1982-034•Kansas Attorney General Opinion 1982-034
Gesamter Gesetzestext
February 12, 1982 ATTORNEY GENERAL OPINION NO. 82- 34 The Honorable Robert H. Miller State Representative, Eightieth District Rm. 115-S, Statehouse Topeka, Kansas 66612 Re: Waters and Watercourses -- Water Plan Storage -- Contracts for Withdrawal and Use; Provisions Required Synopsis: Pursuant to the State Water Plan Storage Act, K.S.A. 82a-1301 et seq., the Kansas Water Resources Board and its successor, the Kansas Water Office, are empowered to enter into contracts for the with- drawal and use of waters held in storage by the state. Waters so withdrawn and used by a purchaser are subject to a charge fixed by the respective state agency not less than 5 cents nor more than 10 cents per one thousand gallons of water. Re- gardless of the amount actually used in any one year, the purchaser is subject to a minimum charge equal to 50% of the annual amount contracted for multiplied by the rate fixed by the agency. While K.S.A. 82a-1306(c) provides that this rate shall be adjusted every 10 years after the contract is made, the provision fixes the maximum period which may elapse prior to review, and so does not pre- clude a more frequent adjustment of the rate in light of changed conditions. Cited herein: K.S.A. 82a-901, 82a-1301, 82a-1305, 82a-1306, L. 1981, ch. 303. Dear Representative Miller: As Chairman of the House Energy and Natural Resources Committee, you request our opinion as to two provisions contained in con- tracts for the sale of water stored by the state in various
reservoirs constructed by the United States, acting through the Corps of Engineers. Five such contracts have been sub- mitted to the Legislature this session, with that body having the power to disapprove and revoke any or all of the contracts. [K.S.A. 82a-1307(a).] As this power must be exercised during the first sixty calendar days of the session, we have endea- vored to expedite the issuance of this opinion. Initially, it should be noted that the authority to make such contracts is derived from the State Water Plan Storage Act, K.S.A. 82a-1301 et seq. While the Act states Tat K.S.A. 82a-1301(c)] that the state agency empowered to enter into these contracts is the Kansas Water Resources Board, such language must be read in light of 1981 Senate Bill No. 303. That measure, enacted as L. 1981, ch. 302, transferred all functions, duties and powers of the water resources board to the Kansas Water Office as of July 1, 1981. Accordingly, the contracts presently before the Legislature are made between the water office and various municipal purchasers, despite the language of the Act which was not amended in 1981. The authority of the water office to enter into contracts of the type at issue here is set forth by K.S.A. 82a-1305, wherein it is provided: "Whenever the board [water office] finds that a proposed withdrawal and use of water will advance the purposes set forth in article 9 of chapter 82a of Kansas Statutes Annotated, it may enter into written contracts with any persons for withdrawal and use of waters from conservation water supply capacity committed to the state." Specific provisions of such contracts are set forth by the succeeding section, K.S.A. 82a-1306, and concern such items as the rate charged per one thousand gallons, minimum charges, periodic adjusting of rates and provisions for the apportion- ment of water if total demand exceeds the available supply in a particular year. Your inquiry concerns two of these provisions and the way in which they are expressed in the language of the contracts, i.e. are the contracts compatible with state law? The first such subsection is K.S.A. 82a-1306(b), which states that the contract shall include "provisions for a minimum charge to be paid in equal annual installments during the term of the contract, the sum of which shall be fifty percent (50%) of the total amount of water con- tracted for during the term of the contract
multiplied by the rate fixed under paragraph (a), and that such minimum charge is to be paid each calendar year whether or not such amount of water is withdrawn during the cal- endar year . . . ." As written, you inform us that the contracts themselves pro- vide (quoting Article 6 of Water Purchase Contract 81-6 as an example): "In determining the amount of water to be in- cluded in this contract, allowances have been made to provide water for anticipated needs of the Purchaser. "The State specifically retains the right to review the quantity and purpose for which water is used throughout the term of this con- tract. Whenever the State determines the water is not being used for beneficial pur- poses or the quantity contracted is in excess of actual needs of the Purchaser, the State shall have the option to reduce the contract quantity and reduce the amount of the State's obligation to furnish raw water in any year. "Any reduction in the annual quantity of water to be supplied under the terms of this contract shall be accompanied by a reduction of the minimum annual payment specified in Article 9. "The following shall in part constitute satis- factory evidence that the Purchaser is devel- oping a need for the total quantity of water as specified in this contract: "(a) Annual use of fifty percent (50%) or more of the total annual contract quantity during the five years of the term of this contract as defined in Article 2, and "(b) Annual use of an additional ten percent (10%) or more of the total annual contract quantity by the end of each subsequent five- year period during the term of this contract up to a maximum of one hundred percent (100%) of the total contract quantity by the thirtieth (30th) year of the term of this contract." (Emphasis added.)
