Kansas Attorney General Opinion 1982-130

1982-130Kanag

Gesamter Gesetzestext

June 17, 1982
ATTORNEY GENERAL OPINION NO. 82-130
Thomas J. Toepfer
111 West 13th Street
P. 0. Box 579
Hays, Kansas 67601
A
Re: Drainage arid Levies -- Watershed Districts --
Open Meetings of Directors; Exception for Attorney-
Client Discussions
Synopsis: Pursuant to K.S.A. 24-1212, a watershed district
board may not go into executive session at any time.
However, as a watershed district is also governed
by the terms of the Open Meetings Act, K.S.A.
75-4317 et seq., a conflict arises between the
two enactments, .in that the latter permits execu-
tive sessions for certain specified purposes.
Among these purposes is consultation with an attor-
ney which is privileged under the attorney-client
relationship. As the two enactments cannot be
reconciled, that portion of K.S.A. 24-1212 pro-
scribing such executive sessions is repealed by
implication. Cited herein: K.S.A. 24-1212, K.S.A.
1981 Supp. 75-4318, 75-4319.
Dear Mr. Toepfer:
As counsel for Wet Walnut Creek Joint Watershed District No.
58, you request our opinion concerning the ability of the
district's board of directors to meet in executive session.
Specifically, you inquire whether the effect of K.S.A. 24-1212
is to prevent the board from meeting in such closed session
with you, as board attorney, to discuss matters that would
otherwise be confidential communications under the attorney-
client privilege. You inform us that two lawsuits involving
the board which concern a condemnation of land are pending
at this time.
The watershed district in question is organized pursuant to
K.S.A. 24-1201 et seq. One of the statutes contained therein
which is relevant to your request, K.S.A. 24-1212, states:
"Regular meeting's] of the board of directors
shall be held quarterly at the office of the
corporation on such day as is selected by the
board of directors. Notice of such meeting
shall be mailed to each director at least five
(5) days prior to the date thereof, and spe-
cial meetings may be held at any time upon
waiver of notice of such meeting by all di-
rectors or may be called by the president or
any two directors at any time: Provided, That
notice in writing, signed by the persons call-
ing any special meeting, shall be mailed to
each director at least two (2) days prior to
the time fixed for such special meeting. A
majority of the directors shall constitute a
quorum for the transaction of business and in
the absence of any of the duly elected offi-
cers of the district a quorum at any meeting
*may select a director to act as such officer
pro tem. Each meeting of the board, whether
regular or special, shall be open to the pub-
lic and the board shall at no time go into
executive session." (Emphasis added.)
We note that this statute was part of the original act of
1953, and has not been amended since that time.
As you indicate in your request, K.S.A. 24-1212 appears to be
in conflict with an act passed in 1972, popularly known as
the Open Meetings Act, K.S.A. 75-4317 et seq. That act pro-
vides [at K.S.A. 1981 Supp. 75-4318(a)] that
"all meetings for the conduct of the affairs
of, and the transaction of business by, all
legislative and administrative bodies and
agencies of the state and political and taxing
subdivisions thereof, including boards, commis-
sions, authorities, councils, committees, sub-
committees and other subordinate groups there-
of, receiving or expending and supported in
whole or in part by public funds shall be open
to the public and no binding action by such.
bodies shall be by secret ballot, . . . "
However, at K.S.A. 1981 Supp. 75-4319 certain exceptions are
made to the general policy set out above. Procedural limi-
tations on executive sessions are set out at subsection (a),
with a list of permitted topics included at subsection (b).
One of these exceptions [at paragraph (2)] allows a body to
meet behind closed doors for "consultation with an attorney
for the body or agency which would be deemed privileged in
the attorney-client relationship."
In our opinion, there can be no question that a watershed
district, being a taxing subdivision of the state, is a body
subject to the Open Meetings Act. This would include the
requirements of K.S.A. 1981 Supp. 75-4318(b) concerning
notice of regular or special meetings, as well as the require-
ments of subsections (d) (furnishing of agendas) and (e) (use
of cameras and recording devices). The question which remains,
however, is whether the provisions of K.S.A. 1981 Supp. 75-4319
which allow executive sessions in certain cases can be recon-
ciled with the clear prohibition against such sessions in K.S.A.
24-1212.
In determining this question, it may initially be noted that,
as both of the above statutes relate to the subject of execu-
tive sessions, they should be read in pari materia, even
though enacted at different times. Bosler v. Zoning Board
for Aubry Township, 228 Kan. 6 (1980). If possible, they
should be read together and harmonized so that both may be
given force and effect. City of Overland Park v. Nikias,
209 Kan. 643 (1972). However, as that is not possible here,
in our opinion resort must be had to the concept of repeal
by implication. A number of considerations lead us to this
conclusion, i.e. that portion of K.S.A. 24-1212 banning execu-
tive sessions is repealed by K.S.A. 1981 Supp. 75-4319.
While the law does not favor the repeal of a statute in this
manner, a former statute can be so eliminated when a latter
enactment is so repugnant to it that both cannot be given
force and effect. Matter of Suesz' Estate, 228 Kan. 275 (1980).
Furthermore, it is also a well-recognized rule of statutory
construction that older statutes must be read in light of
later legislative enactments. Thomas v. Board of Trustees
of Salem Township, 224 Kan. 539 (1978). While an earlier,
more specific statute is not automatically repealed by impli-
cation upon the enactment of a later, more general statute
dealing with the same subject [Howard v. Hulbert, 63 Kan. 793
(1901)], when it appears that the general act was intended to
be of universal application or where the two acts are irrecon-
cilable with each other, the more general will prevail.
In this particular situation, there appears to be no public
policy which is served by treating the meetings of a watershed
district in a different fashion than the meetings of any
other unit of government covered by the Open Meetings Act.
Indeed, it would be contrary to public policy for a watershed
district board to hold all consultations with its attorney
concerning a pending lawsuit in public session, as this would
give opposing parties a decided advantage. Where, as here,
the subject matter of the suit concerns the expenditure of
district funds in a condemnation proceeding, the damage to
the district could well be measured in dollars if a higher
price were asked or a larger award given. In short, to read
K.S.A. 24-1212 without reference to the exceptions contained
in K.S.A. 1981 Supp. 75-4319(b) would conflict with another
publicly stated policy (i.e., private communications with one's
attorney are privileged to the extent necessary for him or her
to possess the information necessary to do the job profession-
ally), and ignores established rules of statutory construction.
For these reasons, therefore, it is our opinion that that por-
tion of K.S.A. 24-1212 which proscribes any executive session
whatsoever must be read together with K.S.A. 1981 75-4319,
which is part of a more recent act establishing a uniform
open meetings policy for this state. In that the total prohi-
bition of the former cannot be reconciled with the limited
exceptions of the latter, that portion of K.S.A. 24-1212 which
so states has been repealed by implication, leaving a watershed
district board free to meet in executive session for the pur-
poses listed at K.S.A. 1981 Supp. 75-4319(b). Among these
purposes is consultation with the board's attorney which would
be held privileged by the attorney-client relationship.
Very truly yours,
ROBERT T. STEPHAN
ATTORNEY GENERAL OF KANSAS
JeffreyS.Southard
Assistant Attorney General
RTS:JSS:hle

Setzen Sie Ihre Recherche in ChatGPT oder Claude fort

Verbinden Sie Omnilex, um den Rechtskorpus über Ihren KI-Assistenten zu durchsuchen.