Kansas Attorney General Opinion 1982-160

1982-160Kanag

Gesamter Gesetzestext

July 26, 1982
ATTORNEY GENERAL OPINION NO. 82-160
The Honorable John Carlin
Governor of Kansas
2nd Floor, State Capitol
Topeka, Kansas 66612
Re: State Departments; Public Officers, Employees --
Department of Administration -- Application of
Allotment System
Synopsis: K.S.A. 75-3722 provides for an allotment system to
assure that expenditures for any particular fiscal
year will not exceed the available resources of
the general fund or any special revenue fund for
that fiscal year. In determining whether an allot-
ment system is to be imposed, the secretary of
administration may utilize the revenue estimates
of the director of the budget.
An allotment system may be imposed on any appro-
priation from any fund for which the allotment
system is established, including appropriations
to fund statutorily-prescribed state aid programs,
and it need not be applied equally or on a pro
rata basis to all such appropriations. However,
an allotment system has no application to a sta-
tutorily-prescribed transfer of money from one
fund in the state treasury to another fund in the
state treasury, since such transfer does not con-
stitute an appropriation. Nor may an allotment
system be imposed in any fiscal year for the pur-
pose of increasing the estimated ending balance
of any such fund for that fiscal year or for the
purpose of controlling temporary cash shortages.
At the point in time the secretary of administra-
tion notifies a state agency as to the imposition
of an allotment system on such agency's appropria-
tions, such agency is to be regarded as subject
to the allotment system, for purposes of K.S.A.
75-3723, and the director of the budget is thereby
empowered under K.S.A. 75-3723(1) to require such
agency to furnish information regarding its esti-
mated revenues and expenses. Cited herein: K.S.A.
75-3715, K.S.A. 1981 Supp. 75-3718, K.S.A. 75-3722,
75-3723, 75-3724, 75-3725a, 77-136, Kan. Const.,
Art. 2, §24.
Dear Governor Carlin:
You have requested our response to several specific questions
regarding the provisions of K.S.A. 75-3722 to 75-3725a, inclu-
sive. In general, you have requested our opinion regarding
the "management prerogatives and procedures available to
assure fiscal integrity of the State General Fund" pursuant
to these statutes.
Particularly pertinent to your inquiry is K.S.A. 75-3722,
which provides for an allotment system applicable to legisla-
tive appropriations from the state general fund and special
revenue funds. It states as follows:
"An allotment system will be applicable to the
expenditure of the resources of any state
agency, under rules and regulations estab-
lished as provided in K.S.A. 75-3706, only if
in the opinion of the secretary of administra-
tion on the advice of the director of the bud-
get, the use of an allotment plan is necessary
or beneficial to the state. In making this
determination the secretary of administration
shall take into consideration all pertinent
factors including (1) available resources,
(2) current spending rates, (3) work loads,
(4) new activities, especially any proposed
activities not covered in the agency's request
to the governor and the legislature for appro-
priations, (5) the minimum current needs of
each agency, (6) requests for deficiency appro-
priations in prior fiscal years, (7) unexpended
and unencumbered balances, and (8) revenue
collection rates and prospects.
"Whenever for any fiscal year it appears that
the resources of the general fund or any spe-
cial revenue fund are likely to be insufficient
to cover the appropriations made against such
general fund or special revenue fund, the sec-
retary of administration, on the advice of the
director of the budget, shall, in such manner
as he or she may determine, inaugurate the
allotment system so as to assure that expen-
ditures for any particular fiscal year will
not exceed the available resources of the gen-
eral fund or any special revenue fund for that
fiscal year. The allotment system shall not
apply to the legislature or to the courts or
their officers and employees. Agencies af-
fected by decisions of the secretary of admin-
istration under this section shall be notified
in writing at least thirty (30) days before
such decisions may become effective and any
affected agency may, by written request ad-
dressed to the governor within ten (10) days
after such notice, ask for a review of the
decision by the finance council. The finance
council shall hear appeals and render a deci-
sion within twenty (20) days after the gover-
nor receives requests for such hearings."
