2:25-cv-01293•KNOX v. NEW JERSEY DEPARTMENT OF CORRECTIONS et al
Gesamter Gesetzestext
UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT
DISTRICT OF NEW JERSEY
TRISMA KNOX,
Plaintiff,
v.
NEW JERSEY DEPARTMENT OF
CORRECTIONS and NICHOLAS
CALICCHIO,
Defendants.
No. 25-cv-12 93 (MEF) (MAH)
OPINION and ORDER
* * *
For the purposes of this brief Opinion and Order, the Court
largely assumes familiarity with the procedural history and
allegations of this case.
* * *
A woman 1 ("the Plaintiff") sued her Employer 2 and her
Supervisor, 3 alleging "discrimination, harassment, and
retaliation." Complaint and Jury Demand ("Complaint") (ECF 1)
<JI<JI 9-11, 15.
The Employer and the Supervisor now move to dismiss some of the
Plaintiff's claims under Federal Rules of Civil Procedure
12 (b) ( 1) and 12 (b) ( 6) . See Brief in Support of Defendants'
Partial Motion to Dismiss the Complaint Pursuant to Rule Fed. R.
Civ. P. 12 (b) (1), and 12 (b) (6) ("Defendants' Brief") (ECF 7-1)
at 1.
1
2
3
Trisma Knox.
New Jersey Department of Corrections.
Nicholas Calicchio.
Case 2:25-cv-01293-MEF-MAH Document 19 Filed 02/03/26 Page 1 of 6 PageID:
<pageID>The motion is mainly granted. * * * First, consider the Plaintiff's claims for breach of the implied covenant of good faith and fair dealing. See Complaint 11 79- 82. The Employer, the New Jersey Department of Corrections, argues that this claim cannot go forward because it is protected by sovereign immunity. See Defendants' Brief at 8-9. This has it right. Under the Constitution, "states [are] generally immune from suit by private parties in federal court." MCI Telecomm. Corp. v. Bell Atl. Pa., 271 F.3d 491, 503 (3d Cir. 2001). "This immunity extends to state . . departments." Id. And that includes the New Jersey Department of Corrections. See Fox v. Bayside State Prison, 726 F. App'x 865, 867-68 (3d Cir. 2018) (so holding) . 4 As to the Supervisor, who also works for the New Jersey Department of Corrections 5 --- he argues that because the Department gets immunity, he (the Supervisor) is shielded by immunity, too. See Defendants' Brief at 5-6, 8-9. This argument works. The Supervisor is taken as having been sued here in his official capacity. 6 And "[i]ndividual state employees sued in their official capacity are . . entitled to [sovereign] immunity because official-capacity suits generally represent only another way of pleading an action 4 Accord, e.g., Jones v. DiBenedetto, 2025 WL 1040387, at *2 (D.N.J. Apr. 8, 2025); Graham v. New Jersey, 2022 WL 4010856, at *5 (D.N.J. Sept. 2, 2022); Tellus v. Murphy, 2025 WL 3707430, at *3 (D.N.J. Dec. 22, 2025) 5 See Complaint 1 3. 6 The complaint does not explicitly indicate whether the Supervisor is sued in his official or personal capacity. But in their brief, the Defendants said that the Supervisor is sued in "his official capacity," Defendants' Brief at 5-6, and the Plaintiff did not challenge this characterization in her reply. See Melo v. Hafer, 912 F.2d 628, 635 (3d Cir. 1990) (noting that courts can refer to the "course of [the] proceedings" to determine the capacity in which a given defendant has been sued) (cleaned up). 2 Case 2:25-cv-01293-MEF-MAH Document 19 Filed 02/03/26 Page 2 of 6 PageID: <pageID>
against the state." Betts v. New Castle Youth Dev. Ctr., 621
F.3d 249, 254 (3d Cir. 2010) (cleaned up).
Bottom line: the Employer, the New Jersey Department of
Corrections, gets sovereign-immunity protection from the implied
covenant claim --- and drafting behind, so does the Supervisor,
the New Jersey Department of Corrections employee. 7
* * *
Come now to the Plaintiff's claims that the Employer violated
the Age Discrimination in Employment Act and the Americans with
Disabilities Act, two federal laws. See Complaint~~ 56-60, 67-
72.
