Kansas Attorney General Opinion 1982-170

1982-170Kanag

Gesamter Gesetzestext

August 9, 1982
ATTORNEY GENERAL OPINION NO. 82- 170
Robert F. Lytle
Bennett, Lytle, Wetzler,
Winn & Martin
5100 West Ninety-Fifth Street
Prairie Village, Kansas 66208
Re: State Boards, Commissions and Authorities--Public
Employees Retirement System--Out-of-State Public
School Employment
Synopsis: For purposes of the Kansas Public Employees'
Retirement System, the phrase "public school
system of another state," as used in K.S.A.
74-4936a, includes public community colleges
and area vocational-technical schools, as well
as public elementary and secondary schools.
Thus, any person who is an employee of a partic-
ipating employer and a member of the Kansas
Public Employees' Retirement System, and who
was previously employed in a teaching position
with a public elementary or secondary school, or
a public community college or area vocational-
technical school of another state, may elect,
under and to the extent specified by K.S.A.
74-4936a, to purchase additional benefits under
the Kansas Public Employees' Retirement System.
Attorney General Opinion No. 77-16 is withdrawn.
Cited herein: K.S.A. 74-4931, 74-4932, 74-4936a.
Dear Mr. Lytle:
As counsel for Johnson County Community College, you ask
us to review Attorney General Opinion No. 77-16, which
concluded that an instructor at a Kansas community college,
who is a member of the Kansas Public Employees' Retirement
System (KPERS) and who was previously employed in a teaching
position with a community junior college of another state,
could not elect to purchase additional benefits for such out-
of-state employment, under the provisions of K.S.A. 74-4936a.
K.S.A. 74-4936a, in part relevant to your inquiry, provides:
"Any employee of a participating employer
who is a member of the Kansas public employees
retirement system, who was previously employed
in a teaching position with a public school
system of another state may elect to purchase
additional benefits for not to exceed ten (10)
years of such out-of-state public school
employment." (Emphasis added.)
The issue in controversy is whether community colleges
can be considered a part of the "public school system of
another state," so that persons, who now are members of
KPERS and who were previously employed as teachers in out-of-
state community colleges, may purchase additional benefits under
KPERS for such prior out-of-state employment.
It is not clear whether such out-of-state employment qualifies
a person to take advantage of the election prescribed in this
statute. Therefore, as was done in the prior opinion of this
office, resort must be made to the rules of statutory construc-
tion in order to ascertain and give effect to the legislative
intent.
We agree with the prior statement of this office that the
meaning of the term "public schools" depends upon the context
in which the term is employed. However, we disagree with the
conclusion reached in Attorney General Opinion No. 77-16, that
the context of K.S.A. 74-4936a, when considered in conjunction
with several rules of statutory construction, does not embrace
employment with a community college.
A brief statement of the history of K.S.A. 74-4936a is
appropriate and helpful. The provisions of this statute were
enacted in 1972 (L. 1972, ch. 305, §1) and were introduced in
the legislature as 1972 House Bill No. 1969 (1972 HB 1969).
These provisions have not been amended since the time of their
enactment.
The relation of the provisions of 1972 HB 1969 to other
statutes and the general purpose of those provisions is
reflected in the title of that act, which reads: "AN ACT
relating to the Kansas public employees retirement system;
authorizing the purchase of additional benefits for out-of-
state school employment." (Emphasis added.) As was stated
in Arredondo v. Duckwall Stores, Inc., 227 Kan. 840 (1980):
"Though the heading or title given
an act by the legislature forms no
part of the statute itself, State v.
Logan, 198 Kan. 211, 217, 424 P.2d
565 (1965), the language of the
title cannot be ignored as an aid
in determining legislative intent.
Baker v. Land Co., 62 Kan. 79, 82-83,
61 Pac. 412 (1900); Mitchell v.
State, 61 Kan. 779, 784, 60 Pac.
1055 (1900)." (Emphasis added.)
Id. at 846.
The title given the 1972 act, as well as the context of the
act itself, leads to the inescapable conclusion that the act
was designed to allow certain persons who are current members
of KPERS to purchase additional benefits under that system,
based upon out-of-state school employment.
Although the 1972 act does not define any term used therein,
the term "school employment" is defined in another statute
relating to KPERS. That statute is K.S.A. 74-4932, which
was enacted just two years prior to K.S.A. 74-4936a. We
believe these two statutes are in pari materia and should
be construed together in determining legislative intent. See,
e.g., Claffin v. Walsh, 212 Kan. 1 (1973) and Flowers v.
Marshall, 208 Kan. 900 (1972). Moreover, it is a well-settled
rule of statutory construction that, "[o]rdinarily, identical
words or terms used in different statutes on a specific