All of the questions you have submitted for our considera-
tion require an interpretation of various provisions of the
above-quoted statute. Our interpretations, of course, must
be guided by established principles of statutory construction,
the cardinal rule of which is that the purpose and intent of
the legislature governs when that intent can be ascertained
from the statutes. Southeast Kansas Landowners Ass'n v. Kansas
Turnpike Auth., 224 Kan. 357, 367 (1978). It also is an
accepted rule that "[t]he historical background and changes
made in a statute are to be considered by the court in deter-
mining legislative intent for the purpose of statutory con-
struction." Callaway v. City of Overland Park, 211 Kan. 646,
650 (1973).
With these principles in mind, and before considering your
specific questions, it is appropriate to review the legisla-
tive history and background of K.S.A. 75-3722. It was enacted
as section 22 of 1953 Senate Bill No. 68 (L. 1953, ch. 375,
§22), which created various state agencies (including the
state department of administration) and provided for coordin-
ating their respective functions and duties with respect to
"administering public finance." Other than the editorial
changes made by the Revisor of Statutes (see K.S.A. 77-136),
primarily as a consequence of the 1972 act reorganizing the
department of administration (L. 1972, ch. 332), this statute
has remained unchanged since its enactment. However, we note
that the provisions of this statute conferring powers upon
the state finance council were held unconstitutional as a
violation of the separation of powers doctrine in State, ex
rel., v. Bennett, 219 Kan. 285, 295, 298 (1976), where it
also was determined that such powers devolved upon the governor.
Id. at 301.
1953 Senate Bill No. 68 was originally Legislative Council
Bill No. 13, which was submitted to the 1953 Legislature to
implement, in part, the Kansas Legislative Council's recom-
mendations emanating from a two-year study of consolidating
the state's "fiscal,, accounting, purchasing, personnel and
budget affairs into a single state administrative department."
Report and Recommendations of the Kansas Legislative Council,
Part I -- Regular, submitted to the 1953 Legislature (Proposal
No. 21), pp. 108-189. Section 22 of the 1953 enactment was
identical to the corresponding section of the Council's bill
and, as previously indicated, is identical for all substantial
purposes to K.S.A. 75-3722.
With its report and recommendations to the 1953 Legislature on
Proposal No. 21, the Legislative Council submitted other
"available information" to the appropriate legislative commit-
tees. Id. at 111. Of pertinence is Fiscal Reorganization,
Publication No. 183 of the Kansas Legislative Council's Research
Department, which was prepared at the direction of the Legis-
lative Council committee to which Proposal No. 21 was assigned.
Among other things, this publication provides an analysis of
the provisions of Legislative Council Bill No. 13, including
the allotment system authorized by section 22 thereof. Hence,
considering the identity of section 22 and K.S.A. 75-3722,
this publication's analysis is pertinent to our consideration
of the legislative intent and purpose underlying the current
statute. Our reliance on this publication in providing insight
as to legislative intent is appropriate in light of the follow-
ing statement in Harris v. Shanahan, 192 Kan. 629 (1964):
"In 1933 the legislature created the legisla-
tive council to deal with questions of state-
wide interest and to prepare a legislative
program in the form of bills for the consider-
ation of the legislature. To assist it in
carrying out its duties, the council estab-
lished its own research department. (G. S.
1949, 46-308.) The research department of the
council is an arm of the legislature itself.
In assisting in the legislative work, the re-
search department is akin to the function of
a legislative or a code revision commission,
reports of which may be considered in constru-
ing a statute. (State, ex rel., v. Davis,
Governor, 116 Kan. 663, 229 Pac. 757; 82 C.J.S.,
Statutes, §356, p. 757.)" Id. at 637.
Regarding the proposed allotment system, the Legislative
Council's Research Department stated:
"An allotment system means that appropriations
made by the legislature do not become avail-
able to a state agency until that agency sub-
mits to the central department a work program
for the three months of the ensuing quarter,
explaining how much of its appropriation is
needed in that period and justifying the re-
quest. This request must be approved by the
central agency before any expenditures are
authorized thereunder. The central agency
may raise questions concerning the program
and may decrease the amount requested.
"Under the current bill, such a system would be
applied only if, in the opinion of the execu-
tive director on the advice of the budget di-
rector, the use of such allotment plan is deemed
necessary or beneficial to the state. The bill
specifies the factors which must be taken into
consideration, including, among others, the
rate of spending, to ascertain that the agency
will have enough money for the remaining quar-
ters; the history of the agency on requests
for deficiency appropriations in prior years;
and consideration as to whether the revenue
collections are meeting the estimates and
whether any deficit might be expected because
of inadequate revenues. In the latter event,
in any fiscal year, the bill instructs the
executive director to inaugurate an allotment
system to be sure expenditures for that year
will not exceed available resources of the
general fund or of any special revenue fund.
