Kansas Attorney General Opinion 1981-006

1981-006Kanag

Gesamter Gesetzestext

January 12, 1981
ATTORNEY GENERAL OPINION NO. 81- 6
Mr. David W. Kester
Director, Legal Services Section
Kansas Department of Education
120 East Tenth Street
Topeka, Kansas 66612
Re: Schools--Transportation of Students--Misbehavior
on School Buses
Synopsis: A school district, while complying with state law,
may discipline a child for "misbehaving" on a school
bus by refusing to continue to furnish transportation
for the child to and from school in the regular school
buses. However, the school district must provide
transportation for the child by employing any one
of the alternative methods prescribed by law, one of
which is to reimburse the child's parents for transporting
the child to and from school, as provided in K.S.A.
72-8301(c)(5).
In addition, if the behavior of a child is such as
to be encompassed within the provisions of K.S.A.
72-8901, which specify the grounds upon which a child
may be suspended or expelled from school, the school
district can resort to such action as a means of
disciplining the child. Cited herein: K.S.A. 72-8301,
72-8302, 72-8901.
Dear Mr. Kester:
You seek our opinion on "whether school districts have the
authority to 'kick-off' or temporarily or permanently suspend
misbehaving students from bus transportation to and from school."
It is firmly established that school authorities have the right
to provide reasonable means of disciplining children for mis-
behavior while such children are under the control of the school.
In Ingraham v. Wright, 430 U.S. 651, 97 S.Ct. 1401, 51 L.Ed.2d
711 (1976), the Court said:
"Assessment of the need for, and the ap-
propriate means of maintaining, school
discipline is committed generally to the
discretion of school authorities subject
to state law. '[The Court has repeatedly
emphasized the need for affirming the
comprehensive authority of the States and
of school officials, consistent with funda-
mental constitutional safeguards, to prescribe
and control conduct in the schools.' Tinker v.
Des Moines School Dist. 393, U.S. 503, 507,
21 L.Ed.2d 731, 89 S.Ct. 733, 49 Ohio Ops.2d
222 (1969)." (Footnote omitted and emphasis
added.) 430 U.S. at 682-683.
That children who are provided transportation by school buses
are under the control and discipline of the school is made clear
by the provisions of K.S.A. 72-8305, which specify that even
when children are merely being provided transportation by school
buses to extracurricular activities, "fain students so transported
shall be= under school control and discipline . . ." Therefore,
it is our opinion that school authorities may provide appropriate
means of maintaining discipline on school buses. However, it
further is our opinion that the means selected must be consistent
with state law and, certainly, cannot have the effect of relieving
a school district of a duty imposed upon it by law.
Subsection (a) of K.S.A. 72-8302, provides:
"The board of education of any school district
may provide or furnish transportation for students
to or from any school of the school district.
Every school district shall provide or furnish
transportation for every pupil who resides in
the school district and who attends any of grades
kindergarten through twelve at a school of the
school district . . . fin certain cases]."
(Emphasis added.)
In clear and unambiguous language, this statute requires every
school district to provide or furnish transportation for certain
of its students. No exception is provided expressly in the law,
and it is our opinion that no exception can be implied in the law.
Thus, there is a duty on the part of every school district to
provide or furnish transportation to those students whose residence
entitles them to such transportation. Given this duty, it is
our opinion that a school district may not refuse to provide
or furnish transportation to those students who are entitled to
such transportation under the provisions of K.S.A. 72-8301 et seq.,
as a means of disciplining a child for "misbehaving" on a school
bus.
However, under the school transportation statutes, K.S.A. 72-8301
et seq., a school district is not required to provide school
bus transportation to and from school. In said statutes, the
words "provide or furnish transportation" mean:
"[T]he right of a school district to: (1)
Purchase, operate and maintain school buses
and other motor vehicles; (2) contract, lease
or hire school buses and other motor vehicles
for the transportation of pupils, students
and school personnel; (3) purchase, operate and
maintain buses other than school buses for the
transportation of pupils, students- or school
personnel to or from school-related functions
or activities; (4) contract, lease or hire
buses other than school buses for the trans-
portation of pupils, students and school personnel
if said buses are owned and operated by a public
common carrier of passengers under a certificate
of convenience and necessity granted by the state
corporation commission or the interstate commerce
commission and are operating within the authority
granted to said public common carrier; and (5)
reimburse persons who furnish transportation to
pupils, students or school personnel in privately
owned motor vehicles." K.S.A. 72-8301(c).
A school district, therefore, can fulfill its statutory obligation
to transport students to and from school by employing any of
the alternative methods prescribed in K.S.A. 72-8301. Such
fact has long been recognized in the State of Kansas. See
Harkness v. School District, 103 Kan. 573, 575 (1918). Con-
sequently, a school district, while complying with state law,
may discipline a child for "misbehaving" on a school bus by
refusing to allow the child to be transported to and from school
in the regular school buses. However, the school district must
provide transportation for the child by employing any one of
the alternative methods prescribed by law.
In addition, if the behavior of the child is such as to be
encompassed within the provisions of K.S.A. 72-8901, which specify
the grounds upon which a child may be suspended or expelled from
school, the school district could resort to such action as a means
of disciplining the child.
Of course, consistent with the Court's holding in Ingraham, supra,
a school district can employ such other reasonable and appropriate
means of maintaining discipline as in the discretion of the school
authorities is necessary, so long as the means selected are
consistent with state law.
Thus, in answer to your inquiry, it is our opinion that as long
as a child is not suspended or expelled from school and is
entitled to have transportation provided to him or her under
the provisions of K.S.A. 72-8301 et seq., school authorities may
not refuse to provide or furnish transportation to such child as
a means of disciplining the child for "misbehaving" on a school
bus. However, other means of disciplining a child, such as those
mentioned hereinabove, are available to school authorities.
Very truly yours,
- ROBERT T. STEPHAN
Attorney General of Kansas
Rodney J. Bieker
Assistant Attorney General
RTS:BJS:RJB:jm

Setzen Sie Ihre Recherche in ChatGPT oder Claude fort

Verbinden Sie Omnilex, um den Rechtskorpus über Ihren KI-Assistenten zu durchsuchen.