As to these claims, the Employer again points to sovereign
immunity, see Defendants' Brief at 4-6, 8 but the Plaintiff has a
counterargument: sovereign immunity is off the table because she
is looking for "injunctive relief . . to end continuing or
ongoing violations of federal law." Plaintiff's Memorandum of
Law in Opposition to Defendants' Partial Motion to Dismiss
Pursuant to Rule 12 (b) (1) and 12 (b) (6) ("Plaintiff's Brief")
(ECF 9) at 4.
7 Against this conclusion, the Plaintiff argues that New Jersey
has given up its immunity as to implied covenant claims, via the
New Jersey Contractual Liability Act. See Plaintiff's
Memorandum of Law in Opposition to Defendants' Partial Motion to
Dismiss Pursuant to Rule 12 (b) (1) and 12 (b) (6) (ECF 9) at 8-9
(citing N.J. Stat. Ann. § 59:13-3). But that Act only applies
to lawsuits brought in New Jersey state courts. See NJSR
Surgical Ctr., L.L.C. v. Horizon Blue Cross Blue Shield of N.J.,
Inc., 979 F. Supp. 2d 513, 518-20 (D.N.J. 2013); Winfield Scott
Tower Urb. Renewal LP v. Luciani, 2024 WL 4570908, at *4 n.5
(D.N.J. Oct. 24, 2024) (following NJSR); Prelle v. U.S. Mint,
2024 WL 4898064, at *6 (E.D. Pa. Nov. 26, 2024) (same); see also
Patriot Aviation, LLC v. New Jersey, 2007 WL 604793, at *4
( D. N. J. Feb. 2 0, 2 0 0 7) .
8 Federal statutes can sometimes remove a state's sovereign
immunity. But for the sorts of workplace discrimination claims
in play here, the ADA does not do that. See Bd. of Trs. of
Univ. of Ala. v. Garrett, 531 U.S. 356, 360 (2001). And neither
does the ADEA. See Kimel v. Fla. Bd. of Regents, 528 U.S. 62,
91 (2000).
3
Case 2:25-cv-01293-MEF-MAH Document 19 Filed 02/03/26 Page 3 of 6 PageID:
<pageID>It is true that sovereign immunity can work differently when forward-looking injunctive relief is sought. See Ex parte Young, 209 U.S. 123, 159-60 (1908). But that switch is only flipped when the defendant in question is an "individual state officer[]." MCI Telecomm. Corp., 271 F.3d at 506. And the Employer-defendant, the New Jersey Department of Corrections, is not that. It is an agency, not an individual. "[SJ uits against . . States and their agencies . . are barred regardless of the relief sought." P.R. Aqueduct & Sewer Auth. v. Metcalf & Eddy, Inc., 506 U.S. 139, 146 (1993); see also Shahin v. Del. Dep't of Fin., 344 F. App'x 765, 766 (3d Cir. 2009); Kreiger v. Pa. Off. of Atty. Gen., 44 F. App'x 537, 537 (3d Cir. 2002). That is, "the relief sought," an the defendant is an individual. 506 U.S. at 146. But not where, "State[] . agenc[y] ." Id. injunction, can matter where P.R. Aqueduct & Sewer Auth., as here, the defendant is a Accordingly, the ADA and ADEA claims against the Employer, the New Jersey Department of Corrections, must be dismissed. * * * Look, finally, to the ADA and ADEA claims against the Supervisor. As to these, the back-and-forth starts out as before. The Supervisor invokes sovereign immunity. See Defendants' Brief at 4-6. And the Plaintiff again says that the above-discussed sovereign-immunity exception applies --- the one for suits that seek prospective injunctive relief against individual state officials. See Plaintiff's Brief at 4-5. When it comes to the Supervisor, the Plaintiff seems to have the winning argument. After all, the Supervisor is an individual, and the Plaintiff is seeking a forward-looking injunction against him. 9 9 An injunction to give the Plaintiff an "[a]bility to volunteer for overtime," to change her everyday workplace responsibilities, and some other things. See Complaint at 12. 4 Case 2:25-cv-01293-MEF-MAH Document 19 Filed 02/03/26 Page 4 of 6 PageID: <pageID>
But the counterargument from the defendants is this: the
injunction the Plaintiff seeks against the Supervisor is really,
in substance, a request for an injunction against her Employer,
the New Jersey Department of Corrections. The state, the
argument goes, "is the real, substantial party in interest in
this matter." Reply Brief in Support of Defendants' Partial
Motion to Dismiss the Complaint Pursuant to Fed. R. Civ. P.