Each agency affected by such a system would
have written notice at least 30 days in ad-
vance and could ask for review of its situa-
tion and requests by the finance council."
(Emphasis added.) Fiscal Reorganization,
supra at 33, 34.
With respect to the functions and duties of the budget divi-
sion of the department of administration proposed by Legis-
lative Council Bill No. 13, the Research Department's publi-
cation also addresses the allotment system, as follows:
"Allotment System. Most states with a reor-
ganized fiscal agency provide that the appro-
priations made by the legislature must be
allotted to the agencies from quarter to quar-
ter, on statements from the agencies of their
work programs showing what portion of the ap-
propriation they will need during the coming
quarter. Under the proposed Kansas plan no
allotment system is required except under spe-
cial conditions. It would be permissible,
under regulations approved by the finance coun-
cil, only when deemed necessary and [or] bene-
ficial by the executive director on advice of
the budget director.
"In any fiscal year where it appeared that the
resources of the general fund or any special
revenue fund were likely to be insufficient to
cover the appropriations, the executive direc-
tor, to prevent deficits and keep the expendi-
tures within the amount of money actually avail-
able, is required to inaugurate an allotment
system. It might also be used where agencies
appear to be expending at a more rapid quarterly
rate than the appropriation would permit or
where the agency has had a history of requests
for deficiency appropriations in prior years,
to show that such agencies will be able to
keep within the funds available to them on an
annual basis.
"Agencies affected would have a 30-day notice
and opportunity for review of the decision by
the finance council. No appropriation made
to a state agency subject to an allotment sys-
tem would become available for expenditures
until the allotment had been approved, in-
creased or decreased under the procedure indi-
cated above." (Emphasis added.) Fiscal Reor-
ganization, supra at 22, 23.
We believe the foregoing excerpts from Fiscal Reorganization,
supra, provide a general context for the consideration of
your inquiries, and will assist in specific instances in as-
certaining the legislature's intended purpose.
One further general comment is necessary. We note that K.S.A.
75-3722 contemplates the use of an allotment system under two
general circumstances. The first paragraph of the statute
addresses the permissive use of an allotment system when it
is "necessary or beneficial to the state," whereas the first
portion of the statute's last paragraph requires inauguration
of the allotment system "[w]henever for any fiscal year it
appears that the resources of the general fund or any special
revenue fund are likely to be insufficient to cover the appro-
priations made against such general fund or special revenue
fund." Although your letter does not specifically so state,
it is apparent from the context of your inquiry that your
questions regarding an allotment system pertain, for the most
part, to the latter type, i.e., an allotment system which is
required to be inaugurated because of an estimated deficiency
in the state's financial resources. Hence, our responses to
your inquiries will be framed within this context, unless
otherwise indicated to the contrary.
Your first question regarding K.S.A. 75-3722 is whether the
allotment system may be applied "only to the extent necessary
to avoid a potential deficit ending balance or may it be
applied in a manner that increases the estimated State General
Fund ending balance to a level deemed necessary or beneficial
to the State."
In our judgment, an allotment system may not be applied for
the purpose of increasing the estimated ending balance of the
general fund for the current fiscal year. The allotment sys-
tem required to be instituted is of limited duration, being
applicable only during a particular fiscal year, and in the
language of the statute, it is intended "to assure that ex-
penditures for any particular fiscal year will not exceed the
available resources of the general fund . . . for that fiscal
year." We believe this plain and unambiguous language evi-
dences a clear legislative intent that such required allot-
ment system is intended only to insure there is an equation
between the resources of the general fund and the authorized
expenditures from said fund in a particular fiscal year. As
noted in Fiscal Reorganization, supra, it is intended "to pre-
vent deficits."