The minimum annual payment itself is addressed at Article 9 of this contract, to wit: "On the first day of commencement of the term of this contract as defined in Article 2 or within thirty (30) days thereafter, and on each succeeding anniversary date or within thirty (30) days thereafter, the Purchaser shall pay to the State the minimum annual pay- ment. This shall entitle the Purchaser, dur- ing the year, to receive one-half (1/2) of the maximum annual quantity of 87.0 million gal- lons as set forth in Article 6. The minimum annual payment shall be calculated by multi- plying one-half (1/2) the annual quantity in thousands of gallons of raw water times the rate for each one thousand (1,000) gallons of raw water. The initial minimum annual pay- ment shall be $3,219.87 and thereafter the Purchaser shall be notified in accordance with . Article 7 of any adjustment in the minimum annual payment. Failure to furnish such noti fication shall not relieve the Purchaser of the obligation to pay such adjusted minimum annual payment." (Emphasis added.) In our opinion, no conflict exists between these two provi- sions and K.S.A. 82a-1306(b). The underscored language of Article 9 quoted above is an accurate restatement of the sub- section, providing that a minimum charge representing 50% of the water contracted for annually must be paid. For its part, Article 6 speaks to an area not covered by the statute, namely a purchaser who, over a period of years, does not demonstrate a need for the entire amount of water it has contracted for. In the event such a situation exists, the state reserves the right to reduce the appropriated amount of water under the contract. If this is done, the minimum amount due under Article 9 is also adjusted. Nothing present therein provides for a revision upward of the minimum amount. As we read them, the criteria set forth at subsections (a) and (b) of Article 6 provide notice to a purchaser that an excess amount has been contracted for. Furthermore, the in- clusion of this clause benefits both the purchaser, who is not premanently obligated to buy more water than it may need, and the state, which can then reallocate the excess to other potential users. This result is consistent with one of the goals of the state water plan set out at K.S.A. 82a-901, i.e. the maximum beneficial use of the state's water resources.
The second issue you raise concerns K.S.A. 82a-1306(c). That
subsection requires contracts for the sale of stored water
to include
"provisions that the board shall adjust the
rate provided under paragraph (a) on the
tenth anniversary of the execution of the con-
tract and each tenth anniversary thereafter,
to reflect any change in experience by sub-
stituting the adjusted rate for the rate then
stated in the contract . . . ."
Article 7 of the contract used as an example states that:
"The State shall review the rate provided in
this article in compliance with 82a-1306(c),
as amended, and shall determine the new rate
which will become effective on the fifth (5th)
anniversary of the execution of this contract
and remain effective for the ensuing five (5)
year period. This procedure shall be repeated
at the end of each five (5) year period through-
out the term of the contract."
In view of the obvious fact that five years is not the same
as ten years, you ask whether the contract provision Can be
reconciled with the language of the statute.
At the outset, it should be noted that the mere use of the
word "shall" in the statute ("Every contract made . . . shall
include the following") is not dispositive of the question.
