Martinez v. Berfield et al

1:20-cv-01759Pamd26.11.2025

Gesamter Gesetzestext

UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT
MIDDLE DISTRICT OF PENNSYLVANIA
ALBERT E. MARTINEZ, 	:
Plaintiff 	: 	CIV. ACTION NO. 1:20-CV-1759
v. 	: 	(JUDGE MANNION)
JASON BERFIELD, et al., 	:
Defendants 	:
MEMORANDUM
This is a prisoner civil rights case that is before the court for resolution
of the issue of whether plaintiff exhausted administrative remedies prior to
filing 	suit. 	As 	explained 	below, 	based 	on 	the 	court’s 	consideration 	of
testimony and evidence produced during an April 2025 evidentiary hearing
and 	the 	parties’ 	supplemental 	briefs 	following 	the 	hearing, 	the 	court
concludes 	that 	actions 	by 	prison 	officials 	in 	responding 	to 	plaintiff’s
grievances 	rendered 	administrative 	remedies 	unavailable. 	Plaintiff 	was
therefore excused from the duty to exhaust administrative remedies, and this
case will be scheduled for a trial on the merits of his claims.
I. 	BACKGROUND
Plaintiff, Albert E. Martinez, was incarcerated in Camp Hill State
Correctional Institution (“SCI-Camp Hill”) at all relevant times. He filed this
Case 1:20-cv-01759-MEM-LT Document 130 Filed 11/26/25 Page 1 of 15
2
case on September 25, 2020, alleging violations of his First, Fourth, Eighth,
and Fourteenth Amendment rights during and after a five-day period when
he was placed in a “dry cell” based on suspicions that he was in possession
of contraband.1 (Doc. 1). The case was initially assigned to United States
District Judge Christopher C. Conner.
After the close of pleadings and discovery, defendants moved for
summary judgment on July 31, 2023. (Doc. 66). Judge Conner denied the
motion without prejudice on November 1, 2023, concluding that additional
discovery was necessary before defendants’ summary judgment arguments
could be resolved. (Docs. 81-82). Judge Conner accordingly reopened
discovery 	and 	granted 	defendants 	leave 	to 	file 	a 	renewed 	motion 	for
summary judgment after the completion of discovery. (Id.)
Defendants filed a renewed motion for summary judgment on February
29, 2024. (Doc. 85). On September 26, 2024, Judge Conner granted the
motion 	as 	to 	all 	claims 	and 	defendants 	except 	for 	Martinez’s 	Eighth
1 “A ‘dry cell’ is a cell that lacks water—all standing water has been
drained from the toilet, the room’s water supply has been shut off, and the
sink and toilet have been capped to prevent inmate access. An inmate may
be placed in a dry cell when prison staff have observed the inmate attempt
to ingest an item of contraband or they learn that the inmate is attempting to
introduce contraband into the prison. 	Dry cells are used to closely observe
the inmate until natural processes allow for the ingested contraband to be
retrieved.” 	Thomas v. Tice, 948 F.3d 133, 137 (3d Cir. 2020).
Case 1:20-cv-01759-MEM-LT Document 130 Filed 11/26/25 Page 2 of 15
3
Amendment claim against defendants Berfield and Evans, holding that there
were genuine issues of material fact on both whether Martinez exhausted
administrative remedies for the claim and the merits of the claim. (Docs. 103-
04). 	Judge 	Conner 	referred 	the 	case 	to 	mediation, 	which 	proved
unsuccessful. (Docs. 105-06). The case was reassigned to the undersigned
on January 21, 2025, following Judge Conner’s retirement from the court.
In February 2025, the court scheduled this case for an evidentiary
hearing 	to 	decide 	whether 	plaintiff 	exhausted 	administrative 	remedies.
(Docs. 107, 109). The court conducted the hearing on April 1, 2025, and April
28, 2025.2 The court ordered supplemental briefs from the parties after the
hearing, which were submitted on June 16, 2025, and July 11, 2025. (Docs.
123, 127). The exhaustion issue is now ripe for the court’s consideration.
