zu durchsuchen.