Kansas Attorney General Opinion 1981-022

1981-022Kanag

Gesamter Gesetzestext

January 27, 1981
ATTORNEY GENERAL OPINION NO. 81-22
Darrel E. Johnson
Morton County Attorney
701 Vilymaca Street
Drawer "0"
Elkhart, Kansas 67950
Re: State Departments; Public Officers, Employees--Open Meetings
--Oral Notice; Closed Sessions
Synopsis: Although written requests for notice of government meetings
are preferred and the absence of a written request makes
prosecution under the Kansas Open Meetings Act nearly
impossible, oral requests for notice are to be honored.
In addition, meetings for the discussion of personnel
matters of non-elected personnel may be held in executive
session, but only after the notice requirements and
procedures for recessing into closed sessions have been
followed. Cited herein: K.S.A. 75-4317, 75-4317a, K.S.A.
1980 Supp. 75-4318, K.S.A. 75-4319, 75-4320.
Dear Mr. Johnson:
You inquire regarding the application of the Kansas Open Meetings Act,
K.S.A. 75-4317 et seq., to meetings of the school board for U.S.D.
No. 218. Specifically, you advise that the school board met on
November 19, 1980, and voted to seek the resignation of a senior high
school principal of the district. Subsequently, on December 8, 1980,
the board again met in full public view; in fact, roughly 300 district
patrons attended this meeting to inquire regarding the reasons for
the requested resignation. At the December 8 meeting the board did
not elaborate on the reasons for the resignation request, but offered
to do so at the next meeting. Some patrons attending the December 8
meeting orally requested to be notified of the next meeting.
Following the December 8 meeting the board met in "special session"
to discuss and prepare the answers to the questions raised by the pre-
vious public meeting. This special session was held in private (some
non-members were expelled from these meetings) without the providing
of the notice requested by the patrons attending the December 8 meeting.
In this context, you request our opinion whether the circumstances as
described are a possible violation of the Kansas Open Meetings Act.
Clearly, the Kansas Open Meetings Act applies to meetings of school
boards, since school boards are legislative or administrative bodies
or agencies of the state or its political or taxing subdivisions.
K.S.A. 1980 Supp. 75-4318. Equally clear is that gatherings of board
members for the purpose of discussing the reasons for a requested
resignation is a "meeting" for the purpose of discussing the business
or affairs of the body. K.S.A. 75-4317a.
Hence, we see the questions you ask as concerning the notice requirements
of the Act, the scope of the meetings covered by the Act and the
procedures to be followed for executive sessions.
K.S.A. 1980 Supp. 75-4318(b) provides in pertinent part: "Notice
of the date, time and place of any regular or special meeting of a
public body designated hereinabove shall be furnished to any person
requesting such information." The fact that the request for notice
of meetings of governmental bodies was communicated to the school
board orally does not in itself negate its effect as a valid request
for notice of future meetings. If, in fact, an oral request for notice
is communicated to the governmental agency or body in a reasonable
fashion such that notice may be provided without undue burden on the
public agency, such request must be honored. Intentional failure of
any member to honor a request for notice may subject the members to
civil penalties not to exceed $500. K.S.A. 75-4320.
This office stated in Kansas Attorney General Opinion No. 81-20:
"We have on previous occasions cautioned the public and
press to submit requests for notice in writing because
of the severe practical problems involved with prosecution
of notice violations under the Act where the request is not
recorded in black and white. Written requests for notice
are clearly preferred. However, we cannot allow requests for
notice made orally to be ignored when effectively communicated
to a governmental body or agency." Id. at 3.
As previously noted, the notice requirements apply to both regular and
special meetings. Indeed, the label attached to a gathering of school
board members is not decisive as to the application of the Open
Meetings Act. The Kansas law applies to prearranged gatherings "for
the conduct of the affairs of, and the transaction of business by"
the local school boards. This includes meetings commonly labeled work
sessions, study sessions, etc. That no binding action is taken is
not particularly important in the application of the open meetings
principle.
If there was ever any doubt that such gatherings were subject to the
Act, these apprehensions were laid to rest by the Kansas Court of Appeals
in Coggins v. Public Employees Relations Board, 2 Kan. App. 2d 416 (1978),
where the Court concluded that the term "meetings," as used in the Act,
"includes all gatherings at all stages of the decision-making process."
Id. at 423. We cannot overemphasize the need to view all prearranged
gatherings of school board members as subject to the Act if the public's
business is discussed. The formalities of agenda, minutes or even a
quorum are not prerequisite to application of the Act.
Finally, there seems to be considerable confusion among local units of
government as to the proper procedure for and use of closed or executive
sessions. All meetings subject to the Act are open unless closed
pursuant to K.S.A. 75-4319. But whether open or closed, any meeting
subject to the Act requires compliance with the law's notice provisions.
In addition, closed or executive sessions are "recesses," not closed
meetings. The law clearly contemplates that members will meet in
the open and then recess to a closed meeting only after following the
formal procedures outlined in K.S.A. 75-4319(a).
Discussions of personnel matters of non-elected personnel may be discusses
during closed sessions conducted during otherwise open meetings for
which the notice requirements have been met. Personnel matters of
non-elected personnel may not b6 discussed at secret meetings or gather-
ings where the procedures for executive sessions have not been followed.
In sum, although written requests for notice of government meetings are
preferred and the absence of a written request makes prosecution under
the Kansas Open Meetings Act nearly impossible, oral requests for notice
are to be honored. In addition, meetings for the discussion of personnel
matters of non-elected personnel may be held in executive session, but
only after the notice requirements and procedures for recessing into
closed sessions have been followed.
Very truly yours,
ROBERT T. STEPHAN
Attorney General of Kansas
Bra	dl	e	y	J.Smoot
De ty Attorney General
RTS:BJS:phf

Setzen Sie Ihre Recherche in ChatGPT oder Claude fort

Verbinden Sie Omnilex, um den Rechtskorpus über Ihren KI-Assistenten zu durchsuchen.