subject are interpreted to have the same meaning in the
absence of anything in the context to indicate a different
meaning was intended." Williams v. Board of Education, 198
Kan. 115, 124 (1967), quoted and followed in Callaway v. City
of Overland Park, 211 Kan. 646, 652 (1973).
We note that nothing in the context of K.S.A. 74-4936a
indicates an intent on the part of the legislature to give
the term "school employment" a different meaning from that
prescribed in K.S.A. 74-4932(8). In addition, we have reviewed
the minutes of the legislative committees that considered 1972
HB 1969, and find nothing in those minutes which indicates
that the term "school employment," as used in K.S.A. 74-4936a,
was to have a meaning different from that prescribed in K.S.A.
74-4932(8).
Finally, in determining the meaning of K.S.A. 74-4936a, we
believe we must invoke the rules of statutory construction
that, in determining legislative intent, it is essential to
consider statutes in existence when the statute involved was
enacted [see State, ex rel., v. Shawnee County Comm'rs, 159
Kan. 87, 90 (194T) and Motor Equipment Co. v. Winters, 146
Kan. 127 (1937)] and that the provisions of related statutes
should be construed together to make them consistent, harmonious
and sensible [see NEA-Wichita v. U.S.D. No. 259, 225 Kan. 395,
399 (1979)].
In 1970, the legislature . enacted a law (1970 House Bill No.
1971; L. 1970, ch. 326) under which the benefits of KPERS
were made available to certain governmental employees who had
not previously been entitled to those benefits. This 1970 act
is now codified at K.S.A. 74-4931 et sea. Under Section 1 of
that act (now K.S.A. 74-4931), the following governmental agencies
were made "eligible employers" for purposes of KPERS: "(1) Kansas
public school districts; (2) Kansas area vocational-technical
schools; [and] (3) Kansas community junior colleges." (Emphasis
added.)
In Section 2 of that 1970 act (now K.S.A. 74-4932), the
legislature prescribed definitions for various terms used
in the act, including definitions of the terms "employee"
and "school employment." The latter term was defined thusly:
"'School employment' means the employment
of a member when employed by an eligible
employer as specified in any of subsections
(1), (2) or (3) of K.S.A. 74-4931."
As subsections (1), (2) and (3) of K.S.A. 74-4931 make public
school districts, area vocational-technical schools, and
community junior colleges "eligible employers," the above-
quoted definition may be read so that "school employment"
means the employment of a member when employed by a public
school district, an area vocational-technical school, or a
community junior college. Thus, in 1970, the legislature made
the benefits of KPERS available to persons who were employed
by community junior colleges, and who met other eligibility
requirements under that act.
Then, in 1972, the legislature enacted the provisions of
K.S.A. 74-4936a, under a title reflecting that its provisions
were for the purpose of authorizing KPERS members to purchase
"additional benefits for out-of-state school employment."
(Emphasis added.)
We cannot believe the legislature, in 1970, extended the benefits
of KPERS to qualified employees of community junior colleges,
then, in 1972, intended to exclude those same employees from
the right to purchase additional benefits under that system.
While it is true that K.S.A. 74-4936a uses the phrase "public
school system of another state," and that, quite often, the
term "public schools" includes only elementary and secondary
schools, we believe the context in which the phrase is used
and the history of this legislation indicate the legislature
intended that phrase to include community colleges and area
vocational-technical schools. In our judgment, construing the
phrase "public school system of another state" in this manner
effectuates the purpose of the legislature for enacting the
provisions of K.S.A. 74-4936a, i.e., to allow the purchase of
additional benefits under KPERS by those persons which the
legislature had just recently brought under that system.
Thus, it is our opinion that, for purposes of the Kansas Public
Employees' Retirement System, the phrase "public school system
of another state," as used in K.S.A. 74-4936a, includes public
community colleges and area vocational-technical schools, as
well as public elementary and secondary schools. Thus, we also
are of the opinion that any person who is an employee of a partic-
ipating employer and a member of the Kansas Public Employees'
Retirement System, and who was previously employed in a teaching
position with a public elementary or secondary school, or a public
community college or area vocational-technical school of another
state, may elect, under and to the extent specified in K.S.A.
74-4936a, to purchase additional benefits under the Kansas
Public Employees' Retirement System.
Attorney General Opinion No. 77-16 is withdrawn.
Very truly yours,
ROBERT T. STEPHAN
Attorney General of Kansas
Rodney J f Bieker
Assistant Attorney General
RTS:BJS:RJB:jm

Setzen Sie Ihre Recherche in ChatGPT oder Claude fort

Verbinden Sie Omnilex, um den Rechtskorpus über Ihren KI-Assistenten zu durchsuchen.