Ford et al v. Red Roof Inn et al

1:24-cv-03414Mdd16.12.2025

Gesamter Gesetzestext

IN THE UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT
FOR THE DISTRICT OF MARYLAND
*
AAIRAH FORD ET AL.,
*
Plaintiffs,
*
v.
* 	Civil No. 24-3414-BAH
RED ROOF INNS, INC., ET AL.,
*
Defendants.
*
* 	* 	* 	* 	* 	* 	* 	* 	* 	* 	* 	*
MEMORANDUM OPINION
* 	*
Pro se plaintiffs Aairah Ford and Nathan Ford ("Plaintiffs") filed suit 1 against Red Roof
·rnns, Inc. ("Red Rooflnn"), Michaela Randle ("Randle"), Michael Kenneth Johnson ("Johnson"),
and James Ross ("Ross") (collectively "Defendants") seeking compensatory and punitive damages
related to a series of events occurring on November 3, 2024 at a motel in Annapolis, Maryland.
'ECF 16 (amended complaint). 	Pending before the Court is Defendants' motion to dismiss the
amended complaint. 	ECF 29 (motion); ECF 29-1 (memorandum of law in support). 	Plaintiffs
responded (ECF 31) after receiving a Rule 12/56 Notice from the Court (ECF 30). Plaintiffs also
·filed a physical exhibit-"an audio recording of a 911 call made by Defendant [Randle]" the night
• of the incident. 	ECF 33, at 1. 	Defendants filed a reply. 	ECF 36. 	The Court has reviewed all
relevant filings and finds that no hearing is necessary. See Local Rule 105.6 (D. Md. 2025). For
1 Plaintiffs filed an original complaint on November 26, 2024. 	ECF 1. An amended complaint,
ECF 16, was timely filed after Defendants filed a motion to dismiss Plaintiffs' initial complaint.
See ECF 14. "[A]n amended pleading ordinarily supersedes the original and renders it ofno legal
effect" Youngv. City ofMt. Ranier, 238 F.3d 567,572 (4th Cir. 2001) (quoting Crysen/Montenay
.Energy Co. v. Shell Oil Co., 226 F.3d 160, 162 (2d Cir. 2000)). Accordingly, the motion to dismiss
the original complaint (ECF 14) was denied as moot. ECF 40, at I n.1.
Case 1:24-cv-03414-BAH Document 42 Filed 12/16/25 Page 1 of 15
the reasons noted below, the motion is GRANTED, and the Court dismisses Plaintiffs' claims that
·arise under federal law with prejudice. 	The Court declines to· exercise jurisdiction over the
remaining state law claims and thus dismisses them without prejudice.
I. 	FACTUAL BACKGROUND
The following facts are drawn from Plaintiffs' amended complaint, which the Court will
"accept as true ... and construe[] in the light most favorable to the plaintiff." Wikimedia Found
v. Nat'/ Sec. Agency, 857 F.3d 193,208 (4th Cir. 2017) (citing SD3, LLC v. Black & Decker (US.)
,Inc., 801 F.3d 412,422 (4th Cir. 2015)). Plaintiffs allege that they checked into the Red Rooflnn
in Annapolis on November 3, 2024 for a "prepaid five-night stay as an extension to their previous
four day stay in the same room." ECF 16, at 4 '\[ 9. Randle was allegedly worked at the Red Roof
_Inn, as did Johnson. Id'\['\[ 6-7. Ross was the general manager. Id'\[ 8.
Plaintiffs allege that they were "subjected to racially discriminatory and hostile treatment"
throughout 	their 	stay 	"[d]espite 	complying 	with 	hotel 	policies 	and 	displaying 	courteous
conduct[.]" 	Id 	'\[ 10. 	Plaintiffs allege that they arranged "with Defendant [Johnson]" for
housekeeping service to be provided at noon every day. Id '\[ 11. After Aairah Ford told Johnson
that she might not need the daily service, Johnson explained that hotel staff needed to enter
Plaintiffs' room regardless because staff "needed to check Plaintiffs' room" because they "know
people 'be cooking in the rooms,"' an apparent reference to alleged illegal drug activity. Id '\[ 12
(emphasis omitted). This comment "[o]ffended" Aairah Ford who "returned to her room feeling
dirty and belittled" but nonetheless "agreed to housekeeping coming at noon." Id.
After housekeeping arrived late, Aairah Ford declined the service. 	Id. at 5 '\[ 13. 	Later,
Johnson allegedly "starting knocking on the door .... demanding immediate access to the room."