Numerous Kansas decisions have construed statutes containing
"shall" as being directory, rather than mandatory, when the
context requires it. City of Kansas City v. Wyandotte County
Commissioners, 213 Kan. 777 (1974), Spalding v. Price, 210
Kan. 337 (1972), Paul v. City of Manhattan, 212 Kan. 381
(1973). In Paul, the Court stated:
"In determining whether a legislative provi-
sion is mandatory or directory, it is a gener-
al rule that where strict compliance with the
provision is essential to the preservation of
the rights of parties affected and to the val-
idity of the proceeding, the provision is man-
datory, but where the provision fixes a mode
of proceeding and a time within which an offi-
cial act is to be done, and is intended to se-
cure order, system and dispatch of the public
business, the provision is directory." Syl.
1! 1."Factors which would indicate that a statute or ordinance is mandatory are: (1) the pre- sence of negative words requiring that an act shall be done in no other manner or at no other time than that designated, or (2) a pro- vision for a penalty or other consequence of noncompliance." Syl. ¶2. (Emphasis added.) In the present situation, there exist no "negative words" which would preclude the use of a lesser time span before the rate may be adjusted, i.e. the subsection does not limit adjustments only to ten year intervals, nor are lesser periods prescribed. In our opinion, if the contracts required an ad- justment only after twenty years or made no such provision at all, a different question would be presented. However, a five year review does comply with the standard established by the Legislature, for a review and possible adjustment of the rate will in fact occur on the tenth anniversary of the contract and every ten years thereafter. We also note that the ability of the water office to employ a shorter time period is in accord with their duty under K.S.A. 82a-1305, i.e. water sale contracts may be made when the purposes of the State Water Plan, K.S.A. 82a-901 et seq., will be advanced. In addition to the policy of securing maximum beneficial water use cited earlier, under the _plan the water office must also consider how to obtain "reasonable payment" from purchasers receiving water. K.S.A. 82a-901. The use of a five year, as opposed to a ten year, rate-ad- justment period evidently reflects a determination by the water office that reasonable payment cannot be made where rates are fixed for so long a period of time. Accordingly, the water office may be said to necessarily possess the au- thority to determine the period after which rates can be ad- justed in order to meet the policy goals of the plan, as long as the minimum standards of the statutes are met. State ex rel. v. Davis, 114 Kan. 270 (1923), Edwards County Commr's v. Simmons, 159 Kan. 41 (1944). In conclusion, pursuant to the State Water Plan Storage Act, K.S.A. 82a-1301 et seq., the Kansas Water Resources Board and its successor, the Kansas Water Office, are empowered to enter into contracts for the withdrawal and use of waters held in storage by the state. Waters so withdrawn and used by a pur- chaser are subject to a charge fixed by the respective state agency not less than 5 cents nor more than 10 cents per one thousand gallons of water. Regardless, of the amount actually used in any one year, the purchaser is subject to a minimum charge equal to 50% of the annual amount contracted for mul- tiplied by the rate fixed by the agency. While K.S.A. 82a-1306(c)
provides that this rate shall be adjusted every 10 years after the contract is made, the provision fixes the maximum period which may elapse prior to review, and so does not preclude a more frequent adjustment of the rate in light of changed con- ditions. Very truly yours, ROBERT T. STEPHAN ATTORNEY GENERAL OF KANSAS JeffreyS.Southard Assistant Attorney General RTS:BJS:JSS:hle
Was bedeutet dieser Text für Ihre Situation?
Kostenlose und unverbindliche Beratung
Schildern Sie uns Ihre Situation. Unser Team meldet sich per E-Mail bei Ihnen für Ihre Beratung.
Setzen Sie Ihre Recherche in ChatGPT oder Claude fort
Verbinden Sie Omnilex, um den Rechtskorpus über Ihren KI-Assistenten zu durchsuchen.