Montana Wildlife Federation et al v. Bernhardt et al

4:18-cv-00069Mtd12.12.2025

Gesamter Gesetzestext

1
IN THE UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT
FOR THE DISTRICT OF MONTANA
GREAT FALLS DIVISION
MONTANA WILDLIFE
FEDERATION et al.,
Plaintiffs,
v.
DOUGLAS BURGUM, et al.,
Defendants.
CV-18-69-GF-BMM
ORDER ON
MOTION TO INTERVENE
Applicant for intervention, Rockies Resources Holdings LLC (“Rockies
Resources”) moves to intervene as of right pursuant to Federal Rule of Civil
Procedure 24(a)(2). (Doc. 435 at 10.) Plaintiffs do not oppose the motion. (Doc.
449.) Defendant-Intervenor Wyoming opposes the motion. (Doc. 448.) The Court
previously has allowed Jonah Energy, LLC, Western Energy Alliance, Anschutz
Exploration Corporation, Inc., Peak Powder River Acquisitions, LLC, R&R
Royalty, Ltd., Continental Resources, LLC, and Chesapeake Exploration, LLC to
intervene as Defendants in this action. (Docs. 305, 365, 378, 402.)
BACKGROUND
Plaintiffs challenge the Bureau of Land Management’s (“BLM”) issuance of
the 2018 Instruction Memorandum on Greater Sage Grouse conservation and
Case 4:18-cv-00069-BMM Document 501 Filed 12/12/25 Page 1 of 10
2
subsequent oil and gas leasing decisions in Nevada, Wyoming, and Montana. (Doc.
263.) The Court explained the background of this case in depth in the Phase One
and Phase Two summary judgment orders. (Doc. 147 at 1–13; Doc. 335 at 1–3.)
The Court will assume familiarity with the prior decisions.
Phase Three consists of six Montana and Wyoming lease sales that were
added in Plaintiffs’ Second Amended and Supplemental Complaint. (Doc. 263.)
The lease sales at issue are March and December 2019 Montana lease sales,
February, September, and December 2019 Wyoming lease sales, and the December
2020 Wyoming lease sale. (Id.) Rockies Resources acquired 31 leases for over $7
million dollars from the February 2019 and September 2019 Wyoming lease sales.
(Doc. 435 at 6–7.) Rockies Resources alleges that challenges to the leases have
frustrated its potential investment returns. (Id. at 5.)
Rockies Resources requested the BLM to cancel the challenged leases in
2021. (Id.) Rockies Resources also requested a refund of its purchase of the leases.
(Id.) BLM has rejected the requests. (Id.) Plaintiffs filed a Second Amended and
Supplemental Complaint in June 2021. (Doc. 263.) The Amended Complaint
added challenges to leases sold in February 2019 and September 2019 Wyoming
lease sales. (Id.) Rockies Resources filed a motion to seek leave to intervene in
Phase Three of this litigation on September 10, 2025. (Doc. 434.)
Case 4:18-cv-00069-BMM Document 501 Filed 12/12/25 Page 2 of 10
3
LEGAL STANDARD
Courts generally construe Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 24(a) liberally in
favor of intervention. Citizens for Balanced Use v. Mont. Wilderness Ass’n, 647
F.3d 893, 897 (9th Cir. 2011). To intervene as of right under Rule 24(a)(2), an
applicant must show that “(1) it has a significant protectable interest relating to the
property or transaction that is the subject of the action; (2) the disposition of the
action may, as a practical matter, impair or impede the applicant’s ability to protect
its interest; (3) the application is timely; and (4) the existing parties may not
adequately represent the applicant’s interest.” In re Estate of Ferdinand E. Marcos
Human Rights Litig., 536 F.3d 980, 984 (9th Cir. 2008). Courts deciding motions
to intervene as of right are “guided primarily by practical considerations, not
technical distinctions.” See U.S. v. City of Los Angeles, 288 F.3d 391, 397 (9th Cir.
2002) (stating that “equitable considerations” guide determination of motions to
intervene as of right) (citation omitted). Nonetheless, the “[f]ailure to satisfy any
one of the requirements is fatal to the application.” Perry v. Prop. 8 Official
Proponents, 587 F.3d 947, 950 (9th Cir. 2009).
DISCUSSSION
I. Rockies Resources maintains a right to intervene under Rule 24(a)
Rockies Resources seeks to intervene to protect its interests in oil and gas
leases in Wyoming. (Doc. 435 at 5.) Wyoming argues that Rockies Resources
Case 4:18-cv-00069-BMM Document 501 Filed 12/12/25 Page 3 of 10
4
cannot intervene because Rockies Resources made an untimely motion, that
intervention proves unnecessary to protect Rockies Resources’s interests, and
intervention would also prejudice existing parties. (Doc. 448 at 3.)
A. Rockies Resources Timely Moved for Intervention
Timeliness depends on three factors under the totality of the circumstances:
“(1) the stage of the proceeding at which an applicant seeks to intervene; (2) the
prejudice to other parties; and (3) the reason for and length of the delay.” United
States v. Alisal Water Corp., 370 F.3d 915, 921 (9th Cir. 2004). “The ‘stage of
proceeding’ factor uses a ‘nuanced, pragmatic approach’ to examine whether the