Id. '\[ 14. 	When Aairah Ford did not open the door, Johnson began "banging on the door in a
2
Case 1:24-cv-03414-BAH Document 42 Filed 12/16/25 Page 2 of 15
disruptive and aggressive manner." Id. 1 15. The matter escalated to involve Nathan Ford, who
allegedly made contact with Johnson's arm that Plaintiffs describe as a "gentle reach" that was
"neither aggressive nor intended to cause distress." 	Id. 1 16. 	Plaintiffs allege that Johnson
"shouted that both Plaintiffs were being loud and aggressive when in fact [Johnson] was the only
one yelling or reacting hostile [sic] toward Plaintiffs for their innocent assertions of reasonable
privacy expectations by two black Plaintiffs who just wanted to know why they were being kicked
out of their room." Id.
Though it is unclear precisely when she got involved, Randle joined the encounter and
°Johnson and Randle "called police claiming Plaintiffs were being loud and acting 'aggressively."'
Id. 1 17. 	Plaintiffs allege that "[i]t was clear [that.Johnson and Randle] suspected Plaintiffs of
being criminals, simply because of the color of their skin and a reasonable request for privacy
'throughout their stay coupled with bad timing on [h]ousekeeping." Id. Plaintiffs allege that Randle
and Johnson demanded that they leave the Red Roof Inn immediately. 	Id. at 6 1 19. 	Plaintiffs
claim that after police arrived, Plaintiffs agreed "to vacate the premises to avoid being arrested and
·getting their children taken aw,ay by Child Protective Services." 	Id. at 5 1 18. 	Aairah Ford
allegedly asked Randle to allow Plaintiffs and their children to remain, but the request was denied.
Id. at 6119. Police purportedly warned Plaintiffs that that they "needed to leave" and "if Plaintiffs
.returned to the Red Rooflnn" they would be arrested for trespassing. Id. 	1 20. Plaintiffs claim
they "were promised a full refund within 2-5 days," but the refund "never came." Id. 119.
After Plaintiffs did not vacate the premises quickly enough, Randle allegedly called police
,again alleging that Plaintiffs were "trespassing." 	Id. 1 21. 	Plaintiffs allege that Randle was not
truthful with police given that Plaintiffs were "packing up their car" and engaged in a "clear good
faith retreat" and "not a trespass·." Id. 	Plaintiffs allege that the second call to police "led to the
3
Case 1:24-cv-03414-BAH Document 42 Filed 12/16/25 Page 3 of 15
involvement of crisis 	intervention personnel, 	further 	confirming the racially 	charged and
discriminatory treatment Plaintiffs endured." Id. ,r 22.
Plaintiffs allege they received only a "partial refund" of their "unused nights." Id. ,r 23.
When Aairah Ford tried to contact Ross the following day,.R.oss allegedly ignored her demands
and "issued an email denying the occurrence of racial discrimination, stating that Plaintiffs were
_banned from the property without providing any explanation." 	Id. at 6-7 ,r,r 24-25. 	Plaintiffs
allege that the incident that marred their stay at the Red Roofinn caused them "extreme emotional
and physical distress" and "forced [them] to spend the night in their vehicle." Id. at 7,r 27. A few
_days later, Nathan Ford alleges he "experienced a mental health breakdown," which resulted in his
hospitalization. Id. ,r 29. Plaintiffs contend that "Defendants"• conduct was racially motivated and
intended to cause them harm and humiliation." Id. ~ 28.
The amended complaint asserts racial discrimination in violation of state and federal law
against Johnson and Randle (Count I); intentional infliction of emotional distress against Johnson
and Randle (Count II); negligence as to all Defondants (Count III); false statements to law
enforcement in violation of Md. Code Ann., Crim. Law § 9-501 against Johnson and Randle
(Count IV); breach of contract against Red Roof Inn (Count V); defamation against Johnson and
Randle (Count VI); obstruction of justice in violation_ of.Md. Code Ann., Crim. Law § 9~306
against Johnson and Randle (Count VII); and conversion against Red Roofinn (Count VIII). ECF
'
16, at 7-15. 	Plaintiffs also attach a number of documents to the amended complaint including a
police report, ECF 16-2; records and emails from the Red Roofinn, ECF 16-3, at 1-5, and a 2024
annual report created by Red Roofinn' s corporate parent, id., at 6-I 9.
4
Case 1:24-cv-03414-BAH Document 42 Filed 12/16/25 Page 4 of 15
II. 	LEGAL STANDARD
Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 12(b)(6) governs dismissals for failure to "state a. claim
upon which relief can be granted." In considering a motion under this rule, courts discount legal
·conclusions stated in the complaint and "accept as true all of the factual allegations contained in
the complaint." Erickson v. Pardus, 551 U.S. 89, 94 (2007); see also Ashcroft v. Iqbal, 556 U.S.