II. 	STANDARD OF R EVIEW
Under 	the 	Prison 	Litigation 	Reform 	Act 	(“PLRA”), 	prisoners
complaining 	about 	the 	conditions 	of 	their 	confinement 	must 	exhaust
available administrative remedies before they may file suit in federal court.
42 U.S.C. §1997e(a). The PLRA requires proper exhaustion, meaning
plaintiffs must administratively grieve their claims in accordance with the
2 Additional proceedings were needed on a second day because a
family emergency made one witness unavailable during the first proceeding.
Case 1:20-cv-01759-MEM-LT Document 130 Filed 11/26/25 Page 3 of 15
4
procedural rules of the prison in which they are incarcerated. Downey v. Pa.
Dep’t of Corr., 968 F.3d 299, 305 (3d Cir. 2020) (citing Woodford v. Ngo, 548
U.S. 81, 88 (2006)). Failure to exhaust 	administrative remedies 	is 	an
affirmative defense that defendants must plead and prove; it is not a pleading
requirement for plaintiffs. Jones v. Bock, 549 U.S. 199, 216 (2007).
A prisoner is only required to exhaust administrative remedies that are
“available.” 	Rinaldi v. United States, 904 F.3d 257, 268 (2018) (citing
Woodford, 548 U.S. at 93). An administrative remedy is unavailable, and
administrative exhaustion is thus excused, in three situations: “(1) when ‘it
operates as a simple dead end—with officers unable or consistently unwilling
to provide any relief to aggrieved inmates’; (2) when it is ‘so opaque that it
becomes, practically speaking, incapable of use,’ such as when no ordinary
prisoner can discern or navigate it; or (3) when ‘prison administrators thwart
inmates from taking advantage of a grievance process through machination,
misrepresentation, or intimidation.’” Id. at 266-67 (quoting Ross v. Blake, 578
U.S. 	632, 	643-44 	(2016)). 	If 	defendants 	establish 	failure 	to 	exhaust
administrative remedies, the burden shifts to the plaintiff to show that the
administrative remedy process was unavailable. Id. at 268.
District courts “may resolve factual disputes relevant to the exhaustion
issue without the participation of a jury.” 	Paladino v. Newsome, 885 F.3d
Case 1:20-cv-01759-MEM-LT Document 130 Filed 11/26/25 Page 4 of 15
5
203, 210 (3d Cir. 2018) (citing Small v. Camden County, 728 F.3d 265, 271
(3d Cir. 2013)). Exhaustion is a “preliminary issue for which no right to a jury
trial exists.” 	Small, 728 F.3d at 271.
III. 	EVIDENTIARY H EARING
During the evidentiary hearing conducted in April 2025, the court heard
testimony from three witnesses: Michael Bell, a grievance officer with the
Department of Corrections’ Secretary’s Office of Inmate Grievances and
Appeals 	(“SOIGA”); 	Martinez; 	and 	Tony 	Heist, 	the 	Superintendent’s
Assistant and grievance coordinator at SCI-Camp Hill. (Docs. 121-22).
Bell began his testimony with general background on his employment
history and the process for filing and appealing a grievance in the DOC’s
grievance system. (Doc. 121 at 7-9). He then testified that he reviewed
Martinez’s grievance and appeal history prior to the hearing. (Id.) At that
point, the court admitted into the record defendants’ Exhibit 1, an appeal
related to Grievance #787052. (Doc. Id. at 11; see also Ex. D-1, Doc. 116).
Bell reviewed the grievance packet and testified that there was “no outcome”
when Bell appealed the grievance to SOIGA because Martinez had not
previously appealed the grievance to the prison’s superintendent. (Doc. 121
at 11-12).
Case 1:20-cv-01759-MEM-LT Document 130 Filed 11/26/25 Page 5 of 15
6
The court next heard testimony from Martinez, who was called as on
cross by defendants. (Id. at 15). At the outset of his testimony, the court
admitted into the record defendants’ Exhibit 2, a grievance packet for
Grievance #784833. (Id. at 15-16; see also Ex. D-2, Doc. 117). Martinez
testified that he submitted this grievance to complain about how he was
treated in the dry cell, but that it was rejected because it exceeded the DOC’s
two-page limit for grievances. (Id. at 16). After the grievance was rejected,
he testified that he filed a “follow-up grievance” that complied with the page
limit. (Id.) The court admitted this grievance—Grievance #787052—into the
record as defendants’ Exhibit 3. (Id. at 17; Ex. D-3, Doc. 118). Martinez
testified that this grievance was rejected because it improperly advanced a
claim pursuant to the Prison Rape Elimination Act (“PREA”) in a standard
grievance and because it grieved multiple issues in the same grievance.