We are cognizant that this statute vests rather broad discre-
tionary powers in the secretary of administration. However,
the authority to determine what is "necessary or beneficial
to the state" does not, in our judgment, permit the secretary
of administration to deviate from the statutory purposes of
an allotment system. Rather, such language provides discre-
tion as to "the use of an allotment system," i.e., it provides
discretion as to when it is "necessary or beneficial to the
state" to impose an allotment system on one or more state
agencies. As will be discussed more fully with respect to
your inquiry concerning K.S.A. 75-3725a, we believe that,
even where an allotment system is instituted at the discre-
tion of the secretary of administration, its only purpose is
to insure that the affected state agencies operate within the
fiscal constraints of appropriations made to such agencies in
a particular fiscal year. It is toward the achievement of
this objective that the statute provides discretion regarding
the implementation of an allotment system.
It must be recognized that, when the secretary of administra-
tion establishes an allotment system pursuant to K.S.A. 75-3722,
he is exercising a delegated legislative function. Without
question, "the appropriation of money and the setting of limi-
tations on expenditures by state executive agencies constitutes
[sic] an exercise of legislative power." State, ex rel., v.
Bennett, supra at 300. Of course, "the legislature may dele-
gate a legislative function when constitutional authority for
the delegation is present and the statutory delegation is cir-
cumscribed by sufficient legislative guidelines to cover the
nature and extent of the legislative function intended to be
delegated." State, ex rel., v. State Board of Education, 215
Kan. 551, 554 (1974).
These principles are extremely pertinent in evaluating the
extent of the secretary of administration's authority under
the statute. If such authority is construed as including
the discretion to determine the purposes for which an allot-
ment system may be used in addition to the purposes stated
therein, we believe such delegation of authority would be
overbroad, since there are no parameters prescribed by this
statute to circumscribe the exercise of such authority.
Hence, we are constrained from implying any such authority.
Not only would the implication of such a broad, unfettered
power raise serious constitutional questions as to the pro-
priety of such delegated authority, but we are also mindful
that a power not expressly granted should not be implied un-
less it is clearly necessary for the exercise of the powers
expressly granted. As stated in Murray v. State Board of
Regents, 194 Kan. 686, 689, 690 (1965):
"Governmental agencies are creatures of the
legislature, and can exercise only such pow-
ers as are expressly conferred by law and
those necessary to make effective the powers
expressly conferred. (State, ex rel., v. City
of Kansas City, 181 Kan. 870, 317 P.2d 806;
State, ex rel., v. City of Overland Park, 192
Kan. 654, 391 P.2d 128)."
In our judgment, the authority conferred by K.S.A. 75-3722,
to establish an allotment system to assure that expenditures
from the general fund will not exceed the general fund's avail-
able resources for a particular fiscal year, does not carry
with it the implication of authority to apply the allotment
system for the purpose of increasing the general fund's ending
balance for that fiscal year to a level deemed necessary or
beneficial to the state. Such implied power is not necessary
to the exercise of the power expressly conferred. It is
unnecessary for the protection of the general fund's resources
for the fiscal year in which the allotment system is imposed.
The "resources" of the general fund for a particular fiscal
year consist of the receipts of the general fund during that
year, plus the moneys remaining in said fund at the end of
the preceding fiscal year. Accordingly, moneys remaining in
the general fund at the end of the fiscal year in which an
allotment system is instituted are resources of the general
fund for the next ensuing fiscal year. Thus, if an allotment
plan were designed to increase the projected ending balance
of the general fund at the close of the fiscal year in which
the allotment system is applied, it would be enhancing the
resources of the general fund for the next ensuing fiscal
year, rather than protecting that fund's resources for the
current fiscal year, as the statute requires.
Therefore, it is our opinion that an allotment system, which
is required under K.S.A. 75-3722 in a particular fiscal year,
cannot be instituted for the purpose of increasing the esti-
mated ending balance of the general fund for that fiscal year
to a level which the secretary of administration deems neces-
sary or beneficial to the state.
You next inquire:
"May allotments to the various executive branch
agencies be applied equally to each State Gen-
eral Fund appropriation or may the allotments
vary as to percentages of reductions among the
various state agency General Fund appropria-
tion or otherwise selectively applied to cer-
tain agencies?"
We find nothing in K.S.A. 75-3722 which would compel the
conclusion that an allotment system must be applied equally
or on a pro rata basis to all appropriations from the general
fund. To the contrary, when an allotment system is initiated
at the discretion of the secretary of administration, the
language of the statute clearly permits the selective appli-
cation of the allotment system. The statute authorizes its
application "to the expenditure of the resources of any state
agency," which we believe permits the use of an allotment
system that is applicable only to the appropriations made to
a single state agency. And from information provided us by
the Legislative Research Department, we are aware of two
prior instances in which an allotment plan has been so applied.