662, 678 (2009). 	A court then draws all reasonable inferences in favor of the plaintiff and
·considers whether the complaint states a plausible claim for relief on its face. 	Nemet Chevrolet,
Ltd. v. Consumeraffairs.com, Inc., 591 F.3d 250,. 253 (4th Cir. 2009). 	"A claim has facial
plausibility when the plaintiff pleads factual content that allows the court to draw the reasonable
·inference that the defendant is liable for the misconduct alleged." Iqbal, 556 U.S. at 678.
"The complaint must offer 'more than labels and conclusions' or 'a formulaic recitation of
the elements ofa cause of action[.]"' Swaso v. Onslow Cnty. Bd. of Educ., 698 F. App'x 745, 747
,(4th Cir. 2017) (quoting Bell At!. Corp. v. Twombly, 550 U.S. 544, 5J5 (2007)). At the same time,
a "complaint will not be dismissed as long as [it] provides sufficient detail about [the plaintiffs]
claim to show that [the-plaintiff] has a more-than-conceivable chance of success on the merits."
.Owens v. Bait. City State's Att'ys Off, 767 F.3d 379,396 (4th Cir. 2014).
The Court may consider "documents attached to the complaint, 'as well as those attached
to the motion to dismiss, so long as they are integral to the complaint and authentic."' Fusaro v.
_Cogan, 930 F.3d 241,248 (4th Cir. 2019) (quoting Philips v. Pitt Cnty. Mem. Hosp., 572 F.3d 176,
180 (4th Cir. 2009)). 	A document is "integral" when "its 'very existence, and not the mere
information it contains, gives rise to the legal righti asserted."' Chesapeake Bay Found., Inc. v.
Severstal Sparrows Point, LLC, 794 F. Supp. 2d 602, 611 (D. Md. 2011) (citation omitted)
(emphasis omitted).
5
Case 1:24-cv-03414-BAH Document 42 Filed 12/16/25 Page 5 of 15
Because Plaintiffs bring this suit pro se, the Court must liberally construe the pleadings,
holding them to a less stringent standard than those drafted by attorneys. Haines v. Kerner, 404
U.S. 519, 520 (1972). 	This leniency has its limits, though. "A court may not construct the
_plaintiffs legal arguments for him, nor is a district court required to recognize 'obscure or
extravagant claims defying the most concerted efforts to unravel them."' Runge v. Barton, No.
CIVA 6:08-0231-GRA, 2009 WL 3245471, at *l (D.S.C. Oct. 2, 2009) (first citing Small v.
Endicott, 998 F.2d 411 (7th Cir. 1993), then quoting Beaudett v. City of Hampton, 775 F.2d 1274,
1277 (4th Cir. 1985)), aff'd, 368 F. App'x 361 (4th Cir. 2010).
'
III. 	ANALYSIS
A. Plaintiffs' federal claims of racial discrimination are dismissed with prejudice.
Plaintiffs first allege racial discrimination on the part of Johnson and Randle in violation
of 42 U.S.C. § 1981, Title II of the Civil Rights Act of 1964 (42 U.S.C. § 2000a), and Md. Code
Ann., State Gov't § 20-304. "Section 1981 establishes that '[a]ll persons ... have the same right	. 	.
... to make and enforce contracts ... as is enjoyed by white citizens."' Denny v. Elizabeth Arden
Salons, Inc., 456 F.3d 427, 434 (4th Cir. 2006) (quoting 42 U.S.C. § 1981(a)). 2 Defendants
.2 Defendants construe Plaintiffs allegations as "relating to the purchase of goods or services."