district court has substantively—and substantially—engaged the issues in [the]
case.’” Kalbers v. U.S. Dep’t of Just., 22 F.4th 816, 826 (9th Cir. 2021) (citation
omitted). A court may consider the time elapsed since the proceeding’s initiation,
how much activity has yet occurred in the case, and whether the court has issued
rulings in the case when analyzing the “stage of the proceeding” factor. See Smith
v. L.A. Unified Sch. Dist., 830 F.3d 843, 854 (9th Cir. 2016).
Wyoming suggests that Garza v. County of Los Angeles, 918 F.2d 763 (9th
Cir. 1990) supports its contention that Rockies Resources made an untimely
motion. (Doc. 448 at 7–9.) Garza dealt with a challenge to redistricting in a voting
rights action. 918 F.2d at 765. An electoral candidate attempted to intervene in the
action “[d]uring the remedial phase” of the case. Id. at 767, 777. The three month-
Case 4:18-cv-00069-BMM Document 501 Filed 12/12/25 Page 4 of 10
5
trial had already commenced. Id. The Ninth Circuit determined that the remedial
phase failed to constitute a “new phase” in the case to justify intervention. Id. at
777. The “new phase” failed to “develop[] as a result of a change in the law or the
factual circumstances.” Id. Rather, “the new phase came about in the general
progression of the case to a close.” Id. The Ninth Circuit further concluded that
“[i]ntroduction of a new party at that late stage could have resulted in irreversible
prejudicial delay in a case where time was of the essence.” Id.
In contrast, Western Wastersheds Project granted a lessee’s motion to
intervene in the first phase of a case that challenged BLM’s issuance of oil and gas
leases. 22 F.4th 828, 839 (9th Cir. 2022). The district court had divided the case
into several phases. Id. at 834. The lessee sought to intervene after the district court
had previously determined the merits of the first phase of the case. Id. The district
court denied the motion to intervene. Id. The Ninth Circuit reversed on appeal. Id.
at 842. The Ninth Circuit concluded that “the beginning of a ‘new stage’ in a case
may be the appropriate time for a party to intervene.” Id. at 839. The Ninth Circuit
noted the “significant financial and property interests at stake.” Id. at 838.
Western Watersheds Project controls the outcome here. Unlike the electoral
candidate in Garza who attempted to intervene during the end stage of the
proceedings, Rockies Resources seeks to intervene before the parties submit merits
briefing in Phase Three of the case. 918 F.2d at 767; see also Western Watersheds
Case 4:18-cv-00069-BMM Document 501 Filed 12/12/25 Page 5 of 10
6
Project, 22 F.4th at 839. The Ninth Circuit formerly directed the Court to grant
other parties leave to intervene in Phase One of the case. Mont. Wildlife Fed’n,
2022 WL 42794, at *2. The Court previously had issued a decision on the Phase
One leases. Id. Rockies Resources attempts to intervene at an earlier stage in the
Phase Three proceedings than previous intervenors. The Court has yet to engage
substantially in the issues of the Phase Three proceedings. Kalbers, 22 F.4th at
826. Rockies Resources’s motion to intervene in Phase Three of the proceedings
proves excusable given that the claims that Rockies Resources seeks to intervene
on “involves a discrete set of factual and legal issues whose resolution is
procedurally distinct from [other] phases of the litigation.” Western Watersheds
Project, 22 F.4th at 837. Rockies Resources also has “significant financial and
property interests at stake.” Id. at 839.
The prejudice to the parties appears minimal. A “[m]ere lapse of time alone
is not determinative.” Smith, 830 F.3d at 854. Rather, “the only relevant ‘prejudice’
is ‘that which flows from a prospective intervenor’s failure to intervene after [it]
knew, or reasonably should have known, that [its] interests were not being
adequately represented.” Western Watersheds Project, 22 F.4th at 838 (quoting
Smith, 830 F.3d at 857). Rockies Resources requests to intervene in Phase Three of
the proceedings to defend its interests in its 31 leases. The parties have yet to
submit summary judgment briefing. To allow intervention at this point in the case
Case 4:18-cv-00069-BMM Document 501 Filed 12/12/25 Page 6 of 10
7
would not “result[] in irreversible prejudicial delay.” Garza, 918 F.2d at 777.
Rockies Resources’s positions may also not undermine the positions of Defendants
and Defendant-Intervenors. Rockies Resources contends that it would not
challenge the legality of BLM’s leasing decisions. Rockies Resources suggests
instead that “it may file a motion for vacatur of the leases without a determination
of the merits.” (Doc. 453 at 12) (emphasis in the original). The Court has yet to
determine the outcome of the leases as well. Given these facts, intervention at this
time would likely not prejudice existing parties.