12(b)(l), and12(b)(6) ("Defendants' Reply") (ECFl0) at 4. And
so, it is said, the state's sovereign immunity should cover the
Supervisor.
This argument is not persuasive.
It cannot be squared with Ex parte Young, which allows for
certain injunctive suits against a state official, even though
the practical impact of these injunctions often falls on the
state the official works for. See 209 U.S. at 159-60.
Moreover, the argument is at odds with Board of Trustees of
University of Alabama v. Garrett, in which the Supreme Court
held that the part of the ADA invoked here by the Plaintiff 10
"can be enforced . in actions for injunctive relief" against
individual state officials, like the Supervisor. 531 U.S. 356,
374 n. 9 (2001).
And finally, the Supervisor's argument runs aground on Koslow v.
Commonwealth of Pennsylvania, in which the Third Circuit held
that sovereign immunity did not prevent a plaintiff from seeking
(as here) prospective injunctive relief under the ADA against an
employee at a state department of corrections. 11 See 302 F.3d
161, 179 (3d Cir. 2002).
The Supervisor's motion to dismiss the ADA claim on sovereign
immunity grounds must be denied. 12
10 Title I. See Complaint 11 67-72; Garrett, 531 U.S. at 360.
11 There, the state was Pennsylvania. Koslow, 302 F.3d at 165.
Here, it is New Jersey.
12 The same analysis applies to the Plaintiff's ADEA claim. It
can go forward to the extent the Plaintiff seeks prospective
injunctive relief against the Supervisor. See Smith v. Sec'y of
Dep't of Env't Prot. of Pa., 540 F. App'x 80, 82 (3d Cir. 2013);
Dennison v. Ind. Univ. of Pa., 2022 WL 3213657, at *11 (W.D. Pa.
Aug. 9, 2022), aff'd on other grounds, 2023 WL 8595426 (3d Cir.
Dec. 12, 2023); Howell v. Millersville Univ. of Pa., 2017 WL
5
Case 2:25-cv-01293-MEF-MAH Document 19 Filed 02/03/26 Page 5 of 6 PageID:
<pageID>* * * In short: The motion to dismiss at ECF 7 is granted as to (i) the implied covenant claims pressed against each defendant, and (ii) the ADA and ADEA claims against the Employer, the New Jersey Department of Corrections. The motion is denied as to the ADA and ADEA claims brought against the Supervisor, to the extent the Plaintiff seeks prospective injunctive relief. 13 IT IS on this 2nd day of February, 2026~ SO ORDERED. Michael E. Farbiarz, U.S.D.J. 3189209, at *3 (E.D. Pa. July 27, 2017); Thelen v. Pa. State Sys. of Higher Educ., 2021 WL 3370791, at *10 (W.D. Pa. Aug. 3, 2021). 13 In one spot, the Complaint arguably seeks damages under the ADA and the ADEA against the Supervisor. See Complaint at 12. The Supervisor argues that these claims are barred by sovereign immunity, see Defendants' Brief at 5-6, and the Plaintiff's push-back ignores damages --- focusing only on the idea that she is indeed seeking injunctive relief. See Plaintiff's Brief at 4-5. If the Plaintiff seeks damages against the Supervisor under the ADA and/or the ADEA, then she will need to clarify her intentions during any subsequent stages of this litigation. If she does so, the Supervisor will then be afforded an opportunity to press any arguments in response. 6 Case 2:25-cv-01293-MEF-MAH Document 19 Filed 02/03/26 Page 6 of 6 PageID: <pageID>
Was bedeutet dieser Text für Ihre Situation?
Kostenlose und unverbindliche Beratung
Schildern Sie uns Ihre Situation. Unser Team meldet sich per E-Mail bei Ihnen für Ihre Beratung.
Setzen Sie Ihre Recherche in ChatGPT oder Claude fort
Verbinden Sie Omnilex, um den Rechtskorpus über Ihren KI-Assistenten zu durchsuchen.