Kansas Attorney General Opinion 1982-047

1982-047Kanag

Gesamter Gesetzestext

February 22, 1982
ATTORNEY GENERAL OPINION NO. 82- 4 7
Patrick J. Regan, Chairman
Kansas Water Authority
1400 Kansas State Bank Building
125 North Market Street
Wichita, Kansas 67202
Re: State Boards, Commissions and Authorities -- Kansas
Water Office and Kansas Water Authority -- Powers of
Authority's Ex Officio Members.
Synopsis: Ex Officio members of the Kansas Water Authority are pre-
cluded by K.S.A. 1981 Supp. 74-2622 from voting on matters
considered by the Authority, but such members are entitled
to participate fully in that body's deliberations regarding
such matters. Participation in the Authority's deliberative
process includes the ability to make or second a motion,
which is but a formalized expression of proposed action,
and is not an integral part of the voting process whereby
members of the Authority cast their votes to express
approval or disapproval. Cited herein: K.S.A. 1981 Supp.
74-2622.
Dear Mr. Regan:
You have inquired whether a nonvoting member of the Kansas Water
Authority may make or second notions for consideration at meetings of
the Authority. Your question is predicated on the provisions of K.S.A.
1981 Supp. 74-2622, concerning the establishment of the Kansas Water
Authority and providing in relevant part:
"The state geologist, the chief engineer of the division
of water resources of the state board of agriculture, the
director of the division of environment of the department'
of health and environment, the director of the Kansas water
office and the director of the agricultural experiment
stations of Kansas state university of agriculture and
applied sciences shall be nonvoting members of the
authority ex officio." (Emphasis added.)
We recognize that the term "ex officio" may generate some confusion.
However, simply stated, it means "by virtue of the office." Black's
Law Dictionary 661 (Rev. 4th Ed. 1968). In this instance, then, the
legislature is prescribing that by virtue of holding certain specified
offices, the officers designated in the statute shall also be members
of the Kansas Water Authority.
The general rule in regard to the power and authority of ex officio
members of a board is that "[e]x officio members of a public body
are members for all purposes." (Footnotes omitted.) 1 Am.Jur.2d
Administrative Law §61. However, as evidenced by K.S.A. 1981 Supp.
74-2622, this general rule is at times subject to an express legislative
direction that the powers of ex officio members be limited. In this
instance, the legislature has precluded ex officio members of the
Authority from voting.
While we have found no pertinent Kansas decisions addressing the scope
of such a limitation, and although there is not an abundance of relevant
case law from other jurisdictions, the cases we have reviewed indicate
the power and authority of ex officio mothers of a body should be
limited only by those restrictions specified in the pertinent legislation.
See, generally, Louisville and Jefferson County Planning Comm. v. Ogden,
210 S.W.2d 771 (1948); Matter of Farrel v. Board of Health, 243 App. Div.
332 (N.Y. 1938). In Farrel, supra, the court noted that "[o]rdinarily a
membership on any board or body carries with it a right to vote."
Id. at 334. Furthermore, "a restriction upon such power will not
be extended beyond the limitation clearly intended to be imposed by
the law, rule or order creating the restraint." Id.
Accordingly, we believe that the limitation in 74-2622 on the Authority's
ex officio members should not be extended beyond the clearly intended
restriction of these matters' voting power. Thus, for example, we believe
these members are entitled to full participation in the Authority's
deliberative process regarding matters under consideration by the
Authority. They are entitled to partake fully in discussions, by
suggesting courses of action, indicating their support of or opposition
to proposed action and otherwise expressing their opinions on matters
before the Authority.
However, even though the restriction on the ex officio members' powers
is not to be extended beyond the statutory preclusion of their right to
vote, the question arises as to whether the making or formal endorsement
of a notion is an integral part of voting. Although we are unaware of
any case law precisely pertinent to this issue, we note that "[a] 'motion'
is usually a proposal for action by [a] deliberative assembly. Lindahl v.
Independent School Dist. No. 306 of Hubbard County, 133 N.W.2d 23, 26,
270 Minn. 164." 27A Words and Phrases (1981 P.P.) 27. It is a formal
proposal made to evoke action, and when acted upon it becomes the formal
expression of a deliberative body's will. 27A Words and Phrases (1961)
354. It also should be recognized that in parliamentary procedure, a
motion proposing action by a body is required in many instances as a
condition precedent to the discussion of such proposed action by the body.
Clearly, then, a notion is but a formalized expression of proposed action;
and even though a motion is a condition precedent to making a decision
upon a proposal, it is not, in our judgment, an integral part of the voting
process whereby members of the body cast their votes to express their
approval or disapproval. Rather, we believe a motion to be as much a
part of the deliberative process as is the ensuing discussion of the
motion.
With this in mind, and in recognition of the fact that the legislature
has not precluded the ex officio members of the Water Authority from
participating in the Authority's deliberative process, we are unable to
conclude that the legislature has intended to foreclose such members
from formalizing their suggestions or proposals. In our judgment, the
legislature has intended only that the Authority's ex officio members
be precluded from voting.
In summary, then, it is our opinion that ex officio members of the Kansas
Water Authority are precluded by K.S.A. 1981 Supp. 74-2622 from voting
on matters considered by the Authority, but such members are entitled to
participate fully in that body's deliberations regarding such matters.
Participation in the Authority's deliberative process includes the right
to make or second a motion, which is but a formalized expression of
proposed action and is not an integral part of the voting process whereby
members of the Authority cast their votes to express approval or disapproval.
Very truly yours,
ROBERT T. STEPHAN
Attorney General of Kansas
W. Robert Alderson
First Deputy Attorney General
RTS:WRA:may

Setzen Sie Ihre Recherche in ChatGPT oder Claude fort

Verbinden Sie Omnilex, um den Rechtskorpus über Ihren KI-Assistenten zu durchsuchen.