Kansas Attorney General Opinion 1982-037

1982-037Kanag

Gesamter Gesetzestext

February 12, 1982
ATTORNEY GENERAL OPINION NO. 82- 37
Paul D. Handy
Finney County Attorney
County Courthouse
Garden City, Kansas 67846
Re: Waters and Watercourses -- Groundwater Management
Districts -- Petition for Dissolution
Synopsis: Nothing in the statutes pertaining to groundwater ,managementdistricts(K.S.A.82a-1020etseq.)
either expressly or impliedly requires that a
district's board of directors or officers main-
tain a current list of the district's eligible
voters. However, when a petition for dissolution
of a district is presented to the secretary of
the district's board pursuant to K.S.A. 82a-1034,
in order that the board's secretary can discharge
his or her duty to determine the sufficiency of
such petition (i.e., determine that each person
signing the petition is an eligible voter of the
district and the number thereof equals twenty per-
cent of the district's eligible voters), it is
the board's duty to prepare or cause to be prepared
a list of those persons who are eligible voters
of the district as of the time the petition is
filed. Cited herein: K.S.A. 25-3601, 25-3602,
45-201, K.S.A. 1981 Supp. 75-1117, K.S.A. 82a-1020,
82a-1021, 82a-1025, K.S.A. 1981 Supp. 82a-1028,
82a-1030, K.S.A. 82a-1034.
*
Dear Mr. Handy:
You have requested our opinion concerning the procedure for
dissolving a groundwater management district. Your inquiry
is prompted by a similar request made of you by several per-
sons who own land included within the boundaries of South-
west Kansas Groundwater Management District No. 3. You ad-
vised these landowners that the procedures for the dissolu-
tion of a groundwater management district were specified by
K.S.A. 82a-1034, and that one of the methods provided therein
was an election on the question of dissolution following the
presentation of petitions, signed by not less than twenty per-
cent of the district's eligible voters, to the secretary of
the district's board of directors.
These landowners then circulated petitions among the district's
eligible voters for the purpose of calling an election on the
question of the district's dissolution. You indicate that
these landowners claim to have over 200 such petitions and,
in order to determine whether the number of eligible voters
who signed the petition is equal to twenty percent of the
district's eligible voters, they requested a list of the dis-
trict's eligible voters from the district's board of direc-
tors. However, as you noted in your letter, "[title District
declined to provide the group with a voting list, contending
they do not maintain such a list, and could not, without a
great deal of difficulty, provide one." Accordingly, your
specific question to us is whether the district's board of
directors must provide a list of the district's eligible
voters when requested by an eligible voter of the district.
Regrettably, our answer cannot be framed as simply as your
question. There is no case law precisely on point, and the
statutes governing the creation, operation and management of
groundwater management districts are of little assistance.
However, having reviewed these statutes, several observations
can be made.
First, there is nothing in the statutes (K.S.A. 82a-1020 et
seq.) concerning groundwater management districts which ex-
pressly requires the board of directors or officers of a
district to keep and maintain a list of the district's eli-
gible voters. Second, there is nothing in these statutes,
in our judgment, which supports a conclusion that there is
an implied duty to keep and maintain such list in the normal
course of the district's operations. We are persuaded to
this position by the fact that, in each instance where the
statutes provide for notice to be given eligible voters as
to meetings, hearings or elections, publication notice only
is required. Nowhere do these statutes provide for actual
notice, which would necessitate maintaining a current list
of eligible voters. Moreover, we have found no requirement
that the identity and qualifications of a person as an eli-
gible voter be determined prior to such person voting on any
matter submitted to a district's eligible voters, and in each
instance where a meeting or election of eligible voters is
prescribed, the statutes are silent as to any quorum require-
ment, specifying only that a "majority of the votes cast" is
all that is necessary to approve any proposition.
Thus, from our reading of these statutes, there is nothing
implying the necessity for a district's board or officers to
keep and maintain on a regular basis a list of the district's
eligible voters. However, this is not to suggest that there
is no occasion for the preparation of such a list. In addi-
tion to the provisions of K.S.A. 82a-1034 regarding a petition
for dissolution of the district, K.S.A. 1981 Supp. 82-1030(d)
provides for a petition of the district's eligible voters in
opposition to the board's proposal to issue no-fund warrants
