Kansas Attorney General Opinion 1983-045

1983-045Kanag

Gesamter Gesetzestext

April 4, 1983
ATTORNEY GENERAL OPINION NO. 83- 45
Jack Cramer, Chairman
Johnson County Extension Council
1205 East Santa Fe
Olathe, Kansas 66061
Re: Agriculture -- County Extension Councils; Boards
and Agents -- Budgets; Procedure for Approval
Synopsis: Participation by a board of county commissioners
in the preparation of the county extension coun-
cil's budget pursuant to K.S.A. 2-610 requires
the exercise of the board's judgment and discre-
tion. Therefore, this function is in the nature
of a public trust and not delegable to an agent
or employee of the board of county commissioners.
Unless agreement can be reached by consensus, a
vote must be taken by the individuals specified
in K.S.A. 2-610 to approve an extension council's
budget, and under this statute each county com-
missioner has one vote in the extension council's
budget approval process. Cited herein: K.S.A.
2-610.
*
Dear Mr. Cramer:
You have requested the opinion of this office regarding issues
relative to preparation and approval of the Johnson County
Cooperative Extension service budget. Specifically, you
inquire as follows:
"1) In reference to meeting and preparing the
budget, the County Commissioners have delegated
the responsibilities to their financial person-
nel to meet with the Executive Board and the
Director of Extension's representative. Does
the law require the County Commissioners to
meet with the Executive Board and the Director's
representative or may this responsibility be
delegated?
"2) Does the law provide for a vote to be
taken in the adoption of the budget?
"3) If the law provides for a vote to approve
the budget, does this mean that the County Com-
missioners have one vote, the Director's repre-
sentative have one vote, and the Chairman of
the Executive Board have one vote, or does
each County Commissioner have a vote, the
Director's representative have one vote, and
the Chairman of the Executive Board have one
vote?"
K.S.A. 2-610 provides as follows:
"On or before the thirteenth day of June each
year, the executive board of the county exten-
sion council shall file with the county com-
missioners in the office of the county clerk:
"(a) A list of current members of the county
extension council and its executive board: (b)
a certification of election of officers as pro-
vided in subsection (c) of K.S.A. 2-611: (c)
a certificate by the director of extension of
Kansas state university of agriculture and ap-
plied science that the county extension council
is properly functioning and entitled to re-
ceive the appropriations provided by law; and
(d) a budget prepared in cooperation with the
board of county commissioners and the director
of extension of Kansas state university of
agriculture and applied science for the ensu-
ing calendar year. The budget shall clearly
show all receipts from all sources. After the
approval of such budget by (1) the board of
county commissioners, (2) the director of ex-
tension of Kansas state university of agricul-
ture and applied science or the director's
duly authorized representative, and (3) the
chairperson of the executive board of the
county extension council, acting as a body,
the board of county commissioners shall then
make an appropriation and certify to the
county clerk the amount of tax necessary to
be levied on all tangible taxable property of
the county sufficient to provide a program of
county extension work and to pay a portion
of the principal and interest on bonds issued
under the authority of K.S.A. 12-1774, and
amendments thereto, by cities located in the
county, which levy shall not exceed the limi-
tation prescribed by K.S.A. 1982 Supp. 79-1947,
and amendments thereto."
Regarding your first inquiry, it is a well-settled proposi-
tion of law that
"the right of a county board to delegate its
authority depends on the nature of the duty
to be performed. Powers involving the exer-
cise of judgment and discretion are in the
nature of public trusts and cannot be delegated
to a committee or agent. Duties which are
purely ministerial and executive and do not in-
volve the exercise of discretion may be dele-
gated by the board to a committee or to an
agent, an employee, or a servant." (Footnotes
omitted.) 20 C.J.S. Counties §89.
In Kansas Milling Co. v. Ryan, 152 Kan. 137 (1940), the Kansas
Supreme Court cited Martin, Governor v. Ingham, 38 Kan. 641
(1888), for the proposition that
"[a] ministerial act is one which a public
officer or agent is required to perform on a
given state of facts, in a prescribed manner,
in obedience to the mandate of legal author-
ity, and without regard to his own judgment
or opinion concerning the propriety or impro-
priety of the act to be performed." 152 Kan.
at 140. (Emphasis added.)
See also: County of Los Angeles v. Nesvis, 41 Cal. Rpts.
918 (1965), Bowley v. City of Omaha, 149 N.W. 2d 417 (Neb.
1967), Levine v. Perry, 49 S.E. 2d 821 (GA. 1948), and Cf.
Kellett v. Fulton Co., 111 S.E. 2d 264 (Ga. 1959).
We think it to be axiomatic that the setting of budgets by
local governmental bodies is a discretionary, rather than
ministerial, function. Determination of the amount and pur-
pose for each item of the budget involves the exercise of
personal judgment, knowledge of the needs of the community
in question and the setting of priorities in the expenditure
of limited resources. Specifically, the preparation of the
extension council's budget involves the exercise of judgment
and discretion by those involved in the process. Moreover,
the language of K.S.A. 2-610 evinces a legislative intent
that boards of county commissioners be directly involved in
the budget preparation process. Therefore, such responsi-
bility is in the nature of a public trust and not amenable
to delegation.
Secondly, you inquire whether a vote is required in order to
adopt the extension council's budget. K.S.A. 2-610 is silent
as to the specific method by which approval of the budget is
to occur, except that the statute requires the participants
to act "as a body." In order for the individual participants
to reach a single consensus and "act as a body," they must
express their individual views in the form of a vote approv-
ing some particular course of action.
Your third inquiry concerns whether the budget approval method
specified in K.S.A. 2-610 allows the members of the board of
county commissioners to each have a vote or, alternatively,
only one vote which would represent the entire board of
county commissioners. K.S.A. 2-610 requires that the exten-
sion council's budget be approved by
"(1) the board of county commissioners, (2) the
director of extension of Kansas State Univer-
sity of agriculture and applied science or
the director's duly authorized representative,
and (3) the chairperson of the executive board
of the county extension council, acting as
a body . . . ." (Emphasis added.)
We believe that the phrase "acting as a body" contemplates
all individuals specified in the above-quoted portion of
K.S.A. 2-610 will meet and consider the extension council's
budgetary requirements and vote as individual members com-
prising the approving body. Therefore, in direct response
to your inquiry, we believe each county commissioner has one
vote in the extension council's budget approval process.
In conclusion, the participation of a board of county commis-
sioners in the preparation of the county extension council's
budget pursuant to K.S.A. 2-610 requires the exercise of the
board's judgment and discretion. Therefore, this function
is in the nature of a public trust and not delegable to an
agent or employee of the board of county commissioners. Fur-
ther, unless agreement can be reached by consensus, a vote
must be taken by the individuals specified in K.S.A. 2-610
to approve an extension council's budget, and under this
stattue, each county commissioner has one vote in the exten-
sion council's budget approval process.
Very truly yours,
ROBERT T. STEPHAN/ ATTORNEY GENERAL OF KANSAS
Robert Vinson Eye
Assistant Attorney General
RTS:BJS:RVE:hle

Setzen Sie Ihre Recherche in ChatGPT oder Claude fort

Verbinden Sie Omnilex, um den Rechtskorpus über Ihren KI-Assistenten zu durchsuchen.