Rockies Resources sufficiently sets forth reasons for its delay, including that
its rights under the leases have yet to be addressed in the litigation. (Doc. 435 at
13.) The totality of the circumstances demonstrate that Rockies Resources has
timely moved to intervene. Smith, 830 F.3d at 854.
B. Rockies Resources Presents a Significant Protectable Interest
Rockies Resources purchased 31 oil and gas leases at issue in Phase Three of
this litigation. (Doc. 435 at 6–7.) Rockies Resources invested $7,277,000 in the
leases. (Id. at 14.) The Ninth Circuit acknowledges that a lessee possesses a
“substantial due process interest” in the outcome of litigation regarding its
contractual oil and gas leases. Mont. Widlife Fed’n v. Haaland, 2022 WL 42794, at
*2 (9th Cir. Jan. 5. 2022). Rockies Resources demonstrates that “it will suffer a
practical impairment of its interests as a result of the pending litigation” based on
Case 4:18-cv-00069-BMM Document 501 Filed 12/12/25 Page 7 of 10
8
its investments in the leases. City of Emeryville v. Robinson, 621 F.3d 1251, 1259
(9th Cir. 2010) (quoting State ex rel. Lockyer v. United States, 450 F.3d 436, 441
(9th Cir. 2006)).
C. Rockies Resources’s absence from the proceedings will impair its
ability to protect its interests, and the existing parties do not
adequately represent Rockies Resources’s interests
The Court considers three factors to determine whether existing parties will
adequately represent the applicant for intervention’s interests: “(1) whether the
interest of a present party is such that it will undoubtedly make all the intervenor’s
arguments; (2) whether the present party is capable and willing to make such
arguments; and (3) whether the would-be intervenor would offer any necessary
elements to the proceeding that the other parties would neglect.” Sw. Ctr. for
Biological Diversity v. Berg, 268 F.3d 810, 822 (9th Cir. 2001). The burden to
demonstrate that existing parties may not adequately represent a party’s interests
“is minimal and is satisfied if the applicant can demonstrate that representation of
its interests ‘may be’ inadequate.” Helena Hunters & Anglers Ass’n v. Marten,
2019 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 143056, at *6 (D. Mont. Aug. 22, 2019) (quoting Arakaki
v. Cayetano, 324 F.3d 1078, 1086 (9th Cir. 2003)).
Rockies Resources presents arguments unique to its investments in the
February 2019 and September 2019 Wyoming lease sales. Rockies Resources
demonstrates a time-value loss for its investments for the years of delay involving
Case 4:18-cv-00069-BMM Document 501 Filed 12/12/25 Page 8 of 10
9
litigation of the leases. Rockies Resources contends that it would seek to move
separately for entry of a stipulation to vacate its leases. (Doc. 435 at 17.) Vacatur
of the leases would potentially curtail Rockies Resources’s ongoing financial
losses. Rockies Resources’s prove distinct from the interests of Wyoming.
Wyoming challenges Rockies Resources’s application for intervention based on
Wyoming’s potential loss of tax revenue. (Doc. 448 at 3.) Defendants and
Intervenor-Defendants will likely not raise Rockies Resources’s concerns in their
Phase Three summary judgment motions. The interests of the parties similarly
diverge given that the Defendants and Intervenor-Defendants contend that the
Court should deny vacatur of the leases. Plaintiffs also would fail to represent the
interests of Rockies Resources. Plaintiffs advocate for vacatur of all the leases.
Rockies Resources would seek relief limited to its own Phase Three leases.
Rockies Resources “demonstrates that representation of its interests ‘may be’
inadequate.” Helena Hunters & Anglers Ass’n, 2019 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 143056, at
*6.
CONCLUSION
Rockies Resources satisfies all the requirements for intervention as of right.
Fed. R. Civ. Pro. 24(a). Rockies Resources possesses a significantly protectable
interest in the outcome of the litigation. Mont. Widlife Fed’n, 2022 WL 42794, at
*2. Absence from the litigation would impair Rockies Resources’s ability to
Case 4:18-cv-00069-BMM Document 501 Filed 12/12/25 Page 9 of 10
10
protect its interests. Existing parties may not adequately represent Rockies
Resources’s interests. Sw. Ctr. for Biological Diversity, 268 F.3d at 822.
Accordingly, IT IS HEREBY ORDERED that Rockies Resources’s motion
to intervene (Doc. 434) is GRANTED. The Clerk of Court shall file Rockies
Resources’s Proposed Answer as a separate docket entry. Rockies Resources shall
follow the briefing schedule set forth in the Phrase Three Case Management Order.
(Doc. 447.)
DATED this 10th day of December, 2025.
Case 4:18-cv-00069-BMM Document 501 Filed 12/12/25 Page 10 of 10

Setzen Sie Ihre Recherche in ChatGPT oder Claude fort

Verbinden Sie Omnilex, um den Rechtskorpus über Ihren KI-Assistenten zu durchsuchen.