to defray operating expenses of the district, until revenues
are available from the district's user charges and assessments.
Although in neither case do the statutes specify the particu-
lars of determining the sufficiency of such petition, we be-
lieve the presentation of any such petition to the board
necessitates the preparation of a list of the district's eli-
gible voters.
In our judgment, when a petition for dissolution of the dis-
trict is presented to the secretary of the district's board,
pursuant to K.S.A. 82a-1034, the secretary has an implicit
duty to determine the sufficiency of such petition. This
requires a determination that each person signing the peti-
tion is an eligible voter of the district and that the number
thereof equals twenty percent of the district's eligible
voters. Obviously, these duties cannot be performed unless
the secretary has available a list of the district's eligible
voters. Thus, it is our opinion that, at the time a petition
for dissolution of a groundwater management district is pre-
sented to the secretary of the district's board, the board
must prepare or cause to be prepared a list of the district's
eligible voters.
Before concluding, several additional observations are appro-
priate. First, we note the conspicuous absence of any statu-
tory direction as to the procedures for preparing, circulat-
ing, filing and determining the sufficiency of these peti-
tions. At first blush it would appear that the provisions
of K.S.A. 25-3601 et seq. would be applicable, since a ground-
water management district is, in our judgment, a "municipality"
within the contemplation of K.S.A. 25-3601. [See K.S.A.
82a-1025(b), K.S.A. 1981 Supp. 82a-1028(b) and 75-1117 and
McQuillin, Municipal Corporations, §2.07a (3rd Ed., 1971).]
However, it is clear from a reading of K.S.A. 25-3602 that
these statutory provisions have application only to petitions
by registered electors for a question submitted election
under the general election laws. Thus, in the absence of
legislative guidance, we believe that the sufficiency of a
petition for dissolution must be determined as of the time
the petition is filed with the secretary of the board. Ac-
cordingly, the list of the district's eligible voters also
must be prepared as of that time, i.e., the list must reflect
those persons or entities who are eligible voters as of the
time the petition is filed.
We also recognize that the absence of any expressed or im-
plied statutory requirement that a groundwater management
district's board of directors keep and maintain a current
list of the district's eligible voters reflects a legislative
policy which creates uncertainty for those eligible voters
petitioning for the district's dissolution. However, the
statutes are not totally void of guidance as to the number
of signatures required on the petition. We note that K.S.A.
82a-1030 authorizes a district's board to impose a user
charge on each water user in the district and to make an
annual assessment against lands within the district. While
neither the landowners nor the water users are necessarily
the equivalent of the district's eligible voters (see defini-
tion of "eligible voter" in K.S.A. 82a-1021), we suggest
that the number of persons in each of these groups provides
an indication as to the potential number of eligible voters
in the district. Records of persons paying water user char-
ges and landowners paying annual assessments should be main-
tained in the district's office for purposes of the district's
annual audit (K.S.A. 1981 Supp. 82a-1030) and, consequently,
are available for public inspection pursuant to K.S.A. 45-201.
Moreover, since a district's charges and assessments made in
each county of the district are certified to and collected by
the county clerk of each such county, such information also
should be available in each such county clerk's office.
In summary, it is our opinion that nothing in the statutes
pertaining to groundwater management districts (K.S.A. 82a-1020
et seq.) either expressly or impliedly requires that a dis-
trict's board of directors or officers maintain a current
list of the district's eligible voters. However, when a pe-
tition for dissolution of a district is presented to the
secretary of the district's board pursuant to K.S.A. 82a-1034,
in order that the board's secretary can discharge his or
her duty to determine the sufficiency of such petition (i.e.,
determine that each person signing the petition is an eligi-
ble voter of the district and the number thereof equals twenty
percent of the district's eligible voters), it is the board's
duty to prepare or cause to be prepared a list of those per-
sons who are eligible voters of the district as of the time
the petition is filed.
Very truly yours,
ROBERT T. STEPHAN
ATTORNEYGENERAL	OF	KANSAS
R	obe	rtAlde	rson
First Deputy Attorney General
RTS:WRA:hle

Setzen Sie Ihre Recherche in ChatGPT oder Claude fort

Verbinden Sie Omnilex, um den Rechtskorpus über Ihren KI-Assistenten zu durchsuchen.