Similarly, even where an allotment system is mandated to
protect the fiscal integrity of the general fund, the statute
provides that such system be inaugurated by the secretary of
administration "in such manner as he or she may determine . .
so as to assure that expenditures for any particular fiscal
year will not exceed the available resources of the general
fund . . . for that fiscal year." By this plain and unambi-
guous language the legislature has vested the secretary of
administration with the authority and responsibility for deter-
mining the manner in which an allotment system can best be
applied. As long as such discretion is not abused and the
allotment system achieves the statute's overriding purpose of
insuring the equation of the general fund's resources and
authorized expenditures therefrom, the details of such system
are to be prescribed by the secretary of administration.
You also have asked whether the revenue estimates of the
director of the budget are to be used "in determining whether
the resources of the State General Fund are likely to be insuf-
ficent to cover the appropriations made for the fiscal year."
This question apparently is prompted by the fact that, since
1974, "concensus" estimates of general fund revenues have
been made by a selected group of state officers and employees.
This group was convened at the request of the Legislative
Budget Committee at the conclusion of its consideration of
1974 Interim Study Proposal No. 55 -- General Fund Appropria-
tions. (See Reports of Special Committees to the 1975 Kansas
Legislature, pp. 1073, 1074.) We understand that such concen-
sus estimates have been accepted and generally relied upon by
the governor and legislative leaders alike. Nonetheless,
there is no statutory basis for such concensus estimates, and
we must premise our response on the provisions of K.S.A. 75-3722
which require that the secretary of administration obtain "the
advice of the director of the budget" in determining whether
to initiate an allotment system. In light of the director of
the budget's statutory responsibilities regarding the estima-
tion of revenues [K.S.A. 75-3715(1), K.S.A. 1981 Supp. 75-3718(a)],
we believe K.S.A. 75-3722 permits the secretary of administration
to utilize the revenue estimates developed by the director of
the budget in determining the necessity of an allotment system.
Your fourth question concerns the provisions of K.S.A. 75-3723
and the requirement in K.S.A. 75-3722 that
"[a]gencies affected by decisions of the sec-
retary of administration under this section
shall be notified in writing at least thirty
(30) days before such decisions may become
effective . . . ."
K.S.A. 75-3723 provides in pertinent part as follows:
"The director of the budget shall obtain from
each state agency when subject to the allot-
ment system as provided in this act [L. 1953,
ch. 375], and it shall be the duty of the ad-
ministrative head of such agency, to furnish
upon forms prescribed by the director of the
budget and in such detail and with such supple-
mental and supporting information as the di-
rector of the budget may require, the follow-
ing:
"(1) Thirty (30) days (or at such other time
as requested by the director of the budget)
before the beginning of the fiscal year, or
before the effective date the agency is re-
quired to come under the allotment system, if
it is different than the fiscal year, a state-
ment of the funds estimated to become avail-
able, together with classifications of anti-
cipated expenditures by month, quarter, semi-
annual or annual periods as determined." (Em-
phasis added.)
In light of the foregoing requirements of these two statutes,
you ask:
"May the thirty day requirement (or such other
time period requested by the Director of the
Budget) provided for in K.S.A. 75-3723 run con-
currently with time requirements provided for in
K.S.A. 75-3722 or does the procedure prescribed
in K.S.A. 75-3723 follow only after an allot-
ment system is established under the provisions
of K.S.A. 75-3722?"
The decision to impose an allotment system is to be made by
the secretary of administration pursuant to K.S.A. 75-3722.
However, any decision made by the secretary of administration
pursuant to that section will not be effective unless agencies
affected thereby have received at least 30 days' written
notice of such decision. On the other hand, the emphasized
portion of the first paragraph of the above-quoted provisions
of K.S.A. 75-3723 restrict the application of this statute to
state agencies which are "subject to the allotment system."
The thrust of your inquiry, then, is whether a state agency,
which has been notified of the secretary of administration's
decision to impose an allotment system on that agency's appro-
priations, is "subject to the allotment system" until the
decision to impose such system has become effective.