(Doc. 121 at 18).
Martinez testified that after Grievance #787052 was rejected, he filed
an appeal to the facility manager but did not get a response. (Id.) Martinez
subsequently filed a request slip asking for a response to his appeal, and
when he did not get a response to that, he submitted an appeal to SOIGA
because he “felt like [he] had not other recourse but to file the appeal to
central office explaining to that that [he] didn’t receive the second level
Case 1:20-cv-01759-MEM-LT Document 130 Filed 11/26/25 Page 6 of 15
7
appeals.” (Id.) SOIGA rejected Martinez’s appeal for his failure to file an
appeal with the facility manager, at which point he filed the complaint that
initiated this case. (Id. at 19-20). Martinez acknowledged that after SOIGA
rejected his appeal, he did not make a second attempt to appeal to the facility
manager. (Id. at 20). Martinez stated that if he had attempted to do so it
would have been rejected as untimely. (Id.)
After Martinez provided his general understanding of how grievances
are filed by inmates in the prison’s restricted housing unit (“RHU”), the court
admitted into the record defendants’ exhibit 4, a copy of the grievance packet
for grievance #787052 that was previously produced to the court during
summary judgment proceedings. (Id. at 23-24; see also Ex. D-4, Doc. 119).
Martinez acknowledged that the appeal to the facility manager contained in
the exhibit was not marked as received by the facility manager. (Id. at 25).
Martinez then reviewed the request slip included in the exhibit, and noted
that it also did not contain any stamp indicating that it had been received by
the facility manager. (Id.) Martinez stated that this was because the copy he
included in his summary judgment exhibit was a carbon copy he made of the
request slip at the time he submitted it. (Id. at 25-26).
After Martinez’s cross examination ended, the court noted that it could
not proceed with Heist’s testimony because a family emergency had made
Case 1:20-cv-01759-MEM-LT Document 130 Filed 11/26/25 Page 7 of 15
8
her unavailable. (Id. at 28). The court allowed Martinez to return to the stand
to provide his testimony for his case in chief. (Id. at 28). After clarifying details
of his testimony regarding when he submitted his grievances and appeals,
the court asked him how long he waited after submitting his appeal to the
facility manager before submitting a request slip inquiring about the appeal.
(Id. at 35). Martinez stated that it was approximately 60 days after he
submitted the appeal. (Id.) The court then asked Martinez why he had carbon
copies of the appeal and request slip relevant to this grievance when he did
not appear to have other carbon copies. (Id. at 37). Martinez stated that this
“might have” been caused by “various situation[s]” where he could not get
his property from the prison’s property room. (Id.)
When 	the 	hearing 	resumed 	on 	April 	28, 	2025, 	the 	court 	heard
testimony from Heist. (Doc. 122 at 3). Heist began by testifying as to her
duties as the grievance coordinator at SCI-Camp Hill and the process for
inmates to submit grievances and related appeals. (Id. at 4-5). The court
stated that it would take judicial notice of the DOC policy governing the
submission of grievances and appeals, DC-ADM 804. (Id. at 6).
After reviewing the grievance packet for Grievance #787833, Heist
testified that it was rejected by the facility because it pertained to a non-
grievable issue—administrative custody procedures—and because it was
Case 1:20-cv-01759-MEM-LT Document 130 Filed 11/26/25 Page 8 of 15
9
over two pages long. (Id. at 7-8). Heist testified that no further action was
taken on this grievance after it was rejected. (Id. at 8). Heist then reviewed
Grievance #787052, which she testified was rejected because it grieved one
or more topics and because it presented a PREA complaint. (Id. at 8-9). Heist
testified that no further action was take on this grievance either after it was
rejected. (Id. at 9). She further testified that there was no record of an appeal
to the facility manager being filed for either grievance. (Id.) Heist reviewed
the appeal and request slip that Martinez stated he submitted, and noted that
there were no date stamps on the documents indicating that they had been
received by the facility manager. (Id. at 10-12). Heist testified that the prison
never received an appeal to the facility manager from Martinez. (Id. at 14).