ECF ,29-1, 	at 	6. 	Plaintiffs respond by 	citing 	to 	cases 	alleging 	discrimination 	in hotel
accommodations. 	ECF 31, at 4 (citing Heart of Atlanta Motel, Inc. v. United States of America,
379 U.S. 241 (1964)). The elements of each claim are nearly identical. See Williams v. Staples,
Inc., 372 F.3d 662,667 (4th Cir. 2004) ("To establish a prima facie case of discrimination in a§
1981 cause of action relating to the purchase of goods'or services, [a plaintiff] must establish that:
(1) he is a member of a protected class; (2) he sought to enter into a contractual relationship with
'the defendant; (3) he met the defendant's ordinary requirements to pay for and to receive goods or
services ordinarily provided by the defendant to other similarly situated customers; and (4) he was
denied the opportunity to contract for goods or se_rvices that was otherwise afforded to white
customers."); Murrell v. Ocean Mecca Motel, Inc., 262 F.3d 253, 257 (4th Cir. 2001) ("A plaintiff
makes out a prima facie case under § 1981 of discrimination in hotel accommodations when she
demonstrates that (1) she is a member of a protected class, (2) she sought to enter into or had a
·contract with a hotel for accommodations, (3) she met the hotel's standard requirements for
occupancy, and (4) she was denied accommodations that were available to guests outside of the
protected class."). "To prove a§ 1981 claim, therefore, a plaintiff must ultimately establish both
6
Case 1:24-cv-03414-BAH Document 42 Filed 12/16/25 Page 6 of 15
contend that these claims must be dismissed primarily because "[n]one of the factual allegations
in Count I of the Amended Complaint or any of the factual allegations that Plaintiffs incorporate
therein constitute direct evidence of racial discrimination." ECF 29-1, at 8. The Court agrees.
In raising a claim under§ 1981, "[a] plaintiff must D show that the interference with a
·contractual interest would not have happened but for the plaintiffs race." Nanendla v. WakeMed,
24 F.4th 299, 305 (4th Cir. 2022) (citing Comcast Corp. v. Nat'! Ass'n of African Am.-Owned
Media, 589 U.S. 327 (2020)). Though not required to present a prima facie case at this early stage
·of litigation, to survive a motion to dismiss a § 1981 claim, "a plaintiff must initially plead [] that,
but for race, it would not have suffered the loss of a legally protected right." Comcast Corp., 589
U.S. at 341. "A plaintiff must make more than a general statement that he was treated differently
·as a result of race." Asi v. Info. Mgmt. Grp., Inc., Civ. No. GLR-18-3161, 2019 WL 4392537, at
*6 (D. Md. Sept. 13, 2019) (citing Robinson v. Loudon Cnty. Pub. Schs., 2017 WL 3599639, at *4
(E.D. Va. Aug. 18, 2017)).
Plaintiffs clearly allege that thyy are Black, thus satisfying the first element of their race
discrimination claims. 	ECF 16, at 8 , 35. 	However, they do little more than make general and
conclusory statements that their unquestionably uncomfortable treatment on November 3, 2024
_was attributable to their race. 	See, e.g., id at 4 , 	10 ("Plaintiffs were subjected to racially
discriminatory and hostile treatment."); id. , 12 (alleging "that they did not feel comfortable with
an intrusion of privacy, especially after being accused of 'cooking' drugs in their hotel room due
to the stereotypes of their race" (emphasis omitted)); id. at 5, 17 (alleging that calling police
"further worsen[ed] the encounter and create[ed] an atmosphere ofracial discrimination"); id. ("It
·that the defendant intended to discriminate on the basis of race, and that the discrimination •
interfered with a contractual interest." Denny, 456 F.3d at 434.
7
Case 1:24-cv-03414-BAH Document 42 Filed 12/16/25 Page 7 of 15
was clear [Defendants] suspected Plaintiffs of being criminals, simply because of the color of their
skin[.]"). Plaintiffs offer no evidence of racial discrimination beyond two broad assumptions: 1)
that the alleged statement that Defendants feared Plaintiffs might be "cooking" in their room was
a veiled reference to drug activity; and 2) that the statement was made only because of Plaintiffs'
race. 	More than mere speculation and assumption is required "to draw the reasonable inference
that the defendant is liable for the misconduct alleged." Iqbal, 556 U.S. at 678; Prince v. Overton,
Civ. No. SAG-25-00724, 2025 WL 3003680, at *5 .(D. Md. Oct. 27, 2025) (dismissing a§ 1981
claim where the plaintiff failed to plead "facts plausibly suggesting that he received unequal.
service on the basis of his race"). 	Even if Plaintiffs conclude that there is no other reason for their
treatment other than their race, the Fourth Circuit has held that "[b ]eing aware of no alternative
explanation and guessing that conduct is racially motivated does not amount to pleading actual
facts to support a claim ofracial discrimination." Bing v. Brivo Sys., LLC, 959 FJd 605, 618 (4th
Cir. 2020). 	Stated differently, Plaintiffs fail to allege direct evidence of discrimination and raise
little more than the vague allegation that race "may have played some role, or even been a
motivating factor" in their treatment. Nadendla v. WakeMed, 2021 WL 1056521, at *2 (E.D.N.C.