In our judgment, the legislature intended that an agency be
regarded as subject to the allotment system, for the purposes
of K.S.A. 75-3723, at the point in time the agency is notified
of the secretary of administration's decision to impose the
allotment system on that agency. To ascertain such legisla-
tive intent, we have utilized the well - established principle
of statutory construction that, in determining legislative
intent, statutes in pari materia should be construed together
so as to harmonize their respective provisions, if reasonably
possible to do so. Callaway v. City of Overland Park, 211
Kan. 646, 650 (1973) - . It deserves no discussion to note that
K.S.A. 75-3722 and 75-3723 are statutes in pari materia. Thus,
we have considered their respective objectives in concert for
the purpose of reconciling any inconsistencies, if reasonably
possible to do so.
Under K.S.A. 75-3722, the decision to impose an allotment sys-
tem on a state agency does not become effective for at least
thirty days after the agency is notified of such decision.
Prior to such decision becoming effective, this statute pro-
vides for an appeal of such decision as follows:
"[A]ny affected agency may, by written request
addressed to the governor within ten (10) days
after such notice, ask for a review of the de-
cision by the . . . [governor]. The . . .
[governor] shall hear appeals and render a
decision within twenty (20) days after the
governor receives requests for such hearings."
(Deletions and bracketed material reflect de-
cision in State, ex rel., v. Bennett, supra,
that these powers devolve upon the governor.)
Obviously, any decision by the governor regarding an agency's
appeal pursuant to the foregoing provisions must take into
consideration that agency's estimated revenues and expenses
during the time the allotment system will be in effect. Such
information is required to be furnished the director of the
budget pursuant to the previously-quoted provisions of K.S.A.
75-3723(1). Thus, an unreasonable result would obtain if it
were determined that these requirements are not applicable
to an agency until the decision to impose the allotment system
had become effective, i.e., until after the time for an appeal
of this decision had passed.
In addition, we note that K.S.A. 75-3723(1) contemplates that
information regarding the agency's budgeted revenues and ex-
penses be provided "[t]hirty (30) days (or at such other time
as requested by the director of the budget) . . . before the
effective date the agency is required to come under the allot-
ment system." (Emphasis added.)
For these reasons, then, it is our opinion that, at the point
in time the secretary of administration notifies a state
agency as to the imposition of an allotment system on such
agency's appropriations, such agency is to be regarded as
subject to the allotment system, for purposes of K.S.A. 75-3723.
At that point in time, therefore, the director of the budget
is empowered under K.S.A. 75-3723(1) to require such agency
to furnish information regarding its estimated revenues and
expenses.
Next, you inquire whether an allotment system may be applied
to statutorily prescribed state aid programs. In framing
your inquiry, you have cited several examples of statutorily
prescribed state aid programs, including school district equal-
ization act payments, local ad valorem tax reduction fund
payments, city-county revenue sharing fund payments and others,
all of which depend upon general fund resources. The examples
you cited are only a few of the host of similar local govern-
ment aid programs which the legislature has established.
According to information provided this office by the Legisla-
tive Research Department, there are 34 such local aid programs
which will distribute approximately 693.3 million dollars to
various units of local government during Fiscal Year 1983.
All such aid is derived directly or indirectly from resources
of the general fund.
Considering the number of these local aid programs, it is
apparent that we cannot, in this opinion, evaluate the appli-
cation of an allotment system to each of these statutory pro-
grams. Of necessity, our response must be limited to a gen-
eral consideration of the scope and extent of an allotment
system.
In our judgment, when an allotment system is required to be
inaugurated by K.S.A. 75-3722, such allotment system may be
imposed on any appropriation from any fund for which the allot-
ment system is established. As previously noted, this statute
requires that an allotment system be established "[w]henever
for any fiscal year it appears that the resources of the gen-
eral fund or any special revenue fund are likely to be insuf-
ficient to cover the appropriations made against such general
fund or special revenue fund." (Emphasis added.) We also
note that K.S.A. 75-3724 provides as follows:
"No appropriations to any state agency subject
to the allotment system as provided in this
act shall become available for expenditure un-
til an allotment has been applied for on forms
prescribed by the budget director and has been
approved, increased or decreased and funds
allotted as hereinbefore or hereinafter pro-
vided." (Emphasis added.)
