Paige v. Smith et al

1:24-cv-00073Mtd29.01.2026

Gesamter Gesetzestext

1
IN THE UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT
FOR THE DISTRICT OF MONTANA
BILLINGS DIVISION
Case No. CV-24-73-BLG-DWM
ORDER
Defendant Tracey has moved for summary judgment on Plaintiff Douglas
Paige’s Complaint. (Docs. 41 – 45.) After a delay, Paige responded. (Doc. 47.) The
motion is granted.
I. 	BACKGROUND
At the time of filing his Complaint, Plaintiff Paige was a federal detainee at
Yellowstone County Detention Facility. (Doc. 2 at 2.) He alleged that detention
center staff, namely Food Director Tracey, was not providing him with the kosher
food that is required by his religion. (Doc. 2 at 4.) In particular, he alleged that pots
and pans “were used with defiled food,” only vegetables and peanut butter were
kosher, and food preparers were not using “instructions provided through…Jewish
dietary laws.” (Doc. 2 at 5.) Paige alleged that his treatment at Yellowstone County
DOUGLAS PAIGE,
Plaintiff,
v.
TRACEY at YELLOWSTONE
COUNTY DETENTION FACILITY,
Defendant.
Case 1:24-cv-00073-DWM Document 48 Filed 01/29/26 Page 1 of 8
2
violated his First and Fourteenth Amendment rights. (Doc. 2 at 3.)
II. 	ANALYSIS
A. Standard for Summary Judgment
Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 56(a) entitles a party to summary judgment
“if the movant shows that there is no genuine dispute as to any material fact and
the movant is entitled to judgment as a matter of law.” The movant bears the initial
responsibility of informing the district court of the basis for its motion, and
identifying those portions of the pleadings, depositions, answers to interrogatories,
and admissions on file, together with the affidavits, which it believes demonstrate
the absence of a genuine issue of material fact. Celotex Corp. v. Catrett, 477 U.S.
317, 323 (1986). A material fact is one that might affect the outcome of the suit
under governing law. Anderson v. Liberty Lobby, Inc., 477 U.S. 242, 248 (1986).
Disputed facts that do not change the Court’s analysis under the law may be
disregarded.
Once the moving party has satisfied its burden, the non-moving party must
go beyond the pleadings and designate by affidavits, depositions, answers to
interrogatories, or admissions on file, “specific facts showing that there is a
genuine issue for trial.” Id. at 324. In deciding a motion for summary judgment, the
Court views the evidence in the light most favorable to the nonmoving party and
draws all justifiable inferences in the non-moving party’s favor. Anderson v.
Case 1:24-cv-00073-DWM Document 48 Filed 01/29/26 Page 2 of 8
3
Liberty Lobby, Inc., 477 U.S. 242, 255 (1986); Betz v. Trainer Wortham & Co.,
Inc., 504 F.3d 1017, 1020-21 (9th Cir. 2007). But “[a] conclusory, self-serving
affidavit, lacking detailed facts and any supporting evidence, is insufficient to
create a genuine issue of material fact.” F.T.C. v. Publishing Clearing House, Inc.,
104 F.3d 1168, 1171 (9th Cir. 1997).
B. Discussion
Defendant’s motion disputes Plaintiff’s claims in his Complaint that the food
he was served at Yellowstone County was not a sufficient kosher diet. (Doc. 42.)
In support, Defendant filed a Statement of Unconverted Facts, as required by the L.
R. 56.1, supported by the Affidavit of Defendant Tracy Martin. (Docs. 43 and 44.)
Defendant’s brief explains that Paige was approved for a kosher diet. Defendant, as
the Food Director, is in charge of producing the food and not designing the
authorized religious diet itself, which is the province of the facility’s dietician.
(Doc. 42 at 7.) The pots and utensils used for kosher food are kept and washed
separately. “To the extent possible, given the physical facilities available and
resources provided by YCDF,” the food and materials for kosher meals are kept
separate from non-kosher food and materials. (Doc. 42 at 7.) Defendant
emphasizes three unanswered requests for admission: that Paige was served kosher
meals at Yellowstone County, ate them, and received adequate nutrition. (Doc. 43
at 5 – 6.)
Case 1:24-cv-00073-DWM Document 48 Filed 01/29/26 Page 3 of 8
4
In response, Paige disputes Defendant’s factual assertions. (Doc. 47.) First,
he states that though Defendant was following the policy and diet established by
others, no rabbi was involved or blessed the meals, “so by admission the meals are
not kosher...” (Doc. 47 at 1.) Paige’s conclusion is that the food “was not up to
Jewish Religious Standards.” (Doc. 47 at 2.) His second point is that even though
the kosher pans were washed separately from the non-kosher pans, the same
dishwashers were used, “making them unclean.” (Doc. 47 at 1.) Paige construes
this “admission” by Defendant as establishing not only her liability, but that of her
employer, Summit, and dietician John Smith, neither of whom are currently
defendants in this matter. (Doc. 47 at 2.) Finally, Paige disputes Defendant’s
assertion that she served discovery requests on him that went unanswered. (Doc.
47.)
Paige’s brief relies on his factual assertion that the food was not properly
kosher, but Paige failed to file the required Statement of Disputed Facts, despite
being advised of the requirement in a Rand notice filed by Defendant. (Doc. 45.)
As the Local Rule says, “Failure to file a Statement of Disputed Facts will be