Feb. 23, 2021). 	More is required to nudge a §1981 claim-"across the line from conceivable to
plausible." Twombly, 550 U.S. at 570. 3
3. Even assuming the police report and other documents attached to the amended complaint are
"integral" to the allegations can be considered, they do nothing to further Plaintiffs' claim of racial
'discrimination. Indeed, the police report makes no mention of allegations of racial discrimination
and nott?s only that Aairah Ford "was offended by the condescending nature of Johnson and [Ford]
felt verbally attacked by Johnson." ECF 16-2, at 2. Similarly, the observation that a police officer
inquired into whether Plaintiffs thought the inciderif was "racially motivated," ECF 16, at 6 'ii 22,
was merely a question and fails to transform the allegations of race discrimination into something
"'more than labels and conclusions' or 'a formulaic recitation of the elements of a cause of
·action,"' Swaso, 698 F. App'x at 747 (quoting Twombly, 550 U.S. at 555).
8
Case 1:24-cv-03414-BAH Document 42 Filed 12/16/25 Page 8 of 15
The Court is mindful of the fact that "[r]ace,based ... animosity can be shown by direct
evidence of discrimination, or differential treatment of similarly situated ... white [customers]."
McNeil v. Loyola Univ., Civ. No. WDQ-13-1473, 2014 WL 320494, at *9 (D. Md. Jan. 27, 2014).
Regardless, Plaintiffs offer no proposed comparators that would suggest that their treatment at the
Red Roof Inn was different than customers of different races. 	Plaintiffs do not allege that they
·were "denied accommodations that were available to guests outside of the protected class."
Murrell, 262 F. 3d at 257; see also Lemon v. Myers Bigel, P.A., 985 F.3d 392,400 (4th Cir. 2021)
("Because in the absence of plausible allegations that, for example, [] white partners were similarly
·situated, such an allegation indicates only that [the plaintiff] was treated differently, not that she
was treated differently because of her race."); Prince, 2025 WL 3003680, at *5 (noting nb
alleg&tions "that white patrons received materially faster or meaningfully cheerier service or that
.their orders were delivered entirely free of mistakes."). 	The repeated refrain that Plaintiffs were
treated the way they were because oftheir race "is simply too conclusory" and "[o]nly speculation
can fill the gaps in [Plaintiffs'] complaint[.]" McCleary-Evans v. Maryland Dep 't ofTransp., State
.Highway Admin., 780 F.3d 582, 586 (4th Cir. 2015). 	Dismissal of Plaintiffs' § 1981 claim is
required.4
4 Defendants appear to argue that Plaintiffs' discrimination claims must be dismissed because they
fail to "assert a prima facie case of racial discrimination" as required under "the McDonnell
Douglas test." 	ECF 29-1, at 5-6 (citing Grant v. Atlas Rest. Grp. LLC, 2024, 2024, U.S. Dist.
LEXIS 21100, *7 (D. Md. 2024)). Despite Defendants' assertions, the Court is mindful of the fact
that a plaintiff "need not plead facts sufficient to establish a prima facie case of race-based
discrimination to survive a motion to dismiss[.]" Woods v. City of Greensboro, 855 F.3d 639, 648
(4th Cir. 2017). Though the McDonnell Douglas framework serves "to inform a court's evaluation
of the allegations," Hart v. Lew, 973 F. Supp. 2d 561, 580 (D. Md. 2013); the Court dismisses both
claims because they fail to "meet the standard established in Iqbal and Twombly," McGill v. Karas,
LLC, Civ. No. JKB-20-03191, 2021 WL 4170402, at *6 (D. Md. Sept. 14, 2021).
9
I
'
I
I
Case 1:24-cv-03414-BAH Document 42 Filed 12/16/25 Page 9 of 15
As to Plaintiffs' Title II claim, "[t]his Court has applied the same framework for analyzing
discrimination claims under both Tide II and Secti~n 1981, thus typically dismissing the Title II
claim if the Section 1981 claim has already been dismissed." Univ. ofMd. E. Shore Nat'! Alumni
Ass'n, Inc. v. Schulte Hospitality Grp., Inc., Civ. No. RDB-23-2141, 2024 WL 3424088, at *9 (D.
Md. July 15, 2024) (citing Sherman v. Marriott Hotel Servs., Inc., 317 F. Supp. 2d 609, 616 (D.
Md. 2004) and Callwoodv. Dave & Buster's, Inc., 98 F. Supp. 2d694, 721 (D_. Md. 2000)). Having
dismissed Plaintiffs' § 1981 claim, the Court will likewise dismiss Plaintiffs Title II claim for the
same reasons. 5
The Court has broad discretion to dismiss claims with or without prejudice. 	Weigel v.