It is clear from these statutes the legislature has required
the establishment of a system for allotting the appropriations
made to an agency from any fund, when it is determined that
the resources of such fund in any fiscal year will likely
be insufficient to cover such appropriations. In our judgment,
the allotment system so established may apply to any such
appropriation made to that agency. The allotment system sta-
tutes make no distinction as to the types of appropriations
which are subject to allotment, and we find nothing in the
previously-quoted statements of the Legislative Council Re-
search Department in Fiscal Reorganization, supra, to indi-
cate that the 1953 Legislature intended any such distinction.
Hence, we must conclude that an allotment system may be made
applicable to a general fund appropriation of moneys which
are to be distributed to units of local government.
An appropriation, of course, is an authorization to expend
moneys from a fund in the state treasury. Before any moneys
may be withdrawn from the state treasury, there must be a
"specific appropriation made by law." Kan. Const., Art. 2,
§24. This constitutional provision was defined in State, ex
rel., v. Fadely, 180 Kan. 652 (1957), as follows:
"The term 'specific appropriation made by law'
may be defined as an authority of the legisla-
ture, given at the proper time and in legal
form to the proper officials, to apply a dis-
tinctly specified sum from out of the state
treasury, in a given period, for a specified
objective or demand against the state. In
general terms a 'specific appropriation made
by law' is the act of setting money apart for-
mally or officially for a special use or pur-
pose by the legislature in clear and unequivo-
cal terms in a duly enacted law (42 Am.Jur.
Public Funds, §43, p. 747; 81 C.J.S., States,
§163, p. 1207, §164b, p. 1215 and §164c, p.1217)."
Id. at 661.
The foregoing discussion is pertinent to your inquiry for two
reasons. First, it adds further support to our conclusion
that appropriations of moneys for aid to local governments
may be subject to an allotment system. Even though the appro-
priated funds are distributed to units of local government,
they are appropriated first, as noted in Fadely, supra, "to
the proper officials," i.e., they are appropriated to a state
agency. For this reason, and absent any limiting statutory
language, we find no basis for narrowly construing the allot-
ment system statutes as having application only to appropria-
tions made to an agency for the operations of that agency.
The second reason for discussing the nature of an appropria-
tion is that it is our opinion there are certain local aid
programs creating claims upon the resources of the general
fund that are immune from an allotment system. These programs
are immune because their claims against general fund moneys
are not made pursuant to appropriations. Rather, they are
made by virtue of statutorily-prescribed transfers of money
from the general fund to another fund. Such "demand transfers"
do not constitute appropriations. An appropriation is an
authorization granted by the legislature to designated public
officials to withdraw from the state treasury, within a par-
ticular period of time, a stated sum of money for a specific
purpose. Thus, a transfer of money from one fund in the
state treasury to another fund in the state treasury does
not satisfy this definitional criteria. Accordingly, we
adhere to the conclusion we reached in Attorney General Opin-
ion No. 81-82, that "fa] transfer of moneys within the trea-
sury lacks the essential withdrawal authorization and does
not, in our judgment, constitute an appropriation." Id. at 6.
The Legislative Research Department has identified for us
six funds in the state treasury which, in whole or in part,
are used to provide aid to local governments and are funded
in whole or in part by demand transfers from the general fund,
viz., the Local Ad Valorem Tax Reduction Fund, Kansas Public
Employees Retirement Fund, School District Income Tax Fund,
County and City Revenue Sharing Fund, Solar Energy Property
Tax Refund Fund and County Inheritance Tax Fund. In our judg-
ment, therefore, even though each of these is funded by a
transfer of general fund moneys, the claim made by each of
these funds upon the general fund's resources is not subject
to restriction by an allotment system. These statutory demand
transfers do not constitute appropriations which are subject
to allotment.
Finally, you have asked whether an allotment system may be
"invoked to reduce State General Fund expenditures in order
to allay a temporary cash shortage." As you note, K.S.A.
75-3725a addresses this matter directly, providing in per-
tinent part as follows:
"Whenever it shall appear that the estimated
resources for any fiscal year in the state
general fund are sufficient to meet in full
the estimated expenditures for that fiscal
year, but that the estimated resources in the
state general fund in any month or months of
such fiscal year are insufficient to meet in
full the estimated expenditures for such month
or months, the director of the budget shall so
inform the secretary of administration. Un-
less such secretary finds that the estimates
of the director of the budget are grossly in-
correct, such secretary shall inform the
governor of the report of the director of the
budget, and thereupon the governor shall call
a meeting of the state finance council within
forty-eight (48) hours after receiving such
notice for the sole purpose of implementing
provisions of-this act. At such meeting the
director of the budget shall inform the state
finance council of the facts which caused the
meeting to be called and together with the
director of accounts and reports shall report
upon the finances of the state relevant to the
call of such meeting, including the availabil-
ity of cash in state bank accounts to meet all
the obligations of the state as the same become
due. Thereupon the state finance council may
by unanimous vote order the pooled money in-
vestment board to issue a written certificate
of indebtedness subject to redemption from the
state general fund not later than sixty (60)
days after the date of issuance thereof or on
the June 30 next following the issuance of
such certificate of indebtedness, whichever is
the sooner." (Emphasis added.)