deemed an admission that no material facts are in dispute.” L.R. 56.1(d).
As a preliminary matter, Paige’s request for relief in his Complaint is
sequential: he asks for injunctive relief, in the form of ordering specific frozen
kosher meals, but “if case goes to trial after a court order for an injunction, I will
Case 1:24-cv-00073-DWM Document 48 Filed 01/29/26 Page 4 of 8
5
be asking for an award of $100,000 in punitive damages and $1 in nominal
damages.” (Doc. 2 at 5.) Paige is no longer detained at Yellowstone County and
does not appear likely to return, as he is a federal inmate no longer in Montana. His
request for injunctive relief is thus moot. See Rhodes v. Robinson, 408 F.3d 559,
566 n. 8 (9th Cir.2005) (prayers for injunctive relief are mooted by a prisoner's
release or transfer to another facility). Paige’s request for damages appears
contingent on the issuance of an injunction, which is no longer available.
Accordingly, Paige’s Complaint as a whole may be moot at this point. However,
even if considered on the merits, Defendant is entitled to summary judgment.
“In ruling on a prisoner's First Amendment free exercise claim, we first
determine whether the challenged prison policy or practice substantially burdened
the prisoner's free exercise of his or her religion.” Long v. Sugai, 91 F.4th 1331,
1337 (9th Cir. 2024). A “substantial burden exists when the state places
‘substantial pressure on an adherent to modify his behavior and to violate his
beliefs.’” Jones v. Slade, 23 F.4th 1124, 1142 (9th Cir. 2022) (quoting Warsoldier
v. Woodford, 418 F.3d 989, 995 (9th Cir. 2005)). “[M]ore than an inconvenience
on religious exercise,” a substantial burden has “a tendency to coerce individuals
into acting contrary to their religious beliefs.” Jones v. Williams, 791 F.3d 1023,
1031–32 (9th Cir. 2015) (quoting Ohno v. Yasuma, 723 F.3d 984, 1011 (9th Cir.
2013)). On the facts before the Court, Defendant’s practices at Yellowstone
Case 1:24-cv-00073-DWM Document 48 Filed 01/29/26 Page 5 of 8
6
County did not substantially burden Paige’s free exercise of his religion.
“[T]he failure to provide food consistent with a prisoner's sincerely held
religious beliefs constitutes a substantial burden on the prisoner's free exercise.”
Long v. Sugai, 91 F.4th 1331, 1337 (9th Cir. 2024); McElyea v. Babbitt, 833 F.2d
196, 198 (9th Cir. 1987) (per curiam) (“Inmates ... have the right to be provided
with food sufficient to sustain them in good health that satisfies the dietary laws of
their religion.”). This matter comes down to a factual dispute over whether the
practices the defendant engaged in “substantially burdened” Paige’s religious
practice. That is not exactly the same as a dispute over what, exactly, the required
practices are. Paige’s Complaint did not allege any of the required specific
practices. In his response, he provides conclusions about what they might be, but
he has not entered any evidence into the record. Paige asserts, without record
support, that the meals are not sufficiently kosher, because they are not prepared by
a rabbi, but there is no evidence to show that preparation by a rabbi is required.
Paige’s other assertion is that washing the kosher dishes in the same dishwasher as
the non-kosher dishes, even at different times, is not acceptable. Again, there is
also no evidence in the record as to whether this assertion is factually correct, one
way or the other.
The material question here is whether the Defendant substantially burdened
Paige’s religious practice, with her own actions. Given Defendant’s position as the
Case 1:24-cv-00073-DWM Document 48 Filed 01/29/26 Page 6 of 8
7
Food Service Director, she had limited discretion in terms of providing Paige with
kosher food. The facts in her affidavit show that she is following the menu created
by a registered dietician, upon whom she relies to ensure adequate nutrition and
compliance with kosher requirements. (Doc. 44 at 22.) She also washes the dishes
separately, and serves the food on disposable trays, thus maintaining the food’s
kosher status, as she understands it, with the resources she has available. She was
not a decisionmaker about the diet itself, or the facilities available in which to
produce it. Paige has not provided evidence to dispute the sufficiency of these
practices. Defendant is entitled to summary judgment.
III. 	CONCLUSION
Plaintiff Paige has failed to demonstrate that there is a genuine issue of
material fact that prevents summary judgment as to whether Defendant Tracey
substantially burdened Paige’s free exercise of his religion. Defendant’s motion is
granted.
Accordingly, it is HEREBY ORDERED:
1. Defendant’s motion for summary judgment is GRANTED. (Doc. 42.)
The Clerk of Court is directed to close this matter and enter judgment, pursuant to
Fed. R. Civ. P. 58.
2. The Clerk of Court is directed to have the docket reflect that the Court
certifies pursuant to Rule 24(a)(3)(A) of the Federal Rules of Appellate Procedure
Case 1:24-cv-00073-DWM Document 48 Filed 01/29/26 Page 7 of 8
8
that any appeal of this decision would not be taken in good faith.
DATED this 29 th day of January, 2026.
Case 1:24-cv-00073-DWM Document 48 Filed 01/29/26 Page 8 of 8

Setzen Sie Ihre Recherche in ChatGPT oder Claude fort

Verbinden Sie Omnilex, um den Rechtskorpus über Ihren KI-Assistenten zu durchsuchen.