Kansas Attorney General Opinion 1983-169

1983-169Kanag

Gesamter Gesetzestext

November 15, 1983
ATTORNEY GENERAL OPINION NO. 83- 169
Honorable Denise C. Apt
Representative, Tenth District
810 Meadowbrook
Iola, Kansas 66749
Re: Schools--Vocational Education--Plan for Establish-
ment; Approval by State Board of Education
Synopsis: The State Board of Education lacks the discretion
to reject a plan for the establishment of a proposed
area vocational school solely for the reason that
the legislature may not provide additional financial
support therefor. Cited herein: K.S.A. 72-4416, Kan.
Const., Art. 6, §§1, 2 and 6.
Dear Representative Apt:
You seek our opinion on whether the State Board of Education
may reject a plan for the establishment of an area vocational
school, even though the information submitted in support of the
establishment of the area vocational school, as prescribed in
K.S.A. 72-4416, indicates the area vocational school meets the
criteria established by the Board. Specifically, you inquire
whether a plan may be rejected because of concern that a new
area vocational school may create a demand for financial support
in excess of the amount the state legislature may provide.
In our judgment, the State Board lacks the authority to deny a
plan on this basis alone. This conclusion is premised in part
upon our consideration of Sections 1, 2(a) and 6(b) of Article 6
of the Kansas Constitution, which provide, respectively:
"§1. Schools and related institutions and
activities. The legislature shall provide
for intellectual, educational, vocational
and scientific improvement by establishing
and maintaining public schools, educational
institutions and related activities which
may be organized and changed in such manner
as may be provided by law.
"§2. State board of education and state
board of regents. (a) The legislature
shall provide for a state board of education
which shall have general supervision of
public schools, educational institutions
and all the educational interests of the
state, except educational functions del-
egated by law to the state board of regents.
The state board of education shall perform
such other duties as may be provided by law.
"S6. Finance. . . •
"(b) The legislature shall make suitable
provision for finance of the educational
interests of the state. No tutition shall
be charged for attendance at any public
school to pupils required by law to attend
such school, except such fees or supplemental
charges as may be authorized by law. The
legislature may authorize the state board
of regents to establish tutition, fees and
charges at institutions under its supervision."
(Emphasis added.)
These sections of the constitution clearly prescribe certain
duties which are the responsibility of the state legislature and
certain other duties which are the responsibility of the State
Board of Education.
Under Article 6, Section 1, the duty to provide for, inter alia,
vocational improvement, by establishing and maintaining public
schools, educational institutions and related activities, is
placed squarely upon the legislature. However, in providing
for the establishment of schools, institutions and related
activities, the legislature may require the State Board to lend
assistance. See Article 6, Section 2(a), supra, and State ex rel. v.
State Board of Education, 215 Kan. 551 (1974), in which case, the
Kansas Supreme Court held:
"Under Art. 6, Sec. 1 and 2 of our consti-
tution the State Board of Education is
authorized to perform any duties pertaining
to the educational interests of the state
which the legislature deems wise and prudent
to impose upon the board, and the legislature
has authority to delegate to that board the
power to perform duties which, in the general
classification of powers of government, are
legislative in character . . . ." Id. at Syl.
$3.
Pursuant to its authority to delegate to the State Board of
Education the power to perform duties legislative in character,
the legislature has prescribed, in K.S.A. 72-4416, that the State
Board review plans for the establishment of new area vocational
schools, conduct hearings and investigations in regard to any
such plan, and, based upon the factors prescribed by the leg-
islature, approve, modify and approve as modified, or reject
any such plan. This all is set forth in K.S.A. 72-4416, which
provides:
"Any board may present a plan to the state
board for the establishment and operation
of any area vocational school. The plan
may specify that the area vocational school
is to be a department or a division of a
school district or a community junior col-
lege or an institution under the state board
of regents or any municipal university. The
plan shall be prepared in such form as is
prescribed by the state board.
"Information included in support of the plan
shall include, but not be limited to the
following:
"(a) Concentration of population within a
reasonable community service area;
"(b) Total school enrollments in grades
one through eight, and in grades nine
through twelve, separately;
"(c) Number of persons graduating from
high school within the area;
"(d) Probability of growth in school en-
rollments within the area;
"(e) Identification of vocational education
services needed within the area;
"(f) Local interest and attitudes toward
the program;
"(g) Ability to contribute to the financial
support of the program;
"(h) Consideration of the area in relation
to other programs or requests for programs
of vocational education to prevent, as nearly
as is practicable, overlapping or duplication
of educational services.
"Upon receipt and examination of a plan,
the state board shall conduct hearings and
make such investigations related to the plan
as it deems appropriate. If the plan submitted
is approved, or approved after amendment, the
state board may designate a school district,
community junior college, an institution under
the control of the state board of regents or
a municipal university as an area vocational
school."
When functioning under the provisions of this statute, the
State Board is performing the legislative function of determining
whether an educational institution should be established. The
State Board is performing this function only pursuant to a del-
egation of legislative authority. Consequently, the State Board
has only such authority as has been conferred upon it by the
legislature. See, e.g., State ex rel. Dix v. State Board of
Education, 224 Kan. 38 (1978). Like any executive agency or
department to whom the legislature delegates administrative
authority, the State Board, legally, must confine its actions
within the perameters of the authority conferred by the legislature.
See, e.g., Cray v. Kennedy, 230 Kan. 663 (1982) and the cases
cited therein at 675-676. As was said in Cray, supra:
"The Kansas cases have consistently held,
whether in the case of administrative acts
or in the adoption of rules and regulations,
that administrative agencies must act within
the ambit of their specific statutory authority
and not beyond." 230 Kan. at 675.
Thus, the power of the State Board under the provisions of K.S.A.
72-4416 is only as broad as the specific statutory authority
conferred therein.
The matters that the State Board is to consider are adequately
detailed in the statute or necessarily implied therefrom. K.S.A.
72-4416 neither states expressly, nor implies, that the State
Board is to consider whether the legislature will provide the
financial support necessary to maintain additional area voca-
tional schools. Such speculation is beyond the authority
delegated to the State Board. Thus, the State Board, except
as an interested observer and a source of information and recom-
mendations, may not consider, upon review of an application for
an area vocational school, whether the legislature will provide
funding for an area vocational school which meets the legis-
lative and administrative criteria.
Therefore, based upon the above considerations, we are of the
opinion that the State Board of Education lacks the discretion
to reject a plan for the establishment of a proposed area vo-
cational school solely for the reason that the legislature
may not provide additional financial support therefor.
Very truly yours,
ROBERT T. STEPHAN
Attorney General of Kansas
Rodney J. Bieker
Assistant Attorney General
RTS:BJS:RJB:jm

Setzen Sie Ihre Recherche in ChatGPT oder Claude fort

Verbinden Sie Omnilex, um den Rechtskorpus über Ihren KI-Assistenten zu durchsuchen.