Maryland, 950 F. Supp. 2d 811, 826 (D. Md. 2013) (citing 180s, Inc. v. Gordini US.A., Inc.; 602
F. Supp. 2d 635, 638-39 (D. Md. 2009)). When a plaintiff has not had the opportunity to amend
a complaint, "the dismis~al should generally be without prejudice." King v. Rubenstein, 825 F.3d
206, 225 (4th Cir. 2016). 	However, where, as here, "the plaintiff amended the pleading and the
s·Though the Court declines to exercise supplemental jurisdiction over Plaintiffs' state law claims,
_including the claim alleging racial discrimination under Md. Code Ann., State Gov't § 20-304,
Maryland law does not permit a private right of action under this state statute. 	Section 20-304
provides that "[a]n owner or operator of a place of public accommodation ... may not refuse,
withhold from, or deny to any person any of the accommodations, advantages, facilities, or
privileges of the place of public accommodation because of the person's race[.]" However, state
law holds that a patron who •alleges discrimination in public accommodations "may file a
complaint" with the Maryland Commission on Civil Rights, whi~h •is permitted to issue a
·complaint against the alleged perpetrator of discrimination "on its own motion." Md. Code Ann.,
State Gov't § 20-1004. "Although the statute expressly provides the rightto file a civil action to
individuals subject to employment discrimination ... and discrimination in housing practices ...
there is no comparable provision providing a private· right of action for claims of discrimination in
public accommodations." MR. by & Through NR. v. Tajdar, Civ. No. TDC-17-3836, 2018 WL
6050888, at *5 (D. Md. Nov. 19, 2018) (citations omitted). "[T]hus, Maryland anti-discrimination
·statutes do not authorize a private individual to file a civil action in court regarding disability
discrimination in public accommodations." Id; see also Prince, 2025 WL 1331907, at *2 ("[I]t is
evident that the legislature created no private right of action for persons in Plaintiffs position, and
his only recourse rests with the Maryland Commission on Civil Rights.").
10
Case 1:24-cv-03414-BAH Document 42 Filed 12/16/25 Page 10 of 15
·defects nonetheless remain, dismissal with prejudice is warranted." Ghorbani et al. v. Barron et
al., Civ. No. 8:24-CV-03268-PX, 2025 WL 3466877, at *3 (D. Md. Dec. 3, 2025) (citing US. ex
rel. Wilson v. Kellogg Brown & Root, Inc., 525 F.3d 370, 376 (4th Cir. 2008)). 	Despite several' 	.
·attempts at articulating viable allegations of racial discrimination, Plaintiffs have failed to "raise a
right to relief above the speculative level" and have not articulated "enough facts to state a claim •
to relief that is plausible on its face." 	Twombly, 550 U.S. at 570. 	Even after attaching police
·reports and other documentation to their amended complaint (and incorporating those documents,
as well as a 911 call, into their arguments against dismissal), Plaintiffs have failed to cure the
glaring defects in their iillegations of race-based discrimination. 	The Court need not grant
.Plaintiffs another attempt at amending the complaint to re-allege federal claims as it would be
futile. See Cozzarelli v. Inspire Pharms., Inc.; 549 F.3d 618, 630 (4th Cir. 2008) (finding no abuse
of discretion in dismissing complaint with prejudice where "amendment would be futile in li~ht
.of the fundamental deficiencies in plaintiffs' theory ofliability"). Plaintiffs' claims under Title II
and Section 1981 are therefore dismissed with prejudice.
B. The Court declines to exercise supplemental jurisdiction over Plaintiffs' remaining
claims. 	•
Plaintiffs allege that "Li]urisdiction is proper [in federal court] under 28 U.S.C. § 1331 as
this matter involves claims of racial discrimination and violation of civil rights under federal law
including Title VII 6 of the Civil Right Act of 1964 (42 U.S.C. § 2000e et seq.) and Section 1981
·of the Civil Rights Act of 1866 (42 U.S.C. § 1981 DJ, as well as supplemental state claims." ECF
16, at 3 ,r 2. In filing their original complaint, Plaintiffs noted that jurisdiction was proper in federal
6 Plaintiffs' reference to Title VII appears to be an error as Plaintiffs' claims lie in Title II (and 42
U.S.C. § 1981). See ECF 16, at 7 ,r 33.
11
Case 1:24-cv-03414-BAH Document 42 Filed 12/16/25 Page 11 of 15
court solely due to "federal question jurisdiction." ECF 1-1, at 1 (Civil Cover Sheet). 7 Having
disposed of all of Plaintiffs' federal claims, the Court must turn to the question of whether to
continue to exercise jurisdiction over any remaining state law claims, namely those alleging
discrimination under state law (the remainder of Count I), intentional infliction of emotional
distress (Count II), state law negligence (Count III), false statements to law enforcement (Count
IV), 8 breach of contract (Count V), defamation (Count VI), obstruction of justice (Count.VII), and
conversion (Count VIII).