On cross-examination, Heist acknowledged that it is “possible” that
appeals can be misplaced by prison officials while they are being processed.
(Id. 	at 16). She further testified that while she was aware of inmates
complaining 	about 	prison 	staff 	intentionally 	destroying 	grievances 	and
appeals, she was not personally aware of any incidents in which staff
members had done so. (Id. at 17).
Martinez subsequently asked Heist about the two relevant grievances
in this case. (Id. at 30). Heist initially stated that Grievance #787052 was not
a resubmission of Grievance #784833, but rather a new and independent
Case 1:20-cv-01759-MEM-LT Document 130 Filed 11/26/25 Page 9 of 15
10
grievance. (Id. at 30). When pressed, however, Heist acknowledged that she
“made a mistake on this one,” and that Grievance #787052 should have been
processed as a resubmission of Grievance #784833 because it contained
the previous grievance number in its first sentence. (Id. at 31). Heist testified,
however, that the two grievances were “not exactly the same” because
Martinez “made a PREA complaint” in the second grievance. (Id. at 32). She
then noted that the prison’s security captain and PREA compliance manager
made the decision whether a grievance raised a PREA issue and that this
was not her decision. (Id. at 34-35).
Heist further testified that in this case, because Martinez had already
re-filed his grievance once, he would not have been able to file a second
grievance under DOC policy. (Id. at 40). She then confirmed that when the
second grievance was rejected, it was “at a dead end,” though the PREA
claim would be investigated separately. (Id. at 41-42).
IV. 	F INDINGS OF FACT
Based on the testimony and evidence adduced during the evidentiary
hearing, the court makes the following findings of fact:
1. 	On 	January 	29, 	2019, 	Martinez 	filed 	Grievance 	#784833,
complaining that prison officials had violated his civil rights during
Case 1:20-cv-01759-MEM-LT Document 130 Filed 11/26/25 Page 10 of 15
11
his confinement in a dry cell earlier in January 2019. (Ex. D-2,
Doc. 117 at 2).
2. 	The grievance was rejected on February 4, 2019, because it
challenged administrative custody procedures and because it
exceeded the two-page limit for grievances. (Ex. D-2, Doc. 117
at 1).
3. 	Under the DOC’s grievance policy, DC-ADM 804, a grievance
that has been rejected “may be re-submitted, using the same
grievance number, within five working days of the rejection notice
date.” DC-ADM 804, §1(A)(20).
4. 	It is unclear from the record when Martinez was given notice of
the rejection of Grievance #784833.
5. 	On February 15, 2019, Martinez filed Grievance #787052, in
which he stated that he was “resubmitting Grievance #784833
for exceeding the two page limit.” (Ex. D-1, Doc. 116 at 2).
6. 	Grievance #787052 complied with the two-page limit. (Ex. D-1,
Doc. 116 at 2-3).
7. 	Grievance #787052 was rejected on February 19, 2019, because
it improperly asserted a PREA claim and because it grieved more
than two issues. (Ex. D-1, Doc. 116 at 4). The rejection did not
Case 1:20-cv-01759-MEM-LT Document 130 Filed 11/26/25 Page 11 of 15
12
note that the grievance was untimely or that it improperly grieved
administrative custody procedures. (Id.)
8. 	The factual allegations that gave rise to the finding that the
grievance asserted a PREA claim were essentially unchanged
from Grievance #784833 (Compare Ex. D-2 Doc. 117 at 2 (“I was
also forced to expose my genitals while I was forced to urinate
and defecate in front of female correctional officers and staff”),
with Ex. D-1 Doc. 116 at 1 (“I was forced to expose my genitals
while I was forced to urinate and defecate in front of female
officers and staff.”).
9. 	Grievance #787052 was mistakenly treated as a new grievance
rather than a re-submission of Grievance #787052. (Doc. 122 at
31).
