Kansas Attorney General Opinion 1982-043

1982-043Kanag

Gesamter Gesetzestext

February 19, 1982
ATTORNEY GENERAL OPINION NO. 82- 43
Mr. Warren D. Andreas
Winfield City Attorney
200 East 9th Avenue
P. 0. Box 646
Winfield, Kansas 67156
Re: Cities and Municipalities -- City Councils --
Members Abstaining from Voting
Synopsis: If a quorum of a municipal council is present and
a majority of the members voting vote in favor of
a particular matter, abstentions from voting are
to be counted as acquiescence with the votes of
the majority, and the action will bind the body.
Abstentions from voting may not be counted as
acquiescence where there is a tie vote and the
proposition fails for lack of a majority voting
in favor thereof. Cited herein: K.S.A. 1981
Supp. 72-8205.
Dear Mr. Andreas:
You have requested an opinion regarding the effect of commis-
sioners abstaining from voting in two certain factual situa-
tions. First, you state that the City Planning Commission is
comprised of nine members. On one occasion, five members were
present which constituted a quorum. On a particular vote,
two members voted in favor of a recommendation and the other
three members abstained. You ask whether less than a majority
of a quorum may bind the group and what effect the abstentions
have on the vote. Second, you ask what is the outcome of a
vote by the three-member City Commission when one member votes
in favor, one votes in opposition and one member abstains
from voting.
Kansas follows the common law rules regarding abstentions
from voting, as was set forth in Attorney General Opinion
No. 77-391:
"Under the common law, a majority of a body,
such as a municipal council . . . constitute
a quorum, and the vote of a majority of those
present, providing they comprise a quorum, is
legally sufficient to constitute valid action
of the body."
The opinion further states that because in some instances
a member would attempt to block passage of a particular
matter by abstaining, "the rule evolved that abstention from
voting by a member of the body would generally be regarded
as acquiescence in action which is favored by a majority of
those who do vote with respect to the matter." Id. at p.2.
See, also, Equity Investors, Inc. v. Ammest Group, Inc., 1
Kan. App. 2d 276 (1977), 63 A.L.R. 3d, 1072.
We note that the Kansas legislature has changed the latter
rule with regard to school boards in K.S.A. 1981 Supp. 72-8205,
by specifically providing that an abstention from voting in
most instances shall be counted as having voted against the
motion or resolution. However, it will be necessary for the
legislature to statutorily change the common law rule as it
pertains to other bodies should it intend that abstentions
be counted as voting against a matter.
Applying these rules to the circumstances you present, we
find that, in the first instance, a quorum was present and a
majority of those voting voted in favor of the resolution.
The abstentions would be considered as acquiescing with those
in favor of the resolution. Therefore, the resolution passed
and the commission is bound by the vote.
In the second instance, the vote was equally split, with no
majority resulting. Therefore, the abstention may not be
counted with the vote in favor and the resolution will not
pass.
In conclusion, if a quorum of a municipal council is present
and a majority of the members voting vote in favor of a par-
ticular matter, abstentions from voting are to be counted as
acquiescence with the votes of the majority, and the action
will bind the body. Abstentions from voting may not be
counted as acquiescence where there is a tie vote and the
proposition fails for lack of a majority voting in favor
thereof.
Very truly yours,
ROBERT 'T. STEPHAN
ATTORNEY GENERAL OF ,KANSAS
Brenda L. Hoyt
Assistant Attorney General
RTS:BJS:BLH:hle

Setzen Sie Ihre Recherche in ChatGPT oder Claude fort

Verbinden Sie Omnilex, um den Rechtskorpus über Ihren KI-Assistenten zu durchsuchen.