Federal courts "are courts of limited jurisdiction." 	Royal Canin U. S. 	A., 	Inc. 	v.
Wullschleger, 604 U.S. 22, 26 (2025). 	"Congress determines, through its grants of jurisdiction,
which suits those courts can resolve." 	Id. 	"And of special importance here, Congress has long
7 Plaintiffs make no claim. that the court has "diversity jurisdiction" over this case pursuant to 28
U.S.C. § l332(a)(l). 	To the contrary, Plaintiffs note that all Defendants "reside" in Maryland.
ECF 1-1, at 1. Even if Plaintiffs were to allege that Red Roof Inn was a citizen of another state,
jurisdiction still would not lie as diversity jurisdiction requires "complete diversity," meaning that
"no party shares common citizenship with any party on the other side." Mayes v. Rapoport, 198
F.3d 457, 461 (4th Cir.1999) (internal citation omitted). 	Since Plaintiffs, Johnson, Randle, and
Ross all appear to be Maryland citizens, diversity,jurisdiction would not lie regardless of the
corporate defendant's citizenship.
8 To the extent Plaintiff allege that their claims alleging violations of state criminal law are
·somehow cognizable in federal court, they provide no basis for that conclusion. Nor could they.
As is well-established, "'[u]nless there is a clear [legislative] intent to provide a civil remedy, a
plaintiff cannot recover civil damages for an alleged violation of a criminal statute."' United States
ex rel. Angel v. Scott, 697 F. Supp. 3d 483, 490 (E.D. Va. 2023) (citing Brown v. Clements, No.
15-cv-104, 2015 WL5677296, at *9 (E.D. Va. Sept. 23, 2015)) (alterations in original). "A bare
criminal statute provides for no express civil remedy." 	Id. (quotation and citation omitted).
Additionally, the decision of whether to prosecute, and what criminal charges to bring, generally
rests with the prosecutor. 	Shahin v. Darling, 606 F. Supp. 2d 525, 538 (D. Del. 2009) (citing
United States v. Batchelder, 442 U.S. 114, 124 (1979)); see also Smith v. Shaw, Civ. No. 09-1001,
2012 WL 1832340, at *l (S.D.W. Va. April 25, 2012) ("Plaintiff has no right to initiate criminal
proceedings against Defendant."). 	Plaintiff purports to bring civil claims under state criminal
statutes, namely Md. Code. Crim. Law§ 9-501 (Count 4) and Md. Code Crim. Law§ 9-306 (Count
.7). These statutes do not provide private causes of action. Accordingly, these claims, if somehow
raised under federal law, would nonetheless be dismissed. See Moore v. Scott, Civ. No. 24-2210-
BAH, 2024 WL 4529268, at *3 (D. Md. Oct. 18, 2024).
12
Case 1:24-cv-03414-BAH Document 42 Filed 12/16/25 Page 12 of 15
conferred jurisdiction on federal courts to resolve cases 'arising under' federal law.§ 1331." Id.;
, 	·see also 28 U.S.C. § 1331 ("The district courts shall have original jurisdiction of all civil actions
arising under the Constitution, laws, or treaties of the United States."). And while a federal court	. 	.
"may exercise supplemental jurisdiction over [companion] state claim[s] so long as [they] 'derive
•from' the same 'nucleus of operative fact' as the federal one," "[t]hat derivative jurisdiction ... is	. 	.
to some extent discretionary[.]" Id. (first citing Mine Workers v. Gibbs, 383 U.S. 715, 725 (1966)
then citing 28 U.S.C. § 1367). Under 28 U.S.C. § 1367(c), a district court may "decline to exercise
.supplemental jurisdiction over a claim ... if ... the district court has dismissed all claims over
which it has original jurisdiction." 28 U.S.C. § 1367(c)(3).
The Fourth Circuit has noted "that trial courts enjoy wide latitude in determining whether
.or not to retain jurisdiction over state claims when all federal claims have been extinguished."
Shanaghan v. Cahill, 58 F.3d 106, 110 (4th Cir. 1995). Among the factors to consider in deciding
whether to retain jurisdiction over state law claims are "convenience and fairness to the parties,
the existence of any underlying issues of federal policy, comity; and considerations of judicial
economy." 	Id (citing Carnegie-Mellon University v. Cohill, 484 U.S. 343, 350 n.7 (1988)).