We agree with your observation that this statute is designed
"to treat extraordinary cash flow demands on the State General
Fund." The emphasized portion of the above-quoted provisions
thereof clearly restrict the application of this section to
those times when the resources of the general fund "are suffi-
cient to meet in full the estimated expenditures for that
fiscal year." Thus, at those times when this section may be
utilized, K.S.A. 75-3722 would not require the inauguration
of an allotment system, since such requirement is effectual
only when general fund resources are insufficient to cover
appropriations. Thus, we assume the thrust of your inquiry
is whether, under the discretionary authority vested in the
secretary of administration by K.S.A. 75-3722, an allotment
system for the purpose of alleviating general fund cash flow
problems might be established.
The secretary of administration is authorized by K.S.A. 75-3722
to apply an allotment system whenever, in his opinion and on
the advice of the director of the budget, "the use of an allot-
ment plan is necessary or beneficial to the state." In formu-
lating his opinion, the secretary of administration is required
to "take into consideration all pertinent factors," including
the eight factors listed in the statute. Our review of these
statutorily prescribed considerations reveals an overriding
legislative purpose that the allotment system be used to in-
sure that a specified state agency or agencies operate within
the fiscal constraints of appropriations made to such agencies
in a particular fiscal year. This conclusion is consistent
with the explanation of these provisions offered in Fiscal
Reorganization, supra, which indicated that an allotment sys-
tem might be used
"where agencies appear to be expending at a
more rapid quarterly rate than the appropria-
tion would permit or where the agency has had
a history of requests for deficiency appropri-
ations in prior years, to show that such agen-
cies will be able to keep within the funds
available to them on an annual basis." (Em-
phasis added.) Id. at 23.
Thus, we do not believe that an allotment system may be imposed
for the purpose of controlling cash flow. A "temporary cash
shortage," as you have described the problem, presupposes that
sufficient moneys will be available to fully fund the appro-
priation over the duration of the fiscal year, but that the
resources of the fund are less than the anticipated expendi-
tures from the fund during a particular portion of the fiscal
year. However, as previously noted, an allotment system is
intended to insure an equation of the fund's resources and
appropriations from the fund on an annual basis. It is intended
to prevent a deficit in the fund at the end of the fiscal year.
This objective is separate and distinct from the objective of
controlling cash flow, and it is our opinion, therefore, that
an allotment system may not be imposed for the purpose of
alleviating a temporary cash shortage.
We are supported in this conclusion by the enactment of K.S.A.
75-3725a (L. 1970, ch. 363, §1). It was enacted subsequent
to K.S.A. 75-3722, and provides a specific remedy for temporary
cash shortages. We think it fair to suggest that the enact-
ment of K.S.A. 75-3725a reflects legislative recognition that
the allotment procedure does not provide a means for controll-
ing cash flow.
In passing, it should be noted that the provisions of K.S.A.
75-3725a cannot be utilized simultaneously with the inaugura-
tion of an allotment system, because of the contradictory prem-
ises necessary for implementing these extraordinary remedies.
However, once an allotment system is in place and it can be
determined that the resources of the general fund will be
'sufficient to meet in full the estimated expenditures for
that fiscal year" under the allotment system, we believe the
provisions of K.S.A. 75-3725a may be invoked to alleviate tem-
porary cash shortages.
Very truly yours,
ROBERT T. STEPHAN
ATTORNEY GENERAL OF KANSAS
W. Robert Alderson
First Deputy Attorney General
RTS:WRA:hle

Setzen Sie Ihre Recherche in ChatGPT oder Claude fort

Verbinden Sie Omnilex, um den Rechtskorpus über Ihren KI-Assistenten zu durchsuchen.