10. 	No further resubmissions of Grievance #784833 were permitted
by DC-ADM 804 after Grievance #787052 was rejected. DC-
ADM 804 §1(A)(20).
11. 	Based on the witnesses’ demeanor and mannerisms during the
evidentiary hearing, the court finds the testimony of Tonya Heist
credible that SCI-Camp Hill never received any appeal from the
rejection of Grievance #787052 or Grievance #784833. The
Case 1:20-cv-01759-MEM-LT Document 130 Filed 11/26/25 Page 12 of 15
13
court finds plaintiff’s testimony to the contrary that he filed an
appeal and never received a response not credible.
V. 	C ONCLUSIONS OF LAW
Based on the above factual findings and the relevant legal standard,
the court makes the following conclusions of law:
1. 	Defendants met their initial burden to show that plaintiff failed to
exhaust administrative remedies based on his failure to file an
appeal of either one of his relevant grievances.
2. 	Tonya Heist’s mistake of treating Grievance #787052 as a new
grievance rather than a resubmission of Grievance #784833,
however, rendered the grievance process unavailable.3
3 Although Heist testified credibly that she simply made a mistake in
processing Martinez’s grievance, her actions effectively created a “blind
alley” or “quagmire” that made it 	impossible to exhaust 	administrative
remedies. Ross, 578 U.S. at 644. The initial rejection of Grievance #784833
indicated that it did not comply with the two-page limit, suggesting that if it
was resubmitted in a manner that complied with the page limit, it would be
accepted 	as 	properly 	filed. 	When Martinez 	resubmitted 	the 	grievance,
however—which was clearly labeled as a resubmission—she treated the
grievance as a new grievance that was then rejected on procedural grounds
that Martinez had not previously been instructed to correct. (See Doc. 116 at
4). The terms of DC-ADM 804 also prevented Martinez from filing any
additional re-submissions, see DC-ADM 804 §1(A)(20), despite the fact that
he was never given the opportunity to cure the defects identified in his first
resubmission.
Case 1:20-cv-01759-MEM-LT Document 130 Filed 11/26/25 Page 13 of 15
14
3. 	Plaintiff is deemed to have exhausted administrative remedies at
that point because the grievance process was unavailable. See
Shifflett v. Korszniak, 934 F.3d 356, 365 (3d Cir. 2019) (holding
that as soon as a prison fails to respond to a grievance in a
manner 	that 	complies 	with 	its 	own 	procedural 	rules, 	the
grievance process is unavailable, and the plaintiff is deemed to
have exhausted administrative remedies).
4. 	Plaintiff’s 	subsequent 	failure to file an 	appeal is 	immaterial
because the grievance process was rendered unavailable when
prison officials failed to treat his second grievance as a re-
submission.
5. 	Respondent argues to the contrary that under Talley v. Clark,
111 F.4th 255, 263-64 (3d Cir. 2024), Martinez was required to
request an extension of time to complete the grievance process
once 	the 	circumstances 	that 	made 	the 	grievance 	process
unavailable were rectified. (Doc. 127 at 5).
6. 	This argument is unpersuasive. Unlike Talley, where the plaintiff
alleged that he could not timely file a grievance because he did
not have access to writing materials, the grievance process in
this case was rendered unavailable based on prison officials’
Case 1:20-cv-01759-MEM-LT Document 130 Filed 11/26/25 Page 14 of 15
15
failure 	to 	comply 	with 	DC-ADM 	804. 	Further 	exhaustion 	of
administrative remedies was excused as soon as prison officials
failed to comply with the rule. Shifflett, 934 F.3d at 365.
VI. 	C ONCLUSION
For the foregoing reasons, the court concludes that the affirmative
defense of failure to exhaust administrative remedies fails. The court will
schedule this case for a trial on the merits of plaintiff’s claims. An appropriate
order follows.
s/ Malachy E. Mannion
Malachy E. Mannion
United States District Judge
Dated: November 26, 2025
20-1759-01
Case 1:20-cv-01759-MEM-LT Document 130 Filed 11/26/25 Page 15 of 15

Setzen Sie Ihre Recherche in ChatGPT oder Claude fort

Verbinden Sie Omnilex, um den Rechtskorpus über Ihren KI-Assistenten zu durchsuchen.