"When the balance of these factors indicates that a case properly belongs in state court, as when
the federal-law claims have dropped out of the lawsuit in its early stages and only state-law claims
remain, the federal court should decline the exercise of jurisdiction by dismissing the case without
prejudice." Carnegie-Mellon, 484 U.S. at 350 (citing Gibbs, 383 U.S. at 726-27). "There are no
situations wherein a federal court must retain jurisdiction over a state law claim, which would not
by itself support jurisdiction." Shanaghan, 58 F.3d at 110 (emphasis in original).
The Court has reviewed the relevant factors outlined in Shanaghan and finds that they favor
dismissal of all remaining state law claims. First, the matter has not progressed to discovery and
13 	•
Case 1:24-cv-03414-BAH Document 42 Filed 12/16/25 Page 13 of 15
thus dismissal at this early stage will not waste judicial resources or result in unfairness to either
party. 9 	Moreover, having found that Plaintiffs' federal claims alleging racial discriminatiori are
wholly conclusory, what remains is a dispute between Plaintiffs and defendants entirely grounded
in state law. 	Shanaghan, 58 F.3d at 110 ("[T]he jurisdictional basis of the action [has] fade[d]
away and the court is left with what. would otherwise be a state law case."). "Put simply, the
Cons_titution does not contemplate the federal judiciary decidin·g issues of state law among non-
diverse litigants." Lovern v. Edwards, 190 F.3d 648, 655 (4th Cir. 1999). Retaining jurisdiction·
to opine on Plaintiffs myriad state law claims would not heed the Supreme Court's admonition
that "[n]eedless decisions of state law should be avoided both as a matter of comity and to promote
justice between the parties, by procuring for them a surer-footed reading of applicable law." Gibbs,
383 U.S. at 726. Since "it appears that the state issues substantially predominate, [both] in terms
·of proof, of the scope of the issues raised, [and because] the comprehensiveness of the remedy
sought, the state claims [are] dismissed without prejudice and left for resolution to state tribunals."
Id. ( alterations added).
lV. 	CONCLUSION
In light of the foregoing, it is hereby ORDERED that:
(1) Defendants' motion to dismiss the amended complaint, ECF 29, is GRANTED;
'Plaintiffs will not suffer any financial loss as they were permitted to proceed in forma pauperis
and thus did not have to pay a filing fee and service was effectuated by the U.S. Marshal pursuant
to Fed. R. Civ. P. 4(c)(3). See ECF 8, at 1. Plus, to·the extent Plaintiffs attempt to argue that the
matter is not at an early stage, the Court notes that the litigation has been extended primarily due
to Plaintiffs who have amended their complaint, opposed Defendants' request for short extensions
.to deadlines, see ECF 24, and sought sanctions on a basis the Court found likely to be improper,
see ECF 40, at 3. Plaintiffs have the right to litigate their case as they see fit, and the Court, of
course, takes no position on the decision to amend pleadings, to oppose continuances, or, if proper,
to seek sanctions. However, the fact remains that these tactics have resulted in any arguable delay
in the progression of this case. 	As to inconvenience to Defendants, their arguments as to the
viability of all state law claims are well briefed and need little, if any, modification to be raised
_again in state court (if that proves necessary). See ECF 29-1, at 10-21.
14
Case 1:24-cv-03414-BAH Document 42 Filed 12/16/25 Page 14 of 15
(2) Theyiolations of Title II and 42 U.S.C. § 1981 alleged in Count I are dismissed with
prejudice as are any federal claims resting in the alleged violation of state criminal law
as alleged in Counts IV and VII; and
(3) The remaining state law claims alleging discrimination (Count!); intentional infliction
of emotional distress against Johnson and Randle (Count II); negligence as to all
Defendants (Count III); false statements to law enforcement in violation of Md. Code
Ann., Crim. Law§ 9-501, against Johnson and Randle (Count IV); breach of contract
against Red Rooflnn (Count V); defamation against Johnson and Randle (Count VI);
obstruction of justice in violation of Md .. Code Ann., Crim. Law § 9-306, against
Johnson and Randle (Count VII); and conversion against Red Roof Inn (Count VIII)
are dismissed without prejudice dismissed to be raised again, if ever, before the proper
state tribunal.
A separate implementing order will issue.
Dated: December 16, 2025 	Isl
Brendan A. Hurson
United States District Judge
15
Case 1:24-cv-03414-BAH Document 42 Filed 12/16/25 Page 15 of 15

Setzen Sie Ihre Recherche in ChatGPT oder Claude fort

Verbinden Sie Omnilex, um den Rechtskorpus über Ihren KI-Assistenten zu durchsuchen.